Medical and Healthcare phishing

Are all these supplements really necessary? Isn't a good multivitamin sufficient for most resonably healthy people?

I believe most FDA commisioners don't believe in any supplements.

Theoretically a well ballanced diet will contain everything that you need.

Of course, there is that thing called reality, folate supplements reduce neural tube defects, but who is arguing?
 
I believe most FDA commisioners don't believe in any supplements.

Theoretically a well ballanced diet will contain everything that you need.

Of course, there is that thing called reality, folate supplements reduce neural tube defects, but who is arguing?
Skepticdoc, do you not check your facts before making public statements? Especially in light of your making general recommendations to people.

First, the FDA is not responsible for supplement recommendations, per se. I cited them as a source warning against daily aspirin for everyone, not as a source recommending particular supplements. Aspirin is a very useful drug for many people. I believe 80 mg every other day is sufficient for anticoagulant effects if indicated for the individual in the first place.

FDA Mission Statement
The FDA is responsible for protecting the public health by assuring the safety, efficacy, and security of human and veterinary drugs, biological products, medical devices, our nation’s food supply, cosmetics, and products that emit radiation. The FDA is also responsible for advancing the public health by helping to speed innovations that make medicines and foods more effective, safer, and more affordable; and helping the public get the accurate, science-based information they need to use medicines and foods to improve their health.

Specifically, the FDA position on dietary supplements is the
FDA is responsible for taking action against any unsafe dietary supplement product after it reaches the market .... FDA's post-marketing responsibilities include monitoring safety, e.g. voluntary dietary supplement adverse event reporting, and product information, such as labeling, claims, package inserts, and accompanying literature. The Federal Trade Commission regulates dietary supplement advertising.

It is the USDA that is responsible for the Recommended Dietary Allowances. Food & Nutrition Information Center: Dietary Reference Intakes (DRI) and Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDA)
In light of new research findings and a growing public focus on nutrition and health, the expert panel responsible for formulation RDAs reviewed and expanded its approach--the result: Dietary Reference Intakes. ...
This new series of references greatly extends the scope and application of previous nutrient guidelines. For each nutrient the book presents what is known about how the nutrient functions in the human body, what the best method is to determine its requirements, which factors (caffeine or exercise, for example) may affect how it works, and how the nutrient may be related to chronic disease. ... Based on analysis of nutrient metabolism in humans and data on intakes in the U.S. population, the committee recommends intakes for each age group--from the first days of life through childhood, sexual maturity, midlife, and the later years. Recommendations for pregnancy and lactation also are made, and the book identifies when intake of a nutrient may be too much. Representing a new paradigm for the nutrition community, Dietary Reference Intakes encompasses:

* Estimated Average Requirements (EARs). These are used to set Recommended Dietary Allowances.
* Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDAs). Intakes that meet the RDA are likely to meet the nutrient requirement of nearly all individuals in a life-stage and gender group.
* Adequate Intakes (AIs). These are used instead of RDAs when an EAR cannot be calculated. Both the RDA and the AI may be used as goals for individual intake.
* Tolerable Upper Intake Levels (ULs). Intakes below the UL are unlikely to pose risks of adverse health effects in healthy people.

This new framework encompasses both essential nutrients and other food components thought to pay a role in health, such as dietary fiber. It incorporates functional endpoints and examines the relationship between dose and response in determining adequacy and the hazards of excess intake for each nutrient.

Their recommendations are available online. RE Folate and pregnancy:
To reduce the risk of neural tube defects for women capable of becoming pregnant, the recommendation is to take 400 µg of folic acid daily from fortified foods, supplements, or both in addition to consuming food folate from a varied diet.

There is extensive current research going on in the field of anti-oxidants and their effects on both aging and cardiovascular disease.

My position on these supplements is as follows.

Everyone who doesn't eat a proper diet (about 90% of us by my guess) should probably take at least a good daily vitamin. Only kids and menstruating women or people with other bleeding disorders need daily iron. And for menstruating women and perhaps kids as well, alternating one bottle with iron and the next without is more than adequate unless blood tests indicate other wise. You'd be amazed how fast your iron stores are replenished considering how iron supplements are marketed to women.

And just a reminder, toddlers who eat the bottle of vitamins with iron are in need of the ED and a call to poison control. Vitamins without iron are not as great a poisoning risk as those with iron, though I'd consult poison control with any and every thing a child consumed they were not supposed to. It never hurts to call while not calling can hurt.

The importance of certain supplements are well documented. Folic acid before, during and after pregnancy if breast feeding is one of those supplements. If a person cares to ensure they get the minimum amount from dietary sources and prefers not to use supplements, they can certainly accomplish it. Most women have no opposition to taking supplements during pregnancy. It is easier plus assures adequate intake.

Any woman attempting weight loss or experiencing mild depression or SAD, Seasonal Affective Disorder, should consider the recommendations in Dr. Brown's work on "Body Blues" and consider those supplements along with a daily dose of "going outside".

Many supplements have only preliminary data available as to their benefits beyond basic identified minimum doses. In that case I have my practical guidelines and these are the same for supplements and alternative medicine as well.

If there might be a benefit... (when the benefit is ruled out stop taking the stuff)
If it doesn't hurt you...
If it is relatively inexpensive...
If you aren't taking it in lieu of something with proven results...

Then go ahead.

I take a number of supplements that have potential anti-aging effects. If the research indicates they are of no benefit, I will stop. If a patient asked me about them, I'd let the patient know where the current research stood. Once the research indicated strong support of the benefit of the use of the supplement, then I would definitely recommend it to all patients it applied to.
 
Last edited:
Again, wow, just wow!

Don't you think the saline "recipe" was just a bait?

What is the tonicity/osmolarity of my Pt's recipe?

Your arguments and criticism of my posts tell more about you than me, arguing about a salty solution to rinse the nose? What is next, arguing about how I put on my pants? How I type?

Compare the posts, few lines ellicit many, many more! Do you really work? How come you have time to keep arguing with me, and even tracking my posts in other threads?

When you are not using it, does your broom rest on the floor or does it hover/ levitate over the ground?
 
Doctor's Ward round, 8am.

SD: "Hey Nurse! Yes, you there! Tell me about my first patient!"

Cardiac Specialist Nurse: "We admitted Mrs Jones last night. She is a 55 year old with ischaemic heart disease..."

SD: "What do you mean by "we"? Did you nurses clerk the patient in personally? How do you presume to know what is wrong with her? And how do you spell ischaemic?"

Cardiac Specialist Nurse: "I meant that we did all the admitting paperwork, clinical examination and cardiac observations. Her ischaemic heart disease is well documented from previous admissions, and was the reason for referral."

SD: "Well she looks alright to me... why can't you send her home?"

Cardiac Specialist Nurse: "Her initial EKG showed 4mm ST elevation in the anterior leads, indicating acute infarction. Her cardiac troponins were also significantly raised with a TnI of 6.5. She was successfully thrombolysed with Alteplase. According to standardised protocol, she requires gradual mobilisation, and exercise treadmill test at day 5 and involvement of the cardiac rehabilitation nursing team."

SD: "Don't you patronise me! Do you think I went through 6 years of med school without knowing how to treat a heart attack? No, wait, maybe you'd better not answer that one. And don't you dare mention nursing teams to me as though they contribute anything to patient care! Haven't you got a bed pan to go and empty, or a broom to fly off on?"

SD is carried off the ward by two men in white coats, waving his right hand which has the middle finger extended, jabbing it at the ceiling. His parting cry can just be heard above the sound of universal laughter from patients, nurses and doctors:
"How dare you all LOL! You should read my manifesto! Now, before its too late!"
 
I shut down my Nimbus 2000, and store when I am not using it.

BTW, the saline helps a lot of people, it is cheap, and maybe effective for relief of allergic rhinitis. I felt it would be just a small civil gesture to share my patient's recipe. Go figure!
 
I considered just letting the whole issue go, and just keep poking with some sarcasm/irritation until others just let the thread die.

But then I had an epiphany, where else can I have an honest discussion of a relatively simple topic? This is perhaps the premiere site against homeopathy and quackery in the world! ( I have never logged on to the Quackwatch discussion list, I sent the blank e-mail as I was writing this ).

What is wrong with providing the Saline recipe as written by my patient to others?

I know there are no case-control group studies.
I would venture that I will get as many different compositions as the number of "cooks" ( the volume could be a constant using a measuring cup, but there are two many variables with the teaspoon measure, 2-3? heaping? or not?)

I have advised my patients to squirt it, rinse the nasal cavity, snort and blow the nose from a cupped hand or even gargle with it. I tell them to modify the recipe to their taste.

Medically/scientifically my justifications are to provide mucosal humidity, wash out dust and pollen. I tell my patients, that if they feel it is helping them, do it as needed. Many ENT specialists recommend this, similar recipes or the commercial versions like Ayr, Ocean or other brands.

This is not homeopathy, we can measure the salt or bicarbonate in the solution, I doubt anybody will fund the scientific study of a cheap and presumably safe solution of salt, modified to taste by the individual who is using it!

Please either coment on the thread or send me a PM.

Thanks
 
Medically/scientifically my justifications are to provide mucosal humidity, wash out dust and pollen. I tell my patients, that if they feel it is helping them, do it as needed. Many ENT specialists recommend this, similar recipes or the commercial versions like Ayr, Ocean or other brands.

This is not homeopathy, we can measure the salt or bicarbonate in the solution, I doubt anybody will fund the scientific study of a cheap and presumably safe solution of salt, modified to taste by the individual who is using it!

Please either coment on the thread or send me a PM.

Thanks

Nothing is wrong with it. There are a number of products on the market and they are widely recommended by ENTS and other physicians when dealing with blocked nasal passages. Oxygen and CPAP patients are
especially prone to nasal drying and these kinds of products are recommended all the time. It depends on whether the patient can be trusted to formulate their own which is not rocket science but may be for some people. Also the nifty spray bottles that commercial products come in are helpful.

http://www.nasalcomfort.com/

http://www.flemingcompany.com/products/OCEAN/index.htm
 
Thanks Steve, for a moment I felt like I was in "The Twilight Zone" or one of Dante's circles!
 
Again, wow, just wow! ....

What is the tonicity/osmolarity of my Pt's recipe?
Is this supposed to be impressive? News flash! A nursing degree requires courses in chemistry, both organic and inorganic, as well as in physiology. It doesn't take 4 years to get that bed bath part down.

But the real issue here isn't the hypothesis regarding the saline vs saline with bicarb. I actually was quite interested in the difference and will investigate further. Last I worked in ICU, quite a few years back, we still irrigated trach tubes with saline. I hope, if the citation I found has been confirmed with further studies, that the irrigation practice has been revised.

The real issues here are:
  • 1) does saline vs saline + bicarb matter in nasal irrigation,

    2) does it matter enough to justify making the "recipe" more complicated,

    3) if one makes the recipe more complicated are more mistakes in concentration made and are any of those mistakes likely to result in serious consequences that create risk which outweighs the benefit of the more complex recipe,

    4) and most important of all, is there really a benefit in irrigating one's nose in the first place (infants excepted) or has the practice been recommended since before evidence based medicine without adequate testing?



S'doc said:
Your arguments and criticism of my posts tell more about you than me, arguing about a salty solution to rinse the nose? What is next, arguing about how I put on my pants? How I type?

Compare the posts, few lines ellicit many, many more! Do you really work? How come you have time to keep arguing with me, and even tracking my posts in other threads?
Well since you asked....

There have been two sequential reasons I have continued with this interesting exchange. The first was merely to explain the science of nursing and how it differs from the science of medicine. The practice of nursing could use a lot more PR than the typical TV ads proclaiming "nurses care".

After posting a sufficient amount of information on the science of nursing and how nursing and medicine overlap in so many ways, I thought I had said enough and didn't expect to say much more. But then.....

You started posting "bad" medicine. Not the anecdotes, but rather the recommendations and elaborating on the manifesto.

The origin of the skeptics' community, websites and forums came from a common desire many of us have to address "bad" science and/or "junk" science. For me personally, I have to address the "bad" medical beliefs and the "junk" science beliefs of my patients and students on a daily basis. In order to teach about preventing infectious disease I must first address the incorrect beliefs already held. In addition, the ability of marketers, religious and political leaders to dupe people has dire consequences for us all from unnecessary war to unchecked global warming.

You, OTOH, made claims about wanting to meet other skeptics in the medical field. You mentioned atheism as if that was all the skeptical community was about. But from your posts, it's pretty clear you don't really get the concept of skepticism. Skepticism is about evidence and science. In medicine it's about evidence based medicine. You don't support a recommendation for saline and bicarb nasal wash with the science of chemistry and the physiology of nasal mucous membranes. You start there. But you support that practice recommendation with research that shows the outcome is indeed the outcome you desire. And if you can't support the practice, then you shouldn't be recommending it.

Atheism does not equate to skepticism. There are many theist skeptics. I may think their theist beliefs contradict skepticism but theist skeptics manage to compartmentalize those beliefs and maintain skeptic values overall.

I post "pages of material" when called for to refute any "bad" medicine or "junk" science if it is on a matter I feel I have enough expertise to comment on. Not just yours. One must support one's opinion or conclusions if one is going to challenge "bad" medicine. Otherwise one is just giving one opinion that differs from another opinion. Replying to "bad" medicine and "junk" science is one reason I post in these forums at all. The other reasons are to learn from others and to get a little emotional support knowing there are other people who think "junk" science and "bad" science are indeed very important issues.

Whether you ever "get it" or if you even pick up a little insight into what skepticism and the skeptical community are all about, I may never know. It seems you are either in denial about the content of what I've posted, or you can't admit in this forum, anything I've said is logical, correct, and supported by the evidence. But even if it doesn't sink into your brain, other people read the threads. I believe sharing my insight is helpful as is my reading the insight of other skeptics. Information exchange is almost always useful to someone.

As far as time to post is concerned, I read and type fast. I check all sorts of sites on the Internet almost daily to keep up on certain events anyway (politics and bird flu currently, along with earthquakes, solar flares and science breakthroughs for fun). And you have given great openings to post some important points. It was your insulting posts and attitude about nurses that led me to check what you had posted in other forums. That and the fact you referred in an earlier post in this thread to what you had posted on the Skeptic's forum. Now that you have revealed you don't really understand what evidence based medicine and skepticism are all about, I'm glad I didn't just ignore you.

When you are not using it, does your broom rest on the floor or does it hover/ levitate over the ground?
Oh the irony! Interesting metaphor considering that in the history of medicine, there is evidence physicians and other male "healers" exploited the concept of witches to get female healers and midwives out of their way. Witches, Midwives and Nurses : A History of Women Healers
 
Normal or physiological saline is 0.9 per cent. These products use hypertonic saline such as 2.5 per cent. I believe bicarb or other buffers are added to adjust the pH to that of normal saline.

Patients with CF have particularly tenacious often infected secretions and impaired mucociliary clearance. A recent study demonstrated that inhaling a nebulized solution of hypertonic saline
was better than the enzyme deoxyribonuclease in the short term but not the long:

http://www.cochrane.org/reviews/en/ab001506.html

Here is an analysis of multiple trials with hypertonic saline:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=10796798&dopt=Abstract

which doesn't support hypertonic saline nebulization in CF.
 
Last edited:
Well make yourselves comfortable, looks like we are in for a LONG ride.

In my corner of the world, I see Podiatrists claiming to be primary care physicians, there is even a dentist that completed a Maxillo-Facial surgery Residency and somehow was allowed to take the Medical Boards and add M.D. to his signature. I have also briefly enraged DOs that claimed that manipulation helped people survive the Spanish Flu in 1918 ( probable misnomer, the epidemic may have lasted 3 years, but peaked in 1918? ). my point?

Medicine now is like a bad Rodney Dangerfield skit, no respect!

Between our little circle of forum friends: the doctors themselves are probably their own worst enemy! The specialists dumping on the primary care physicians, and hiring themselves nurses to work like doctors for them.
 
Good points skeptic nurse:

1) does saline vs saline + bicarb matter in nasal irrigation ... yes

2) does it matter enough to justify making the "recipe" more complicated
....yes if you use hypertonic saline you want to lower the pH. Don't ask
me how/why, I tell my patients to buy the stuff. Or use normal saline
to begin with, also store bought or prescribed if insurance will pay for it)

3) if one makes the recipe more complicated are more mistakes in concentration made and are any of those mistakes likely to result in serious consequences that create risk which outweighs the benefit of the more complex recipe....

...probably.

4) and most important of all, is there really a benefit in irrigating one's nose in the first place (infants excepted) or has the practice been recommended since before evidence based medicine without adequate testing?

yes. We can learn from patients on nasal O2 who have a problem with drying even when the O2 is humidifed with a bubbler which is a lousy form of ambient temperature humidifcation but it may help a little bit. The nasal secretions become dry and block the nsal passages rather insidiously blocking the inhalation of the oxygen which then escapes back out the nares into the room and the patient may not know it. Some people sense this and pick their nose with their fingers or a Q-tip and end up with bleeding. It is better to irrigate,soften the dried mucus and then blow your nose. So home nasal O2 patients with this problem are instructed to do this routinely every hour or couple of hrs as necessary. I am surprised this isn't paid more attention on in-patients for whom we rely on pulse ox readings to make sure the O2 is
getting in, and then if not, to find out why or up the O2 if indicated. In trouble shooting such problems I always ask the patient to blow out through the nose and whether or not they can breathe through the nose. Irrigation is added if this indicates it to be the problem.

Yes babies are obligatory nasal breathers so keeping their little noses clear with irrigation and a bulb syringe is pretty important. But children and adults also breathe through their noses so it would benefit them as well. Mouth breathing is not as effective, increases the work of breathing, is just less efficient. I would prefer both passages remain patent: nasal and oropharyngeal.
Wouldn't you?

You dont have to be on O2 to get dried nasal passages, particularly in the wintertime.
 
Last edited:
Nothing is wrong with it. There are a number of products on the market and they are widely recommended by ENTS and other physicians when dealing with blocked nasal passages. Oxygen and CPAP patients are
especially prone to nasal drying and these kinds of products are recommended all the time. It depends on whether the patient can be trusted to formulate their own which is not rocket science but may be for some people. Also the nifty spray bottles that commercial products come in are helpful.

http://www.nasalcomfort.com/

http://www.flemingcompany.com/products/OCEAN/index.htm
S'doc implied the use of nasal wash was questioned. Perhaps my last post explains better what my point was. But lest the distortion of my post go unchecked allow me to add a bit of clarification here.

It was the boiling of the water for 10 minutes that was the main objection, not the nasal wash itself. That practice has not been supported with any evidence so far.

In addition I asked for evidence the bicarb was necessary. (See above post for more details.) In response to the request for evidence, S'doc provided an "expert opinion" as his evidence. Experts are nice but a lot of our medical practices are based on the infamous, "we've always done it that way" rationale. I did, however, find my own evidence for the bicarb and shared that. BTW, in that same article the researchers also make a case against commercial products because the preservatives have deleterious effects on the cilia as well. It's worth looking at.

The only reason I said I don't recommend the wash was in direct questioning of my own practice. I have not seen any evidence other than in infants that a general recommendation to wash out one's nose was of any benefit. For any more than that re my own practice, it would depend on the problem one was addressing. And, if you read my post I said I wouldn't discourage a patient who already used the practice. I don't have any negative evidence there either but I can think of several hypotheses why not to do it.

For example in my practice: a nare blocked with dried mucus, sure, use the wash. How often does that occur? Not very.

Dry membranes or bloody noses from dry membranes: there are various measures to increase the humidity in one's environment from houseplants to steam or a humidifier. Wetting your nose intermittently will actually result in a drier membrane. That's what happens when you lick your lips and they dry out and become chapped. As the moisture evaporates it takes additional tissue moisture with it. By increasing the humidity in the air, you decrease the evaporation gradient instead. With O2 it needs to be humidified. You've seen that little bottle of water on the hospital wall the O2 bubbles through on its way to the patient no doubt? Humidifiers can be added to home O2 administration and CPAP devices as well. But even if not available, an ointment will work much better than a nasal wash. (It appears from looking for home O2 humidifiers, infection control issues occur. Were I to prescribe home O2 I would investigate further. I do not currently have patients coming to me for chronic respiratory care. The ointment is still preferable over the nasal irrigation.)

Nasal congestion: I see no benefit unless the patient believes it helps.

Just because there are products for sale does not mean there is a benefit. Just because medical providers use or recommend the products does not mean there is a benefit. Listerine and dentists is an excellent example.

And the issues here is not the saline washes. The issue is where's the evidence?

**Note added: Nasal sprays do not appear to be FDA approved. So they do not need to provide evidence of effectiveness as long as they don't make claims of treating medical conditions.
 
Last edited:
Good points skeptic nurse:

1) does saline vs saline + bicarb matter in nasal irrigation ... yes

2) does it matter enough to justify making the "recipe" more complicated
....yes if you use hypertonic saline you want to lower the pH. Don't ask
me how/why, I tell my patients to buy the stuff. Or use normal saline
to begin with, also store bought or prescribed if insurance will pay for it)

3) if one makes the recipe more complicated are more mistakes in concentration made and are any of those mistakes likely to result in serious consequences that create risk which outweighs the benefit of the more complex recipe....

...probably.

4) and most important of all, is there really a benefit in irrigating one's nose in the first place (infants excepted) or has the practice been recommended since before evidence based medicine without adequate testing?

yes. We can learn from patients on nasal O2 who have a problem with drying even when the O2 is humidifed with a bubbler which is a lousy form of ambient temperature humidifcation but it may help a little bit. The nasal secretions become dry and block the nsal passages rather insidiously blocking the inhalation of the oxygen which then escapes back out the nares into the room and the patient may not know it. Some people sense this and pick their nose with their fingers or a Q-tip and end up with bleeding. It is better to irrigate,soften the dried mucus and then blow your nose. So home nasal O2 patients with this problem are instructed to do this routinely every hour or couple of hrs as necessary. I am surprised this isn't paid more attention on in-patients for whom we rely on pulse ox readings to make sure the O2 is
getting in, and then if not, to find out why or up the O2 if indicated. In trouble shooting such problems I always ask the patient to blow out through the nose and whether or not they can breathe through the nose. Irrigation is added if this indicates it to be the problem.

Yes babies are obligatory nasal breathers so keeping their little noses clear with irrigation and a bulb syringe is pretty important. But children and adults also breathe through their noses so it would benefit them as well. Mouth breathing is not as effective, increases the work of breathing, is just less efficient. I would prefer both passages remain patent: nasal and oropharyngeal.
Wouldn't you?

You dont have to be on O2 to get dried nasal passages, particularly in the wintertime.
But adults can blow their noses so don't need irrigating, that's the difference there.

I agree we may not humidify the O2 in the hospital enough.

I have seen studies that even with nasal prongs inhaling through the mouth draws the O2 in.

> than a few liters via nasal prongs one gets no additional benefit with nasal O2 so a mask is needed and humidity a different issue.

Do you have any studies that intermittent nasal wash is effective for dry mucous membranes? I believe we do disagree here.

I noticed the Ocean product did not appear to have anything but isotonic saline and a preservative, IE no bicarb.
 
But adults can blow their noses so don't need irrigating, that's the difference there.

....if the mucus and membranes are dried irrigating improves that

I agree we may not humidify the O2 in the hospital enough.

......O2 is a bone dry gas; bubbling through room temperature water raises
the RH to about 20% depending on the room temperature. It is not nearly enough to compensate for the water loss from through the epithelium
to raise the RH% to that of body temperature. CPAP Machines are now finally
becoming more widespread with accessory or built in heated passover humdifiers
and should always be ordered this way. They can always be turned down or off if not
wanted.


I have seen studies that even with nasal prongs inhaling through the mouth draws the O2 in.

......this is called blow-by. Only a small % of the 2 to 4 LPM of nasal oxygen turned away due to blocked nares ends up captured by oral breathing. Most is diluted with the room and
dissipates.


> than a few liters via nasal prongs one gets no additional benefit with nasal O2 so a mask is needed and humidity a different issue.

....in the hospital a venti mask. O2 concentrators do not have sufficient
flow for their use at home. You would need tanks in the house and they would need to be changed every day and a half. This would be prohibitely expensive. Any patient in this situation would be better off in the hospital. Nasal O2 via concentrator has made it much easier and far less expensive for patients to be at home on O2.

.....Do you have any studies that intermittent nasal wash is effective for dry mucous membranes? I believe we do disagree here.

This technique harkens back to decades ago, is well studied on the basis of physical principles involving relative humidity. I gave you a couple of references where hypertonic saline was no better than controls and only had short term benefit over an enzyme that breaks down/liquifies dried mucus in the worst kinds of cases which are patients with CF. The literature on this is huge but the ideas are textbook by now and often
are at odds with each other. Sometimes you have to go with what works.
No, I can't point to anyone study which doesn't have another which contradicts. When a patient complains of nasal dryness, scabbing in the nose, blocked nasal passages and hasn't used routine irrigation then it is worth trying. I disagree that blowing the nose alone in people with dried up secretions in the nasal airways is always helpful; it may even be hazardous as such strong blowing is necessary it could result in vagal stimulation. I'd rather make it easier for them and this seems to work. I agree ointments are definitely worth using also. I have tried Boroleum and RoEzIt.

www.boroleum.com

www.roezit.com


I noticed the Ocean product did not appear to have anything but isotonic saline and a preservative, IE no bicarb.

....bicarbonate would be unnecessary if you used isotonic or normal saline solution to begin with (0.9%).

edited to add:

Here is an abstract of a study of iso vrs hypertonic saline irrigation using CBF as the indicator. The authors echo my sentiments regarding the conflicting results obtained in innumerable studies. Nasal irrigation, by the way, produces 750K hits on Google.

[SIZE=+1]A blinded, randomized, controlled study on the effect of buffered 0.9% and 3% sodium chloride intranasal sprays on ciliary beat frequency.[/SIZE]

Wabnitz DA, Wormald PJ.

Department of Surgery, Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Adelaide and Flinders Universities, Adelaide, South Australia.

BACKGROUND: There are conflicting reports regarding the effect of intranasal saline sprays on the various components of the mucociliary clearance system. This study evaluates the effect of normal saline and hypertonic saline on the ciliary beat frequency (CBF). METHODS: Eight healthy volunteers were randomized to receive 0.9% saline spray to one nostril and 3.0% saline spray to the other. Ciliated cells were collected, and the CBF was calculated using computerized microphotometry. RESULTS: Although neither solution significantly altered the CBF from baseline measurements, there was a significant difference between the CBFs of the two solutions at 5 minutes postadministration (9.1 Hz with 0.9% saline, 10.1 Hz with 3.0% saline, P < .05). This was a transient effect and was not seen when cells were examined at 60 minutes postadministration. CONCLUSION: The administration of hypertonic saline results in a significantly faster CBF 5 minutes after administration. This effect is not seen 60 minutes after administration.
 
Last edited:
So S'girl, what is your calculation for my patient's recipe?
I missed it when I read your post.

Again, why is boiling the water a bad idea?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom