Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
So we have evidence supporting the addition of bicarb to nasal irrigation solutions.
Clinicians will still have to assess if the additional complexity of the recipe will matter, (likely individual patient considerations here).
There are mixed opinions as the the effectiveness of irrigation merely to moisten membranes.
Patient needing to clear nasal passages for various reasons exist and the procedure is useful there. Consideration of the alternative, a patient picking his/her nose excessively, irrigation may be preferable.
Discouraging a patient from irrigating the nose if the patient already does it is not necessary in most cases.
I think we are mostly on the same page here.
As to some additional issues:
S'doc has provided no evidence of the need for nor benefit of wasting the time and energy to boil the tap water for the home made recipe.
The formula for the solution s'doc has provided is much more hypertonic than most recipes I found online. This does not mean the formula is better, worse or equal. It does mean s'doc might want to support the use of the hypertonic recommendation with some research and not just an ENT colleague's endorsement. And I'm wondering if 10 minutes of boiling results in much volume loss and the variation in "2 or 3 tsp." of salt making the tonicity of the formula unpredictable is a problem.
I also found recommendations that the iodine in table salt was the reason for choosing "sea salt" though s'doc didn't say that was his reason for the choice. I found nothing that supported iodized salt mattered.
S'doc still has not presented any evidence he "gets" what evidence based medicine or skepticism as defined by the skeptic community is all about. And SteveG doesn't seem to have weighed in one way or the other on his opinion of s'doc's lack of critical analysis skills as represented by what he posts. I am curious if SteveG had an opinion on that matter but respect his right not to get involved.
Clinicians will still have to assess if the additional complexity of the recipe will matter, (likely individual patient considerations here).
There are mixed opinions as the the effectiveness of irrigation merely to moisten membranes.
Patient needing to clear nasal passages for various reasons exist and the procedure is useful there. Consideration of the alternative, a patient picking his/her nose excessively, irrigation may be preferable.
Discouraging a patient from irrigating the nose if the patient already does it is not necessary in most cases.
I think we are mostly on the same page here.
As to some additional issues:
S'doc has provided no evidence of the need for nor benefit of wasting the time and energy to boil the tap water for the home made recipe.
The formula for the solution s'doc has provided is much more hypertonic than most recipes I found online. This does not mean the formula is better, worse or equal. It does mean s'doc might want to support the use of the hypertonic recommendation with some research and not just an ENT colleague's endorsement. And I'm wondering if 10 minutes of boiling results in much volume loss and the variation in "2 or 3 tsp." of salt making the tonicity of the formula unpredictable is a problem.
I also found recommendations that the iodine in table salt was the reason for choosing "sea salt" though s'doc didn't say that was his reason for the choice. I found nothing that supported iodized salt mattered.
S'doc still has not presented any evidence he "gets" what evidence based medicine or skepticism as defined by the skeptic community is all about. And SteveG doesn't seem to have weighed in one way or the other on his opinion of s'doc's lack of critical analysis skills as represented by what he posts. I am curious if SteveG had an opinion on that matter but respect his right not to get involved.
