Medical and Healthcare phishing

Just answer the question:

Originally Posted by skeptigirl :
"Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need."


Who does not want to be cured if a cure is possible?
 
Without looking back to see the context, I'd say that depends on whether the cure is worse than the condition.

[edit] This is my personal answer, based on my condition. YMMV.
 
Who does not want to be cured if a cure is possible?
Without looking back to see the context, I'd say that depends on whether the cure is worse than the condition.....
In addition, the decision of which is worse is for the patient to make and it will differ in many cases. It will sometimes differ in the same patient over time.

I also had in mind people who were terminally ill and in their final disease stages. S'doc only added "if there were a cure" in the above post.

So let me give you two scenarios before getting back to the post I did not finish answering.

Skepticdoc totally berated nurses in this thread when I told a brief, true anecdote about my own father's death. This quote is from my post on page one:
...when my Dad was dying of cancer. He had liver metastases and was getting acites from the liver damage. He told the doctor of the discomfort and the doctor offered him a surgical treatment called a Levine shunt. I explained to my Dad the experience my patients in the hospital had had with the shunt and the positive and negative he could expect from it. My Dad decided against the shunt. He died a little over a week later. I was very glad to have been able to offer him the informed choice instead of having a doctor say we can do this for your problem without knowing what the patient really experienced from the procedure.

Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need.
I have seen many patients with cirrhosis of the liver come in the hospital with Levine Shunts in place or to have them put in. If you have cirrhosis, while it is terminal without a transplant, a person may have many many months left to live. My Dad had terminal cancer with spread to the liver. He was in liver failure. He had days to live.

I know from experience the shunts do a poor job of relieving discomfort of acites. If you have months to live, a shunt will benefit you since the fluid will continually leak into the abdomen until hydrostatic pressure is equal inside and outside of the blood vessels. That puts a lot of pressure on your abdominal blood vessels. The shunt takes fluid from the abdomen and dumps it back into a major vein in your chest. The acites does not go away. It improves but by < 20-30% at best but that's enough to keep blood flowing at least. If you only have days to live, the amount of relief is not worth the pain of the surgery. I know this because comfort and coping with liver disease is in the nursing field of expertise.

The physician in my Dad's case either didn't realize how little relief the shunt provided or offered it anyway since it was all he had to offer. Surgical intervention in this case is in the medical field. Nursing care more than medical care was what my Dad needed at that point in time. And I don't mean nursing care as in feeding and bathing, I mean nursing care as in professional advice (or "nursing orders" to put it in terms skepticdoc might possibly begin to understand) on how to best obtain comfort and a peaceful death.

Now if you doubt that some physicians are clueless about prescribing comfort and peaceful dying as part of their medical care, read skepticdoc's reply to the above account:
To Skeptigirl:

Before I unleash my wrath against you, I need to know a couple of things.

Are you practicing in the USA?

Would you have sent Randi to the undertaker with nursing comfort?
Fortunately, just as nurses often know a lot of medicine, most doctors are not quite as far off the scale as skepticdoc when it comes to knowing the nursing side of patient care. Patients need both medical care and nursing care. Like the patients who have TB I mentioned in my previous post. The antibiotics won't work if the nurse doesn't assist the patient to take the full course. And the nurse couldn't treat the patient without the medicine. Pain medicine provides comfort but in many cases one needs more than just pills.

For the other example, it is exactly the point Meffy is making. Patients do not always choose to take what medicine is ordered. Talk to just about any HIV infected patient who has to take 30-40 pills/day, on a rigid schedule. Drug X can't be mixed with drugs a & b. B & c can't be taken with food but drugs y & z have to be with food. Drugs a, b & x cannot be off schedule by more than 30 minutes and so on. Then there is the problem of taking the drugs when you can't keep them down. Which ones can you skip and for how long? What's the trade off? Can you take a whole day off meds or a week? And this goes on now the rest of your life. This kind of patient requires both very intensive nursing care and very extensive medical care. It is not a simple matter of merely writing up a drug list and time schedule. Care for HIV infected patients requires an advanced practice nurse if one is available.
 
Last edited:
Cave Dave, you earn more than some doctors. I know of ER/Urgent Care positions that pay $50/hr.
I did not mean to imply, when I stated our shop rate, that I kept all of that $75.00 (I get a percentage per billable hour I generate).

My point was that even though we don't advertise, and we charge a higher rate than the majority of shops in our area, many owners of high-end vehicles (many are physicians and other professionals) seek us out because we have a reputation of solving problems that the authorised dealeships and other shops have given up on.

[sidebar]
It has been said that physicians have it easy compared to automotive technicians: Physicians only work on one *make* produced in two *models* that are the same design year-to-year, and most of their work is performed in clean, well-lit, climate-controlled areas, mostly with the subject comfortably within reach from a sitting or standing position.

Automotive techs must have the ability to rapidly become knowlegable in dozens of various systems on dozens of makes with dozens of models or variations each, which all change, to varying degrees, at least once a year.

What I am mostly involved with is not old-style *grease monkey* work, but complicated powertrain, convenience, and comfort control electronics that are almost never adequately described in the available literature and require body positions that resemble carnival contortionism, and educated guesswork on whatever interfering parts need removal to just get a *peek* at the component, much less to gain access for testing.

This must all be accomplished in a variety of conditions where poor lighting, extreme temperatures, and a stunning assortment of filth are predominant. Often the customer places one in a time-bind that they refuse to negotiate, and watches over ones shoulder, patting their foot, and questioning every move one makes. Great fun.:D

But for me, that is the challenge that I relish: make it right *despite* the odds.
[/sidebar]

[grammar police]
skepticdoc said:
...they do not want to waddle in the mud with the forum crowd or myself! ...
The word should really be ME

It gets my goat how a few pompous blowhards adopted that (incorrect) form years ago, and now everyone seems to think that they sound more sophisticated when they use it! :mad: :mad:
[/grammar police]

Cheers,
Dave
 
Hi Skeptigirl,

Sorry to interrupt this thread, but I have a technical question with regards the Levine shunt.

Would an ascitic tap - (the needle and draining off the fluid from the belly whilst running albumin through) intermittently not work as effectively as a Levine shunt?

I would appreciate your thoughts on this.

Although I have spent a lot of time in the US - doing training in bodywork modalities and physical therapy, I am based in the UK now. I must say that the training I gained in the US was great and I would not have missed these opportunities for the world.
 
...[continued]...
I am probably wasting a little energy explaining myself to this crowd, but I believe taking care of patients, curing ailments that can be cured, and providing comfort/palliative care requires many different people and skills. From the garbage collector to the Neurosurgeon, everybody plays an important part. Skeptigirl probably agrees with that, but she is not going to admit that we both agree on this point!
Finally an admission one's profession does not make one superior to another. But judging from the rest of your post here, you're just mouthing the words.

Re-read the thread, the impression I get from this "skeptigirl" is that either she is a Super-Woman, or delusional.

She wrote:
"first I have a solo practice in occupational infectious disease"

I interpret that as she is the only nurse in her hospital working with employees that handle hazardous waste, are exposed to bodily fluids or have suffered needlesticks/puncture wounds.
If you didn't have tunnel vision when it comes to nurses it might have dawned on you I have my own private practice. I am the only provider in the practice. It's a practice, s'doc, you know, like the one you maybe have? There is an office, you see patients there. It is a unique practice, but it is like any other medical practice in how it is set up. My patients work for fire departments, police departments, cities, security firms, dental practices, nursing homes, home health agencies, and doctors offices.

I also provide education and consulting services for those same employers and one small hospital all of whom contract with my practice to provide occupational infectious disease services for their employees. And in the case of the hospital they contract with me to provide infection control services as well. I write policies including recommended medical protocols for treatment of infections in the hospital that pays me for that service. And at the hospital I also see patients who have infections if requested by either the nurses or the doctors. I also review all of the charts of anyone who is prescribed an anti-infective agent or is reported on the infection list. I use the epidemiology data to manage infection control there.

Reminds me, one of the first policy changes I made there was to give the nurses the authority to order isolation for a patient.

Later she wrote:
"The medical model, and forgive me for grossly oversimplifying a very complex issue, is the practice of treating the disease. The nursing model is the practice of treating the patient."

"Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need."

"I practice in both fields. I think you may have gotten the impression I was judging one field as better than the other. Absolutely not. They compliment each other
.

What are Skeptigirl two fields of practice?
Does she have a split personality, Doctor-Nurse, Nurse-Doctor?
Who does not want to be cured?!!!!!!
The problem here s'doc, isn't that I haven't explained my role, it's that you are having a hard time understanding what nurses in general do. You don't seem to have a concept of an entire profession. Yet I gave example after example of nursing practice and medical practice. I gave you examples of nurses who in addition to nursing, also provide medical care and doctors who in addition to medicine, provide nursing care. This is where I begin to question your being a doctor. I find it simply incredulous you have no clue about a profession where one can earn a Doctorate in Nursing Science.

Meffy and I both addressed the desire for cure question in a previous post.

I asked: So, what do Doctors do?

Skeptigirl wrote:
Surgical, pharmaceutical and similar interventions for medical problems.

Nurses do more teaching and helping the patient carry out the medical care and live with the disease if that is needed.

Both fields have considerable overlap which is why I said I was oversimplifying my description.


So, is that her limited vision of Medical Practice, or just her own justification for her anti-doctor prejudice?
Why does she want to do pharmaceutical interventions, is that the field of doctors?
Actually it was my dumbing down the explanation just for you since you didn't comprehend what everyone else reading the thread did. Why would I prescribe an anti-infective agent? Maybe because that's my specialty? Maybe because I have the education and license to do so? Maybe because people sometimes need prophylaxis if they've been exposed to an infectious agent or treatment if they have an infection?

Is my view of medical practice limited? Is that question supposed to convince anyone of that fact in light of all the things I've posted here, or is it just you who can't tell how unlimited my vision actually is?

I asked: So, where else in the developed western world do nurses claim to be equal to physicians? There was no answer.
None that you understood anyway.

I have no doubt you haven't impressed anyone in this forum with your superior reading skills, debating skills, knowledge base or common sense. So if you are the 'doctor' example, I'm not equal, I'm no doubt far superior.

Other than that, I have a long post above specifically answering that question. Since all you can muster is a straw man in response to all I've had to say, I took the time to deal with it. I'm happy to discuss my profession where I know other people are reading it. You may not get it yet but other forum members might be discovering more about nurses than they had previously known.

Skeptigirl wrote:
"Another reason for the discrepancy however is the fact that nursing encompasses a wide spectrum of skilled workers. We don't do a good job in our profession of distinguishing between an RN with a 2 year college degree doing basic patient care and an RN with either a higher degree and/or extensive experience performing the most skilled care for critically ill patients.

We have begun to distinguish nurse specialists. Those are nurses who perform much more complex nursing in almost all fields. Such a nurse might manage chronically ill patients in a doctor's office or oversee the infection control in a hospital. The extent of specialized nursing is very wide. And as far as medicine is concerned, nurses in the USA provide medical care from family practice to anesthesia."


In my little corner of the world, there is great division and stratification of nursing duties in the hospital from PCT, to LPN, to RN, to CRN, to CCRN, to CRNA. Many times this division involves dumping the less glamorous duties to the whoever is lowest in the Totem pole, and sometimes I see LPNs that are care more about the patient and are more medically competent than RNs!
If this is a true picture of your little corner, you are practicing in one sorry place. And such places do indeed exist. It is not a good representation of the nursing profession at all though.

In my years of being a nurse, before I began this practice, I had worked in big hospitals, little ones, in med/surg, pediatrics, ICU/CCU, bone marrow transplant, ED, employee health, public health and as an NP in a family practice clinic. It really adds to one's knowledge base to see such a wide variety of work places. Not only have I picked up a broad experience in practice, I saw functional and very dysfunctional work sites. I saw people complain constantly, always blaming the other department, the other shift, or someone. I saw many of what I consider more blue collar nurses. Go to work, go home, not a lot of ambition to get better at one's job. Even a good nurse, when put in such a setting can end up having some of it rub off.

Then there are the rest of us. Professionals, college educated or very experienced or both, very good at what we do and very ambitious to always learn something else, something new. If you can't figure that out because you have that limited view, I recommend at least making an effort to learn about what the rest of the nurses in the world are up to. Just because you work in a crappy place is no excuse for ignorance.

Skeptigirl wrote:
"Any bleeding? So if you cut your finger cutting the carrots for your stew, and it bleeds, go to the doctor.

Any pain that you have not experienced before? So the first time you go to Disneyland and your feet hurt at the end of the day and that never happened before, go to the doctor.....


I only interpret this as mocking signs and symptoms of potentially serious diseases/conditions.
Your "General Practitioner's Manifesto", which you thought was so good you posted it in at least two forums, merely represents some fantasy that your advice to people in that statement is actually desired or even needed by those people. There is no evidence based medicine in your "manifesto". I already responded to this whining. You're ignoring the post that challenges your manifesto. If you care to respond to the real issue instead of this cop out, I'll be happy to defend my position. In the meantime, as I said before, the members of this forum are skeptics. They know a dodge when they read one.

Originally Posted by skepticdoc:
in the US, ... I see looming crisis in the allocation of resources for healthcare, with families of demented elderly demanding everything that Medicine can offer, expecting Medicare and the States to pay for it at the same time that Americans do not want to pay more taxes to pay for those services!

Originally Posted by skeptigirl:
"Interesting that "families of demented elderly demanding everything Medicine can offer" is the example used by the same person who claimed doctors were there to cure and a nurse advocate for assisting a patient in a peaceful death was a threat to that patient. Again, I digress but it's so satisfying to point out the hypocrisy of this person."

Where is the hypocrisy?
Where's your cure for that demented elderly patient? For that matter, where's any medical treatment that might help the family and demented elderly person? Perhaps you would apply chemical restraints for the old person and tell family their needs are low priority in the doctor's handbook so tough luck?

You want to know what I do for a health care worker exposed to some deadly disease that doctors don't do? I address their fear as well as the potential infection. And I consider that fear to be a very high priority in treating the patient.

The above family needs nursing intervention. They don't need scorn from a physician who can't be bothered with another's needs if those needs aren't solvable with a pill. The hypocrisy is in a physician who claims nurses merely carry out medical orders then uses an example without recognizing the nurse, not the doctor is what the patient in the example needs.

Skeptigirl wrote:
"I teach infectious disease precautions to health care workers. I often include examples of what I call tunnel vision. I learned it from another nurse teaching ED nurses how to assess a patient in the ED. The patient in question had an ax literally stuck in his forehead. What do you do? Unless there is an artery spurting from the ax wound (your airway breathing circulation check), you do your normal head to toe assessment of the patient. Turned out the guy also had an icepick stab wound in the heart that if it wasn't addressed first would have killed him."

So are you just repeating an anecdote? Are you also a Trauma Nurse?
So, was the example and following discussion just over your head? You didn't get it because you don't recognize your own tunnel vision?

Why bother with this kind of reply? Other people read the post. I wrote the post. We all know what is in the post or can go read it if we don't know. Who is it you are talking to in this thread that you believe will just ignore what I wrote about tunnel vision and take this little picked cherry you have repeated as if it were meaningful alone? Skepticdoc, you are the only one.

Skeptigirl wrote:
"The medical care I provide overlaps into my field of ADVANCED NURSING PRACTICE. The nursing care the physician in my example provides overlaps into his medical practice. Nurses are not doctors as well, doctors are not nurses. But we both have critical roles in the health care field. You can't treat TB effectively with either medicine or nursing alone.

You can't treat a critically ill patient without both doctors and nurses. You can't perform major surgery without nurses. Doctors haven't delegated the tasks they don't want to perform to nurses. We arrived in the field on our own, thank you. And we developed nursing care on our own as well. And whether or not you, skepticdoc, drop your foolish attitude about nursing and medicine, I have very much enjoyed this opportunity to educate a few forum readers as to just what nursing practice actually is."


So do you agree that nowhere are doctors and nurses equal?
This has been replied to. How many times are you going to ask the same question yet never read the answer? I think anyone else reading this thread has had that question answered to their satisfaction. Maybe if you read the answers a couple more times....

In some underdeveloped countries, they deliver care without nurses or doctors, the use people that can read and follow a protocol that has been developed to deliver medical care, they probably still have "Barefoot Doctors" in rural areas of China.

Still no doctors have replied to my first post, maybe its like Baptists at Hooter's (they don't recognize each other!) or they do not want to waddle in the mud with the forum crowd or myself! Either way I have found my answer in the physician-only forum.
This is hilarious. Are we supposed to be impressed?
 
Hi Skeptigirl,

Sorry to interrupt this thread, but I have a technical question with regards the Levine shunt.

Would an ascitic tap - (the needle and draining off the fluid from the belly whilst running albumin through) intermittently not work as effectively as a Levine shunt?

I would appreciate your thoughts on this.

Although I have spent a lot of time in the US - doing training in bodywork modalities and physical therapy, I am based in the UK now. I must say that the training I gained in the US was great and I would not have missed these opportunities for the world.
When my father died the shunt was the only option other than diuretics and limiting sodium intake. If the tap you mention was being done then I wasn't aware of it and the physician did not discuss it as an option either. However, the treatment you speak of is done today and the shunts rarely used. Here's a brief description.
 
...
It has been said that physicians have it easy compared to automotive technicians: Physicians only work on one *make* produced in two *models* that are the same design year-to-year, and most of their work is performed in clean, well-lit, climate-controlled areas, mostly with the subject comfortably within reach from a sitting or standing position....
Cheers,
Dave
But the number of different things that can go wrong with those two models is enormous. No matter how many different models you have with cars they still all have combustion engines, transmissions and drive trains and experience the same problems.

Medics and EMTs might argue with your about that controlled environment as well. :D
 
Anecdotes are not the basis of medical practice.

Many times a medical problem cannot be "cured", but it can be treated (hypertension for example).
 
Anecdotes are not the basis of medical practice.
Care to point out anywhere in this thread where someone claimed they were? The only anecdotes I see in this thread were used to illustrate points.

skepticdoc said:
Many times a medical problem cannot be "cured", but it can be treated (hypertension for example).
Is this supposed to be a meaningful post?

Are you incapable of responding to the actual posts? So you treat chronic hypertension. How is that relevant to the following exchange?:

skeptigirl: Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need.

skepticdoc: Who does not want to be cured if a cure is possible?

Meffy: I'd say that depends on whether the cure is worse than the condition.
 
Just answer the question:

Originally Posted by skeptigirl :
"Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need."


Who does not want to be cured if a cure is possible?
Wow. Are you being intentionally obtuse or are you really that thick?

If you had read skeptigirl's statement in the context of her post (and subsequent posts) you'd understand what she was saying. Everyone else did. Sometimes doctors get tunnel vision -- they want to fix the problem of the day and sometimes don't consider the big picture or the longer term "quality of life" issues for the patient. Somes fixing the immediate problem, as in the example skeptigirl gave of her father's treatment, is not the wisest thing to do when the complete situation is evaluated.

From the start of this thread, you've been very hostile to skeptigirl and for no good reason. I too have doubt's that you're a real MD. Unlike skeptigirl, you haven't presented any medical knowledge that convinces me that you're even a medical professional. Your simplistic manifesto, your inability to understand what people are saying, and to respond like a reasonable person, make me doubt that you are even that well educated.

So please, stop making yourself look like a jerk. You owe skeptigirl an apology.
 
skeptigirl, my casual (but heartfelt) comment on the decision to cure or not pales compared to your hard-hitting, accurate barrages. I'm at the periphery of health care, but you're in the midst of it and clearly know your stuff.

OT: I deserve the million-dollar prize for prescience, because I've seen this whole thread play itself out before in forum after forum. Each time there's a different topic for the button-pushing and chain-yanking the troll engages in; here, medicine; other places, audio engineering or evolution or what-have-you. Sometimes the person doing the trolling is a genuine qualified professional, other times it's just someone who bothered to read enough basic information to pass as a pro. But almost invariably the entire episode aims toward one sentence that goes something like this:

"Oh, by the way, never mind -- I found my answer on a board where the real professionals go and hoi polloi aren't allowed."

And I'll be dogged if it didn't appear right on cue.

Anyway, you're fighting the good fight and scoring pretty much all the points.
 
Thanks for letting me know I wasn't only posting to skepticdoc. That's the real reason I've taken the time here. Nurses do need more public info campaigning. S'doc's classic stereotype believing answers provided avenues to explain what nursing is really all about.

As to s'doc being a doc, I think we do have more than sufficient evidence here that he isn't one. I suspect a doctor wannabe rather than an outright purposeful troll. No doubt there are many people on the Net who love to pretend. What better place than this one to be something you are not. But even here once you start revealing yourself, a facade is not always as easy to keep up as one might think.

So unless you have something of substance to say, skepticdoc, I think I've more than made the case doctors can just as easily take nursing orders from nurses as nurses can take medical orders from doctors.
 
Last edited:
Internet Trolling

From Wikipedia: In Internet terminology, a troll is someone who comes into an established community such as an online discussion forum, and posts inflammatory, rude or offensive messages designed to annoy and antagonize the existing members or disrupt the flow of discussion (see Anonymous Internet posting).

I extend an invitation to read my posts in the Skeptic Forum, I use the same Forum name. Skeptigirl has joined the Skeptic Forum under a different name to follow me, or to harass me, not sure yet of her intentions.

Could her actions be considered trolling?

The best defense against a charlatan is to use their own words against them.

The facts as I see them are:

1) it takes many different kind of workers to take care of the medical needs of humans

2) a Cardiologist saved my life by performing an angioplasty in my blocked coronary, nurses helped him, but he did the most important part

3) a Surgeon saved my life by removing my appendix when I was in 7th grade, nurses helped him, but he did the most important part

4) Doctors write orders for nurses to follow in the hospital.

The only regret I have is using the wording of wrath when Skeptigirl posted: "Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need." I probably should have ignored that post.
 
Last edited:
skepticdoc, I've seen a lot of trolls in my years online. And I know who fits the profile. 'Nuff said.
 
Words from a wise man

The Skeptic Forum administrator just posted this:

Once, at another forum where I was administrator for a brief time, we attempted to settle the question of "What is a troll?" and never arrived at a satisfactory answer. The way I see it as far as this forum is concerned, "troll" is likely to be thought of as little more than namecalling. I personally object to the term because it immediately sidetracks substantive discussion into personality clashes. I've seen it used far too often as a means of marginalizing an opponent.

I do ask that people focus on substantive questions and issues and not on the perceived faults of other people. There is much to be learned from another person's point of view. We each have different experiences and different lives, and it would be a pity to disregard what each of us has to offer merely because of disagreement.


I feel it is worthwhile to post here, please forgive me for not asking for the permission of the author.

As a physician I am in a constant tug of war between the system and the patients. It is very frustating to deal with the insurance companies, the demands/expectations of the patients and trying to do what is the best scientific/ethical decision for another person in or outside of the hospital.

At the end we all will be patients at the mercy of Doctors, Nurses, Orderlies and others in the Hospital/Healthcare system, how we treat others may be the guide others will follow to treat us. (Item 3 in my personal manifesto!).

I am trying to get other points of view to waddle through the swamp of uncertainty, is there a spiritual component to Life? How can I balance belief, belief in belief and science while taking care of patients and my own family? We love life, we have two Corgis, two cats, one conure, one lovebird and an ornamental pond with over fifty Koi (this just for you dear Supercorgi, how did you become involved?).

Intellectually I am probably a reductionist atheist, I don't even fall for the "we are startdust" ideas, even fecal matter came from "starstuff".

I hope there is something else beyond death because I would like to continue to enjoy the Universe.
 
Last edited:
The admin has her or his definition (or lack of one), I have mine, and I'll call 'em like I see 'em. One of my principles is that it's quite rare for a person to be "all troll," but that some people indulge in the activity of trolling who are capable of carrying on civil conversations as well. I'd prefer the latter. Just about everyone prefers the latter.

As for sidetracking, it seems to me the substantive discussion was being not just sidetracked but derailed pretty effectively by name-calling and denigration. It's the behavior of a person that does the marginalizing. Recognizing and naming that behavior out loud doesn't.

IOW, while you're engaging in civil discourse I can't say you're trolling, and nobody else can either. *taps own head with hollow sound* Verb sap sat est.

Now maybe the thread can get on whatever rails are left unsprung.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom