... if you don't recognize the medical significance of those signs/symptoms, I truly feel sorry for your ignorance. If you send me a PM, I will explain everything to you privately without embarrasing you in the Public Forum ( I would send a copy of any PM correspondence to the Forum administrators, somehow I don't trust you, call it intuition! ).
I am not going to allow two bit barbershop/beauty parlor philosophers hijack my genuine inquiry!
Embarrass away, doc, I don't think it's me that's on the receiving end.
As to genuine inquiry, my posts speak for themselves.
As for my comments on the symptoms you listed in "A Family Doctor's Health Manifesto", since you responded, I did indeed point out potential mis-interpretations which a patient might conclude from your list. Despite your perception that the only purpose I had was to mock you, sarcasm in my post was directed at the condescending tone I felt the list conveyed. Does a patient really need a list that includes "bleeding" to tell them to seek help for a serious injury? Unlikely.
Is there a reason to give patients a list of symptoms for which they should seek medical care?
Emergency departments have always had issues regarding patients presenting with less than emergent problems. As well there are patients who fail to seek emergency care until it is too late to best help them. A medical practice has the same problems. People can arrive in a practitioner's office when they should be in an emergency department as well as people sometimes called the "worried well", come in to see their provider when nothing is really wrong.
Providing a list of symptoms patients should seek health care for such as the one in doc's "Manifesto" have not been shown to be effective in solving the problem of educating patients when and where to seek care. Patients have varying skills with which to interpret such lists. So emergency departments have either policies to see the non-emergency patients anyway, or the departments triage the patients and provide a general medical clinic alongside the emergency department at least during some of the operating hours. They don't hand patients a generic list of symptoms for which to seek care. (Though they might give out a list of reasons to seek care for the specific problem which the patient presented with as I note below.)
I challenge you to provide evidence that giving patients a list such as the one in your manifesto results in any measurable improvement in patients' decisions to seek medical care when it is needed.
When are such lists useful?
"Red flag" lists are appropriate to give patients as part of their discharge instructions. Such information is specific to the problems the patient presented with.
Lists of symptoms for which to seek care can be useful when geared to education about specific problems such as stroke symptoms, heart attack symptoms, specific cancer symptoms, and so on. The
seven warning signals of cancer, for example, along with education on when to get routine screening tests has been used in successful educational campaigns.
Heart Attack, Stroke & Cardiac Arrest Warning Signs from the AHA have been published and are often put out as public service announcements. This is especially useful when specific medical emergencies people fail to get rapid care for have been identified. An education campaign is helpful when new emergency treatments are available such as with strokes that the general public may not be unaware of.
There are groups such as Migraine sufferers 'support groups which have educational material such as
The "red flags" or danger signals that should prompt you to seek medical attention on their websites and in other publications. There are slightly different version of the list, such as the one here,
Red Flags with headaches.
Misc red flags are listed here but I think it's kind of a disjointed list.
There are a number of resources for parents to use in deciding when to take their child to a practitioner.
When Should You Call Your Pediatrician? contains an example of such information. It is clear from this site that it is difficult to merely give a simple list. Instead each symptom or condition really needs a bit more elaboration. I recommend that parents actually have a good resource book at home (or in this day and age, some good Web links) which they can consult when their child is ill.
Side note:
Since I am on the subject, I have a pet peeve about telephone consultations with any provider though in this case a nurse practitioner or physician might be more reliable than a nurse unless the nurse has very specific training in telephone triage or is using strict written protocols. If you cannot see that patient, you have no way of knowing how good the person who is talking to you is in observing or describing what they see. If the caller says the patient has a rash, unless the triage person knows what to ask about that rash you can end up with a dead patient and I have seen that happen twice.
Is a list of symptoms better than the patient's own sense of when to see a health care provider?
The following account from our local newspaper,
All chest-related symptoms should be red flags, provides an example of multiple physicians who couldn't interpret a simple single symptom complaint in a woman with coronary artery disease, CAD, who sought care over a three year period.
For more than three years, Donna Tronvig of Maple Valley visited doctors to determine just what was causing a persistent burning sensation in her chest. The pain was enough at times to make her stop for rest between the car and grocery store door....
She saw multiple doctors including a cardiologist who put her through a stress test which was normal, internists and digestive specialists, and a lung specialist.
...The only diagnosis was severe heartburn. She took high-strength heartburn medication that did nothing to alleviate the burning....
On Oct. 8, 2001, Tronvig felt so lousy that her husband, Richard, refused to go to work that day. Instead he vowed to help his wife "get to the bottom of this." The Maple Valley couple drove to the emergency room at the University of Washington Medical Center.
It was Tronvig's fortune that Dr. Larry Dean, director of the UW Medicine Regional Heart Center, was on call that day....
..."My litmus test is if someone is sick enough to go to the emergency room," Dean said, "then I will look at every possibility about why that person is suffering."...
Here we have a criteria for evaluation not based at all on giving a patient a "list" of symptoms to seek care for but on the patient's assessment that she was sick enough to go to the ED. There the woman finally got an angiography of her cardiac arteries.
..."The procedure showed significant blockage. The doctors wouldn't let me go home. I had surgery (triple bypass) on Monday."....
Tronvig said her age and apparent healthy appearance worked against her. Doctors just looked past heart disease as the cause. A study published this month in the medical journal Chest adds fuel to Tronvig's position -- or that of any woman who has encountered disbelief that a female might be suffering a heart attack or require cardio attention.
The study showed heart attack patients who do not have chest pains are up to three times more likely to die of the illness, probably because doctors do not recognize their symptoms. An estimated 13 percent of patients without chest pain died in the hospital, compared to 4.3 percent of patients with chest pain, said researchers at Concord Hospital in Sydney, Australia.
Patients without chest pain tended to be older women with diabetes, heart failure or high blood pressure. Patients who suffered chest pain were more likely to be smokers with clogged arteries.
Less common but still potentially deadly heart attack symptoms include fainting, shortness of breath, excessive sweating or nausea and vomiting. Any sudden, rapid or unexplained changes related to these symptoms are considered health red flags, said Dean.
From this story one might even conclude that giving patients a list of common symptoms one should seek medical care for could lead them to not seek care should they have something wrong but which isn't on the list. Granted that might be a stretch, but it should be clear from the above example that such lists of symptoms as are in the "manifesto" are likely to be pretty useless. We have to rely on patients knowing something is wrong and we have to be careful when dismissing the symptoms as insignificant that we have indeed looked at all the possibilities.
And just to throw in skepticdoc's biased assumption that I don't have the knowledge and skills to diagnose and treat a patient, or I don't have valuable information to contribute because I am a nurse practitioner and not a physician, similar bias in assessing a patient can be dangerous. If a practitioner doesn't clear the field of bias when approaching a patient, including a bias in judging the patient's knowledge prematurely, the provider is likely to make the wrong diagnosis.
I teach infectious disease precautions to health care workers. I often include examples of what I call tunnel vision. I learned it from another nurse teaching ED nurses how to assess a patient in the ED. The patient in question had an ax literally stuck in his forehead. What do you do? Unless there is an artery spurting from the ax wound (your airway breathing circulation check), you do your normal head to toe assessment of the patient. Turned out the guy also had an icepick stab wound in the heart that if it wasn't addressed first would have killed him.
Tunnel vision directs you to the ax. Tunnel vision directs you to think the woman patient without classical CAD symptoms but who is clearly in distress has heartburn. Tunnel vision directs you to still not consider CAD and ignore the fact heartburn treatment failed which indicates heartburn was the wrong diagnosis. Tunnel vision directs you to dismiss a highly educated broadly experienced nurse, even one practicing successfully in an advanced role for years, as unworthy of being taken seriously. And most importantly in the context of this thread, tunnel vision directs you to think physicians have magical powers that others do not possess, physicians can give patients condescending little lists of how to live their lives and what symptoms are important to seek care for.
Education of the patient is included in that nursing model of patient care, skepticdoc. Treating them like children who need supervision is closer to the medical model.