Medical and Healthcare phishing

Wow, you discovered wheels are round!!!
It's amazing that you manage to be offensive each time you respond to someone. It must have taken you a long time to learn that skill in med school.

There will always be repetition of the obvious when you work with people, humans like dogs need structure ( I love to watch the Dog Whisperer!! ).
Humans get offended when someone's pedantic and condescending. Dogs don't get offended. Can't you see how thinking of someone as having the same faculties as a dog could be offensive?

From a practical standpoint, 99% of my patients are believers, they are not offended. I need to remind myself to spend more time with my son, than on this futile forum.
That's probably a good idea.

But I can't tolerate to lose an argument, we will see who gives up!
I didn't think this was an argument -- I thought it was a somewhat more-or-less civil discussion. You've stated that this shouldn't be a pissing contest -- why then are you treating it as one?

Preview warning: Nutritional supplement recommendations!!
What does this have to do with anything in your post? You seem to jump from thought to thought and your posts are very scattered. Is it fatigue or are you writing prescriptions for yourself?

What a pity, I thought you were sincere with the comment about the elders.
<snip>
Tell me, how can we promote respect for people with more experience that love and nurtured us?
What makes you think I wasn't sincere? The point that I was trying to make, is that no one deserves instant respect just because of their position, title, degree, whatever. Respect is not demanded - it's earned. If I don't think someone is worthy of respect, I don't respect them. Again, this line of your manifesto is more oriented towards children than adults.

How can we rescue the unfortunate children that have been abused by their own parents, or even clergy? I am sure you are not advocating that we just dispose of them, since there is no soul.
What a ridiculous strawman argument! What does the existence or non-existence of souls have to do with a person's worth? Of course such children should be removed from the abusive situation and given psychological help.

Anybody still doubts I am a "real" doctor?
No, I am now convinced you're a real doctor, just not one that I'd like to consult with.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but House is extremely brilliant and he also wouldn't have peddled anything like your manifesto to his patients. Oh, and it's also very clear that he's an avowed atheist.
I only saw one episode of that show. It was the faith healer vs House. I loved the God 3 House 2 scoreboard. They did take big liberties with medical accuracy of the faith healer's disease and symptoms, and the virus' effect on the woman's tumor was a big stretch, but those details were ignorable. They could have left out the roommate's affair with the cancer patient too. The plot itself was pretty good. I'd watch it again if it was on when I was watching TV.
 
I only saw one episode of that show. It was the faith healer vs House. I loved the God 3 House 2 scoreboard. They did take big liberties with medical accuracy of the faith healer's disease and symptoms, and the virus' effect on the woman's tumor was a big stretch, but those details were ignorable. They could have left out the roommate's affair with the cancer patient too. The plot itself was pretty good. I'd watch it again if it was on when I was watching TV.
House is one of my favorite shows. The character is just so interesting (besides Hugh Laurie is brillant and hot :D ). Plus I like the medical fact-finding where they whittle away at different diagnoses before landing on the correct one. (I can forgive some medical inaccurcies in the favor of entertainment - my understanding is that they have a group of doctors as advisors to the show.)
 
Nutritional Supplements Recommendations:
For Everybody:
Vitamin B6 100 mg, one a day (NEVER take more than 200 mgs a day!!!)

Vitamin B12 500-1,000 mcg, one a day
Folic acid 800-2000 mcgs a day (you will find 400 and 800 mcg tablets over the counter, take between 2-5 a day. Make sure you take B12 as recommended above!)

Vitamin C 500 mgs, one a day
Aspirin, plain or enteric coated, 81 to 325 mgs, once a day
Calcium 1,000-1,500 mgs a day, dairy sources preferred, skim milk is a great choice!

For Arthritis:
Glucosamine, with or without Chondroitin, three times a day, or as needed


Nasal Saline recipe:

4 cups of water that has boiled for 10 minutes

2-3 teaspoons of Sea Salt

1 teaspoon Baking Soda

Use as needed


BTW I have never watched House, M.D., somebody mentioned this show earlier in the thread.

Probably the fictional doctor would not have posted this either.
 
Do you (still) subscribe to the concept that elevated homocysteine levels are a risk factor for CAD and recommend folates, B12 and B6 to convert homocysteine to methionine?
 
Last edited:
Do you (still) subscribe to the concept that elevated homocysteine levels are a risk factor for CAD and recommend folates, B12 and B16 to convert homocysteine to methionine?

I try to promote EBM whenever possible, that pathway sounds very reasonable in vitro, but nobody has proved it as far as I know. I have heard of Cardiologists promoting CoQ-10, I am not aware of any objective evidence for that either.

There was a recent study that showed no benefit from folate after CABG or stenting, and another that showed reduced stroke risk with folates.

There is some benefit in prevention and treatment of neuropathies with this combo, it is cheap ( I tell my patients to read the label in their MVI! ) and at these doses, non-toxic.

I used to have Vitamin E in the list until it was shown to be harmful.

Vitamin C's risk/benefits come and go, at least at this dose there is some mild urine acidification.

Calcium is a no-brainer!

Unfortunately, at the end the best thing is to exercise, watch your diet, etc.... It is the hardest combination to practice.
 
Just a drive-by.......

In the UK, maintenance of good standards of medical care fall under the umbrella of the (oft maligned) General Medical Council.
Their "manifesto" on good medical practice can be found here.

The BMJ had a series of articles not too long ago about what makes a good doctor. The editorial links to several BMJ articles, but you have to be a subscriber to gain full access. If anyone is interested in a particular article, please PM me.

And for the record, If I was ill, I'd rather have Skeptigirl look after me than Sceptidoc.
 
Nutritional Supplements Recommendations:
For Everybody:.....Probably the fictional doctor would not have posted this either.
Another bizarre post brought to you by skepticdoc. I wouldn't say these recommendations are based on the best evidence we have to date. In making these recommendations is there some particular research leading to this advice?


skepticdoc said:
Vitamin B6 100 mg, one a day (NEVER take more than 200 mgs a day!!!)

Vitamin B12 500-1,000 mcg, one a day
Folic acid 800-2000 mcgs a day (you will find 400 and 800 mcg tablets over the counter, take between 2-5 a day. Make sure you take B12 as recommended above!)
There was extensive research done by the dean of my University NP program on women's health. Dr Brown's (that's a PhD in nursing science, BTW), original research began looking into PMS. Through evidence based medicine approach she later found and wrote about the "body blues".There were many trials of supplements and other interventions done. The end result found some benefit in the some of the above vitamins suggested by s'doc but in different doses and with a different combination.
...three simple activities, each one proven to boost women's mood and energy or tame their appetites:

1. Walking outdoors at a brisk pace for 20 minutes, 5 or more days a week.
2. Getting more very bright light during the daytime but less light at night. (Is it necessary to use a light therapy device? Learn more about what kind of light is best.)
3. Taking the following six vitamins and minerals on a daily basis: 50 mgs. each of vitamins B-1, B-2, B-6; 400 mcg. folic acid; 400 IU of vitamin D; and 200 mcg. selenium. (Most of these doses are higher than those found in one-a-day multi-vitamin tablets, but all are within safe limits. For more details, refer to the book.)

The LEVITY Program was put to the test in a "placebo-controlled, randomized" 8-week study. One hundred and twelve mildly depressed women spanning the ages from 18-78 took part in the study. Half of the women took a placebo pill, while the other half took part in the three activities.

... at the end of the 8-week study, tests showed that the women had greatly improved. They were less anxious, angry, irritable and stressed. Remarkably, their depression scores were cut in half, which is similar to the results one hopes to see from antidepressants. Just as impressive, in a test of overall well-being, the women moved from the worst to the best possible category. Last but not least, the volunteers had significantly fewer eating problems. In fact, 25 percent of them lost a noticeable amount of weight, even though they had not been asked to diet.

The results of the University of Washington study were published in the scientific journal, Women and Health.
This study applied to women and addressed one area of health. It doesn't mean the vitamins and doses recommended by s'doc aren't helpful in other areas of health. But one must look for evidence. If one recommends particular supplements then the research supporting those recommendations should be cited. Gone are the days one just took an MD's advice without question. Especially this MD if he is one. Regardless, an evidence based approach has not been demonstrated as yet.

skepticdoc said:
Vitamin C 500 mgs, one a day
Vitamin C does nothing for your immune system. The evidence is clear on that one. The initial research by Linus Pauling in the 50s has not been successfully replicated.
At least 16 well-designed, double-blind studies have shown that supplementation with vitamin C does not prevent colds and at best may slightly reduce the symptoms of a cold [5]. Slight symptom reduction may occur as the result of an antihistamine-like effect, but whether this has practical value is a matter of dispute. Pauling's views are based on the same studies considered by other scientists, but his analyses are flawed.
Yet to this day, based on one flawed study, the majority of people in the USA believe vitamin C has some activity against the common cold either in preventing it or treating the symptoms.

Vitamin C and E together have beneficial effect on cardiac health.
Conclusions. Our study shows that a combined supplementation with reasonable doses of both vitamin E and slow-release vitamin C can retard the progression of common carotid atherosclerosis in men. This may imply benefits with regard to other atherosclerosis-based events.

Effect of Supplemental Antioxidants Vitamin C, Vitamin E, and Coenzyme Q10 for the Prevention and Treatment of Cardiovascular Disease

But not every study has had the same results.

At the last conference I attended, the speaker suggested that either vitamin alone did not produce the same beneficial results. While th evidence was leaning toward the benefit of the two vitamins, he said he himself was not taking them. For me, the evidence is strong enough that for now I do take the vitamins but only together.

skepticdoc said:
Aspirin, plain or enteric coated, 81 to 325 mgs, once a day
And yet the FDA says:
In recent years, you may have seen television ads promoting aspirin's ability to reduce the risk of heart attack and stroke in certain groups of people. You should know that deciding to take an aspirin a day is not as simple as it may seem. The FDA's Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) has launched a public education campaign to remind consumers that aspirin is not without risk; the decision to use aspirin to prevent a heart attack and stroke is safest when made in consultation with a health professional.

It's been about 100 years since aspirin was created. And in that time, it has played a major role in treating headaches, fever, and minor aches and pains for millions. Now there are studies showing that aspirin is helpful in lowering the chance of a heart attack and clot-related stroke.

Still, most health professionals agree that long-term aspirin use to prevent a heart attack or stroke in healthy people is unnecessary. If you are using aspirin to lower the risk of heart attack and stroke and you haven't talked with a health professional about it, you may be putting your health at risk.

Aspirin can help prevent a heart attack or clot-related stroke by lowering the clotting action of the blood's platelets. But the same properties that make aspirin work in stopping blood from clotting may also cause unwanted side effects, such as stomach bleeding, bleeding in the brain, kidney failure, and other kinds of strokes. There may be a benefit to daily aspirin use if you have some kind of heart or blood vessel disease, or if you have evidence of poor blood flow to the brain. But only a doctor can tell you whether the risks of long-term aspirin use may be greater than the benefits.
So it would seem this is not something one should recommend without consideration of one's individual situation. You need to take into account whether or not you have a greater risk of a bleeding disorder or a clotting disorder.

skepticdoc said:
Calcium 1,000-1,500 mgs a day, dairy sources preferred, skim milk is a great choice!
Harvard school of public health on calcium and milk
In particular, these studies suggest that high calcium intake doesn't actually appear to lower a person's risk for osteoporosis. For example, in the large Harvard studies of male health professionals and female nurses, individuals who drank one glass of milk (or less) per week were at no greater risk of breaking a hip or forearm than were those who drank two or more glasses per week.(2, 3) Other studies have found similar results.

To illustrate the different conclusions drawn from examining the same body of data, a British committee that is comparable to the U.S. group that established calcium requirements here concluded that 700 mg/day was enough for individuals aged 19 and older.

Should you get calcium from milk?

When most people in the United States think of calcium, they immediately think of milk. But should this be so? Milk is actually only one of many sources of calcium, and there are some important reasons why milk may not be the best source for everyone. These include:

Lactose intolerance
High saturated fat content
Possible increased risk of ovarian cancer
Possible increased risk of prostate cancer

Reaching 1200 mg per day would usually require drinking two to three glasses of milk per day over and above an overall healthy diet.

skepticdoc said:
For Arthritis:
Glucosamine, with or without Chondroitin, three times a day, or as needed
Glucosamine for Arthritis: The Evidence Is Conflicting Stephen Barrett, M.D

Glucosamine and chondroitin for treatment of osteoarthritis: a systematic quality assessment and meta-analysis.
CONCLUSIONS: Trials of glucosamine and chondroitin preparations for OA symptoms demonstrate moderate to large effects, but quality issues and likely publication bias suggest that these effects are exaggerated. Nevertheless, some degree of efficacy appears probable for these preparations.

skepticdoc said:
Nasal Saline recipe:
4 cups of water that has boiled for 10 minutes
2-3 teaspoons of Sea Salt
1 teaspoon Baking Soda
Use as needed
One is to boil this water because?

And "sea" salt as opposed to any table salt matters why?

These are nose drops to assist as a decongestant, not fluid and electrolyte replacement therapy. What is the reason for the bicarb?

Here are some additional resources for research on vitamins and supplements, (quackwatch you probably already know):

Harvard School of Public Health on Vitamins

NIH:National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Medline Plus: Dietary Supplement

quackwatch: "Dietary Supplements," Herbs, and Hormones

AAFP Clinical Care & Research resource links
 
Last edited:
...

And for the record, If I was ill, I'd rather have Skeptigirl look after me than Sceptidoc.
:D Thank you. The key is to empower the patients to recognize evidence based medicine for themselves and to not be afraid to question the provider.


That's a very nice site on good medical practice. As is the other source:
the skills of an applied scientist: good doctors combine individual clinical expertise and best available external evidence; they are thoughtful, evidence based practitioners who use "intangible personal resources" in the care of their patients

Skepticdoc's manifesto was aimed at telling the patients how to behave rather than how the physician should. When I first saw it I thought it was intended to be the doctor's rules but as I read down the list the intended audience became clear.
 
Last edited:
Wow, just wow! What civility, how many constructive comments, your good faith and positive attitude just jumps off the screen!

The nasal saline recipe is what one of my patients has used over 50 years, under the guidance of ENTs and his own trial and error.

The boiling part is my little contrbution, if you don't know why the water should be boiled, I suggest you go back to your microbiology books. Maybe you have sterile tap water on your faucet, in that case you do not have to boil it.

What do you recommend to your patients?
 
Um...

Wow...just.........wow.

Sterile water for a nasal rinse? Is this for people with, like, open bleeding of the mucous membranes? Or are we in some undeveloped country with Cholera in the water?

Reminds me of a joke...

What do you call the guy that graduates last in his class from Med school?





Doctor.
 
Wow, just wow! What civility, how many constructive comments, your good faith and positive attitude just jumps off the screen!
The only reason you don't see my posts as constructive is they question your advice and imagined authority. I believe others here do not think I have been so uncivil nor made less than constructive comments.

skepticdoc said:
The nasal saline recipe is what one of my patients has used over 50 years, under the guidance of ENTs and his own trial and error.
Tradition over evidence? That's old school s'doc. His own trial and error, not typically a very scientific method but I'd be happy to read his data. That is if he kept systematic observations.

I found one reference for you. (Sorry, no link.) But why would this matter unless you were lavaging a trach tube?
Physiologic and hypertonic saline solutions impair ciliary activity in vitro. Boek WM. Laryngoscope, 109(3):396-9 1999 Mar
Physiological salt solution (0.9%) was found to slow cilia movement. Locke-Ringers solution with soda bicarbonate, potassium and calcium chloride, and salt was found best for cilia. "This solution is more appropriate than saline for nasal irrigator and nebulazation or sinus lavage." He reported complete ciliastasis with some hypertonic solutions, often within 5 minutes of exposure.

skepticdoc said:
The boiling part is my little contrbution, if you don't know why the water should be boiled, I suggest you go back to your microbiology books. Maybe you have sterile tap water on your faucet, in that case you do not have to boil it.
You post claims I should know something yet fail to post any evidence. In this case, where might I find some evidence boiling this water makes any difference in outcome?

Boiling tap water? Do you also recommend people boil that water before they drink it? Is your nose sterile? Is what you drink not safe for your nose? Are you afraid someone is going to inhale these drops? In which case wouldn't they be washing nasal and nasal-pharynx bacteria into their lung anyway? Are you recommending the nose dropper and glass you mix this stuff in be sterilized as well? Are your bicarb and salt sterile?

With the exception of cryptosporidia outbreaks from city water supplies that proved very dangerous for the immunocompromised, especially AIDS sufferers, I can't see any evidence boiling tap water for a saline nasal wash is indicated. And in the case of AIDS patients, because of the cryptosporidia, they need to boil or avoid tap water period.

skepticdoc said:
What do you recommend to your patients?
Well I've only recommended saline drops to parents for clearing infant nasal passages and maybe young children if they tolerate it, most toddlers don't.

In the infant with nasal congestion, they breathe through the nose and can't clear their own. Teaching the parent how to clear the infant's nasal passages is a critical need for any new parent. It might be useful in other kids who can't "blow" into a tissue, but otherwise I don't think the drops are very useful.

If your nose is dry or irritated, the steam from tea or soup, or an ointment are options. If your nose is just runny, the saline doesn't do much for that. If your secretions are thick, typically the nasal passages are swollen as well. So your going to be mouth breathing anyway. Your body is trying to expel bacteria and viruses, so why wash them back in, in an effort to clear your nose?

If a patient wants to use the drops, I wouldn't discourage them. I would suggest home mix instead of commercial because of preservatives (unknown effects) and cost.

For anything else, it would depend on the patient's problem.
 
Nutritional Supplements Recommendations:
For Everybody:
Vitamin B6 100 mg, one a day (NEVER take more than 200 mgs a day!!!)

Vitamin B12 500-1,000 mcg, one a day
Folic acid 800-2000 mcgs a day (you will find 400 and 800 mcg tablets over the counter, take between 2-5 a day. Make sure you take B12 as recommended above!)

Vitamin C 500 mgs, one a day
Aspirin, plain or enteric coated, 81 to 325 mgs, once a day
Calcium 1,000-1,500 mgs a day, dairy sources preferred, skim milk is a great choice!
Are all these supplements really necessary? Isn't a good multivitamin sufficient for most resonably healthy people?
 
To whom it may apply: opinions are like as.h..es, everybody has one.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom