Medical and Healthcare phishing

This is true. I have only been marginally involved in making sure patients do not get infected by anything I and my colleagues do as respiratory therapists since about, let's see, 1965. Not long. I am not a nurse, epidemiology specialist or infection control expert. I just can read like everyone else here and draw conclusions which I am glad to debate,learn and teach (if that's the result). In 1996 I got out of critical care and started my institution's sleep lab. I was too old and too tired to keep up the pace. Whenever anyone sees me and asks where I've been, I just tell them "I went to sleep."

Ah, so you are not the reptile guy :D

Just something to take note of. Doing a simple google brings up all kinds of junk.

I much prefer this clarification "from the horse's mouth".

You have my respect Steve.
 
It's not moot. The fact is there are two deceased in-patients who died from Legionella whose only documented contact with the disease was the use of a hospital's water supply to fill their passover humidifiers, devices which DO NOT physically produce aerosols or spray. ..... I don't know or care what you, the CDC or the DOH was saying about it but every vendor of this equipment, every respiratory department and every sleep lab which uses this equipment and has patients which use this equipment immediately revisited the issue and use and recommend only sterile water for these non-aerosol/spray producing devices .... if those two dead people somehow found a shower in the hospital and unbeknownst to any staff member snuck in and took a shower (sorta doubt this). But in the meantime, in clearly what is in the best interests of the patients, not you, CDC or the epidemiologists (& I can report our IC nurse-epis agree) sterile water is used....
Let's look at what you are saying here:
  • The humidifier was the source of the legionella. We agree.
    The humidifier resulted in the organisms reaching the site of infection. We agree.
    Putting tap water in the humidifier results in a risk of infection transmission. Not only do we agree, using at least distilled, if not sterile water in any humidifier is standard practice. To use tap water in a humidifier in a hospital setting is a serious breach of infection control standards. It doesn't surprise me that sleep labs, whether in or out of hospitals, had to learn about infection control standards late in the game.* I have never seen a humidifier in any hospital I've ever worked in filled with anything but sterile distilled water.
    You have an hypothesis that condensation on the tubing rather than aerosolizing directly from the humidifier was the means of transmission. You are still missing the point. The humidifier was the source, not a nasal wash. You are taking the definition of an aerosol as it refers to nebulizers and humidifiers and confusing it with how the term aerosol is used in infectious disease transmission. Can you see steam produced by any humidifier given the temperature is cool enough? Those droplets are big enough to carry legionella.
    CDC did not consider other means of transmission from the humidifier than the direct suspension in the air of the organisms. You underestimate the CDC's thoroughness in disease investigation by far. But regardless, a humidifier isn't a nasal wash. The epidemiology of legionella has not suggested aspiration of contaminated water as a source of infection.
    We agree that using non-sterile water in a nasal spray device is probably an unrecognized hazard for many respiratory infections including legionella. I agree that was a good point. While no recognized cases** have yet occurred, the spray mechanism, as opposed to irrigating, does produce an aerosol.

* Dentists had similar lessons to learn after HIV was transmitted in a Florida dental office. Despite the fact the final ruling was the dentist intentionally infected 6 of his patients, infection control standards in dental offices were found to be appallingly inadequate during the investigation.

** If it was a recognized case, CDC would have considered the nasal spray device unless they missed the fact tap water had been used in it. CDC would have investigated any nasal spray device. They also would have looked at any practice of nasal irrigation. The way an investigation of any infectious disease is done when looking for the source of infection, is to collect every single detail about the infected person's life during the time they would have come in contact with the organism, literally. CDC then compares that to any other case and to past cases where the source was identified to find the common denominator.

There are of course, unrecognized cases. But once again, I could worry there are unrecognized cases of fleas on a dog carrying the plague as well. There is not enough evidence here to warrant boiling water for nasal irrigation.


SteveGrenard said:
And there is the mystery of other hospital and community acquired highly resistent pneumonias which you deflect and keep coming back to Legionella. If these two patients did die from non-shower administered tap water Legionella they certainly are also at risk of other bugs such as Pseudomonas.
And you keep blurring the route of transmission of these organisms and in addition, posting as if I don't recognize other infectious disease hazards. Again, let's break this down.
  • Legionella and mTB have similar epidemiology when it comes to route of entry into the body.
    Pseudomonas and Ralstonia have a different route.
    Legionella, pseudomonas and ralstonia have all been found in potable water sources.
    No one should be putting tap water in humidifiers.
    Hospitals should be using sterile water.
    Distilled water is safe for home use.
    A severely immunocompromised person should probably use sterile water at home as well.
    All water used in humidifiers should be properly stored and handled so as not to contaminate it.
    Humidifiers are known sources of infection and particular infection control practices need to be implemented wherever the humidifiers are in the patient's direct air path. IE on a CPAP, ventilator, or O2 delivery devices.
    Room air humidifiers need routine disinfecting as well.

How is it you keep going on about all these infection control issues as if I disagree? You are fighting windmills.

SteveGrenard said:
While it is too soon to say anything definite, the presence of biofilms, what they are exactly, how tap water may contribute to their formation and how their formation may related to infection may impact the way we think about transmission means and now need to be considered in other scenarios since their ocurrence may not be unique to the VapoTherm device and Ralstonia.
IN HUMIDIFIERS.

You need to make a better case for nasal washes presenting the same hazard of infection with legionella as humidifiers present. Saying humidifiers don't aerosolize water droplets is not a case. Saying inline humidifiers are sources of pseudomonas is not a case for legionella in nasal irrigation. Saying water condenses in the tubing of humidifiers is not a case for legionella entering the lung via anything other than inhaled suspended organisms which would have also been present.

The fact studies are lacking as to nasal irrigations being a source of pseudomonas sinus infections is a case against nasal irrigations but the use of tap water isn't likely to add to that disease burden. There's plenty of pseudomonas sources to make boiling tap water only likely to prevent a rare case. If there are cases, we need to stop irrigating, not boil water.

SteveGrenard said:
Would you to place a solution containing Mycobacterium tuberculosis in your nose and in your mouth? Would you be willing to accept such a challenge if it would be possible? A lot of the TB that enters via the mouth is swallowed which is why if we can't get it from expectorated sputum for AFB and culture, we often can retrieve it by sticking down a G-tube and getting it out of the stomach. Nobody is saying that airborne droplets do not transmit any bacterial pathogens, including MTb and Legionella. But ratcheting up the precautions by boiling water for use in home made solutions we are gonna stick in our noses is really not so terrible then is it? It may be conventional wisdom in your book with no scientific basis or studies but it can't hurt.
Actually, in regards to you first question, would I put mTB in my mouth? Yes. We use N95 masks in the presence of airborne mTB. That means the outside of the mask can collect organisms. If that were the only organism on a mask, I would not hesitate to reuse the mask given the risk of getting mTB on my hands and accidentally innoculating my eye nose or mouth with the organisms.

I'm not sure of your point on the fact we recover mTB from sputum whether swallowed or coughed up. That's how we get it to the lab, not how it gets in the next person.

As to "it can't hurt" to boil the water, probably not but you have not made a case that it isn't a waste of time and energy better spent.

SteveGrenard said:
I have these two measley NYC deaths to point to.
More windmills.

SteveGrenard said:
Could you imagine if everyone who has a use for sterile water, including drinking water, were told don't worry, we haven't wasted time and energy on sterilizing it and its filled with
germs but that's okay, there's no evidence that you won't have a better outcome if you just use tap water?
Goodness! How is this relevant?

SteveGrenard said:
I addressed tooth brushingderailment, washing the brush after use and using tap water to rinse.I suppose everyone has their own ritual including you. If a an occasional nursing home patient aspirates any liquid they are served including tap water you and I both know they are placed at increased risk of aspiration pneumonitis or pneumonia, infectious or chemical.
Are you saying there are not enough cases of tap water aspiration occurring or aspiration pneumonia to comprise a big enough sample size for cases of legionella to have occurred by this route?

To review, tap water is aspirated often. No cases of legionella have been related to aspiration of tap water or any other liquid. For that matter, no cases of legionella have been related to nasal irrigation, which is apparently common though I have no satistics on what % of nasal irrigators make their irrigant with tap water.

SteveGrenard said:
Your long hot shower doesn't have MTb
in it.
I only compared route of entry between mTB and legionella. The source of infection for the two are completely different.


From my post:
...the one thing you need to do to prove your case. Find a case of legionella transmitted via anything put in one's nose or mouth.
SteveGrenard said:
CPAP machines use a unique device called a nasal mask, it is a mask that covers the nose. I would guess that means anything coming through this mask enters the patient through the nose. In fact when used with such masks they are called NCPAP or Nasal CPAP. ....
  • In the nose/through the nose:not the same.
    Inhale/irrigation: not the same.
    Breathing/irrigating the nasal passage: not the same.
    Inhale/aspirate: not the same as it pertains to the route of entry in this case.
    Alveoli/rest of the respiratory tree: not the same route of entry.

SteveGrenard said:
The fluid containing an infectious organism does not have to reach the air sacs as you called them earlier in order to become a problem. Bacteria produce toxins, some of which cause tissue necrosis. They don't have to get all the way through the respiratory system down to the "air sac" to be harmful. They can colonize the bronchi. Why do you think it is only MTb and Legionella we are concerned about? Klebsiella, Pseudomonas, Staph and Strep are also problems. There are others. Would you be willing to instill a cocktail of these four into your nasal passages? Sorry, I have to ask.
Why is it you can't separate routes of transmission re these organisms and legionella? These kind of statements are totally ridiculous.

SteveGrenard said:
MTB is a very tough organism. It has a waxy cell wall that protects it before it colonizes. We will have to let medical workers know they don't need to take precautions anymore when working with people who have active TB, can I refer them to you? These days the only thing we have to protect us against contracting TB is our immune systems. The resurgence of the disease is almost certain to have coincided with the rise of HIV but you don't need to have HIV to have a weakened immune system.
Maybe the only thing you have to protect yourself from mTB is your immune system but the rest of us have all sorts of measures from masks to negative pressure isolation rooms. This paragraph is even more unrelated to the discussion than the rest you are posting.

SteveGrenard said:
You have too much faith in cilia. Cilia of smokers for example, cilia bogged down by excessive mucus.
Epidemiology, Steve, not faith in cilia tell us what is or isn't a risk of transmission. Shouldn't you worry about fleas on cats and dogs? There are still a couple of cases of plague every now and then in this country.

SteveGrenard said:
Don't know. Both are death sentences from my perspective. Political probably. Which disease has a better P.R. machine?
So the fact one has a risk of 200 health care worker deaths per year and one has a risk of <10 HCW deaths per year shouldn't matter in prioritizing infection control efforts given limited resources?

As to why perceived risk does not equal measured risk, Peter Sandman is most often referred to as a source of expertise in this area.

SteveGrenard said:
We all have our own individual perspectives and priorities. If one of those happens to be boiling water before we squirt it up our noses then so be it. ....
Well despite my pages of discussion on principle here, boiling tap water for nasal irrigation is not on my list of things the world needs to address. However, getting more people to understand how to evaluate infection hazards and how to decide what measures to take to prevent infection is one of my highest priorities.
 
s'girl, you sure like to argue with experts! Don't you have something better to do with your time?

Just google "Steve Grenard", I would follow Steve's suggestions to the "T" in anything that involves his fields of expertise!

You sound like GWBush, unable to accept you made a mistake.
Oh m'dear. Appeal to authority is no way to argue. And can you say steve here is the same reptile guy as the one who writes some books for sale that you can find on the net? How would that make him more of an authority on microbes, saline, etc. than anyone else anyway?

For more on Logical Fallicies: http://www.fallacyfiles.org/index.html

And Steve's history here indicates he has some way to go before being dubbed an "expert" on anything.
My field is infectious disease and Steve's is a sleep technologist. I do hope s'doc wasn't thinking male meant doc. (No offense to your profession Steve. I would cetainly consider asking you for advice if I had a question in your field.)
 
This is true. I have only been marginally involved in making sure patients do not get infected by anything I and my colleagues do as respiratory therapists since about, let's see, 1965. Not long. I am not a nurse, epidemiology specialist or infection control expert. I just can read like everyone else here and draw conclusions which I am glad to debate,learn and teach (if that's the result). In 1996 I got out of critical care and started my institution's sleep lab. I was too old and too tired to keep up the pace. Whenever anyone sees me and asks where I've been, I just tell them "I went to sleep."...
I respect your opinion. That doesn't mean your infectious disease knowledge base doesn't need some refinement. I have no doubt you know more about sleep disorders than I do. We probably know different things about respiratory care than each other, so either of us may know more about something than the other.

It sounds like we both have ICU experience. I was certified in critical care and practiced there for years but let that lapse when I started working in occupational infectious disease. I overlapped ICU and my NP job because I made a lot more money as a contracted ICU nurse than I did in the NP clinic job I had at that time. I was involved in the first agency that nurses were independent contractors and the agency handled scheduling and billing for us rather than acting as our employer. But that's another very long story in the history of nursing. :D
 
Keep an eye on the biofilm issue ..... I have a feeling we will hear more about this. It's a hypothesis worth considering since it does away with the need for droplets (in some cases) as a means of transmission. I trust you read the link from VapoTherm and at least scanned the Montana research in the field.

Universal precautions for blood and body fluids should be used as much as practical outside the health care profession as well as in it. People who are not HCWs get sick also ... and in much greater numbers than you reflect here for HCWs.


I do worry whether or not my rottie might have fleas and he's checked
for this and would go to the vet for a dip, etc if he did. Ditto for ticks in Lyme territory.

I don't think the common dog or cat flea is the right kind of flea for plague. I would worry about rodent fleas getting on my dog in the four corners areas of the SW U.S. or anywhere sporadic cases mostly in the western US occur. As of now my dog has never ever demonstrably had any fleas or ticks I am happy to say. Good boy!

http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/plague/

I appreciate distilled water isn't guaranteed sterile but if it is made from steam distillation? Its a runner up and might be less costly. Proper storage, dating the bottle and chucking it out within X amount of time is important. I dont know what the current recommendation is or if
refrigerating helps. ??

I am concerned w/preventing not just Legionella or MTb but all potential respiratory pathogens. Against better judegement and control the industry has always said to patients its okay to fill their humidifiers with distilled water, and years ago, even with tap water. They
labor under the well established principle that humdifiers do not produce aerosol or particulate water. Recent events in the field have proved that it is possible to become infected from these devices. This can not only be in the hospital where control of using sterile water only can be enforced in some cases (it didn't happen at Columbia where the deaths happened) but in the home as well. As an aside we tell all patients to dump the water, wash with dishwashing soap, rinse and dry their humdifiers every morning after use.

More time wasted (?) in the opinion of some patients but this has got to be said even if people ignore the advice.

Thank you for an illuminating discussion. Now maybe we can convince skeptic doctor not to have his patients mix up batches of their own solutions at home. Skeptic nurse says boiling isn't worth the trouble, I say the whole thing is not worth the trouble and your patients would be better off squirting unit doses of normal saline to irrigate their noses.

http://www.homecaredelivered.com/catalog/3600/Kimberly-Clark/116A/Unit_Dose_Saline_09.htm
 
Last edited:
Believe what you want to believe. If you are at peace with yourself, there is nothing else to ask for, is there?

Another wonderful non-sequitur.

I wrote my manifesto, the words are mine, the concept was from a pediatrician, his pamphlet content and formatting is totally different from MY words.

What were the words used by the pediatrician? Do you not see the problem with misrepresenting someone else's ideas as your own, even if you use different words? Ray Parker Junior used the "same concepts" of music as Huey Lewis and the News and used his own words (and a different melody line) and had his ass handed to him in court because what he did was plagiarized Huey Lewis and the News' copyrighted material. Though generally most people don't realize that the "Ghostbusters" song completely rips off the structure and chord progression of "I Want a New Drug." Stealing is still stealing unless you properly cite your source. Of course you are well aware of that what with all your schooling and peer review, right?

So, I changed my mind about ignoring s'girl, is that a crime?

It certainly is not a crime, it just shows quite a bit about you. Firstly, it shows your control issues and holier than thou attitude that forces you to have the last word. Secondly it shows you are a drama queen. While I don't have a large crossection of posts to judge you by, you certainly are not impressing anyone with your grandstanding and self-congratulatory posting.

What are your morals?

Irrelevant.

Have I questioned them?

Irrelevant. See below.

Where did you get them?

Is your expected answer "from religion?" or "from God?" Because that would be a mistake. However, my morals are not the issue at stake, unless you wish to specifically make this a personal argument. You originally made the general statement that implied athiests have no morals, and this is a complete falsehood. It also is a very different statement that me, as a specific athiest, has no morals. Shifting goalposts, and poisoning the well.

This article is one of many that refutes that idea.

To quote a little for your benefit:

Nearly all religions contain a moral code that guards against the societal decay that would inevitably come from unrestrained hedonism. Very often, the “teeth” of the moral code is a system of reward and punishment, both temporal and divine. It is then argued that atheists, lacking this system, contribute to societal decay.

At the start, notice that this is not a valid logical argument against atheism, but an argument from consequences fallacy. Be that as it may, it can still be argued that atheists may have a moral code or “conscience”; however this moral code may not include non-utilitarian restrictions found in those of supposedly divine origin.

So to tally it up, your logical fallacies throughout this post are as follows:

1) Non-sequitur
2) Strawman
3) Argument from consequences
4) Poisoning the well

If you need to brush up on your logical fallacies, please do so here.

I really would expect more from such a learned professional as yourself.
 
Last edited:
Ps. Skepticdoc, perhaps you should pay close attention to how Steve and skeptigirl have discussed an issue. It is a stark contrast to your elistist and condescending attitude.
 
Agreed, fowlsound. I've been impressed and pleased, and though I don't follow all of it I have learned some new stuff.
 
I am just waiting fot s'girl's computations.

Sorry for my condescending attitude, one gets burnt out dealing with drug seekers, smokers with COPD, obese people with DM and DJD, etc....

I am still looking for that Shambhala that I keep hearing about, if humans are innately good, why are there evil actions?

I have seen the extremes from religious organizations, is there even a single atheist soup kitchen? or hospital?
 
I am just waiting fot s'girl's computations.

Sorry for my condescending attitude, one gets burnt out dealing with drug seekers, smokers with COPD, obese people with DM and DJD, etc....

Perhaps you went into the wrong profession if you cannot muster anything but disdain for your patients. Might I suggest lab research? At least there you can surround yourself with a sterile and unchanging environment you can control, and that seems to be your intention. The rest of us realize the world is dirty, messy and ugly at times, and can accept this fact without judgement of others or elitist condescention.

I am still looking for that Shambhala that I keep hearing about, if humans are innately good, why are there evil actions?

I don't see anyone claiming that humans are innately good in this thread. That would make your statement a strawman. Whether someone chooses to act in accordance to "good" or "evil" is not only a personal choice of free will, but is also a matter that is clouded by alot of gray area. Of course, you will remember from your first year college ethics classes that defining "good" and "evil" is problematic at best out of context. Your broad sweeping statement is as meaningful as if you had asked "If water is so wet, why is there water vapor?"

I have seen the extremes from religious organizations, is there even a single atheist soup kitchen? or hospital?

That's your second subtle smear at atheists. Do you have something against atheists?

I digress, I'll address that ridiculous strawman. Firstly, you are implying a hospital is a charity, which is not definitively the case. They are businesses and there are many secular hospitals that make no stand on God or religion. Secondly "soup kitchens" are a charity, and there are many secular charities. Perhaps you've heard of the Red Cross (yes, Clara Barton was a deist, however the organization itself is secular)? Or how about Toys for Tots? Since you are a doctor, I would imagine you are familiar with the secular "Doctors Without Borders?" Or the United Way? Are you saying the only way to be charitable is by having a soup kitchen?

Or do you not see the false dichotomy that you are throwing around? Charities do not have to be "Atheist" to be non-religious.

Your question is once again assuming that the religious have a monopoly on charity and that is not the case. One example of openly atheist charities:

http://www.atheistsforhumanrights.org/

Now what exactly do you have against atheists that you would use such a tired and easily disproved "atheists have no morals" smear campaign?

Your logical fallacies this post were:

1) Ad-hominem attack on atheists
2) Non-Sequiter
3) poisoning the well.
4) False Dichotomy
5) Strawman



If you came to pick a fight with atheists, you are on the wrong forum section. I'll happily take this to the R&P section...

I think you have a grave misunderstanding not only of atheists but of this forum in general.


ETA:

I thought you said you were an agnostic?

Yet here you say you are an athiest. Curious, considering your adhoms on athiests in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Hooray, a peaceful ending is in sight. :)
Keep an eye on the biofilm issue ..... I have a feeling we will hear more about this. It's a hypothesis worth considering since it does away with the need for droplets (in some cases) as a means of transmission. I trust you read the link from VapoTherm and at least scanned the Montana research in the field.
Means of transmission is how the organism goes from a to b. That's where droplets and droplet nuclei come in. Reservoir and/or source of infection is the issue with a biofilm. So I'm confused what you mean by doing away with need for droplets.

I looked at the Montana site. It looks like a good source for patient education.

Just a comment on the Vapotherm site. It has nothing to do with you citing the web page for our discussion. I just wanted to point out an observation I noticed. The Vapotherm site noted patient infections with what I assume matched what also grew in their device. They spent plenty of time discussing increased concentrations of disinfectants as remediation and procedures for doing so. But interestingly, they never quite addressed why their "Membrane technology provides highly effective barrier to particle-borne infection" failed. Convenient. I can see the web site committee meeting in progress:

"You can't say our filters failed, that's one of our selling points."
"We can use the don't ask, don't tell approach."
"Great idea, Smithers. Admit we are worried about infection control and taking voluntary remedial measures, but just don't mention the filters."


Someone should start a thread on the morality of marketers.


SteveGrenard said:
Universal precautions for blood and body fluids should be used as much as practical outside the health care profession as well as in it. People who are not HCWs get sick also ... and in much greater numbers than you reflect here for HCWs.
Now if only we could get the schools to put it in the health curriculum.

SteveGrenard said:
I do worry whether or not my rottie might have fleas and he's checked for this and would go to the vet for a dip, etc if he did. Ditto for ticks in Lyme territory.

I don't think the common dog or cat flea is the right kind of flea for plague.
I was being facetious. Dog and cat fleas do not carry plague. Fleas on jack rabbits and ground squirrels in California and Colorado have been responsible for most cases in the USA. I was trying to illustrate why one needn't worry about an infection hazard that isn't known to occur.

SteveGrenard said:
I am concerned w/preventing not just Legionella or MTb but all potential respiratory pathogens.
Just don't leave out the science of epidemiology in infection control. Look at how things spread to find the best means of interrupting transmission. Epidemiology includes everything from reservoir to host, not just means of transmission and portal of entry.

In case you are interested, airborne transmission is divided into a number of subcategories. True airborne transmission occurs over at least some distance and the organisms stay suspended in the air for at least some time. Some of those organisms get into the air from a person or animal, usually from the pharynx or lung but in the case of chicken pox the virus may become airborne from evaporation directly from skin lesions. Some organisms can become airborne from mere talking and breathing while others require coughing. Pulmonary TB requires coughing to spread but the rare cases of TB of the upper airway can spread without coughing.

Some airborne organisms are spread in dust and other bio matter. Haanta virus is spread when infected mouse droppings are swept or vacuumed causing them to become airborne, while a person with haanta virus is not usually contagious. (Exception occurred in Argentina, unique strain of virus.) After the Northridge earthquake there was an increase in coccidomycosis. It is believed the quake actually caused a dust "event" which carried the organisms.

And many things that are really droplet spread are confused with airborne. They are only airborne about 3 feet from the person. The droplets are large and fall to the ground or other surfaces and do not float in high enough numbers to cause infection. Saliva and contaminated surfaces are the real culprits. And I might mention here that the 3 feet rule noted in our Federal pandemic flu plan is only "sort of" true. While a lot of research shows influenza to be droplet spread, some research has confirmed it can also be airborne. We won't really know until we see the specific strain that emerges.

SteveGrenard said:
More time wasted (?) in the opinion of some patients but this has got to be said ...
You'll never hear me argue against infection control education! "Perhaps that was a bit obvious," she said as she ramped down the overdrive....

SteveGrenard said:
Thank you for an illuminating discussion.
Likewise.

But I think s'doc is a whole other ballgame. Re that computation, I suppose the reference will slide past his radar, but it's the way you deal with kids who keep saying, "But why". After the discussion has been repeated once, you do not keep answering the, "but why" question.
 
I have stated I am agnostic.

Secular is not equal to atheist, re-read my post.

I do not have time to label your posts, I am sure everyone self labels theirs as the truth, and anyone that differs, anything else.
 
Secular is not equal to atheist, re-read my post.

sd, why would you imagine that "atheists" (a term I find leads to sloppy thinking like "atheism is a religion," but it's the one we're using so I'll apply it here too) would found and/or operate exclusively atheistic charitable or service organizations? (I take it that by your insistence on calling them "atheistic" instead of secular, you mean organizations that excluded non-atheists from participating; if this is not the case, please make yourself clear.)

Surely you don't seriously believe that "atheism" is an organized, structured instutition comparable to religious sects. But unless you do believe that I can't see how you would expect atheists to behave in the way religious organizations do, right down to cliquishness and bigotry of the kind we've see in religious-based organizations such as the Boy Scouts of America and the Salvation Army. [edit: By cliquishness and bigotry, I mean excluding anyone whose beliefs do not agree with the institution's religious teachings or principles.]

I hope you'll clear this up by answering a few simple questions, without evasion or circumlocution.

1) Do you think atheists, as a group and excluding non-atheists, participate in a non-religious organization or institution that is capable of applying its funds and power to such efforts as operating hospitals?

2) If not, why would a random bunch of unrelated, unassociated, unconnected atheists spontaneously begin communicating and decide to operate a hospital?

3) If you can't suggest why this would happen, why did you ask whether "atheist" soup kitchens or hospitals exist? Near as I can tell it ought to be self-evident.

[edit] Secular institutions include, they do not exclude. The non-religious people I know are in favor of inclusion, not exclusion. Place your hope in secularism.
 
Last edited:
Sorry for my condescending attitude, one gets burnt out dealing with drug seekers, smokers with COPD, obese people with DM and DJD, etc....
With that attitude, it sounds like it's time to retire. I had professors like you in grad school -- bitter, condescending, tired, disinterested, full-of-themselves -- they were not doing any favors to the students by continuing teaching. I suggest that you are not doing any favor to your patients with your current attitude.
 
I have stated I am agnostic.

...and I pointed out that you also used the term atheist.

Secular is not equal to atheist, re-read my post.

Nor did I say it was. Perhaps you should have read my post more clearly. Not only did I give you a specifically atheist charity, I pointed out your false dichotomy of assuming that a charity must be atheist to be non-religious. The fact of the matter is atheists who give charitably give to secular charities, and you fail to take that into consideration with your snobbish preconceptions of atheism.

I do not have time to label your posts, I am sure everyone self labels theirs as the truth, and anyone that differs, anything else.

Non-sequitur. If you find any inconsistencies in my posts, then by all means post your reply for review.
 
Last edited:
Never mind, I retract my questions. It's wasting my time and annoying the sd. I leave the debate (or half a debate) to my betters, who are managing fine without my "contribution."
 
Never mind, I retract my questions. It's wasting my time and annoying the sd. I leave the debate (or half a debate) to my betters, who are managing fine without my "contribution."



I thought your questions were well done. I would like to see an answer from s'doc on them.
 
Well, okay -- I de-retract. :-} It's starting to feel like multi-player Whac-A-Mole, that's all. Mostly I think I'll sit back und watchen das blinkenlights.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom