Medical and Healthcare phishing

I am not sure if it is an African or Brazilian folk tale, it is about division of labor, goes something like this:

Humans trained monkeys to do the work they did not want, the smart monkeys decided to train inferior monkeys to do that work, and this kept going on until you could not tell which were humans or trained monkeys. (extremely abreviated!)

If the shoe fits, wear it! ( or if the glove does not fit, you must acquit! -J.C.)
Hmmmmm, I smell a troll.


Boo
 
Dear Boo:

Believe what you want to believe.

I started the thread to find out who else was involved in Healtcare, like in the Skeptic Forum, very few answered.

I did not expect to find an atheist Nursing activist!

Only in the USA do doctors have to fight and argue with subordinates in the system. There have been no posts from european forum members supporting advanced nursing practice; I believe over there, if you want to be a doctor, you just go school and become one instead of trying to get around the rules. It is not only nurses, psychologists and optometrists want to prescribe medications in their respective fields in the USA!
 
So by asking for people involved in Healthcare, you weren't including nurses?

"Subordinates in the system", that's a great phrase :). The only involvement I have with the NHS is as a financial auditor of Trusts (yes, everyone's always happy to see their friendly local auditor). Trust board members may be unhappy when medical staff don't keep to budgetary limits, but wouldn't describe this as arguing with subordinates in the system. That's because they perform a different job, working to the same end. Isn't that how skeptigirl sees the split in roles?
 
I don't know what to make of skepticdoc. I would have thought he was just from another country where nurses have a different role. In Pakistan for example, nurses are considered "loose women" since they might look at a man's naked body. That suggests skepticdoc is not a troll.

But then I looked at his other posts and in one thread he talks of meeting other forum members near where he is in the US. That suggests a troll.

But then he seemed to have no clue what a nurse practitioner was and that would be highly unusual for any doctor in the US not to know. That suggests not a doctor.

But then he notes that he also resents other professions having been granted prescriptive authority besides advanced practice nurses. So he must have been lying about not understanding what I do. I haven't met a doctor lately that resented losing the 'good 'ol boy' system of elite medical practice but I know they are out there. That suggests he knew what I was saying all along and if he isn't a troll he certainly posted like one.

I should like to point out two things in that regard. Health care practitioners such as myself have much lower malpractice insurance rates than physicians because we haven't made all the mistakes and provided inferior care that the medical elite crowd would have had us believe. And, granting prescriptive authority to other professionals besides physicians has been expanding because it has been so successful.

If you really are a doctor, which I have serious doubts is true, you must be quite a joy to work with.

As to thread hijacking, skeptidoc, I never intended to change the direction of this thread but I don't believe there are threads which exclude members because they are not in the 'club'. You are the one who began this dispute by your total disrespect for anything I had to say, and for my profession, and toward me personally. I think the level of your responses has been very clear to everyone reading this thread except you.

You have had nothing substantive to say regarding my comments so you ignored them and posted insults instead. This is an evidence based forum. The members here see through that tactic with ease.

But if you wish to drop your nonsensical air of superiority which no one here accepts anyway, and recognize the value of what people have to say on the merits of what they actually say I'm sure you could get your thread back on track. Or maybe you wish to start a new one, "Phishing for doctors who think they are better than anyone else and nurses who know their place". That ought to get some interesting responses.
 
They say be careful what you wish for, you may get it!!

If I do not respond to some message, it is because I may have placed the author in my ignore list. I love that feature, life is too short to take BS!!

Mashuna, maybe you can provide me some references to learn about the British healthcare system, most phsicians in the USA are not knowledgable about the system that most are afraid of, SOCIALIZED MEDICINE! Either post it in the thread or send me a PM.

In the state where I work, I write orders in the patient chart. The hospital nurses implement the orders for medical care, they are required to make sure that the order will not harm the patient ( overlooked allergies, for example ).
I write orders, not suggestions; the orders have to be followed by subordinates. I can't order another doctor to do anything, I can consult a specialist, who in turn gives more orders and may perform some procedures as may be indicated.

I came in contact with the JREF looking for ways to fight quackery, I have become more aware of the influence of religion in healthcare and government policies ( research the reported works of Jesus in the gospels ). I am still trying to be an honest agnostic physician, I will have to find out how other physicians have come to terms from them.

The lesson I have learned from the JREF forum is that I will have to find my answers somewhere else!
 
In Wa State we have a more progressive definition of nursing in the law. Nurses work for the patient, not the physician. Ignored or not I have a different perspective on those "orders". A physician orders medical care for the patient. They are not orders for the nurse. The hospital hires nurses to provide nursing care for the patient. If the nurse does not follow a particular medical order, the physician cannot fire the nurse unless the physician is the employer. I have never been fired.

Sometimes passive aggressive nurses who have to put up with physicians like skepticdoc know how to call such "superiors" at all hours of the day and night on a regular basis lest the lowly nurse dare make an independent decision. Yes, be careful what you wish for, doctor unless you don't mind needless phone calls at 3 am.

I have never been passive aggressive. I just make the decision and ignore physicians who mix up nursing care with medical care. For physicians who I disagree with about medical decisions, I don't argue, I provide the research. If they have something to offer, I learn something new. If they were wrong, they have the research to respond to not me. It works quite well.


Of course, I'm still not convinced skepticdoc is really a doctor. I haven't seen any posts from him yet that sound like one who is knowledgeable about medicine. Perhaps time will tell.
 
I am also extremely dubious that Skeptidoc is a qualified MD.

In the UK we do not write "orders" for "subordinates" to follow. We may determine what particular therapy/management/investigations need to be carried out, and these tasks are usually delegated to others. But nurse practitioners/specialists are crucial in managing and treating many of our patients. Almost every day I find I might be following a course of action actually advised by a specialist nurse practitioner - examples may be which inhaler regimen would suit a patient with airways disease best, which palliative drugs can best offer pain relief to someone with terminal cancer, etc.

Even though I am a specialist in Infection, that doesn't mean I know everything about infection in its broadest sense. For example, if the Control of Infection Nursing Officer recommends a particular course of action to control an outbreak of C. difficile diarrhoea, or prescribes an MRSA clearance regimen for one of my patients, I am highly unlikely to overrule this because of some inflated sense of superiority and self-importance. In a specialist area, a nurse may well know far more than I do. I am sure this applies in Public Health as well as other areas of medicine.
 
I am also extremely dubious that Skeptidoc is a qualified MD.

In the UK we do not write "orders" for "subordinates" to follow. We may determine what particular therapy/management/investigations need to be carried out, and these tasks are usually delegated to others. But nurse practitioners/specialists are crucial in managing and treating many of our patients. Almost every day I find I might be following a course of action actually advised by a specialist nurse practitioner - examples may be which inhaler regimen would suit a patient with airways disease best, which palliative drugs can best offer pain relief to someone with terminal cancer, etc.

Even though I am a specialist in Infection, that doesn't mean I know everything about infection in its broadest sense. For example, if the Control of Infection Nursing Officer recommends a particular course of action to control an outbreak of C. difficile diarrhoea, or prescribes an MRSA clearance regimen for one of my patients, I am highly unlikely to overrule this because of some inflated sense of superiority and self-importance. In a specialist area, a nurse may well know far more than I do. I am sure this applies in Public Health as well as other areas of medicine.
Well now that this thread is sort of hijacked, (or maybe not given the initial intent as I read it), ...

So they do have advanced practice nurses in the UK? I'm so pleased to hear that. I hadn't really been paying attention and now that you mention the practice is wider than just the USA, I'd like to know a bit more.

Anyone care to tell us about the rest of Europe, Canada and Australia? I know Australia has the Flying Doctor Service that relies heavily on nurses practicing in advanced roles. Are those roles formalized?

As far as specialists go, the reason my practice does so well is that it has a very narrow focus which I can then maintain a high level of competency for. And as much as there is in medicine to know now, and as fast as new research is being done, it's very hard for every practitioner to to keep their knowledge base up to speed.

Antibiotic recommendations in light of the ongoing increase in drug resistance is a case in point. The infection control practitioner would be getting regular reports from the lab regarding the trend in drug resistance showing up on cultures. That practitioner may also be in touch with colleagues that work in other hospitals who share information so the infection control person will also have the information on community wide drug resistance. Any physician could obtain the same information but other areas of medicine demand the same level of data collecting. You just can't do it all. So the infection control practitioner is a critical member of the team.
 
To whom it may concern:

If you have any questions about who I am, send me a PM and I will provide you with proof.

I enrolled in a physician forum and received 3 replies to my questions within 48 hrs, of course, in that forum you had to prove you were a physician to participate, here you just provide a name and an email address.

How do I know that the responders to the thread are not some teenager geeks or even perverted sexual deviants? I received only one response to my inquiry, I choose to believe this person, the tone was different, and he was not a physcian.

So Good Night, and Good Luck!
thanks for the responses, B-Bye!
 
To whom it may concern:

If you have any questions about who I am, send me a PM and I will provide you with proof.

I enrolled in a physician forum and received 3 replies to my questions within 48 hrs, of course, in that forum you had to prove you were a physician to participate, here you just provide a name and an email address.

How do I know that the responders to the thread are not some teenager geeks or even perverted sexual deviants? I received only one response to my inquiry, I choose to believe this person, the tone was different, and he was not a physcian.

So Good Night, and Good Luck!
thanks for the responses, B-Bye!
You don't know who we are but after a while you can figure out a lot about people from their posts.
 
If you really are a doctor, which I have serious doubts is true, you must be quite a joy to work with.
I also seriously doubt that he's a doctor, but he's not all that different from some I've encountered.

I'm not a medical professional myself, but I have inlaws who are, including my partner's father. I've dealt with a lot of doctors and other medical professionals both through him and through others. And I've encountered more than one old crank like Skepticdoc who thinks he's God Almighty descended to earth; and who treats nurses and orderlies as sub-human slaves. They're generally condescending and rude to anyone but another doctor with a similar attitude; and are generally pretty poorly skilled relative to their own sense of self-importance. Not doctors I would want to go to for even a routine physical, let alone anything serious; which I know by experience.

Personally, I'm willing to bet that this belligerant individual is either a first-year med student already starting to develop the "Doctors are superior beings and you're all just scum by comparison" attitude; or someone who has a lower-level medical degree of some sort, not an MD, and uses a title like "consultant". He doesn't quite have the air of an old-school MD.

And personally, for more routine medical care, I find a much prefer seeing a Nurse Practitioner; since they're often much more willing to listen to me, and work with me on treatment. Doctors have a tendency to simply assume that they know what's wrong, and try to fit people into some preferred little treatment box regardless of what might be wrong. Assuming that they don't simply dismiss patient concerns out of hand. I've had too much personal experience with doctors claiming I have something, or denying I have something, based on an atypical result on some particular test; then having another doctor tell me something entirely different based on the same result. As well as doctors who prescribe potentially dangerous treatments, without taking the necessary precautions, and simply dismissing concerns with an offhand, I'm-a-doctor-and-you're-just-an-ignorant-peon how-dare-you-question-me? response.
 
A Family Doctor's Health Manifesto

1. Remember that we are on earth to serve God; listen to His messages in its various forms; don't hesitate to ask for His help.

2. Develop your potentials and skills to the fullest extent possible, God gave them to you to help others.

3. Practice the Golden Rule; treat others the way you would like to be treated.

4. Honor and respect your elders; the way you treat your parents will be the guide your children will follow to treat you.

5. Listen to your spouse, children, and/or significant other; show them you love them as often as you can.

6. Enjoy life and the blessings that you have received with your family; sing, dance, fish, play, run, go to the theater, watch a movie, get a pet, etc.; remember to thank God for everything that you have received.

7. If you don't object to wine, consume only one glass of red wine a day, at dinner with your family, never operate a motor vehicle under the influence. If you object to wine, or are an alcoholic, drink purple grape juice.

8. Don't smoke anything.

9. Eat a balanced diet; large amounts of fruits and vegetables, complex carbohydrates and small amounts of fat and protein, enjoy your meals, brush and floss your teeth. Don't overeat.

10. Exercise

11. Listen to your body, don't abuse it, and rest after exercise or hard work.

12. Share with your doctor all your concerns about soul, mind, body and family.

Seek medical attention to evaluate:

Any pain that you have not experienced before,
Any chest pain that you have not experienced before,
Any fever or chill,
Any bleeding,
Any numbness or weakness,
Any nausea, vomiting or inability to eat,
Any unexplained weight gain or loss,
Any shortness of breath,
Any unexplained falls,
Any changes in your vision or hearing,
Any problems with urination or inability to urinate,
Any problem with your bowels,
Any changes in your skin, any new lumps or bumps or changes in your birthmarks.
 
A Family Doctor's Health Manifesto


3. Practice the Golden Rule; treat others the way you would like to be treated.

Is this a manifesto *for* family doctors, or only their *orders* to everyone else?

If it is meant *for* you, you might want to review this entire thread and your (evident) attitude toward skeptigirl in particular and nurses in general in light of #3 (above).

Cheers,
Dave
 
Interpret it as you wish.

There is a hierarchy in any organization, it probably is in our genes. In the hospital somebody has to give orders for the medical care, others implement the orders, somebody has to assist some patients with their personal hygiene ( wipe their .....) and others have to mop the floor and clean the bathroom etc., etc....
I one of my hospitals the administration implemented an elctronic medical record and I and everybody else had to learn how to use it, no arguement, no discussion!

Science respects only facts, not personalities.

Re read the posts, you seem to conveniently ignore some statements like:

Originally Posted by skeptigirl:
Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need..

I rest my case, but I will not allow the impression that I am a troll.

BTW, I have yet to receive any outside references on any european medical system organization.

How do YOU define the role of the physician and the nurse?
 
Hierarchy there may be, but janitorial and housekeeping staff are nowhere on it. We're not part of the medical profession.
 
We are all part of healthcare, a clean environment may even be one of the more important factors to prevent the spread of nosocomial diseases.

Doctors are notorious for not washing their hands between patient exams, RNs and LPNs have better health hygiene practices than Doctors! ( it even goes back to the late 1800s, doctors who performed autopsies spread puerperal fever and sepsis )
 
That list seems like a good way to wind up both patient and doctor :) If a dr tells me God does/does not want me to do or experience something, that would be a good reason to consider finding another dr...

I can just imagine going to my dr with questions about having/not having a soul - I don't think they're trained to deal with that (except occasionally as mental illness). And would you really want a patient to visit the dr every time they were nauseous (hungover?) or bleeding (what about a paper cut?) I could go on, but won't...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom