Medical and Healthcare phishing

So we have evidence supporting the addition of bicarb to nasal irrigation solutions.

Clinicians will still have to assess if the additional complexity of the recipe will matter, (likely individual patient considerations here).

There are mixed opinions as the the effectiveness of irrigation merely to moisten membranes.

Patient needing to clear nasal passages for various reasons exist and the procedure is useful there. Consideration of the alternative, a patient picking his/her nose excessively, irrigation may be preferable.

Discouraging a patient from irrigating the nose if the patient already does it is not necessary in most cases.

I think we are mostly on the same page here.


As to some additional issues:

S'doc has provided no evidence of the need for nor benefit of wasting the time and energy to boil the tap water for the home made recipe.

The formula for the solution s'doc has provided is much more hypertonic than most recipes I found online. This does not mean the formula is better, worse or equal. It does mean s'doc might want to support the use of the hypertonic recommendation with some research and not just an ENT colleague's endorsement. And I'm wondering if 10 minutes of boiling results in much volume loss and the variation in "2 or 3 tsp." of salt making the tonicity of the formula unpredictable is a problem.

I also found recommendations that the iodine in table salt was the reason for choosing "sea salt" though s'doc didn't say that was his reason for the choice. I found nothing that supported iodized salt mattered.

S'doc still has not presented any evidence he "gets" what evidence based medicine or skepticism as defined by the skeptic community is all about. And SteveG doesn't seem to have weighed in one way or the other on his opinion of s'doc's lack of critical analysis skills as represented by what he posts. I am curious if SteveG had an opinion on that matter but respect his right not to get involved.
 
For another opinion from about.com


Search
Allergies
Allergies How to Make a Nasal Saline Solution

Steps for making a saline nasal solution which can help flush thick, dried, or sticky mucus buildup from the nasal passages. It also removes allergens, pollutants, dust, dirt, and pollens.

Difficulty Level: easy Time Required: 1 minute

Here's How:

1. Combine 1/4 teaspoon salt with 8 ounces warm water
2. Add 1/4 teaspoon baking soda (optional)
3. Put this solution in spray bottle, ear syringe, or any container with a small spout.

Tips:

1. Use distilled or filtered water.
2. Use pure, non-iodized salt.
3. Make sure water is warm.

From Judy Tidwell,
Your Guide to Allergies.
FREE Newsletter. Sign Up Now!

Important disclaimer information about this About site.
 
I will help you out with the calculation, one step at a time,

salt density 2.16 grams/cc.

other steps to follow, unless you post them all!
 
The water should be boiled when it's still water and before salt or bicarb is added. Presumably this is for no other reason than to kill any microroganisms that are present. Legionella, Ralstonia and other nasties may be present in tap water. I know, your gonna hit back with well its chlorinated. It is chlorinated at one point but chlorine rapidly dissipates.

In cities like NY particularly in big hospitals here, chlorinated water is tanked before it flows out the tap and Legionella is recoverable from such water. Which is why we use sterile water
for irrigation for everything including irrigation. We have had a few patient deaths in the headlines over this the past year.

Even sea salt comes iodized nowadays. Kosher salt and salt marked non-iodized are the only table salts not iodized.

As you read in the one paper I offered re: hyper-tonic versus isotonic, the cilia are supposedly whipped into some sort of frenzy by hypertonic and this is viewed as a plus. Problem is the more hypertonic a soln is, the more its likely to "burn" so its pH is raised and the burning side effect diminished by adding a buffer such as bicarb.

As I said before dont ask me for any formulas. I would buy it from the druggist as a done deal. This eliminates all objections on preparation problems.

In this day I see no reason to have patients make their own when it can be prescribed.
 
Last edited:
Thank goodness we've reached the recipe-posting phase of the thread.

LATKES (potato pancakes; great for Chanukkah or any time)

o 2 potatoes, peeled
o 1 small onion, peeled
o 2 eggs
o 3 tablespoons milk
o 2 tablespoons melted butter
o 1/4 cup flour
o 1/2 teaspoon salt*
o black pepper to taste
o butter or vegetable oil for frying
o sour cream (optional)

* Instead of adding salt, saline solution may be used to irrigate the grated potatoes.

1. Grate potatoes and onions into a medium-sized mixing bowl.
2. In another bowl add eggs, milk and melted butter and blend.
3. Then add flour, salt and pepper and process to mix.
4. Pour over potatoes and onions and stir to mix.
5. Drop by quarter cupfuls on a prepared griddle or skillet.
6. Spread to make a 4" pancake.
7. Cook until brown on both sides, turning.
8. Serve with sour cream.

DO NOT ATTEMPT TO FIT LATKES NASALLY.

Note: The house will smell of oil for days after making a batch of these.
 
The water should be boiled when it's still water and before salt or bicarb is added. Presumably this is for no other reason than to kill any
microroganisms that are present. Legionella and other nasties may be present in tap water. I know, your gonna hit back with well its chlorinated. It is chlorinated at one point but chlorine rapidly dissipates.
In cities like NY particularly in big hospitals, chlorinated water is tanked before it flows out the tap and Legionella is recoverable from such water.
No, I'm going to come back with, do you know of a single case of legionella from a nasal wash? That's a definite, no, there is not a single case on record I am aware of, and I am quite aware of the epidemiology of this organism.

There have been cases from a display hot tub. It was from the mist created from the jets. I don't know if under-chlorination was involved. Legionella are most often a problem in ventilation and air conditioning units. The organism grows intermittently, is hard to recover, and hard to eliminate. Cases occur in various buildings and on at least one cruise ship. The outbreak at the Legionnaire's convention that led to the discovery of this pathogen actually infected people who walked in front of the building. It was found that some mechanism produced contaminated air that actually drifted down around the hotel's doors.

There were also cases associated with potting soil. The mechanism by which it reached the lungs isn't clear but it is still believed to have been inhalation. Again, to my knowledge, just as with mycobacterium tuberculosis you cannot be infected by contact with the organism. It has to be inhaled and it has to reach the alveoli. It does not grow anywhere in or above the bronchioles. (Injecting it excepted.)

Besides no cases of legionella, and the cryptosporidia I noted in a previous post, what on Earth could be in this tap water you could drink but not squirt in your nose? And how could anything in the tap water be worse than the bacteria in your nose which those cilia are so diligently moving out being washed right back in? I assure you your nasal flora are not always benign bacteria when relocated to other areas of your body.

And do you have any case examples where an infection occurred? Notwithstanding letting the bottle sit around long enough to incubate all sorts of contaminants that could get in before or after boiling.

As far as the chlorination issue, we totally agree here. I never drink from drinking fountains unless I'm really desperate. Then I let the water run a while. Once the water is chlorinated, the chlorine evaporates out, and there is not sufficient time for the chlorine to act at the end of the pipes.

SteveGrenard said:
Even sea salt comes iodizied nowadays. Kosher salt and salt marked non-iodized are the only table salts not iodized.
Yes, I saw that as well which tells you s'doc may not understand the principle of his recipe calling for sea salt so wouldn't know to tell the patient to look for noniodized salt.

SteveGrenard said:
As you read in the one paper I offered re: hyper-tonic versus isotonic, the cilia are whipped into some sort of frenzy by hypertonic and this is viewed as a plus. Problem is the more hypetrotnic a soln is, the more its likely to
burn so its pH is raised and the burning side effect diminished by adding a buffer such as bicarb.
I wasn't sure what to make of that outcome. It would be interesting to see what difference it actually made. Positive frenzy or not, since you are using the saline to wash the nose, what additional action would the cilia provide? Perhaps preventing bacteria you introduced deep into the nasal passages from becoming established? Perhaps it matters if you have a sinusitis risk?

SteveGrenard said:
As I said before dont ask me for any formulas. I would buy it from the druggist as a done deal. This eliminates all onjections on preparation.
In this day I see no reason to have patients make their own when it can be prescribed.
...unless that study I cited was valid which indicated the preservatives were as harmful to the cilia as well. But I agree, I think the preservative effect on bacterial growth as the product sits in you medicine cabinet might outweigh the hazard to the cilia. If I had a particularly vulnerable patient I might look into that further.

I also noticed in my net search a more than a few people who seemed to have nasal washing habits. It made me curious how often if at all you yourself used the wash? Don't answer if you don't want to.
 
Last edited:
Now, now, don't lose your temper S'girl Jesus loves you!!!

for another opinion:

http://allergies.about.com/cs/treatment/a/uc_nasopure1203.htm

How can you scientifically criticize a recipe when you do not know the possible physical properties of the result? Is that Science?



Sorry for the cheap shot! I am not a believer, just taking a gamble that there is no hell to burn in.
What makes you think I am upset? You really are having a hard time understanding what this discussion is about. That doesn't make me angry. But I see no reason to answer all your straw questions.
 
Thank goodness we've reached the recipe-posting phase of the thread.

LATKES (potato pancakes; great for Chanukkah or any time)

.....
DO NOT ATTEMPT TO FIT LATKES NASALLY.

Note: The house will smell of oil for days after making a batch of these.
That is funny. You crack me up.

Not to worry though. I truly am not posting in a huff here. I said before, s'doc is just not threatening.
 
re boiling. I think it is better to be safe than sorry even though as you say chances are slim that a user can develop a URI from a contaminated nasal irrigating soln, especially if the nasal passages are blocked and the soln mixed with softened secretions is discharged. Recent hospital patients
didnt get and die from Legionella in the shower like the first cases but got it in one case I am familiar with by filling their own humdiifer brought from home using the hospital's tap water. Bad idea.

Baltimore Hospital Patients, 5 Cases, 1 Death, July 2005 ...

After Legionella bacteria was found in the hospital's water system on Feb. ...

hcinfo.com/outbreaks-news.htm

Five Cases, Three Deaths, in Italian Hospital
hcinfo.com/legionella_enews_archives.htm

Although Legionella spp. is the most widely recognized waterborne bacteria, ... was linked to 101 cases and 39 deaths in a major London hospital. ...



WROC

Another case of Legionnaires' disease at Strong Hospital
Rochester NY

WROC, NY - 38 minutes ago
... still confident the water treatment and the measures we've taken to date are effective, but if there's any chance there's some area where legionella is still ...

Families calling for water mains action
Weston & Somerset Mercury, UK - May 3, 2006
Last summer, Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust (AWP) notified the residents of 20 former staff cotages that Legionella bacteria had been ...

Ralstonia

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5441a5.htm



Am J Infect Control. 2002 Jun;30(4):246-7.


Bacterial contamination of saline nasal spray/drop solution in patients with respiratory tract infection.

Brook I.

Department of Pediatrics, Georgetown University School of Medicine, Washington, DC, USA.

This study evaluated the potential for bacterial contamination of saline nasal spray/drop solution after 3 days of clinical use in patients. Twenty patients with upper respiratory infection used the saline as a spray, and 20 patients used the solution as drops. Bacterial growth was present in 18 (907%) solution containers of the spray group and in 3 (157%) solution containers of the drops group (P <.005). Twenty isolates were recovered from the spray group and 3 from the drops group. The predominate isolates included Staphylococcus aureus, Staphylococcus epidermidis, alpha Streptococcus species, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli, and Proteus spp. This study demonstrates the contamination of nasal saline-dispensing solution used as a spray with micro-organisms that are part of the normal skin and nasal flora and gram-negative organisms of potential enteric origin. These data support the use of nasal saline-dispensing solution as drops, rather than as spray. They also illustrate the risk for crossinfection if a nasal solution is used by more than 1 patient.
Two cases of Ralstonia pickettii bacteremias in a pediatric oncology unit requiring removal of the Port-A-Caths.



Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2005 Jan;27(1):37-8.

Kismet E, Atay AA, Demirkaya E, Aydin HI, Aydogan H, Koseoglu V, Gokcay E.

Department of Pediatric Oncology, Gulhane Military Medical Academy, School of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.

Ralstonia pickettii is an aerobic, gram-negative bacterium causing bacteremia following the use of contaminated saline vials, respiratory therapy solutions, skin disinfectants, blood culture mediums, and water supplies. It is rarely associated with human infections. The authors report two cases of R. pickettii bacteremia in patients with Port-A-Caths that could be treated only by removal of the ports.
 
I truly am not posting in a huff here. I said before, s'doc is just not threatening.
I know, and think you've done pretty well avoiding being "baited," as sd puts it. The recipe's not targeted at anyone. I have pictures of kittens too. :-)
 
I am both an American Board Certified Anesthesiologist and Family Physician, I respect the nurses that work with me in the hospital. I wish Skeptigirl could get her peer's judgements on my relations with them, you will just have to take my word that most nurses like to work with me ( you can't pease everybody, medical work cannot be a popularity contest ).


Popularity contest or not, I sure hope you weren't the anesthesiologist that put me under for my surgery.

If so, in the future if I need further surgeries from the neurosurgeon that operated on my spine, I will make sure to specifically request a different one. I don't think I need a "manifesto" preached at me as I go under. Especially not one you plagiarized from your kid's pediatrician. I find it telling that a "manifesto" used in an office to obviously tell children how to act is something you think everyone else should read as well.

Also, I prefer medical professionals that don't need a spellchecker to clearly communicate, or that use lame AOL-esque emoticons like "LOL." Really Doc, after all the school and work you've had I would imagine using the same slang as a 14 year old doesn't do service to your esteemed career or work to have you taken seriously.

However, I am sure you wouldn't bother with the opinion of a "two bit barbershop philosopher" like me, eh? Perhaps someone with an MD or PhD is more worthy of communicating with you?
 
Last edited:
The density of Baking Soda is 2.2 g/cc

salt is 40% sodium

1 teaspoon of Baking Soda has 1 gram of sodium
 
Last edited:
S'girl knows what I am talking about.

Someday you will understand that the world does not revolve around you, and that there can be conversations that do not involve you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom