Again, wow, just wow! ....
What is the tonicity/osmolarity of my Pt's recipe?
Is this supposed to be impressive? News flash! A nursing degree requires courses in chemistry, both organic and inorganic, as well as in physiology. It doesn't take 4 years to get that bed bath part down.
But the real issue here isn't the hypothesis regarding the saline vs saline with bicarb. I actually was quite interested in the difference and will investigate further. Last I worked in ICU, quite a few years back, we still irrigated trach tubes with saline. I hope, if the citation I found has been confirmed with further studies, that the irrigation practice has been revised.
The real issues here are:
- 1) does saline vs saline + bicarb matter in nasal irrigation,
2) does it matter enough to justify making the "recipe" more complicated,
3) if one makes the recipe more complicated are more mistakes in concentration made and are any of those mistakes likely to result in serious consequences that create risk which outweighs the benefit of the more complex recipe,
4) and most important of all, is there really a benefit in irrigating one's nose in the first place (infants excepted) or has the practice been recommended since before evidence based medicine without adequate testing?
S'doc said:
Your arguments and criticism of my posts tell more about you than me, arguing about a salty solution to rinse the nose? What is next, arguing about how I put on my pants? How I type?
Compare the posts, few lines ellicit many, many more! Do you really work? How come you have time to keep arguing with me, and even tracking my posts in other threads?
Well since you asked....
There have been two sequential reasons I have continued with this interesting exchange.
The first was merely to explain the science of nursing and how it differs from the science of medicine. The practice of nursing could use a lot more PR than the typical TV ads proclaiming "nurses care".
After posting a sufficient amount of information on the science of nursing and how nursing and medicine overlap in so many ways, I thought I had said enough and didn't expect to say much more. But then.....
You started posting "bad" medicine. Not the anecdotes, but rather the recommendations and elaborating on the manifesto.
The origin of the skeptics' community, websites and forums came from a common desire many of us have to address "bad" science and/or "junk" science. For me personally, I have to address the "bad" medical beliefs and the "junk" science beliefs of my patients and students on a daily basis. In order to teach about preventing infectious disease I must first address the incorrect beliefs already held. In addition, the ability of marketers, religious and political leaders to dupe people has dire consequences for us all from unnecessary war to unchecked global warming.
You, OTOH, made claims about wanting to meet other skeptics in the medical field.
You mentioned atheism as if that was all the skeptical community was about. But from your posts, it's pretty clear you don't really get the concept of skepticism. Skepticism is about evidence and science. In medicine it's about evidence based medicine. You don't support a recommendation for saline and bicarb nasal wash with the science of chemistry and the physiology of nasal mucous membranes. You start there. But you support that practice recommendation with research that shows the outcome is indeed the outcome you desire. And if you can't support the practice, then you shouldn't be recommending it.
Atheism does not equate to skepticism. There are many theist skeptics. I may think their theist beliefs contradict skepticism but theist skeptics manage to compartmentalize those beliefs and maintain skeptic values overall.
I post "pages of material" when called for to refute any "bad" medicine or "junk" science if it is on a matter I feel I have enough expertise to comment on. Not just yours. One must support one's opinion or conclusions if one is going to challenge "bad" medicine. Otherwise one is just giving one opinion that differs from another opinion. Replying to "bad" medicine and "junk" science is one reason I post in these forums at all. The other reasons are to learn from others and to get a little emotional support knowing there are other people who think "junk" science and "bad" science are indeed very important issues.
Whether you ever "get it" or if you even pick up a little insight into what skepticism and the skeptical community are all about, I may never know. It seems you are either in denial about the content of what I've posted, or you can't admit in this forum, anything I've said is logical, correct, and supported by the evidence. But even if it doesn't sink into your brain, other people read the threads. I believe sharing my insight is helpful as is my reading the insight of other skeptics.
Information exchange is almost always useful to someone.
As far as time to post is concerned, I read and type fast. I check all sorts of sites on the Internet almost daily to keep up on certain events anyway (politics and bird flu currently, along with earthquakes, solar flares and science breakthroughs for fun). And you have given great openings to post some important points. It was your insulting posts and attitude about nurses that led me to check what you had posted in other forums. That and the fact you referred in an earlier post in this thread to what you had posted on the Skeptic's forum. Now that you have revealed you don't really understand what evidence based medicine and skepticism are all about, I'm glad I didn't just ignore you.
When you are not using it, does your broom rest on the floor or does it hover/ levitate over the ground?
Oh the irony! Interesting metaphor considering that in the history of medicine, there is evidence physicians and other male "healers" exploited the concept of witches to get female healers and midwives out of their way.
Witches, Midwives and Nurses : A History of Women Healers