Medical and Healthcare phishing

I am neither a physician or a nurse, practitioner or otherwise. I am but a lowly Paramedic and a skepchick. I practice both medical and nursing model dependant upon what my patient needs are. There are times when I have to look them in the eye and tell them if you don't do A, B and C you will die. Then there are times when I hold the hand of a patient that is scared out of their mind and say the Lord's Prayer with them, even if I don't believe.

My job is to get them to the hospital alive, doctors and nurses make them well.


You can argue til you are blue in the face that as skeptics we should be honest with our patients at all times about being honest with terminal patients when they talk about Jesus and stuff, but that's not skepticism, that's atheism.

As a skeptic we can better serve our patients by telling them that we don't always have the answers but for now the best course of healing is through current medical standard of treatment and helping them make an informed decision wherever and whenever we can.
A lowly paramedic? What nonsense! I work with EMT/fire fighters and medics in my practice. About 1/3 of my clients are fire departments. I am their infectious disease consultant and provider when they are exposed. They're some of my favorite people and they do a most incredible job.

I don't think one would make a good doctor or nurse if we couldn't judge what information to give or not give a patient under the circumstances. Of course even the best providers can't get it right all the time. But there is one place where personal stress discussing a subject gets in the way and I would think all three fields experience it. That is when you have to give someone information about their impending death or sometimes their loved one's death.

For a paramedic maybe the decision about what to say isn't so hard. No need to tell someone they are going to die before they get to the hospital. But for the physician telling the cancer patient how long they have left, there's a natural desire to soften the blow. That is not the best practice however, when that patient has to decide what to do with the time they have left. I don't think it's up to me to decide for that patient that they should have anything but the truth. It's up to me to give the best information, whether that means giving them less hope or not.

As far as a patient's beliefs go, it's just that, their beliefs. Nursing means listening to people, not preaching to them. I don't preach atheism to anyone I have a professional relationship with anyway. I don't talk politics or religion at work unless someone else brings it up. And then unless it's someone I know very well I rarely mention my political view and I almost never mention my lack of religion. People are very judgmental when they hear you don't believe in a god.

On the other hand, I do preach evidence based medicine. And while I try to be sensitive about it and I used to be a little more open to cultural beliefs being OK, I've come to believe now that junk science and junk medicine are doing too much harm to just leave people be in their misinformed state. But that's another subject.
 
skeptigirl said:
You are describing one of the biggest differences between the nursing model and the medical model of care. I happen to work with both models. However, I am an atheist and agree with the statement that the above doc made to you as far as the science and biology involved.

The medical model, and forgive me for grossly oversimplifying a very complex issue, is the practice of treating the disease. The nursing model is the practice of treating the patient. .

So, what do Doctors do?
Surgical, pharmaceutical and similar interventions for medical problems.

Nurses do more teaching and helping the patient carry out the medical care and live with the disease if that is needed.

Both fields have considerable overlap which is why I said I was oversimplifying my description.

skepticdoc said:
What does atheism have to do with Medicine? Do you think that Evolution has anything to do with Medicine?
You brought up religion. I merely wanted to state my personal position so it was clear where I stood.

Right now there is a big hoopla in some circles over denial of evolution. Clearly it is a threat to some people's beliefs whether because they don't realize there have been advances in the field since they learned about evolution or whether it outright contradicts their religious convictions. But genetic science has provided overwhelming evidence supporting the theory of evolution. And recent advances in laboratory procedures that made it easier to study DNA have opened the floodgates for medical research in genetics. And I'm not just talking about research in inherited diseases.

Cancer research is going on at the genetic level. Not only are researchers looking at how tumor cells function by looking at their DNA but cancer vaccines are being developed and genetic triggers of tumor growth are being studied so they can be blocked.

We used to develop antibiotics by trial and error. Now we are analyzing the genes of viruses and designing drugs that block those viral genes. We are discovering how bacteria exchange genetic material spreading drug resistance to completely different species. We are looking for ways to design vaccines and anti-infectives so drug resistance is much slower to develop. For example parts of the influenza genome are more stable and parts of it mutate more readily. So drug and vaccine makers are trying to target the stable parts of the virus's genetic material.

The quote you posted from your physician friend reflects the direction of medical research.

skepticdoc said:
skeptigirl said:
Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need..

So, what is wrong with that?

I think I understand what you are trying to say, but it is not coming out right. I know of Oncologists that create false hopes and "torture" patients with chemo, instead of just arranging for palliative care. Most people want to be "cured", "made better" or just made more comfortable. In the Netherlands some even want to be "put out of their misery" (euthanasia?).
Another example is happening with the current human cases of H5N1. The drug Tamiflu only works if given in the first 48 hours after symptoms. Yet patients who are critically ill and have had symptoms >48 hours are being given Tamiflu. Why? Because it's too hard not to give it. Your patient is dying. They might be young. You want to do something, even if you know the research indicates it clearly won't help.

If an influenza pandemic occurs before more Tamiflu can be manufactured, the drug is going to be in short supply. Wasting it on patients who have had symptoms >48 hours will mean it isn't available for someone whom the drug would benefit. That will be harmful.

The problem isn't something inherently wrong with physicians or with medical care or the medical model. The issue is doctors are human. And their training and education is focused on doing something for the patient. When a physician is at a loss as to what to do, it is emotionally difficult.

There are many times when nurses have nothing to offer a patient as well and it is difficult for nurses too. It isn't that the nursing model always has something to offer and medicine doesn't. Try helping a borderline personality with their paranoia. Now there's a case where medication and maybe psych nurses might be able to provide care but the nursing model may not have much to offer the patient.

skepticdoc said:
So, who decides the complicated treatment plan? In the USA many physicians just go for the big money and delegate some of the most menial aspects of medical care to nurses, some of these nurses then think they know as much as doctors!

Some doctors perform at the level of nurses and diminish the caliber of the profession. I know of nurses and assistants that realize that there is more to know and then go to Medical School, they make excellent physicians!
I think you have an incorrect perception of medical and nursing care in the USA.

Let me give you an example. A complicated medical treatment plan might be the drug regimen that a person with HIV needs to take. It would include antivirals as well as prophylactic anti-infectives. That same medical plan imposes some very complex delivery problems for the patient. Certain drugs must be taken very close to the proper intervals. Some drugs are with food, some without. Some must be refrigerated. Some drugs might make the person nauseated or make vision blurry. It isn't a menial task to help the patient devise a drug regimen for this complicated medical plan. Nor is it sufficient to write all the prescriptions and just hand them to the patient and expect them to figure it out. Both medicine and nursing are required for such a patient.

As far as your comment about nurses going to medical school, that is an example of a doctor underestimating what nurses have to offer patients. Did you know you can get a PhD in nursing? Did you know that hospitals (not the ER, not the surgery units), exist mainly to provide nursing care for patients? Do you really think that nurse in the intensive care unit is just doing the menial work that a physician delegates? And hospice care here in the USA is much more a nursing function than a medical function. Medical care would include pain and other drug prescriptions but nurses would do much of the rest.

skepticdoc said:
If anybody has a "chip on her shoulder" it you, skeptigirl. I would too, if I misrepresented myself in the Forum.

True medical practice involves both prevention and treatment, both have to be based on SCIENCE, not opinion or faith or lack of.
Misrepresented myself? You're going to have to explain that one.

Are you unfamiliar with nurse practitioners? I have full medical privileges in WA State. It's up to me to know my competencies so I'm not saying I am qualified to practice brain surgery but then neither are all physicians. I have full prescriptive authority. I have a license to diagnose medical conditions just like any physician. And I have been in private practice for 15 years. I do not work with any physicians except I have several that call me when they want to consult about a health care worker exposed to blood. In fact several actually send me referrals because the follow up takes too much time which my practice is set up to handle.

As far as prevention goes, with the exception of pediatricians and public health physicians, most doctors in the USA are lacking in knowledge about follow up after specific infectious disease exposures. Perhaps I didn't make it clear that was the prevention I was talking about. I thought it was evident when I said I specialize in infectious disease. So let me ask you, if you have a patient with meningococcal meningitis do you investigate the persons exposed to your patient and treat them prophylactically? Do you know which contacts to treat and which don't need treatment? What do you do for a patient who comes in and says they have had a needlestick and they work in a dental office? Could you treat a patient who had contact with a possibly rabid bat or would you have to send them to someone else? I ask you these questions out of curiosity but also to explain what my practice focus is.

In the past the public health did most of such work. But laws were passed here in 1991 making employers responsible to pay for the care of employees exposed to blood. In addition, exposure to blood now requires more involved care than before. The public health needed to narrow its focus because funding was never intended to cover occupational hazards. Employers also began providing care for exposure to all infectious diseases in addition to blood exposures and my practice grew out of the changes.
 
I can no longer edit my post above but I misread skeptidoc's question.
skepticdoc said:
I am confused, is this oncology palliative care?
To which I replied, "End of life care." I was referring to my post about the advice I gave my Dad who died of cancer, not my practice. My practice is occupational infectious diseases. I treat exposed workers, I don't treat infected workers with a few exceptions.
 
Join up, and get in on discussions with Stephen and Harriet and...
Never mind, I found what I needed.

I want to respond to the catch a cold by being cold. The last post on it (15) makes the fallacious claim that cold weakens your immune system.
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl, you sure are long winded!

1) I believe Medicine is the opposite of evolution, allowing the weak to survive and even contribute to the gene pool

2) I don't mix evolution and religion, only religious and atheist fanatics do (different thread!) Even catholics accept evolution.

3) I'm still confused, are you a a Hospice nurse? ID? Oncology? A PhD in nursing is not a medical degree, never will!!! Just like a PhD in microbiology is not a medical degree, and microbiologists cannot prescribe antibiotics, even though they may know more about their actions than physicians. The medical education system has forced the medical students to be somewhat well rounded in looking at the whole picture, even when most will concentrate their efforts in a restricted medical field ( I would not want an Orthopedist doing my Cardiac Cath, nor the Cardiologist doing a catract extraction!).

What do you really do?

4) It was the money grubbing, procedure oriented cardiologists and cardiovascular surgeons that saved The Amazing One's life. The nurses provided the supportive care to carry out the treatment plan that DOCTORS ordered. Henry Ford invented the assembly line, I don't know how much mechanical engineering knowledge he had ( I do know he did not invent the automobile!). The factory workers build the cars, some can make suggestions in changing the assembly line process, or even some automobile design changes; nurses are equivalent to factory workers in the Healthcare industry.

Sorry to burst your bubble!
 
Last edited:
Skepticdoc you have a lot to learn about nursing care.

I would not want a doctor doing a nurse's job if I were in any intensive care unit. Nor would I want a doctor doing the nurse's job as I recovered from that bypass surgery. You are quite unaware of what nurses do if you think a patient only needs the surgery and medicine for that bypass and doesn't need the post op care given by nurses after the surgery.

And you did not answer my questions asking if you knew what to do for a person exposed to meningococcal meningitis, a contaminated needle or a rabid bat.

Of course a PhD in nursing is not a medical degree! Nurses are professionals in their own right and practice in their own field. I am shocked that a physician is not aware of that. Just where are you from? What a pity nurses there have such little recognition.

I will tell you for the third time, I am licensed as an Advanced Registered Nurse Practitioner with prescriptive authority. I am certified in family practice and in occupational health. I have a Master's degree in the Science of Nursing. In the state I live in I am licensed to practice both medicine and nursing. Nurse practitioners practice more basic medicine than physicians do, but our scope of practice isn't specifically limited. It's up to me to determine how far I believe my competency allows me to go.

I am an infectious disease specialist. No I am not a hospice nurse. No I do not practice in the field of oncology, though as a nurse I did work on a bone marrow transplant unit for a while. Which, incidentally is another area I wouldn't want to see the doctor doing the nurse's job!

Who takes care of ICU, CCU and bone marrow transplant patients where you live? Do you really think those nurses merely do menial tasks? Maybe where you live the nurses are not independent. Here they are. Doctors prescribe the medical care for the patient but there are many more things than that which the doctors do not control and which nurses do independent of the medical orders.

I wish you would take the time to read the posts I wrote instead of skimming them and asking questions I've already answered.
 
I am an Infectious Diseases specialist working in the NHS in the UK. I may not know how medical care is organised in the US, but I do know when a "doc" is being patronising about a nursing colleague.
 
I am an Infectious Diseases specialist working in the NHS in the UK. I may not know how medical care is organised in the US, but I do know when a "doc" is being patronising about a nursing colleague.

So, where else in the developed western world do nurses claim to be equal to physicians?
 
skeptigirl, what is your definition for Nursing?

For Medicine?

That way we can have a common ground to start a proper discussion of the topic.

Which questions did you want me to answer? Please enumerate them if you want an answer, I found your post a little difficult to follow rationally, to many topics jumbled together.

If you need medical guidance on how to handle the clinical problems I suggest you contact the Health Department in your state if you do not have an ID specialist in your area. You can also research www.emedicine.com for the specific medical conditions. ( Is that patronizing?!!)
 
Last edited:
I am an Infectious Diseases specialist working in the NHS in the UK. I may not know how medical care is organised in the US, but I do know when a "doc" is being patronising about a nursing colleague.
Thank you. I was having a hard time keeping my temper out of my posts and having a bit of support is immensely helpful.
 
Dear Skeptigirl,

I probably do not count but I do call on Nurse specialists on a daily basis.
I am a Medical Rep for a product used in the supportive care field. I can not go into detail but think of patients with bone mets at risk of pain and skeletal related events, fracture, spinal cord compression etc. I have spent my entire working life in Pharmaceuticals, either in sales, or training.
 
So, where else in the developed western world do nurses claim to be equal to physicians?
I assume by equal you mean in the jobs we perform. For that I have said over and over we have very different jobs to do. And I as a nurse practitioner do both jobs. If you want to argue equality in status or importance, then you have another issue altogether.

In my infinite wisdom I know that both professions are equally important. Society and people like yourself obviously don't know that. The pay discrepancy is one indication. I do think you will find that most people who have had an encounter with nurses caring for someone critically ill or ill for a long period of time come to understand the importance of nurses.

Another reason for the discrepancy however is the fact that nursing encompasses a wide spectrum of skilled workers. We don't do a good job in our profession of distinguishing between an RN with a 2 year college degree doing basic patient care and an RN with either a higher degree and/or extensive experience performing the most skilled care for critically ill patients.

We have begun to distinguish nurse specialists. Those are nurses who perform much more complex nursing in almost all fields. Such a nurse might manage chronically ill patients in a doctor's office or oversee the infection control in a hospital. The extent of specialized nursing is very wide. And as far as medicine is concerned, nurses in the USA provide medical care from family practice to anesthesia.
 
Can I add that when a DGH that I called on decided to develop a post MI protocol, this was manged and driven by the Nurse Specialist.

When a large fund holding primary care practice decided to develop a cardiac primary and secondary intervention protocol for CHD, again it was the nurse specialist who collated all the evidence and provided an evidence based intervention protocol. The Doctors were prepared to follow this.

I find in my job that nurses are very evidence based, ask searching questions, and seek to undertand the real implications for patients in terms of risk reduction either relative or absolute. I am more often asked for numbers needed to treat by a nurse. I treat all my customers with the same level of respect but I am often surprised at what each expects of me. I understand that to both Skeptigirl and Skeptidoc, I amy be viewed as the spawn of the devil, but I always do a good job and do the right thing for the patient who will at the end of the day end up benefitting from what I sell
 
skeptigirl, what is your definition for Nursing?

For Medicine?

That way we can have a common ground to start a proper discussion of the topic.
You don't seem to have read my posts. If you read what I posted the definitions are clearly described.

Which questions did you want me to answer? Please enumerate them if you want an answer, I found your post a little difficult to follow rationally, to many topics jumbled together.

If you need medical guidance on how to handle the clinical problems I suggest you contact the Health Department in your state if you do not have an ID specialist in your area. You can also research www.emedicine.com for the specific medical conditions. ( Is that patronizing?!!)
Oh pleeease! If I want medical advice? I am now beginning to wonder if you are who you say you are and not a troll. No doctor could be that ignorant.

I asked you those questions because those are medical problems I treat which many doctors do not know how to. Clearly you don't know how to treat patients with those needs or you would have said so. I wonder if you can even find the answers on the net. You can't seem to read my posts. Not a long enough attention span perhaps?
 
Can I add that when a DGH that I called on decided to develop a post MI protocol, this was manged and driven by the Nurse Specialist.

When a large fund holding primary care practice decided to develop a cardiac primary and secondary intervention protocol for CHD, again it was the nurse specialist who collated all the evidence and provided an evidence based intervention protocol. The Doctors were prepared to follow this.

I find in my job that nurses are very evidence based, ask searching questions, and seek to undertand the real implications for patients in terms of risk reduction either relative or absolute. I am more often asked for numbers needed to treat by a nurse. I treat all my customers with the same level of respect but I am often surprised at what each expects of me. I understand that to both Skeptigirl and Skeptidoc, I amy be viewed as the spawn of the devil, but I always do a good job and do the right thing for the patient who will at the end of the day end up benefitting from what I sell
Thank you as well. These are great examples.

The only sales people I equate with demons are the ones that relentlessly invade my home with sales calls. ;)

I developed both a protocol for treating uncomplicated UTIs and for treating MRSA in one hospital that contracts for my infectious disease services. I did so after multiple chart reviews showed the doctors were not prescribing the correct antibiotics these infections called for.
 
Last edited:
Somewhere I came across a piece of advice:

Don't wrestle with a pig in the mud, you get muddy and the pig likes it!
(There was also a variation involving the Devil, but that version would be offensive in a Randi/Skeptic Forum!)

skeptigirl, good luck with your life and work, I will not engage in any more exchanges with you.

It will make you feel better, You Win!!!!
 
...

It will make you feel better, You Win!!!!
I never doubted.

On the other hand you lose a chance to learn more about the world around you. Preconceived ideas that aren't subject to re-evaluation are what's wrong with the minds of many people on this planet. To find such a closed mind in the medical field, if you even are a doctor, is tragic.
 
Doctors and Nurses

I am not sure if it is an African or Brazilian folk tale, it is about division of labor, goes something like this:

Humans trained monkeys to do the work they did not want, the smart monkeys decided to train inferior monkeys to do that work, and this kept going on until you could not tell which were humans or trained monkeys. (extremely abreviated!)

If the shoe fits, wear it! ( or if the glove does not fit, you must acquit! -J.C.)
 
When did doctors ever perform nursing care?

You might start with reading a bit about the history of nursing care. It did not grow out of tasks delegated by physicians.

Where ever did you get the idea that medical orders were all it takes to treat the sick? That's unbelievable!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom