Medical and Healthcare phishing

S'girl knows what I am talking about.

Someday you will understand that the world does not revolve around you, and that there can be conversations that do not involve you.


So I was right, those without proper qualifacations are not welcome to discuss things with you? I've been following this conversation since post 1.

I find it telling no docs have responded to your "phishing" as you put it in the OP.

Ps, nice catch on sequitur. Using spellcheck now?
 
So I was right, those without proper qualifacations are not welcome to discuss things with you? I've been following this conversation since post 1.

I find it telling no docs have responded to your "phishing" as you put it in the OP.

Ps, nice catch on sequitur. Using spellcheck now?

curious, how did I manage to piss you off?

I thought your story is remarkable!
 
S'girl knows what I am talking about.

Someday you will understand that the world does not revolve around you, and that there can be conversations that do not involve you.
This is hilarious. It is fowlsound that knows what the exchanges are about and you that just doesn't get it.

Might I tell you what fowlsound meant by, "You truly are the royalty of the non-sequiter."? He meant you never answer anyone's challenges to, comments about, or questions regarding your posts. You just go on your merry way in your merry world as if the real world doesn't exist.
 
So I was right, those without proper qualifacations are not welcome to discuss things with you? I've been following this conversation since post 1.

I find it telling no docs have responded to your "phishing" as you put it in the OP.

Ps, nice catch on sequitur. Using spellcheck now?
Fowlsound, by no means has s'doc replied to anything I have written. And I am not in the clique because as a nurse, any experience or education I have, whether it is far more than s'doc's in any area or not, whatever I have to say is beneath him. And for what ever reason, ego, fraud, or mental illness, he is in denial that he hasn't responded to anything most people in the forum have had to say. I believe he thinks he has.
 
curious, how did I manage to piss you off?

I thought your story is remarkable!

Thanks, but that's another non-sequitur. You have alot of things that haven't been responded to. My point is that you have touted your credentials as an insulation to this.
 
Last edited:
Please do not think I am elitist


Why would I ever mistake you for elitist?

Not to mention you misrepresented yourself when you posted your manifesto. While I am sure it is not subject to copyright, you first said you wrote it, then admitted you took it from your kid's pediatrician's office.

But I digress, for someone that has twice announced they are not paying any more attention to this thread or skeptigirl, you've shown yourself to be very much of your word. :rolleyes:


ETA:

Your post implying athiests have no morals was a good one too.
 
Last edited:
re boiling. I think it is better to be safe than sorry
I teach against this principle because there is no such thing. What you need is 'risk/cost of taking the action vs benefit of the action/risk of not acting'. Better safe than sorry leads to a lot of bad decisions such as the mass consumption of Ciprofloxacin during the anthrax scare. It was assumed taking the antibiotic was better than risking anthrax. The problem using that logic was, most of the people taking the drug were at zero risk for anthrax. That meant there was zero benefit vs some risk from using the antibiotic.

People often think there might be some risk that may be unidentified. That's the rationale you are using here. But we can test for that. We can look at the thousands of people who apparently wash their noses out on a regular basis. (I wonder if it makes their risk of sinus infection greater or less?) If you see infection, then you have to determine if boiling the water makes any difference. Considering the bacterial load your nose would have imparted into the spray bottle, it is unlikely tap water vs boiled tap water would have any impact whatsoever after the bottle was used once. Of the examples you gave regarding the contaminated spray devices none had anything to do with the solution. One compared nose drops to nose spray but the solutions used were all commercial preps. (After reading those examples I again have to question when the benefit of this nose washing really exceeds the risk! I plan to continue my conservative use of nasal washes for sure.)

So we need to just look at the initial use of the spray. Anything beyond that, improper storage or improper cleaning of the spray device should not be significantly impacted by boiling the water one makes the solution out of since once used there will be gross contamination. (I'll get to the legionella below.) However, after an interesting surf on the net, I have yet to find a single study supporting the use of nasal washing. There is the study on the effect on cilia. And there were several on the negative effects of Benzalkonium chloride on cilia. But after 3 pages on Google and a number of differently worded searches for actual clinical data re the practice on Pubmed, I could only find sales pitch sites with all the usual red flags for fake products. I've saved that for a new thread calling for clinical evidence on the practice. I believe I've uncovered another chapter to add to my Listerine/Lysol group of worthless practices. Soon I'll have enough for my book, "The Things We Always Done/Believed That Are Not True."

So for the moment, unless you can explain why we can drink this water but not rinse our noses with it, I'm standing firm that boiling the water is one big waste of time and energy.

The exceptions would be some unique pathogen that one could drink but not squirt in your nose. Regarding the legionella you think may be a problem, your logic ignores the question, wouldn't drinking the water be just as risky? So I see no case made there.

As long as you brought up the potential cases of legionella in potable water supplies, I thought I should address that anyway.

SteveGrenard said:
...even though as you say chances are slim that a user can develop a URI from a contaminated nasal irrigating soln, especially if the nasal passages are blocked and the soln mixed with softened secretions is discharged. Recent hospital patients didnt get and die from Legionella in the shower like the first cases but got it in one case I am familiar with by filling their own humdiifer brought from home using the hospital's tap water. Bad idea.
Amazingly bad idea.

I looked at the list and pulled the following cases from your first source. The rest attributed the legionella to building ventilation, cooling towers, hot tub jet mist, potting soil, all the known mechanisms of transmission.

In all the cases below, the drinking or potable water supply was possibly the source. (Don't make your nasal wash from the hospital's sink! But don't fill your drinking glass from there either. Actually a good recommendation in general as housekeeping services vary from place to place and hospitals are breeding grounds for the worse pathogens.)

Your source, hcinfo
Rochester, N.Y. Hospital, 3 Cases, 1 Death, January-February 2006
Three patients at a hospital in Rochester, N.Y. contracted Legionnaires' disease within the last four weeks. One has died. The first case was diagnosed on Jan. 27 in a patient who was admitted mid-January with advanced cancer. The second patient, who had been suffering from hepatitis, died Sunday, Feb. 19. The third patient, who was admitted Feb. 2 and receiving chemotherapy treatment for leukemia, was in satisfactory condition as of Tuesday, Feb. 21. After Legionella bacteria was found in the hospital's water system on Feb. 13, all patients were given bottled water, showering was restricted, and the water system was chlorinated. Source: News reports


Pennsylvania Nursing Home, 4 Cases, October-November 2005
Three elderly residents and a volunteer at a nursing home in Harleysville, Pennsylvania, were diagnosed with Legionnaires' disease in late October and early November. The three residents, all women, have recovered. The nursing home’s potable water system was disinfected. Source: Associated Press


NYC Correctional Facility, 2 Cases, October 2005
Two Rikers Island inmates were diagnosed with Legionellosis in October. Both are men, aged 25 and 44 years. The domestic water system was chlorinated. The water was also tested, but apparently not until after the disinfection procedures were carried out. The Department of Health is monitoring the health of inmates and correction employees.


Missouri Hospital, 2 Cases, August 2005
On 3 August a hospital in Columbia, MO reported that two of its patients had contracted Legionnaires' disease during their stay there. The hospital suspects that the patients may have become infected with Legionella while showering. One of the patients has been released; the condition of the other was not reported. Source: Columbia Daily Tribune


NYC Hospital, 2 Deaths, April 2005
A hospital in New York City has reported four cases of Legionnaires' to the health department since last month. Two of the patients have died, although the hospital has not confirmed Legionnaires' disease as the cause. One of the patients, a 63-year-old man, checked into the hospital last month for a procedure intended to sustain his life while he waited for a transplant. On 4 April, his family members were told he had Legionnaires' disease. He died nine days later. Although the source of contamination has not been identified, it’s interesting to note that his wife reported having used hospital tap water to fill the humidifier that was connected to his breathing mask. The New York State Department of Health is investigating the deaths. Source: The Journal News
However, all evidence points to the shower, not the water glass even in these cases. If it were the consumed water, one would expect a different pattern of infection. For one it would be one room only, or everyone's drinking water, not just a few. Whereas the source being the shower is a much better fit to the epidemiology pattern here.

As to the water supply in general, we already know that persons who are immunocompromised are at risk from the same water supply everyone else drinks. If you have AIDS or cystic fibrosis you should not irrigate with tap water. Purchasing sterile water rather than boiling it would give you a source you could pour some out of without having to boil water for a new solution every time.

The hospital water supply as a source of nosocomial infections: a plea for action.
Forty-three outbreaks of waterborne nosocomial infections have been reported, and an estimated 1400 deaths occur each year in the United States as a result of waterborne nosocomial pneumonias caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa alone.

CONCLUSION: Because of the seriousness of these nosocomial waterborne infections and the availability, low cost, and proven effectiveness of sterile water, we recommend that hospitalized patients at high risk for infection avoid exposure to hospital water and use sterile water instead.
While this sounds bad, the cases reported here involved immunocompromised people for the most part. And for those that weren't it wasn't pneumonia that was acquired, it was cryptosporidia. There were a couple large outbreaks associated with large city water supplies.

CONCLUSIONS
So what I gather from all this is there is no evidence to support boiling the water in this recipe. If you can drink it, no worry. If you can't use it in your nose, you may not want to drink it.

If you are immunocompromised use a commercial sterile product and depending on your condition, drink bottled water.

I found no evidence to recommend washing one's nose for ordinary hygiene.

And, I found no evidence legionella infections have ever been traced to the oral route of entry. The infection is acquired by inhalation. If you are breathing in when you irrigate your nose you're in trouble anyway. We know from the pattern of epidemiology that putting legionella in one's nose is not associated with inhalation and subsequent infection. The mechanism of infections that begin in the alveoli, typically do not occur if the organisms are trapped on the way down. They have to be aerosolized to spread.
 
Last edited:
As you know in-patients with IVs, dressings, and Foley's do not usually get to take showers in the hospital. In at least two of the NYC cases you discovered above which I have personal knowledge of, the Legionella was found in the humidifiers of their CPAP machines. It was discovered they had used tap water from a sink to fill them. Then the Legionella was discovered in the hospital's water supply. There are means to match the organisms infecting the patient and that of the water supply, for example:

Legionella Reference Services

The APU offers a wide range of reference and confirmatory tests useful in the investigation of individual cases and outbreaks of legionella infection. These are serology, urinary antigen detection, antigen or genome detection and/or culture from clinical material, identification and where appropriate epidemiological typing of referred isolates.
The laboratory is happy to discuss and advise upon particular diagnostic and clinical problems and laboratory aspects of epidemiological investigations, ask for Dr THarrison (extension 6906) or Dr Robert (extension 7222) in the first instance.
The laboratory works very closely with the colleagues responsible for national surveillance and reports all clinically relevant results to them. National and international surveillance of Legionnaires disease is undertaken by Dr Carol J and Dr John W who may be contacted on xxxxxextensions 7497 and 7481 respectively.

How do you equate drinking water w/ inhaling it? You don't allow that a small quantity of irrigating solution could be "aspirated" without noticing? Do you want to take that chance?
Do you think it is possible to inhale via the oropharyngeal cavity?

If showering is the preferred method of acquiring Legionella, given its prevalence in the water supply, I am surprised there isn't a pandemic by now or more people taking baths than previously thought.

Doesn't your view allow for the fact that there are microorganisms that can be swallowed without a problem but if inhaled become pathogenic? Why would anyone worry about drinking legionella? It's done all day long.

I definitely agree that if you use a solution you make on your own multiple times you could be
auto-contaminating it even if it is sterile when first made. This is what make's the Nasal Comfort applicator unit worthwhile and why buying is better than making your own nasal
solution.

http://www.nasalcomfort.com/micro-filtration_sprayer.aspx

But if you are making it, which I still maintain is a bad idea, at least you won't be starting off with a soln that has legionella, pseudomonas or ralstonia on board if you boil the water
used first.
 
Last edited:
Temporary thread hijack to settle legionella route of transmission.

As you know in-patients with IVs, dressings, and Foley's do not usually get to take showers in the hospital. In at least two of the NYC cases you discovered above which I have personal knowledge of, the Legionella was found in the humidifiers of their CPAP machines. It was discovered they had used tap water from a sink to fill them. Then the Legionella was discovered in the hospital's water supply. There are means to match the organisms infecting the patient and that of the water supply, for example:
Yes, in the humidifier. That creates very fine droplets which are then inhaled. There is no contradiction here to what I said. I posted the cases that were in the hospital's potable water. So I'm not sure what you think I missed here.

SteveGrenard said:
How do you equate drinking water w/ inhaling it? You don't allow that a small quantity of irrigating solution could be "aspirated" without noticing? Do you want to take that chance?
Do you think it is possible to inhale via the oropharyngeal cavity?
Epidemiology tells us this doesn't happen. Maybe you missed my citation from CDC: "all evidence points to the shower". There was a wealth of information there. Much more so than in the news clips you cited. The links in the bibliography were useful as well. And you can search the Emerging Infectious Diseases site at CDC my citation was from.

There are a number of way we study disease transmission. Some are in the lab or with other experimental procedures. The other way is epidemiology. If you look at all cases of legionella, regardless of the source of the organism, including potable water in homes and hospitals, you still see no pattern of infection from drinking the water, or entry of any other contaminant into ones mouth. In addition, every known or suspected route of entry involves fine droplet exposures.

Next we look at who became infected. Not all, but a large number of infected persons were elderly or otherwise debilitated. And while outbreaks involved situations one might question the concentration of infectious particulates the overall pattern indicates it probably takes a fair amount of airborne organisms to result in infection. Debilitated persons are more easily infected. The organisms appear to be very widespread yet the cases relatively few. If the infectious dose was small you'd expect more cases and more otherwise healthy people infected.

Then you want to look at how much solution, when used to irrigate one's nose, is aerosolized. Believe it or not the epidemiology of legionella indicate that just aspirating the organisms is not sufficient. If it were, again you'd see people infected that drank contaminated water because they also aspirate. In nursing homes especially you see aspiration pneumonia, it's very common.

The CDC has done extensive investigation of legionella infections. Those hospital cases in your news clips all involved showers, humidifiers or hospital ventilation. When the cases were traced to potable water, and the patients infected had been unable to or didn't use the shower or didn't have a bed near or use a bathroom where someone else took a shower thus exposing the infected person to the steam, then drinking water would have been on the list of possible sources of infection.

The hospital infection control would have investigated the outbreaks as well if CDC was not involved. Legionella is reportable and a report elicits a local or state health department visit. If you are interested, it is worth looking at one of the health department investigation forms. While I haven't seen the one for legionella, the form for E-coli 0157H7 is pages long and includes questions about every place a person went, everything that did, everything that went in their mouth and so on. Those epidemiolgists love data collection.

Could a case of infection via drinking water have been missed? If one or even more were, they are so few that drinking contaminated water is still a negligible portal of entry.

The legionella was in several cases matched to the potable water strain. I'm not sure if you thought I was questioning the source was the regular water taps in the hospital. I wasn't. Many of the cases including the home cases had sources in the hot water tank. But people drink hot water from the tap. No question legionella could be in your tap water. So why not boil the water you brush your teeth with? Ever look at the tiny droplets all over a mirror after brushing your teeth in close proximity? Those indicate some aerosolization has occurred. I would bet more water is aerosolized when you flush the toilet and brush your teeth than with nasal irrigation. (BTW, E-coli gets on toothbrushes from flushing the toilet with the lid open according to bathroom cultures.)

SteveGrenard said:
If showering is the preferred method of acquiring Legionella, given its prevalence in the water supply, I am surprised there isn't a pandemic by now or more people taking baths than previously thought.
Yes. What this tells us as I mentioned is that virulence is low. IE it takes a large dose to cause infection.

SteveGrenard said:
Doesn't your view allow for the fact that there are microorganisms that can be swallowed without a problem but if inhaled become pathogenic? Why would anyone worry about drinking legionella? It's done all day long.
Absolutely organisms can be swallowed safely but not inhaled. What differs however is that irrigating one's nose does not result in a large amount of aerosolization of fine droplets necessary for some infections which are airborne. This is not true for all organisms mind you. Nor is it true for immunocompromised persons.

But it is apparently true for legionella. And we have another example, mycobacterium tuberculosis where the same is true. It has to do with our respiratory tract protection mechanisms and the dose and conditions the organisms needs to initiate growth. Just as tetanus needs an anaerobic environment to grow, mTB and apparently legionella as well, need the environment found in the alveoli. The rest of the respiratory tract defense mechanisms like the mucus lining of the respiratory tree prevent the organisms from growing and from reaching the alveoli in sufficient numbers to cause infection.

SteveGrenard said:
I definitely agree that if you use a solution you make on your own multiple times you could be
auto-contaminating it even if it is sterile when first made. This is what make's the Nasal Comfort applicator unit worthwhile and why buying is better than making your own nasal
solution.

http://www.nasalcomfort.com/micro-filtration_sprayer.aspx

But if you are making it, which I still maintain is a bad idea, at least you won't be starting off with a soln that has legionella, pseudomonas or ralstonia on board if you boil the water
used first.
Do you have a connection to Nasal Comfort applicators? Not saying you are biased but I have to ask.

What you are still lacking here is any evidence boiling tap water in making this solution matters. We know the nares are full of bacteria. Even if this patient boils the tap water, was there some guideline about boiling the container the water was then poured into, the spoon it was stirred with, the eye dropper or other device used to administer the wash or that the organisms one is worried about haven't already colonized in the nares from having drank the same water every day.

If you are at risk of opportunistic infections, use a commercial prep. Otherwise I doubt we can expect the average citizen to not contaminate something while making this solution. There is no evidence boiling the water is worth the time, effort and energy spent doing so.

And the other thing is we can be advocating evidence based medicine. If we make recommendations to our patients that are not supported by evidence, it makes for setting a poor example. "Better safe than sorry" is not decision making based on scientific principles or evidence. It is decision making based on unfounded beliefs or fear.
 
Yes, in the humidifier. That creates very fine droplets which are then inhaled. There is no contradiction here to what I said. I posted the cases that were in the hospital's potable water. So I'm not sure what you think I missed here.

The humidifiers in question did not produce droplets. They were passover humidifiers that humidify the air but no particulates are formed. The only way the bacteria could've got into the patient respiratory system was by aspirating whole H20 which condenses in the tubing and mask. The same way a whole liquid nasal irrigating soln could be aspirated.

Epidemiology tells us this doesn't happen. Maybe you missed my citation from CDC: "all evidence points to the shower". There was a wealth of information there. Much more so than in the news clips you cited. The links in the bibliography were useful as well. And you can search the Emerging Infectious Diseases site at CDC my citation was from.

I am not saying aspirating or inhaling paritculate splashes in the shower aren't a route of infectious transmission, I was saying they aren't the only one. I appreciate that more people don't get sick just from taking a shower because they have better immunities than those that do.

There are a number of way we study disease transmission. Some are in the lab or with other experimental procedures. The other way is epidemiology. If you look at all cases of legionella, regardless of the source of the organism, including potable water in homes and hospitals, you still see no pattern of infection from drinking the water, or entry of any other contaminant into ones mouth. In addition, every known or suspected route of entry involves fine droplet exposures.

Agreed. I said there was no reason why drinking legionella is any cause for concern. Vibrio, Salmonella, some coliform strains and parasites such as Entamoeba yes, but legionella no. You say "every known route of entry must involve fine droplet exposure." So if you aspirate a 1/2 ml of infected water this doesn't qualify?

Next we look at who became infected. Not all, but a large number of infected persons were elderly or otherwise debilitated. And while outbreaks involved situations one might question the concentration of infectious particulates the overall pattern indicates it probably takes a fair amount of airborne organisms to result in infection. Debilitated persons are more easily infected. The organisms appear to be very widespread yet the cases relatively few. If the infectious dose was small you'd expect more cases and more otherwise healthy people infected.

No argument there. If prescribing a nasal irrigating solution to a patient, one assumes they have some degree of compromise. Its not often suggested to healthy people who have no complaints.

Then you want to look at how much solution, when used to irrigate one's nose, is aerosolized. Believe it or not the epidemiology of legionella indicate that just aspirating the organisms is not sufficient. If it were, again you'd see people infected that drank contaminated water because they also aspirate. In nursing homes especially you see aspiration pneumonia, it's very common.

The commercial units do make an aerosol spray, which is all the more reason to have a sterile solution so we are full circle to the rationale for boiling your water ingredient before you make up your concoction. Again, I have said repeatedly that a commercial product was easier, safer and not as liable to auto-contamination with re-use of the applicator bottle. So technique and applicator type come into play. If you irrigate by injecting a cc of irrigating solution from a tuberculin syringe there is no aerosol made and I was thinking this is what we were talking about when we said "irrigate" -- this is irrigation, the other is nasal spray which
seems to me is being erroneously used interchangeably with a nasal spray.

The CDC has done extensive investigation of legionella infections. Those hospital cases in your news clips all involved showers, humidifiers or hospital ventilation. When the cases were traced to potable water, and the patients infected had been unable to or didn't use the shower or didn't have a bed near or use a bathroom where someone else took a shower thus exposing the infected person to the steam, then drinking water would have been on the list of possible sources of infection.

Why do you keep saying I think drinking water is a source of legionella infection when I repeatedly said it wasn't and asked why you would even ask this? I am glad to see you broadened your list of culprits from showers only. Could you see your away to adding a contaminated home made nasal spray to the list? If so, rationale for boiling.

The hospital infection control would have investigated the outbreaks as well if CDC was not involved. Legionella is reportable and a report elicits a local or state health department visit. If you are interested, it is worth looking at one of the health department investigation forms. While I haven't seen the one for legionella, the form for E-coli 0157H7 is pages long and includes questions about every place a person went, everything that did, everything that went in their mouth and so on. Those epidemiolgists love data collection.

In the legionella deaths of the Columbia patients, they brought their CPAP machines from home along with their passover humdifiers and filled them with hospital tap water. They did this even though the hospital already had caution signs posted about not using tap water and the hospital even had bottles of sterile H20 everywhere for people to use as needed. So there is more to these cases than an epidemiological investigation. I am not an epidemiological expert, I am a humidifier/CPAP expert; any epidemiologists who think passover humidifiers produce a fine aerosol spray that deposits Legionella laden droplets are not experts on the particular devices involved. They do not produce aerosol droplets.

Could a case of infection via drinking water have been missed? If one or even more were, they are so few that drinking contaminated water is still a negligible portal of entry.

The humidifier did it ... but not by aeorosl deposition. Here is a comprehensive review of the subject:

http://www.sleepreviewmag.com/Articles.ASP?articleid=S0405F02



The legionella was in several cases matched to the potable water strain. I'm not sure if you thought I was questioning the source was the regular water taps in the hospital. I wasn't. Many of the cases including the home cases had sources in the hot water tank. But people drink hot water from the tap. No question legionella could be in your tap water. So why not boil the water you brush your teeth with? Ever look at the tiny droplets all over a mirror after brushing your teeth in close proximity? Those indicate some aerosolization has occurred. I would bet more water is aerosolized when you flush the toilet and brush your teeth than with nasal irrigation. (BTW, E-coli gets on toothbrushes from flushing the toilet with the lid open according to bathroom cultures.)

OK always shut the lid before flushing. That's what its there for.
Most institutional and public restrooms don't have lids but then again you shouldn't be brushing your teeth there either.

Yes. What this tells us as I mentioned is that virulence is low. IE it takes a large dose to cause infection.

Yup, a tank of humdifier water used for 6 to 8 hours while asleep should do it alright. If you are saying a few spritzes from a nasal spray isn't sufficient I would have to say I don't know.

Do you have a connection to Nasal Comfort applicators? Not saying you are biased but I have to ask.

No connection but I have suggested it to patients and tried it myself this winter past when I had a stuffed dried up nose and both the patients and myself were quite happy with it. Anecdotal sure. Sorry no EBM to unclog my nose. You think EBM is really important in this case or should we do what works? On the other hand there are plenty studies of nasal decongestants that would qualify as EBM but which have some interesting side effects. If you could get relief and not get these side effects, would that be preferable?

What you are still lacking here is any evidence boiling tap water in making this solution matters. We know the nares are full of bacteria. Even if this patient boils the tap water, was there some guideline about boiling the container the water was then poured into, the spoon it was stirred with, the eye dropper or other device used to administer the wash or that the organisms one is worried about haven't already colonized in the nares from having drank the same water every day.

All reasons to buy it ready made which was my comment from page 1.
 
Last edited:
The humidifiers in question did not produce droplets. They were passover humidifiers that humidify the air but no particulates are formed. The only way the bacteria could've got into the patient respiratory system was by aspirating whole H20 which condenses in the tubing and mask. The same way a whole liquid nasal irrigating soln could be aspirated.
This is a moot point. Whether it is humidity in the air from potted plants or evaporation from a cooling tower or in a building ventilation system, legionella cases occur from aerosolized organisms and there are no cases known which have occurred from aspiration. (Again I'll leave open the possibility of an AIDS or bone marrow transplant type immunosupressed patient.) You are making a claim that you have, as yet, not presented a single case. Point out one of those cases you cited that aspiration was the route of transmission.

SteveGrenard said:
I am not saying aspirating or inhaling paritculate splashes in the shower aren't a route of infectious transmission, I was saying they aren't the only one.
But you can't go making up routes of entry because they seem logical to you.

SteveGrenard said:
You say "every known route of entry must involve fine droplet exposure." So if you aspirate a 1/2 ml of infected water this doesn't qualify?
I don't think 0.5 cc would even reach past the bronchi let alone get in the alveoli. We squirt a whole lot more than than down trach tubes all the time. Your respiratory tree is very moist and there's lots of room for 0.5cc to disperse without dripping into an airsack.

SteveGrenard said:
No argument there. If prescribing a nasal irrigating solution to a patient, one assumes they have some degree of compromise. Its not often suggested to healthy people who have no complaints.
Yes, and from what I gathered after looking extensively, there may be absolutely no evidence this is necessary. I actually found the information very enlightening about the practice of washing out one's nose. Claims were made on product web sites the practice decreased sinus infections. But not a single site, nor a pubmed search turned up a single citation for the claim. I think it's very likely as much BS as Listerine and Lysol are effective against anything cleaning isn't.

SteveGrenard said:
...I was thinking this is what we were talking about when we said "irrigate" -- this is irrigation, the other is nasal spray which
seems to me is being erroneously used interchangeably with a nasal spray.
Now here you may have an issue. If people are making any home brew then aerosolizing it with their empty nasal spray bottle that could be a problem. Especially if they inhale as they squirt which is often done with these products. If you were going to worry about legionella here, then you better worry about all the other places you contaminate that solution after the water is boiled. I would rather a commercial product was used than bothering with all that other prep and risk if that's the case. But even th commercial products are occasionally contaminated with organisms. Look at this big contact lens solution recall going on right now.

All the more reason for someone not to wash out one's nose without a specific reason.

SteveGrenard said:
Why do you keep saying I think drinking water is a source of legionella infection when I repeatedly said it wasn't and asked why you would even ask this? I am glad to see you broadened your list of culprits from showers only. Could you see your away to adding a contaminated home made nasal spray to the list? If so, rationale for boiling.
My list was always broadened. I think you misread something. I have talked about drinking water and aspiration because those are the two events if one was going to get legionella from nasal wash you would expect to also see legionella. It's an all or none phenomenon unless you provide evidence nasal washing produces aerosolized legionella.

SteveGrenard said:
In the legionella deaths of the Columbia patients, they brought their CPAP machines from home along with their passover humdifiers and filled them with hospital tap water. They did this even though the hospital already had caution signs posted about not using tap water and the hospital even had bottles of sterile H20 everywhere for people to use as needed. So there is more to these cases than an epidemiological investigation. I am not an epidemiological expert, I am a humidifier/CPAP expert; any epidemiologists who think passover humidifiers produce a fine aerosol spray that deposits Legionella laden droplets are not experts on the particular devices involved. They do not produce aerosol droplets.
Got a reference on the devices in question? I'll be happy to look at it.

SteveGrenard said:
OK always shut the lid before flushing. That's what its there for.
Most institutional and public restrooms don't have lids but then again you shouldn't be brushing your teeth there either.
But the question is should you boil water you brush with since it's possibly contaminated with legionella?

SteveGrenard said:
Yup, a tank of humdifier water used for 6 to 8 hours while asleep should do it alright. If you are saying a few spritzes from a nasal spray isn't sufficient I would have to say I don't know.
As the guy on CSI says, it's the evidence that speaks.

SteveGrenard said:
...Sorry no EBM to unclog my nose. You think EBM is really important in this case or should we do what works? On the other hand there are plenty studies of nasal decongestants that would qualify as EBM but which have some interesting side effects. If you could get relief and not get these side effects, would that be preferable?
EBM as in evidence based medicine? As for decongestants, I'm a very conservative prescriber. Use one if you have to for work or something but otherwise avoid them. Never use them for chronic allergies unless your symptoms are rare. For chronic problems there are better options. If you have an upper respiratory infection, I prefer single symptom relief meds (IE not the combo products) and only use what you really need. A decongestant does not have the same effect as a nasal wash anyway.

We can get back to those reasons for using the wash but I think it was covered. You believe it "unclogs" your nose. If you have a chronically draining nose and you find rinsing preferable to blowing, that would be fine. If you are just washing your nose for hygiene that might not be.

SUMMARY
There's been no evidence presented legionella is a hazard from homemade nasal washes.

There's been no evidence presented boiling the water in homemade nasal washes has any impact on infection risk.

There's been no evidence presented nasal washes are beneficial unless there is a specific reason. (Some reasons are infants and maybe kids who can't otherwise clear their nasal passage, post op after any surgical nose procedure requiring blood and other stuff be rinsed out, very dry excessive nasal mucous or some evidence a patient can't stop picking their nose to clean it and they are injuring the nasal mucosa. Perhaps others?)

Rationale and opinion are only as good as the results of testing the hypotheses or of uncovering evidence supporting the rationale. I presented evidence and the infectious disease science community's conclusions about how legionella infection is and isn't transmitted. The absence of evidence supporting the practice of routine nasal washing awaits rebuttal with evidence I failed to find.
 
Last edited:
This is a moot point. Whether it is humidity in the air from potted plants or evaporation from a cooling tower or in a building ventilation system, legionella cases occur from aerosolized organisms and there are no cases known which have occurred from aspiration. (Again I'll leave open the possibility of an AIDS or bone marrow transplant type immunosupressed patient.) You are making a claim that you have, as yet, not presented a single case. Point out one of those cases you cited that aspiration was the route of transmission.

Humidity is not an aerosol. An aerosol is a droplet or particulate suspended in the air. Humidifiers humidify, atomizers or nebulizers produce aerosols. Shower heads can produce sprays and are in this category. Forcing a large volume of water through a series of smaller holes creating a spray. I gave the URL above because we need to understand the difference between humidity and aerosol. Humidity is "molecular water", pH20, water vapor pressure if you will which is 47 mmHg at 98.6 F. Aerosol or spray is particulate water suspended in the air. It is rain, it is 100% humidity at whatever temperature it occurs at above freezing point of the solution being nebulized. Aerosols can transport micrororganisms. Molecules of H20 cannot but condensation can.

But you can't go making up routes of entry because they seem logical to you.

I really have to take issue with this one. I am not making up "routes" of entry. The route of entry is the same. I didn't say you could get pneumnonia by taking a legionella-laden enema, nor did I say you could get it by swallowing a legionella laden glass of water. If you want to
split the portal to the respiratory tree into nasopharynx and oropharynx fine. But its only a short distance before they converge and become a common entrance or route of entry. You
can aspirate water through either port and end up with the same result. Its like saying you
can drown only through aspirating water through your mouth and any water you inhale through your nose doesn't count. It does.


I don't think 0.5 cc would even reach past the bronchi let alone get in the alveoli. We squirt a whole lot more than than down trach tubes all the time. Your respiratory tree is very moist and there's lots of room for 0.5cc to disperse without dripping into an airsack.

This is true of the solution but how do you know it is true of the
bacterium once it gets past the carina? ? Not even contaminated droplets/aerosols which verifiably cause TB and pneumonias can reach the alveolus. The infection is planted before the air sac and spreads there. Some pneumonias are even necrotizing. That's why we have something called bronchial pneumonia.

You irrigate with unsterile water? I doubt it. You irrigate with sealed bullets of sterile normal saline and then suction it out. You even use a closed system such as a Ballard catheter:

http://www.southwestmedical.com/AB1588000/showdetl.cfm?&DID=7&Product_ID=59936&CATID=86

Yes, and from what I gathered after looking extensively, there may be absolutely no evidence this is necessary. I actually found the information very enlightening about the practice of washing out one's nose. Claims were made on product web sites the practice decreased sinus infections. But not a single site, nor a pubmed search turned up a single citation for the claim. I think it's very likely as much BS as Listerine and Lysol are effective against anything cleaning isn't.

I have no ideas if lysol or listerine are any good, bit a derailment here. The data on nasal irrigation on PubMed is thin ......I guess there's no money in doing studies on saline nasal sprays. I may agree with you about Listerine but I still have faith in Lister.

All the more reason for someone not to wash out one's nose without a specific reason.

Yes, like you can't breathe, you have apneas and hypopneas while sleeping, you desaturate, you provoke catecholamine release, raising blood pressure, increasing heart rate and generally putting you at risk. You can't force someone to mouth breathe, esepcially if they are asleep.


Got a reference on the devices in question? I'll be happy to look at it.

I gave you a URL that discusses humidifcation via passover humidifiers.
If you want to see them you just enter "passover humidifer" in Google for
a bunch of vendor/manufacturer sites.

But the question is should you boil water you brush with since it's possibly contaminated with legionella?

Bit of a derailment here but okay:

Do you brush with water or do you brush with toothpaste? And rinse with water? I assume you rinse the brush after brushing and that it is dry before the next time you place paste on it.

As the guy on CSI says, it's the evidence that speaks.

incessantly.

EBM as in evidence based medicine? As for decongestants, I'm a very conservative prescriber. Use one if you have to for work or something but otherwise avoid them. Never use them for chronic allergies unless your symptoms are rare. For chronic problems there are better options. If you have an upper respiratory infection, I prefer single symptom relief meds (IE not the combo products) and only use what you really need. A decongestant does not have the same effect as a nasal wash anyway.

We can get back to those reasons for using the wash but I think it was covered. You believe it "unclogs" your nose. If you have a chronically draining nose and you find rinsing preferable to blowing, that would be fine. If you are just washing your nose for hygiene that might not be.

EBM.. yes.

Never said you should wash your nose like you wash your hands.
I said use for dried out, inspissated (add adj) nasal mucus, blowing doesn't work unless you apply irrigating soln first to soften.

There's been no evidence presented legionella is a hazard from homemade nasal washes.

I am glad the companies that make nasal sprays and solutions use
sterile water. I am not so glad those who make eyewashes use contaminated solutions as base for their products but glad they've recalled them. If you don't think it is necessary because there is no evidence you can find that not doing so puts a subject in any kind of risk of any kind of infection (not just legionella which was a relevant example given the hospital humidifier cases) you are entitled to this belief.
 
Last edited:
Why would I ever mistake you for elitist?

Not to mention you misrepresented yourself when you posted your manifesto. While I am sure it is not subject to copyright, you first said you wrote it, then admitted you took it from your kid's pediatrician's office.

But I digress, for someone that has twice announced they are not paying any more attention to this thread or skeptigirl, you've shown yourself to be very much of your word. :rolleyes:


ETA:

Your post implying athiests have no morals was a good one too.


Believe what you want to believe. If you are at peace with yourself, there is nothing else to ask for, is there?

I wrote my manifesto, the words are mine, the concept was from a pediatrician, his pamphlet content and formatting is totally different from MY words.

So, I changed my mind about ignoring s'girl, is that a crime?

What are your morals?

Have I questioned them?

Where did you get them?
 
Humidity is not an aerosol.
The moot point isn't what is or isn't an aerosol. I know the dif. The moot point is the humidifier results in legionella organisms being aerosolized. We know that because it has occurred.


SteveGrenard said:
I really have to take issue with this one. I am not making up "routes" of entry. The route of entry is the same....
You are confusing routes of entry. There are organisms that have to be suspended in very fine airborne droplets in order to be inhaled and not come in contact with the airway walls on their way into the lung. That is the only way they enter the host and grow. MTB is one such organism. You can put the organisms directly in your nose and mouth and you will not become infected. Only concentrated airborne droplet nuclei are able to get passed all the surfaces and reach the alveoli. The epidemiology of legionnaire's disease has so far followed this same pattern. I give mTB as an example because we know more about it. Legionella epidemiology is the same so something similar is occurring.

Unless you can find a reported case of entry via aspiration or in a nasal irrigation solution you are not using evidence to draw your conclusion. Since there have been no cases you are assuming that legionella can infect a person via nasal irrigation solution.

It still comes back to risk/cost vs benefit. Remember, we are discussing whether or not you should boil the water to make the nasal irrigation solution. And we have already excluded immunocompromised persons we both agree should use a commercial solution.

Risk/cost of boiling the water is time and energy, and the additional steps in preparation make the recipe more complicated. Benefit as determined by actual evidence is zero. No demonstration has been made showing better outcome when boiling the water. Find some evidence.

If there is enough of a risk here to boil the solution water, then why not boil the water you brush your teeth with? Brushing produces visible droplets. Why not serve sterile water to nursing home patients? They aspirate more than average. And why not stop showering? That action has been demonstrated to be a risk. Why just choose the activity you have focused on? Clearly greater risks exist.

This comes back to that, "better safe than sorry", I teach people to reexamine and approach more scientifically. In a scientific analysis of the legionella risk, we should be eliminating the known hazards and those with greater potential to cause disease. So...do you want to quit showering over the risk of legionella? I don't. The risk isn't great enough to give up the benefit of a long hot shower. Do you recommend boiling the water you brush your teeth with? Why not?

SteveGrenard said:
This is true of the solution but how do you know it is true of the bacterium once it gets past the carina? ? Not even contaminated droplets/aerosols which verifiably cause TB and pneumonias can reach the alveolus. The infection is planted before the air sac and spreads there. Some pneumonias are even necrotizing. That's why we have something called bronchial pneumonia.
You are really going to great lengths here yet haven't done the one thing you need to do to prove your case. Find a case of legionella transmitted via anything put in one's nose or mouth.

"We even have necrotizing pneumonia"? What has that got to do with anything in this discussion? And organisms can infect every part of the respiratory tree as well as the pharynx, nose, mouth, and esophagus. That has no relevance to the discussion of how mTB and legionella enter the body to cause infection either.

Obviously air reaches the alveoli. What do you base your claim that mTB infection occurs or mTB first accumulates anterior to the alveoli? My understanding is it cannot grow anywhere the respiratory tract has a mucus lining. And since the surfaces anterior to the alveoli have that mucus, and the cilia are moving the mucus and everything trapped in it away from the alveoli, and mTB infection doesn't easily occur, your statement doesn't hold up. But if you have a source for that, I'm more than willing to review it. Even if it isn't relevant to boiling one's water for making nasal irrigation solution.

SteveGrenard said:
You irrigate with unsterile water? I doubt it. You irrigate with sealed bullets of sterile normal saline and then suction it out.
You've lost track of the conversation here. You asked if one aspirated 0.5 cc would it reach very far into the lung. There was no discussion about transmission of disease in my answer to that question. Based on the amount of fluid we irrigate trachs with, which I assume is not enough that it ends up in the alveoli which would be a bad thing, less than that amount would not reach the alveoli either.

SteveGrenard said:
I have no ideas if lysol or listerine are any good, bit a derailment here. The data on nasal irrigation on PubMed is thin ......I guess there's no money in doing studies on saline nasal sprays. I may agree with you about Listerine but I still have faith in Lister.
Lister? As in, "I want to lie, ship wrecked and comatose,..." ;)

Listerine and Lysol are my pet peeve products for false medical beliefs, along with vitamin C for colds*. Plenty on the net is available to convince anyone they are useless products. (*Vitamin C has other uses.) Sorry I digressed there. I suspect nasal washing is right up there in the same category.

SteveGrenard said:
...you can't breathe, you have apneas and hypopneas while sleeping,.....
I think we're in agreement on the specific uses here. No sense getting sarcastic unnecessarily.

SteveGrenard said:
Do you brush with water or do you brush with toothpaste? And rinse with water? I assume you rinse the brush after brushing and that it is dry before the next time you place paste on it.
I rinse my toothbrush first.

SteveGrenard said:
... If you don't think it is necessary because there is no evidence you can find that not doing so puts a subject in any kind of risk of any kind of infection.....
Here's where a lot of common sense isn't sensible.

Perceived risk is often what people act on. But we'd be much better off acting on real risk. (And we don't act on every risk either. Seatbelts, easy...giving up bacon to lower artery disease...hard. No brainer on the seatbelt, personal preference on the bacon vs less artery disease.)

Take HIV and risk to health care workers. Hepatitis B has been a risk in health care since the first needle was used. There were ~12,000 new infections and ~200 deaths per year in the USA in health care workers infected on the job when the vaccine was developed we implemented "universal precautions". But it wasn't until HIV appeared that workplace safety laws were written, safer needles were designed, safety campaigns were implemented and universal precautions were expanded to body substance precautions (now called standard precautions). HIV has infected less than 200 health care workers in the USA in the almost 30 years since it was first seen in this country.

Why was so much attention paid to HIV and so little to Hep B? Because the perceived risk of HIV is high, and the perceived risk of Hep B is low. The factors involved in perceived risk have been identified and there is research in this area I won't elaborate on here.

The principle I encourage people to apply in decision making about actions that prevent accidents and infection is to recognize perceived risk vs real risk and not waste energy on the least beneficial actions at the expense of more beneficial actions. In the time spent boiling that water a person could replace the battery in the smoke alarm, boil the kitchen sponge instead (actually I recommend not using one but if you do), make the salad you would have skipped because you had no time, take a power nap, etc., etc., etc. There are any number of actions one can do in ten minutes that provide more health benefits than preventing legionella by an action there is no evidence will even decrease risk anyway.
 
Believe what you want to believe. ....
Apologizing for your elitist attitude about giving nurses orders to follow yet refusing to accept the significant contribution nurses also "order" for the patient's care might be more effective than this post or the patronizing "everyone is important" comment you made a while back. If you believe you really don't have an elitist attitude that is.
 
s'girl, you sure like to argue with experts! Don't you have something better to do with your time?

Just google "Steve Grenard", I would follow Steve's suggestions to the "T" in anything that involves his fields of expertise!

You sound like GWBush, unable to accept you made a mistake.
 
The moot point isn't what is or isn't an aerosol. I know the dif. The moot point is the humidifier results in legionella organisms being aerosolized. We know that because it has occurred.

It's not moot. The fact is there are two deceased in-patients who died from Legionella whose only documented contact with the disease was the use of a hospital's water supply to fill their passover humidifiers, devices which DO NOT physically produce aerosols or spray. Was inadvertent aerosolization of condensate possible? Maybe. I don't know. Also probable is the possibility that non-droplet condensate was aspirated during sleep. Maybe ..I don't know. Was a biofilm involved? (see below). These cases appeared on the front page of several New York newspapers when the deaths were announced. I don't know or care what you, the CDC or the DOH was saying about it but every vendor of this equipment, every respiratory department and every sleep lab which uses this equipment and has patients which use this equipment immediately revisited the issue and use and recommend only sterile water for these non-aerosol/spray producing devices which do not qualify as showers either. Yes, we could all be wrong, and someday somebody may come up with a proven alternative scenario. Now I know two dead people are not much, but we don't know if there are others who went under the radar including those nursing home patients you mention or if those two dead people somehow found a shower in the hospital and unbeknownst to any staff member snuck in and took a shower (sorta doubt this). But in the meantime, in clearly what is in the best interests of the patients, not you, CDC or the epidemiologists (& I can report our IC nurse-epis agree) sterile water is used.I have no connections to the sterile water industry or any water bottlers either...nor have I received funding from such entities. (ed to add: In retro I also don't see the CDC or local DHs saying not to use sterile water whenever possible either. In fact such agencies would the first ones to scream the loudest were there a lapse in the protocol by a hospital or vendor of equipment that somehow involves the use of water.).

And there is the mystery of other hospital and community acquired highly resistent pneumonias which you deflect and keep coming back to Legionella. If these two patients did die from non-shower administered tap water Legionella they certainly are also at risk of other bugs such as Pseudomonas. And you have hardly even heard yet of what I hope doesn't become the next threat, Ralstonia (formerly at one time included as a Pseudomonas species). It's a constant battle and we try. Ralstonia got into patients from a device called the VapoTherm, a high flow oxygen device that also does not produce an aerosol by any stretch of the imagination but merely humidifies the inspired oxygen. The company recalled the devices and issued new recommendations involving the use of sterile water and improved disinfection procedures. They also checked their disposable cartridges to see if they were contaminated but so far I haven't seen the results of that or maybe, because of pending litigation, never will. The VapoTherm situation opened up a whole new route of possible infectious transmission involving the formation of biofilms ... for more preliminary information you may want to look at:

http://www.vtherm.com/about/news.asp?id=62

as well as CDC reports which are also on line. While it is too soon to say anything definite, the presence of biofilms, what they are exactly, how tap water may contribute to their formation and how their formation may related to infection may impact the way we think about transmission means and now need to be considered in other scenarios since their ocurrence may not be unique to the VapoTherm device and Ralstonia. I am stupid enough to say I just don't know. The University of Montana is the leading center for the study of the formation of biofilms. Visit with them at:

http://www.erc.montana.edu/

Listening to reasons to be less cautious, and less vigilant would be counterproductive in waging such battles. Prescribing sterile commercial aqua distillata or saline is more productive.


You are confusing routes of entry. There are organisms that have to be suspended in very fine airborne droplets in order to be inhaled and not come in contact with the airway walls on their way into the lung. That is the only way they enter the host and grow. MTB is one such organism. You can put the organisms directly in your nose and mouth and you will not become infected. Only concentrated airborne droplet nuclei are able to get passed all the surfaces and reach the alveoli. The epidemiology of legionnaire's disease has so far followed this same pattern. I give mTB as an example because we know more about it. Legionella epidemiology is the same so something similar is occurring.

Would you to place a solution containing Mycobacterium tuberculosis in your nose and in your mouth? Would you be willing to accept such a challenge if it would be possible? A lot of the TB that enters via the mouth is swallowed which is why if we can't get it from expectorated sputum for AFB and culture, we often can retrieve it by sticking down a G-tube and getting it out of the stomach. Nobody is saying that airborne droplets do not transmit any bacterial pathogens, including MTb and Legionella. But ratcheting up the precautions by boiling water for use in home made solutions we are gonna stick in our noses is really not so terrible then is it? It may be conventional wisdom in your book with no scientific basis or studies but it can't hurt.



Unless you can find a reported case of entry via aspiration or in a nasal irrigation solution you are not using evidence to draw your conclusion. Since there have been no cases you are assuming that legionella can infect a person via nasal irrigation solution.

I have these two measley NYC deaths to point to. You won't see them written up in any medical journals just yet, probably because they are being litigated. In the meantime we cannot afford to wait for them to be studied. In the meantime I am not gonna sit around and say okay, its just two cases, let's wait and see if there are any more or worse let's see if anyone sues us before we ratchet up the precautions to include sterilized water.


It still comes back to risk/cost vs benefit.

Remember, we are discussing whether or not you should boil the water to make the nasal irrigation solution. And we have already excluded immunocompromised persons we both agree should use a commercial solution.

I have no qualms over saying a commercially prepared sterile solution is a better option than kitchen chemistry.

Risk/cost of boiling the water is time and energy, and the additional steps in preparation make the recipe more complicated. Benefit as determined by actual evidence is zero. No demonstration has been made showing better outcome when boiling the water. Find some evidence.

Could you imagine if everyone who has a use for sterile water, including drinking water, were told don't worry, we haven't wasted time and energy on sterilizing it and its filled with
germs but that's okay, there's no evidence that you won't have a better outcome if you just use tap water?
If there is enough of a risk here to boil the solution water, then why not boil the water you brush your teeth with?

Brushing produces visible droplets. Why not serve sterile water to nursing home patients? They aspirate more than average. And why not stop showering? That action has been demonstrated to be a risk. Why just choose the activity you have focused on? Clearly greater risks exist.

I addressed tooth brushingderailment, washing the brush after use and using tap water to rinse.I suppose everyone has their own ritual including you. If a an occasional nursing home patient aspirates any liquid they are served including tap water you and I both know they are placed at increased risk of aspiration pneumonitis or pneumonia, infectious or chemical.

This comes back to that, "better safe than sorry", I teach people to reexamine and approach more scientifically. In a scientific analysis of the legionella risk, we should be eliminating the known hazards and those with greater potential to cause disease. So...do you want to quit showering over the risk of legionella? I don't. The risk isn't great enough to give up the benefit of a long hot shower. Do you recommend boiling the water you brush your teeth with? Why not?

I am not suggesting any of what you say here. Would you be comfortable irrigating your nose or filling your mouth with water that contains MTb? Your long hot shower doesn't have MTb
in it. I agree if you have a normal immune system there is little risk from Legionella which may or may not be present. Who knows?

You are really going to great lengths here yet haven't done the one thing you need to do to prove your case. Find a case of legionella transmitted via anything put in one's nose or mouth.

CPAP machines use a unique device called a nasal mask, it is a mask that covers the nose. I would guess that means anything coming through this mask enters the patient through the nose. In fact when used with such masks they are called NCPAP or Nasal CPAP. See above for two Legionella cases.



"We even have necrotizing pneumonia"? What has that got to do with anything in this discussion? And organisms can infect every part of the respiratory tree as well as the pharynx, nose, mouth, and esophagus. That has no relevance to the discussion of how mTB and legionella enter the body to cause infection either.

The fluid containing an infectious organism does not have to reach the air sacs as you called them earlier in order to become a problem. Bacteria produce toxins, some of which cause tissue necrosis. They don't have to get all the way through the respiratory system down to the "air sac" to be harmful. They can colonize the bronchi. Why do you think it is only MTb and Legionella we are concerned about? Klebsiella, Pseudomonas, Staph and Strep are also problems. There are others. Would you be willing to instill a cocktail of these four into your nasal passages? Sorry, I have to ask.

Obviously air reaches the alveoli. What do you base your claim that mTB infection occurs or mTB first accumulates anterior to the alveoli? My understanding is it cannot grow anywhere the respiratory tract has a mucus lining. And since the surfaces anterior to the alveoli have that mucus, and the cilia are moving the mucus and everything trapped in it away from the alveoli, and mTB infection doesn't easily occur, your statement doesn't hold up. But if you have a source for that, I'm more than willing to review it. Even if it isn't relevant to boiling one's water for making nasal irrigation solution.

MTB is a very tough organism. It has a waxy cell wall that protects it before it colonizes. We will have to let medical workers know they don't need to take precautions anymore when working with people who have active TB, can I refer them to you? These days the only thing we have to protect us against contracting TB is our immune systems. The resurgence of the disease is almost certain to have coincided with the rise of HIV but you don't need to have HIV to have a weakened immune system.

You've lost track of the conversation here. You asked if one aspirated 0.5 cc would it reach very far into the lung. There was no discussion about transmission of disease in my answer to that question. Based on the amount of fluid we irrigate trachs with, which I assume is not enough that it ends up in the alveoli which would be a bad thing, less than that amount would not reach the alveoli either.

You have too much faith in cilia. Cilia of smokers for example, cilia bogged down by excessive mucus.

Lister? As in, "I want to lie, ship wrecked and comatose,..." ;)

Lister as in Joseph Lister, the guy who dreamed up aseptic surgery and a new use for carbolic acid. Thankfully we have found better apoproaches since his day.

I think we're in agreement on the specific uses here. No sense getting sarcastic unnecessarily.

Pretty much in agreement. Sorry if you think I was sarcastic.

Perceived risk is often what people act on. But we'd be much better off acting on real risk. (And we don't act on every risk either. Seatbelts, easy...giving up bacon to lower artery disease...hard. No brainer on the seatbelt, personal preference on the bacon vs less artery disease.)

Perceived risk can be a good thing. It not only covers your patient's butt, it covers yours.

Take HIV and risk to health care workers. Hepatitis B has been a risk in health care since the first needle was used. There were ~12,000 new infections and ~200 deaths per year in the USA in health care workers infected on the job when the vaccine was developed we implemented "universal precautions". But it wasn't until HIV appeared that workplace safety laws were written, safer needles were designed, safety campaigns were implemented and universal precautions were expanded to body substance precautions (now called standard precautions). HIV has infected less than 200 health care workers in the USA in the almost 30 years since it was first seen in this country.

Long overdue. No argument there.

Why was so much attention paid to HIV and so little to Hep B? Because the perceived risk of HIV is high, and the perceived risk of Hep B is low. The factors involved in perceived risk have been identified and there is research in this area I won't elaborate on here.

Don't know. Both are death sentences from my perspective. Political probably. Which disease has a better P.R. machine?

The principle I encourage people to apply in decision making about actions that prevent accidents and infection is to recognize perceived risk vs real risk and not waste energy on the least beneficial actions at the expense of more beneficial actions. In the time spent boiling that water a person could replace the battery in the smoke alarm, boil the kitchen sponge instead (actually I recommend not using one but if you do), make the salad you would have skipped because you had no time, take a power nap, etc., etc., etc. There are any number of actions one can do in ten minutes that provide more health benefits than preventing legionella by an action there is no evidence will even decrease risk anyway.

We all have our own individual perspectives and priorities. If one of those happens to be boiling water before we squirt it up our noses then so be it. On the other hand buying a sterile, sealed 3 ml bullet of generic normal saline or some other commercial product is a far better approach.
 
Last edited:
s'girl, you sure like to argue with experts! Don't you have something better to do with your time?

Just google "Steve Grenard", I would follow Steve's suggestions to the "T" in anything that involves his fields of expertise!

You sound like GWBush, unable to accept you made a mistake.

Oh m'dear. Appeal to authority is no way to argue. And can you say steve here is the same reptile guy as the one who writes some books for sale that you can find on the net? How would that make him more of an authority on microbes, saline, etc. than anyone else anyway?

For more on Logical Fallicies: http://www.fallacyfiles.org/index.html

And Steve's history here indicates he has some way to go before being dubbed an "expert" on anything.
 
Last edited:
This is true. I have only been marginally involved in making sure patients do not get infected by anything I and my colleagues do as respiratory therapists since about, let's see, 1965. Not long. I am not a nurse, epidemiology specialist or infection control expert. I just can read like everyone else here and draw conclusions which I am glad to debate,learn and teach (if that's the result). In 1996 I got out of critical care and started my institution's sleep lab. I was too old and too tired to keep up the pace. Whenever anyone sees me and asks where I've been, I just tell them "I went to sleep."

To the above reference re TB that is orally ingested, this is usually sputum that has been coughed up and swallowed, just to clarify.

Herpetology, especially snakebite envenomation, is a hobby by the way.....since, er about, 1958 or so.

For an assesment of my background, it seems you defer to the person who thinks snakes have eyelids and people walk around on drumsticks or that someone who claims she remains drug free for 30 days out of 365 each year is not a drug addict. That's fine.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom