It's not moot. The fact is there are two deceased in-patients who died from Legionella whose only documented contact with the disease was the use of a hospital's water supply to fill their passover humidifiers, devices which DO NOT physically produce aerosols or spray. ..... I don't know or care what you, the CDC or the DOH was saying about it but every vendor of this equipment, every respiratory department and every sleep lab which uses this equipment and has patients which use this equipment immediately revisited the issue and use and recommend only sterile water for these non-aerosol/spray producing devices .... if those two dead people somehow found a shower in the hospital and unbeknownst to any staff member snuck in and took a shower (sorta doubt this). But in the meantime, in clearly what is in the best interests of the patients, not you, CDC or the epidemiologists (& I can report our IC nurse-epis agree) sterile water is used....
Let's look at what you are saying here:
- The humidifier was the source of the legionella. We agree.
The humidifier resulted in the organisms reaching the site of infection. We agree.
Putting tap water in the humidifier results in a risk of infection transmission. Not only do we agree, using at least distilled, if not sterile water in any humidifier is standard practice. To use tap water in a humidifier in a hospital setting is a serious breach of infection control standards. It doesn't surprise me that sleep labs, whether in or out of hospitals, had to learn about infection control standards late in the game.* I have never seen a humidifier in any hospital I've ever worked in filled with anything but sterile distilled water.
You have an hypothesis that condensation on the tubing rather than aerosolizing directly from the humidifier was the means of transmission. You are still missing the point. The humidifier was the source, not a nasal wash. You are taking the definition of an aerosol as it refers to nebulizers and humidifiers and confusing it with how the term aerosol is used in infectious disease transmission. Can you see steam produced by any humidifier given the temperature is cool enough? Those droplets are big enough to carry legionella.
CDC did not consider other means of transmission from the humidifier than the direct suspension in the air of the organisms. You underestimate the CDC's thoroughness in disease investigation by far. But regardless, a humidifier isn't a nasal wash. The epidemiology of legionella has not suggested aspiration of contaminated water as a source of infection.
We agree that using non-sterile water in a nasal spray device is probably an unrecognized hazard for many respiratory infections including legionella. I agree that was a good point. While no recognized cases** have yet occurred, the spray mechanism, as opposed to irrigating, does produce an aerosol.
* Dentists had similar lessons to learn after HIV was transmitted in a Florida dental office. Despite the fact the final ruling was the dentist intentionally infected 6 of his patients, infection control standards in dental offices were found to be appallingly inadequate during the investigation.
** If it was a recognized case, CDC would have considered the nasal spray device unless they missed the fact tap water had been used in it. CDC would have investigated any nasal spray device. They also would have looked at any practice of nasal irrigation. The way an investigation of any infectious disease is done when looking for the source of infection, is to collect every single detail about the infected person's life during the time they would have come in contact with the organism, literally. CDC then compares that to any other case and to past cases where the source was identified to find the common denominator.
There are of course, unrecognized cases. But once again, I could worry there are unrecognized cases of fleas on a dog carrying the plague as well. There is not enough evidence here to warrant boiling water for nasal irrigation.
SteveGrenard said:
And there is the mystery of other hospital and community acquired highly resistent pneumonias which you deflect and keep coming back to Legionella. If these two patients did die from non-shower administered tap water Legionella they certainly are also at risk of other bugs such as Pseudomonas.
And you keep blurring the route of transmission of these organisms and in addition, posting as if I don't recognize other infectious disease hazards. Again, let's break this down.
- Legionella and mTB have similar epidemiology when it comes to route of entry into the body.
Pseudomonas and Ralstonia have a different route.
Legionella, pseudomonas and ralstonia have all been found in potable water sources.
No one should be putting tap water in humidifiers.
Hospitals should be using sterile water.
Distilled water is safe for home use.
A severely immunocompromised person should probably use sterile water at home as well.
All water used in humidifiers should be properly stored and handled so as not to contaminate it.
Humidifiers are known sources of infection and particular infection control practices need to be implemented wherever the humidifiers are in the patient's direct air path. IE on a CPAP, ventilator, or O2 delivery devices.
Room air humidifiers need routine disinfecting as well.
How is it you keep going on about all these infection control issues as if I disagree? You are fighting windmills.
SteveGrenard said:
While it is too soon to say anything definite, the presence of biofilms, what they are exactly, how tap water may contribute to their formation and how their formation may related to infection may impact the way we think about transmission means and now need to be considered in other scenarios since their ocurrence may not be unique to the VapoTherm device and Ralstonia.
IN HUMIDIFIERS.
You need to make a better case for nasal washes presenting the same hazard of infection with legionella as humidifiers present. Saying humidifiers don't aerosolize water droplets is not a case. Saying inline humidifiers are sources of pseudomonas is not a case for legionella in nasal irrigation. Saying water condenses in the tubing of humidifiers is not a case for legionella entering the lung via anything other than inhaled suspended organisms which would have also been present.
The fact studies are lacking as to nasal irrigations being a source of pseudomonas sinus infections
is a case against nasal irrigations but the use of tap water isn't likely to add to that disease burden. There's plenty of pseudomonas sources to make boiling tap water only likely to prevent a rare case. If there are cases, we need to stop irrigating, not boil water.
SteveGrenard said:
Would you to place a solution containing Mycobacterium tuberculosis in your nose and in your mouth? Would you be willing to accept such a challenge if it would be possible? A lot of the TB that enters via the mouth is swallowed which is why if we can't get it from expectorated sputum for AFB and culture, we often can retrieve it by sticking down a G-tube and getting it out of the stomach. Nobody is saying that airborne droplets do not transmit any bacterial pathogens, including MTb and Legionella. But ratcheting up the precautions by boiling water for use in home made solutions we are gonna stick in our noses is really not so terrible then is it? It may be conventional wisdom in your book with no scientific basis or studies but it can't hurt.
Actually, in regards to you first question, would I put mTB in my mouth? Yes. We use N95 masks in the presence of airborne mTB. That means the outside of the mask can collect organisms. If that were the only organism on a mask, I would not hesitate to reuse the mask given the risk of getting mTB on my hands and accidentally innoculating my eye nose or mouth with the organisms.
I'm not sure of your point on the fact we recover mTB from sputum whether swallowed or coughed up. That's how we get it to the lab, not how it gets in the next person.
As to "it can't hurt" to boil the water, probably not but you have not made a case that it isn't a waste of time and energy better spent.
SteveGrenard said:
I have these two measley NYC deaths to point to.
More windmills.
SteveGrenard said:
Could you imagine if everyone who has a use for sterile water, including drinking water, were told don't worry, we haven't wasted time and energy on sterilizing it and its filled with
germs but that's okay, there's no evidence that you won't have a better outcome if you just use tap water?
Goodness! How is this relevant?
SteveGrenard said:
I addressed tooth brushingderailment, washing the brush after use and using tap water to rinse.I suppose everyone has their own ritual including you. If a an occasional nursing home patient aspirates any liquid they are served including tap water you and I both know they are placed at increased risk of aspiration pneumonitis or pneumonia, infectious or chemical.
Are you saying there are not enough cases of tap water aspiration occurring or aspiration pneumonia to comprise a big enough sample size for cases of legionella to have occurred by this route?
To review, tap water is aspirated often. No cases of legionella have been related to aspiration of tap water or any other liquid. For that matter, no cases of legionella have been related to nasal irrigation, which is apparently common though I have no satistics on what % of nasal irrigators make their irrigant with tap water.
SteveGrenard said:
Your long hot shower doesn't have MTb
in it.
I only compared route of entry between mTB and legionella. The source of infection for the two are completely different.
From my post:
...the one thing you need to do to prove your case. Find a case of legionella transmitted via anything put in one's nose or mouth.
SteveGrenard said:
CPAP machines use a unique device called a nasal mask, it is a mask that covers the nose. I would guess that means anything coming through this mask enters the patient through the nose. In fact when used with such masks they are called NCPAP or Nasal CPAP. ....
- In the nose/through the nose:not the same.
Inhale/irrigation: not the same.
Breathing/irrigating the nasal passage: not the same.
Inhale/aspirate: not the same as it pertains to the route of entry in this case.
Alveoli/rest of the respiratory tree: not the same route of entry.
SteveGrenard said:
The fluid containing an infectious organism does not have to reach the air sacs as you called them earlier in order to become a problem. Bacteria produce toxins, some of which cause tissue necrosis. They don't have to get all the way through the respiratory system down to the "air sac" to be harmful. They can colonize the bronchi. Why do you think it is only MTb and Legionella we are concerned about? Klebsiella, Pseudomonas, Staph and Strep are also problems. There are others. Would you be willing to instill a cocktail of these four into your nasal passages? Sorry, I have to ask.
Why is it you can't separate routes of transmission re these organisms and legionella? These kind of statements are totally ridiculous.
SteveGrenard said:
MTB is a very tough organism. It has a waxy cell wall that protects it before it colonizes. We will have to let medical workers know they don't need to take precautions anymore when working with people who have active TB, can I refer them to you? These days the only thing we have to protect us against contracting TB is our immune systems. The resurgence of the disease is almost certain to have coincided with the rise of HIV but you don't need to have HIV to have a weakened immune system.
Maybe the only thing you have to protect yourself from mTB is your immune system but the rest of us have all sorts of measures from masks to negative pressure isolation rooms. This paragraph is even more unrelated to the discussion than the rest you are posting.
SteveGrenard said:
You have too much faith in cilia. Cilia of smokers for example, cilia bogged down by excessive mucus.
Epidemiology, Steve, not faith in cilia tell us what is or isn't a risk of transmission. Shouldn't you worry about fleas on cats and dogs? There are still a couple of cases of plague every now and then in this country.
SteveGrenard said:
Don't know. Both are death sentences from my perspective. Political probably. Which disease has a better P.R. machine?
So the fact one has a risk of 200 health care worker deaths per year and one has a risk of <10 HCW deaths per year shouldn't matter in prioritizing infection control efforts given limited resources?
As to why perceived risk does not equal measured risk,
Peter Sandman is most often referred to as a source of expertise in this area.
SteveGrenard said:
We all have our own individual perspectives and priorities. If one of those happens to be boiling water before we squirt it up our noses then so be it. ....
Well despite my pages of discussion on principle here, boiling tap water for nasal irrigation is not on my list of things the world needs to address. However, getting more people to understand how to evaluate infection hazards and how to decide what measures to take to prevent infection is one of my highest priorities.