Medical and Healthcare phishing

A Family Doctor's Health Manifesto

1. Remember that we are on earth to serve God; listen to His messages in its various forms; don't hesitate to ask for His help......
Maybe you think that's why you're here. I certainly don't.

Golden rule??? I think you missed the point.

Originally Posted by skeptigirl:
"Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need.."

I rest my case,
Which is why it's good to have nurses advocating for their patients sometimes. Unless, I suppose, if "doc" thinks a peaceful death is indeed a "cure". I guess one could interpret it that way.

but I will not allow the impression that I am a troll.
I don't think you've succeeded in this goal just yet.

Seek medical attention to evaluate:

Any pain that you have not experienced before,
Any chest pain that you have not experienced before,
Any fever or chill,
Any bleeding,
Any numbness or weakness,
Any nausea, vomiting or inability to eat,
Any unexplained weight gain or loss,
Any shortness of breath,
Any unexplained falls,
Any changes in your vision or hearing,
Any problems with urination or inability to urinate,
Any problem with your bowels,
Any changes in your skin, any new lumps or bumps or changes in your birthmarks.
I'm not sure what to make of this list. Is our friend afraid the average reader here can not judge for themselves when to seek care? Is he afraid of giving accidental advice to someone who might be reading the thread and then make the wrong decision about something? Or perhaps he's saying only a doctor can tell you if any symptom you have is serious?

Any bleeding? So if you cut your finger cutting the carrots for your stew, and it bleeds, go to the doctor.

Any pain that you have not experienced before? So the first time you go to Disneyland and your feet hurt at the end of the day and that never happened before, go to the doctor.

Any fever or chill? Go to the doctor for every single mild sore throat/runny nose if your temperature goes to 99 or higher.

Any numbness or weakness? If you fall asleep with your hand bent under you and you wake up and it is numb, go to the doctor.

Any shortness of breath? When you run the bases this spring in your first softball game of the year and you get short of breath, go to the doctor.



Strange post. Strange personality.
 
Doctors have no problem with the manifesto.

The Skeptic Forum has not reacted yet.

Doctors understand, a patient that would seek attention for symptoms that are a normal part of life is crying for help with a different problem.
 
Doctors have no problem with the manifesto.

So all Doctors believe we're on earth to serve God (and that we can hear his messages)? Either that's not the case, or there's a secret conspiracy of religious doctors to stick to and hide this manifesto :p
 
So all Doctors believe we're on earth to serve God (and that we can hear his messages)? Either that's not the case, or there's a secret conspiracy of religious doctors to stick to and hide this manifesto :p

The majority of doctors are religious, there may be a higher percentage of agnostics and atheists in Medicine by virtue of scientific knowledge, I cannot give give you a percentage, I suspect it is low. That is why I started the thread, so far no physicians have identified themselves as such publicly or via PM.

The manifesto is my creation/opinion, when I wrote it I was not as agnostic as I am now. I am sure you have read about Spinoza! There can be a concept of God that is not "a personal savior". There are even deists in this forum!

I am an agnostic with deist tendencies, just not sure either way.
 
Hierarchy there may be, but janitorial and housekeeping staff are nowhere on it. We're not part of the medical profession.


Well janitorial/housekeeping should be on it.

Sanitation = Infection control.

The NYC Department of Sanitation ( = garbage pick up dept) carries a caduceus on its departmental seal and uniforms. See:

http://www.nyc.gov/html/dsny/html/home/home.shtml

Sanitation and janitorial/housekeeping workers are the first and last line of defense against infectious disease.

In hospitals they occupy a prominent role in the hierachy. Their name was changed years ago to reflect their position and are called "Patient Support Services" to get away from the stereotype of "housekeeping" or janitorial.
 
Last edited:
So... um, there were these 2 lizards, and one lizard said to another "remember not to get so caught up in the words that you forget the reason for the conversation."
 
I'm quite happy some doctors are being reminded of their duties to fellow humans to use their training properly:

Dutch MD's suspended for using alt/med

This is a sordid tale of ignoring conventional treatment in favor of ridiculous diagnostic techniques that resulted in ludicrous diagnoses and inevitably completely useless treatments that led to suffering and death.

The doctors were only following the wishes of their patient, but they are reminded of their responsibilities and punished (not enough imo) for their neglect.

How MDs can ignore their training and common sense is beyond me, but here are several that did.

B, who had previously been suspended for six months for using similar complementary treatments, has been banned from practising as a doctor. The tribunal suspended K for one year and D for six months. They concluded that despite Ms Millecam's known resistance to conventional treatment a registered doctor should have made it clear that such treatment
offered the only chance of recovery.

MDs, to me, have the primary responsibility of making sure their patients get proper care. Other staff must follow their protocol, their diagnosis, their treatment plan.

My personal agenda is to find ways to be honest with my patients when they are in terminal stages and talk about Jesus or whatever.

Be honest about their condition. Refer them to family or their religious leader to talk about anything not medical related (afterlife, etc.). Your opinion on this shouldn't enter into it, so just stick to the proper treatment and truth of the actual condition.
 
Last edited:
The manifesto is my creation/opinion, when I wrote it I was not as agnostic as I am now. I am sure you have read about Spinoza! There can be a concept of God that is not "a personal savior". There are even deists in this forum

Just to be pedantic, Spinoza's God isn't the type of thing that could have put us on earth for any purpose or give us messages.

I'd also see the primary professional responsibility of MDs as being to their patients, regardless of whether or not they believe in a deity or deities.
 
Just to be pedantic, Spinoza's God isn't the type of thing that could have put us on earth for any purpose or give us messages.

I'd also see the primary professional responsibility of MDs as being to their patients, regardless of whether or not they believe in a deity or deities.

Please be pedantic!

We may be where we are for some reason, I am not sure! I don't pray, I don't hear voices, I have never experienced anything supernatural, I am trying to exchange ideas with people that are willing to question anything!

I started reading the Spinoza.net articles, I am confused about what Spinoza believed in, I hope the philosophy does not get over my head!

I am trying to clarify in my own mind many concepts, if there is nothing spiritual, why should we care for the infirm when we know that they will not become productive members of society?

Why would an atheist care about another human being if it does not really matter at the end?

Before anybody jumps to conclusions or rushes to judgement, please read some of my posts in the Skeptic Forum, I use the same forum name! ( I don't want to repeat them here, at least not yet! )
 
Last edited:
Why would an atheist care about another human being if it does not really matter at the end?

It does matter, that's why. It matters to me that my children grow up in a reasonable world where they can reach their full potential and have healthy children themselves. What matters is the living, the LIVING. What matters is ethics, is humanism, being humane to each other, and minimizing pain in the LIVING. I care if others suffer, because I know, can imagine how horrible it would be to die of untreated cancer, to die at the hands of quacks. I want better for me, for others, for my children, for all LIVING beings.

I want to know that medical practitioners care for the LIVING properly. Not give them crap treatments that cause them to suffer and die in horrible pain.

It does not matter to me about what people figure the dead are up to. They are dead. It is the living that matter, they are the ones who suffer at the hands of others that have no respect for the rest of the those that are alive.

I want a healthy life, a relatively happy LIFE, a good life for my children and ancestors that live after I'm gone.
there is nothing spiritual, why should we care for the infirm when we know that they will not become productive members of society

Because they are ALIVE, they feel, and I'd want to be treated with some dignity even if I was considered "infirm". Who cares if they are productive? They are ALIVE, and didn't ask to be here. Do unto others. Make their lives livable, not painful and full of suffering. One day you may be an infirm due to an accident or disease, and you'd want to be treated humanely.
 
Last edited:
Spinoza defines God at the start of his ethics as "a being absolutely infinite--that is, a substance consisting in infinite attributes, of which each expresses eternal and infinite essentiality." He goes on to argue that "God, or substance, consisting of infinite attributes, of which each expresses eternal and infinite essentiality, necessarily exists." (all this is at http://www.spinoza.net/Theworks/Ethics/TSNEthicsPartI.htm) I'd read this as an argument that God is basically being - in Spinoza's pantheism, God is everything that is.

I'd read Spinoza's ethics as an ethics through which one can become more self-determining (instead of one's action's being determined by external factors) and increase one's power of action. Spinoza states that "I shall mean by, "good" that, which we certainly know to be a means of approaching more nearly to the type of human nature, which we have set before ourselves; by "bad," that which we certainly know to be a hindrance to us in approaching the said type. Again, we shall that men are more perfect, or more imperfect, in proportion as they approach more or less nearly to the said type. For it must be specially remarked that, when I say that a man passes from a lesser to a greater perfection, or vice versa, I do not mean that he is changed from one essence or reality to another; for instance, a horse would be as completely destroyed by being changed into a man, as by being changed into an insect. What I mean is, that we conceive the thing's power of action, in so far as this is understood by its nature, to be increased or diminished." (http://www.spinoza.net/Theworks/Ethics/TSNEthicsPartIV.htm) This is a long way from an ethics where one obeys the commands of God.

In terms of why an atheist would care about human beings, Eons gives one explanation of this nicely. The corresponding question, though, is whether belief in a conventional type of God necessarily means that one cares for human beings. If one only treats other humans well because one believes that is what God wants, what happens if one concludes that God wants people to be denied certain treatments (for example, abortion or blood transfusion); presumably, an omniscient and omnipotent God could also decide that He takes pleasure in the death and suffering of (certain) human beings. A religious person would still need to either decide that humans are worth caring about in and of themselves (in which case, they have pretty much the same problems an atheist would) or argue that we should treat humans well because God wants us to (in which case, they're not so much arguing that we should care about human beings, but that we should do what God wants us to do - which happens, for the moment, to involve caring about humans).
 
Thanks jon!

Now, my question to you is: what percentage of common people will understand your post?

I don't know if you are in the US, but I see looming crisis in the allocation of resources for healthcare, with families of demented elderly demanding everything that Medicine can offer, expecting Medicare and the States to pay for it at the same time that Americans do not want to pay more taxes to pay for those services!

Can somebody from the UK or Canada shed some light on the issue from their prspective?
 
Americans do not want to pay more taxes to pay for those services!

I would hope that rising costs of medical insurance and proper education on what is covered by said insurance would clear that up a bit. Why pay more taxes when you are tapped out on monthly medical insurance bills? My Alberta Health Care takes a sizeable chunk off of our take home pay. Add-ons include charges for long term and palliative care. People can either be taxed more, or be more savvy on what their insurance covers when they get older or in case of accidents, diseases, etc.
 
Eos, what is the percentage?
Percentage of take home pay?

Taxes and Health care premiums take about 25% of our gross pay each month. Health care charges/premiums are over 10% of our take home pay. They (both Alberta Health care and my additional Health Insurance) don't cover dental, and other "uneccessary" health care. My additional health insurance (over Alberta Health Care) covers70% of prescription charges. So, we have "adequate" coverage. I have long term insurance, but not short-term through my work Health Benefits, which I pay for myself off of my paycheque. Every work place offers different Health Care insurance plans on top of the payments for Alberta Health Care. If your workplace does not offer you health benefits, then you can add Alberta Blue Cross on top of Alberta Health Care. Every plan is different, and you have to research what is covered and ask for the options if you feel they will benefit you and your situation.

http://www.ab.bluecross.ca/

If you don't have supplemental insurance, then you have to pay 100% of prescription costs, and you have no disability or palliative care, etc. The costs for insurance coverage is over and above what you pay for Alberta Health Care already. Some folks would prefer to pay more taxes and less premiums. Some people here feel we already pay enough taxes to not have to pay so many premiums for extra insurance.
 
Last edited:
On disguised religion in thread topics

As I said, the more you read from a poster, the more that poster is revealed regardless of their stated claims. It seems the title of the thread, "Medical and Healthcare phishing", was not a complete title for the topic skepticdoc had in mind. Statements such as, "1. Remember that we are on earth to serve God; listen to His messages in its various forms; don't hesitate to ask for His help," may be revealing the actual intent of this forum member. Putting such a proclamation on the top of one's list contradicts the claim of being an agnositc. Proselytizers often think if they pretend to be something other than what they are, those of a more science oriented belief system will somehow be cleverly fooled into seeing some magic revelation that brings them to God. Were the poster to reveal his true intent those same science minded folks would otherwise dismiss those magic revelations out of hand.

On skeptidoc's overcompensated inferiority complex

I still can't put the 'doctor god' and 'inferior nurses and everyone else who isn't a doctor', quite into perspective here. Certainly statements like "live by the Golden Rule" and, "I am trying to exchange ideas with people that are willing to question anything!" are in direct contradiction to doc's revealed sentiments. Perhaps it's a part of his personality he just can't let go of. Perhaps it's a cultural thing and he's from one of those dysfunctional male dominated cultures. But I digress.

On the nonsense morality is based in religious beliefs

Deism appears to me to be a mere rationalization that there is a god despite there being no observable evidence. Some people just can't let go of that religious meme instilled in them as kids, that belief in god is purposefully based on faith and lack of evidence is a test of your faith. It is a clever self protecting meme. Lack of evidence becomes the evidence. How do you ever conclude absence of evidence is evidence of absence?

While such a scientific premise, lack of evidence is not evidence, might be an appropriate concept when it comes to things in the Universe such as ET lifeforms, it isn't a useful premise with everything we believe in or don't believe in. There is abundant evidence many theist beliefs are false. We have evidence Zeus doesn't throw lightning bolts and Pele isn't at war with the sea. So why stop there? If there is as much evidence for flying spaghetti monsters and invisible pink unicorns as there is for the God of the Bible, then the accumulated lack of evidence for gods at least 'suggests' evidence of absence.

skepticdoc said:
why should we care for the infirm when we know that they will not become productive members of society?

Why would an atheist care about another human being if it does not really matter at the end?

The idea one only cares for others and/or acts in any other supposed 'moral' way because one holds religious beliefs is ludicrous. It is another religious meme propagated as a truth despite it's absurdity. Are these believers supposedly caring for another human being because they fear a god's wrath? Are they caring for another because they have been instructed to do so by Jesus? Jon's last paragraph is exactly what has occurred in history. A great many have concluded, and in fact it is recorded exactly that way in the Bible, that God instructs people to slaughter other human beings including infants and children. Biblical violence and cruelty is some of the most disgusting vile and immoral crap you can find.

skepticdoc said:
in the US, ... I see looming crisis in the allocation of resources for healthcare, with families of demented elderly demanding everything that Medicine can offer, expecting Medicare and the States to pay for it at the same time that Americans do not want to pay more taxes to pay for those services!
Interesting that "families of demented elderly demanding everything Medicine can offer" is the example used by the same person who claimed doctors were there to cure and a nurse advocate for assisting a patient in a peaceful death was a threat to that patient. Again, I digress but it's so satisfying to point out the hypocrisy of this person. ;)

On health care financing issues

Most people with medical insurance and those that do pay the costs of health care are completely unaware that they, and not the taxpayers support a large portion of the cost of medical care for the uninsured. While there are Medicare and Medicaid taxpayer supported programs, and there are some taxes and donations that support some costs of public hospitals, patients who do not qualify for health care programs and costs not paid by hospital tax districts and donations come out of the hospital's bottom line. And where is that cost recouped? In the bills charged to those that do pay. The percentage varies depending on the amount of uninsured care provided in a region and the negotiating power of your medical insurance provider. Of course whether the insurance provider passes on the negotiated savings or merely pockets the extra profit is also variable.

Of course since those of us who pay for our medical care also pay taxes, we already pay for some universal health care. And we do so in the most inefficient way. A person with no means of paying shows up in the ED for health care where they cannot be turned away. Not only is it the most expensive place to provide health care, such people wait until they are sicker to seek care.

On the influences of market forces on health care

There are additional unseen costs to the public in the current private medical system many people would be surprised to know. Research and development dollars are more and more being invested in pharmaceuticals which bring in the greatest profits. Pretty obvious. But what isn't so obvious is the lack of R&D investments in pharmaceuticals that actually improve medical care for the population. The system is geared to be efficient in producing profits, but the cost is the system is no longer producing efficient health care.

Let me give you two examples. We are currently facing increasing antibiotic drug resistance. You would think that would create a market for new antibiotics to be developed. But one takes an antibiotic medication for a short period of time. And health care practitioners are advised to restrict the use of newer antibiotics to drug resistant infections in order to conserve the usefulness of the drugs for a longer period of time. On the other hand, a statin, which is a cholesterol lowering drug, will likely be prescribed for the rest of a person's life and given to a wide market.

Which is more profitable? Which will save more lives? Which do we have a higher priority for?

You could argue that heart disease kills more people currently than infections, (in the USA anyway). Unfortunately, in the near future, without new antibiotics, that trend will soon be reversed. In addition, there are already a number of statins on the market. A vary large share of pharmaceutical R&D investments go into copycat drugs that take a portion of a known market. Often "new and improved" really isn't improved, rather it is just different enough to not be a patent infringement.

You can see from these examples that having a goal of improving the corporate bottom line will not always result in the best outcome for people as capitalism's supply and demand mechanisms are supposed to provide.

I haven't yet addressed the global competition issues producers face when they compete against companies whose workers' health care is spread out over all companies through taxes rather than through insurance premiums for their employees only. This seems to be the one issue that is motivating change to universal coverage in the US. It seems capitalism will effect change for the better in this area, maybe. The Republican philosophy that government supported health care is bad, is competing with the Republican philosophy that what is good for business is good for the country. Pharmaceutical and insurance company lobbyists are competing with other manufacturers' lobbyists.

The new Massachusetts' law requiring everyone to carry medical insurance the same way one is required to carry car insurance may just be the compromise that results in a breakthrough. Insurance companies are better at keeping medical care costs in check than individuals or the government, but we better consider keeping insurance company profits in check with regulations as well. And the government must step in and fund R&D for products that benefit the public's health as well. The public has to recognize the results corporate profit motives have on society as well as the benefits capitalism has as an economic system.

On allocation including rationing of health care dollars

This is one of those issues most people are in denial about. How can you ethically deny health care to anyone? We ignore the fact a premature infant can consume millions of dollars of health care while the same resources could be spent on a million doses of measles vaccine that are not being provided to other children. We are outraged an insurance company would deny a bone marrow transplant to a woman with breast cancer but don't spend a lot of time thinking about uninsured children whose parents have mental illness or drug addiction.

Instead of focusing on those dilemmas, I say we if solved the problem of all the health care dollars wasted on unproven remedies, we'd have enough money to provide health care for everyone for many years to come.
 
Last edited:
Skeptigirl, I was wondering how long it was going to take for you to spread your vitriol.

What makes you think I am male?

Seems that you certainly like to be the center of attention, IMHO.

Maybe you had to step back, stop fuming and settle down to generate an acceptable post.

Do you have a positive contribution to the thread?

Before you go on a rampage against Deism, let me remind you that Hal Bidlack is a respected member of the Forum, atheism is not a requirement to participate last time I checked. Sorry to burst your atheist bubble! Again!
 
Last edited:
Thank you for all that skeptigirl! Especially for:
Instead of focusing on those dilemmas, I say we if solved the problem of all the health care dollars wasted on unproven remedies, we'd have enough money to provide health care for everyone for many years to come.
 
I thought I was on your ignore list, skepticdoc?

Nothing I have said has made a positive contribution to the thread?

Interesting you speak of attention getting yet ignore anything I post that doesn't have to do with you personally.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom