Medical and Healthcare phishing

Reminds me of a joke.
Two tosspots are at a bar, when the female sez, "Women can do anything men can do, and better."
The male sez, "How far can you piss up a wall?"
"Higher than you."
So they go into the back alley and she goes first. A remarkable performance, with the highest point about 5 feet up the wall.
He says, "No problemo", and is about to micturate when she says, "Hey, Jerko, no hands!"
 
I copied the concept from our child's pediatrician.
So, it was not original with you? I thought you claimed authorship.:confused:

I only posted it to try to relieve the rumors/concerns that I am not a physician, and stirred up the tempest,
How would posting such a manifesto prove or disprove anything about you? It only proves that it could be posted by you, not what your qualifications are or that you even wrote it.:confused: :confused:

BTW "tempest in a teapot" are not my words.
Well, I did a search in the last three-fourths of this thread on "tempest" and on "teapot", and your posts were the earliest I could find. Is my software faulty, or were you referring to its usage in all of literature (where I KNOW they weren't your original words).;)

Cheers
Dave
 
The words are my own. I copied or was inspired by the "concept", you can imagine that a pediatrician's guide would be different in many ways.

"tempest in a teapot" is from a PM, I cannot disclose the author without his/her approval ( I was under the impression PMs are confidential, unwritten "internet commandment")

Any other questions?
 
Reminds me of a joke.
Two tosspots are at a bar, when the female sez, "Women can do anything men can do, and better."
The male sez, "How far can you piss up a wall?"
"Higher than you."
So they go into the back alley and she goes first. A remarkable performance, with the highest point about 5 feet up the wall.
He says, "No problemo", and is about to micturate when she says, "Hey, Jerko, no hands!"
That's great.
 
"tempest in a teapot" is from a PM, I cannot disclose the author without his/her approval ( I was under the impression PMs are confidential, unwritten "internet commandment")
“Where does tempest in a teapot come from?”
[A] I’m not familiar with that American version. If I wanted to express the same idea, I’d say it was a storm in a teacup, which is the common British equivalent. Either way, it’s a delightful phrase for a fuss about nothing very much, or a dispute of only minor or local importance.

These two forms are by no means the only ones. The big Oxford English Dictionary has examples of a storm in a cream bowl and a storm in a wash-hand basin, and suggests that there were others. All have this idea of a violent disturbance in a small compass, by implication therefore one of little significance. The alliteration of tempest in a teapot must have helped its acceptance.

Of the two best-known versions tempest in a teapot seems to be the older, since I’ve found an example from a long-defunct journal called The United States Democratic Review of January 1838 about the Supreme Court: “This collegiate tempest in a teapot might serve for the lads of the University to moot; but, surely, was unworthy the solemn adjudication attempted for it”.

Yes yes, can't quite defend your position on the nursing profession, your manifesto, your claim you are a physician, so best to trivialize what others have had to say. Best to pretend a rational discussion is a rant and dismiss it.

The more you post, the less like a physician you sound. It is the level on which you reply, skepticdoc. A physician would know immediately what was meant by a request to explain the purpose of that manifesto. We have been using evidence based medicine for a decade now. Yet you cannot verbalize the objective in that manifesto in even the most basic terms. You claim it has some purpose of deceiving your patients to think you are a theist, or helping them through serious illness or death when they need religion as a comfort, but the list is given as some rules to live by, fitting neither goal in even a remote way.

You can't verbalize how the manifesto would achieve any purpose. That just isn't the level of discussion a physician would have.

And your "anecdotes" contained medical inaccuracies. Would you like to hear them?
 
Yes. What is it about the question, "What is the purpose of your manifesto", that you do not understand?

Nobody else but a doctor would write the "manifesto".

Truthfully, I am psychic, I read your mind and soul and knew it would piss you off, skeptigirl! ( is that easier to accept? ) I got another vision while reading the NY Times, you may be "cat lady", how many do you have?
 
Last edited:
“Where does tempest in a teapot come from?”

Yes yes, can't quite defend your position on the nursing profession, your manifesto, your claim you are a physician, so best to trivialize what others have had to say. Best to pretend a rational discussion is a rant and dismiss it.

The more you post, the less like a physician you sound. It is the level on which you reply, skepticdoc. A physician would know immediately what was meant by a request to explain the purpose of that manifesto. We have been using evidence based medicine for a decade now. Yet you cannot verbalize the objective in that manifesto in even the most basic terms. You claim it has some purpose of deceiving your patients to think you are a theist, or helping them through serious illness or death when they need religion as a comfort, but the list is given as some rules to live by, fitting neither goal in even a remote way.

You can't verbalize how the manifesto would achieve any purpose. That just isn't the level of discussion a physician would have.

And your "anecdotes" contained medical inaccuracies. Would you like to hear them?

Please, by all means, I can hardly wait!
BTW, look at the thread "Did Randi die?"
 
Skepticdoc
To what extent was the purpose of your initial post to find skeptical physicians who are fighting quackery and how much to find openly atheistic physicians (and therefore to find how they cope with theistic patients) ?
These are two quite different purposes.

I was initially taken aback by your claiming to be an "honest agnostic phsyician" (post 46) and yet having a blatantly theistic manifesto.
 
I copied the concept from our child's pediatrician.
Do you give your manifesto to adults? If so, do you see how something that in concept may work to give guidance to very young children, would be seen as simplistic and condescending by adults? It's also stating your beliefs and they don't necessarily correspond with your patients beliefs or reality. Lets take this one:

4. Honor and respect your elders; the way you treat your parents will be the guide your children will follow to treat you.
What if someone's parents were horrible people who abused or neglected their children? Should someone honor and respect them for that?

Apart from the usefulness or lack of usefulness of your manifesto, you could easily make it religion nuetral and still maintain its "words to live by" message. For the lines that refer to religion or religious concepts they could be edited as follows:
1. Remember that we are on earth to serve God; listen to His messages in its various forms; don't hesitate to ask for His help.
This one you'll just have to strike - there's no way it can be made religiously nuetral unless you just say "Remember that we are here on earth to help our fellow man. Don't hesitate to ask for your friends and communities help."

2. Develop your potentials and skills to the fullest extent possible, God gave them to you to help others.
How about "Develop your potentials and skills to the fullest extent possible and use them to enhance your's and other's lives."

6. Enjoy life and the blessings that you have received with your family; sing, dance, fish, play, run, go to the theater, watch a movie, get a pet, etc.; remember to thank God for everything that you have received.
Strike the last part about God.

12. Share with your doctor all your concerns about soul, mind, body and family.
Try: "Share with your doctor all your concerns about your physical, mental, and emotional health and that of your family."

I don't really see what all the reference to religion are for. Some patients believe and some don't. If someone is a believer, they're going to get comfort from their religion whether you reinforce their beliefs or not. And for those who don't believe, your manifesto is going to alienate them.
 
Thanks supercorgi.

I consider your comments genuine constructive criticism, I will change some parts of my "manifesto"
 
Thanks supercorgi.

I consider your comments genuine constructive criticism, ....
As opposed to mine which suggest one identify the purpose, define objectives that can be measured to determine if the purpose was met, and follow up with an analysis to determine if indeed the 'manifesto' met the objective measures defined subsequent to the purpose.

That obviously isn't constructive. My bad.

I must say though I am not surprised that you again dodged the questions you cannot really provide answers to, the posts with positions you cannot debate, and those with criticisms of your positions you cannot support.
 
Since you asked....
I have a patient that happens to be a nurse, she is slightly obese, and complained of some shortness of breath, and a choking sensation in her neck. Her physical examination was unremarkable, her pulse oximeter was normal. Something made me order a CT of the chest and abdomen, it revealed a hepatic cyst and a cancerous renal mass. Her life was saved by the surgeons who operated on her, my intuition that there was something else going on, and that her insurance company did not question the need for a CT scan.
Is this taking place in a family practice clinic or an ED?

She has a choking sensation but normal O2 sat. She's not in distress according to the "unremarkable" exam. Either setting, there is no emergency.

CT exam, maybe, but certainly not before labwork. Physicians order the least invasive exams first if there is no emergency. Bloodwork and a UA are less invasive than a CT. The reason is you need the lab results to properly direct further exam.

A chest X-ray for anyone with a "choking sensation", would be fairly urgent, and would be done before a more invasive CT.

And physicians don't order tests based on "something told me". They order tests based specifically on what they observe and they can verbalize what it is they observe and why that indicates a particular test.

Given normal labwork, the hepatic cyst is possibly biopsied to rule out malignancy, and maybe drained or "deroofed" as the procedure is called but otherwise most physicians wouldn't treat it. These are common, most often benign, and as many as 20% of elderly patients have them. On the other hand, surgery on the liver carries significant risk of bleeding and obesity increases risk of surgery as well.

You could have a malignant kidney tumor with normal labs. More often you'd find blood in the UA but not necessarily. Discovering a malignant kidney tumor incidentally to an investigation of something else is the only part of your anecdote that is very plausible.

I have in the hospital, a 91 year-old patient, whose daughter is the wife of a minister. He had a fever and a rattly cough, and his chest x-ray showed bilateral pneumonia. His daughter already had arranged for a do not resuscitate order, and I will do whatever his daughter wants me to do for his medical care. I am his servant, the subordinate of my patient and his family, I can provide information to the best of my ability, but I have to follow their decisions. I think I know my place in the hierarchy.
This patient needs antibiotics, not a DNR consent. If the family at this point wanted no intervention, that isn't a DNR request, it is a request to not intervene medically. The order would then be for "comfort measures only". A DNR consent would be included but not the primary focus.

Most healthcare workers ignore the fact that most of the healthcare advances do not come from medicine, do not come from nursing, they come from advances in sanitation, keeping the drinking water separate from the sewage, adequate housing, adequate nutrition, and the existence of hope.
This was true years ago when infectious diseases were first brought under control through sanitation and improving living conditions. And decreasing exposure to environmental toxins was the next big breakthrough. We've passed those breakthroughs now and most advances in medicine today come from science. Just look at the field of oncology and the field of genetic research. Even in infectious diseases, while we still need to practice what we know about sanitation, there are no new discoveries in this field. Advances are in vaccines and anti-viral drugs. We need a breakthrough in antibiotics but very little is being invested in that right now. Do you expect some new advance in killer soaps or something?

If you had said that improvement in sanitation, keeping the drinking water separate from the sewage, adequate housing, and adequate nutrition would do more to save lives among people who lack these things than medical breakthroughs, that would be accurate.

"Breakthroughs" in medicine which are on the horizon hold incredible potential. Recent breakthroughs in laboratory techniques allowed relatively inexpensive, easy to perform DNA analysis to be done. That has led to an explosion in genetic science which is leading to breakthroughs in medicine proceeding at an incredible pace. Cures for cancer, virus infections, and diseases of aging are on the near horizon. Instead of trial and error we are analyzing the molecular structures of pathology and literally designing drugs to intervene. The only trial and error left is to then see if these designed drugs and treatments are safe in human trials.
 
Since you asked....Is this taking place in a family practice clinic or an ED?

She has a choking sensation but normal O2 sat. She's not in distress according to the "unremarkable" exam. Either setting, there is no emergency.

CT exam, maybe, but certainly not before labwork. Physicians order the least invasive exams first if there is no emergency. Bloodwork and a UA are less invasive than a CT. The reason is you need the lab results to properly direct further exam.

A chest X-ray for anyone with a "choking sensation", would be fairly urgent, and would be done before a more invasive CT.

And physicians don't order tests based on "something told me". They order tests based specifically on what they observe and they can verbalize what it is they observe and why that indicates a particular test.

Given normal labwork, the hepatic cyst is possibly biopsied to rule out malignancy, and maybe drained or "deroofed" as the procedure is called but otherwise most physicians wouldn't treat it. These are common, most often benign, and as many as 20% of elderly patients have them. On the other hand, surgery on the liver carries significant risk of bleeding and obesity increases risk of surgery as well.

You could have a malignant kidney tumor with normal labs. More often you'd find blood in the UA but not necessarily. Discovering a malignant kidney tumor incidentally to an investigation of something else is the only part of your anecdote that is very plausible.

Have you heard of the "Art of Medicine", not everything is black and white.
In January the CXR was "no acute pulmonary disease", I treat and diagnose my patients in my office, the symptoms were very vague and non-specific, definitely non-life threatening. the patient is in her late 50s, her urine and labs were negative. Her symptoms had actually resolved a week later, fortunately after the tests were completed! Go back to your icepick anecdote, sometimes no labs or x-rays can make the diagnosis on time. Since you are so competent, I will not remind you of the diagnosis and treatment of tension pneuthorax!

The surgeons resected a large complex hepatic cyst that was eventually identified as "benign biliary cyst adenoma", she required at least 3 additional interventions, drains, antibiotics. She experienced frequent episodes of RUQ pain.

If you would have been the Nurse reviewer for a strict insurance company, you would have probably denied the CT study, indirectly KILLING my patient because the diagnosis would have been made LATE .

This patient needs antibiotics, not a DNR consent. If the family at this point wanted no intervention, that isn't a DNR request, it is a request to not intervene medically. The order would then be for "comfort measures only". A DNR consent would be included but not the primary focus.

The patient received both Avelox and Rocephin, but he is so debilitated from the Alzheimer's ( he can only tolerate Namenda BTW, with no significant improvement ) that he cannot clear his secretions effectively, he cannot stand by himself, he barely recognizes his daughter. Pneumonia has been called the old man's friend in the past, because it ends the suffering from other medical problems. You have revealed yourself as another antibiotic pusher that cures an infection but prolongs suffering from other causes. The primary focus in my judgement is to CURE when a cure is available, and relieve suffering always. I have discussed with my spouse that if I reach a point that I don't know I have to wipe my butt, please pull the plug!

This was true years ago when infectious diseases were first brought under control through sanitation and improving living conditions. And decreasing exposure to environmental toxins was the next big breakthrough. We've passed those breakthroughs now and most advances in medicine today come from science. Just look at the field of oncology and the field of genetic research. Even in infectious diseases, while we still need to practice what we know about sanitation, there are no new discoveries in this field. Advances are in vaccines and anti-viral drugs. We need a breakthrough in antibiotics but very little is being invested in that right now. Do you expect some new advance in killer soaps or something?

If you had said that improvement in sanitation, keeping the drinking water separate from the sewage, adequate housing, and adequate nutrition would do more to save lives among people who lack these things than medical breakthroughs, that would be accurate.

"Breakthroughs" in medicine which are on the horizon hold incredible potential. Recent breakthroughs in laboratory techniques allowed relatively inexpensive, easy to perform DNA analysis to be done. That has led to an explosion in genetic science which is leading to breakthroughs in medicine proceeding at an incredible pace. Cures for cancer, virus infections, and diseases of aging are on the near horizon. Instead of trial and error we are analyzing the molecular structures of pathology and literally designing drugs to intervene. The only trial and error left is to then see if these designed drugs and treatments are safe in human trials.

Now you are completely delusional and intoxicated by Scientism, SHOW ME THE EVIDENCE!! Take Breast cancer, the capitalist system patented the gene, most insurance plans do not cover the cancer gene test, and the women that find out they have the gene, struggle with the decision of having a "prophyllactic mastectomy" or just waiting with the sword swinging on top of their heads.

We do not need new discoveries in sanitation or Public Health, we have to put in practice what we do know everywhere in the world. The pollution from China reaches the West Coast, and the pollution from Mexico the Southern US; we do not need new diagnostic or treatment methods, we have to practice prevention in a Global Scale.
 
As opposed to mine which suggest one identify the purpose, define objectives that can be measured to determine if the purpose was met, and follow up with an analysis to determine if indeed the 'manifesto' met the objective measures defined subsequent to the purpose.

That obviously isn't constructive. My bad.

I must say though I am not surprised that you again dodged the questions you cannot really provide answers to, the posts with positions you cannot debate, and those with criticisms of your positions you cannot support.

You just have to be the center of attention!!!

How many cats do you have? If we compete, can I use my hands?
 
As opposed to mine which suggest one identify the purpose, define objectives that can be measured to determine if the purpose was met, and follow up with an analysis to determine if indeed the 'manifesto' met the objective measures defined subsequent to the purpose.
Shush! I was just trying to institute small changes before we tackle the big stuff. Baby steps you know. ;D

Personally I think the manifesto is simplistic and unessesary -- most adults already know the health maintenance stuff and will reject the personal philosophy stuff unless they already agree with it. I think such a thing might be good for children to learn good health practices, but doesn't float well with adults. Yes my doctor tells me what I should do, and I already know what I should do, but putting it into practice can sometimes be hard.
 
Shush! I was just trying to institute small changes before we tackle the big stuff. Baby steps you know. ;D

Personally I think the manifesto is simplistic and unessesary -- most adults already know the health maintenance stuff and will reject the personal philosophy stuff unless they already agree with it. I think such a thing might be good for children to learn good health practices, but doesn't float well with adults. Yes my doctor tells me what I should do, and I already know what I should do, but putting it into practice can sometimes be hard.

Wow, you discovered wheels are round!!!

There will always be repetition of the obvious when you work with people, humans like dogs need structure ( I love to watch the Dog Whisperer!! ).

From a practical standpoint, 99% of my patients are believers, they are not offended. I need to remind myself to spend more time with my son, than on this futile forum. But I can't tolerate to lose an argument, we will see who gives up!

Preview warning: Nutritional supplement recommendations!!

What a pity, I thought you were sincere with the comment about the elders.
I come from a sheltered upper-middle class environment and I forget that I have been extremely privileged, my parents stayed together until my father died.

Tell me, how can we promote respect for people with more experience that love and nurtured us? How can we rescue the unfortunate children that have been abused by their own parents, or even clergy? I am sure you are not advocating that we just dispose of them, since there is no soul. You can send me a PM if you still want to provide support to skeptigirl, I understand, really.

Anybody still doubts I am a "real" doctor?
 
Have you heard of the "Art of Medicine", not everything is black and white.
I prefer the science of medicine, and evidence based medicine implies the "art" is best left to the surgeons. How does "black and white" apply to "something told me"?


skepticdoc said:
In January the CXR was "no acute pulmonary disease", I treat and diagnose my patients in my office, the symptoms were very vague and non-specific, definitely non-life threatening. the patient is in her late 50s, her urine and labs were negative. Her symptoms had actually resolved a week later, fortunately after the tests were completed! Go back to your icepick anecdote, sometimes no labs or x-rays can make the diagnosis on time. Since you are so competent, I will not remind you of the diagnosis and treatment of tension pneuthorax!

The surgeons resected a large complex hepatic cyst that was eventually identified as "benign biliary cyst adenoma", she required at least 3 additional interventions, drains, antibiotics. She experienced frequent episodes of RUQ pain.
You can try to distort what I said but the post is there for all to read. "Labs to direct further investigation", not your incorrect paraphrasing.

You might also want to get a spell checker that can catch your typos. It's a pneumothorax not a pneuthorax. As well, I believe it is called a cystadenoma, one word.

A large cystadenoma should have resulted in a palpably enlarged liver and more than likely accompanied by at least an elevated AST. Especially given this new description.
skepticdoc said:
If you would have been the Nurse reviewer for a strict insurance company, you would have probably denied the CT study, indirectly KILLING my patient because the diagnosis would have been made LATE .
As to insurance review, if you couldn't articulate why you were choosing to order particular tests, you would expect to run into trouble getting approval from third party payers. You were probably lucky in this case that no one caught it. That is if the story is even true. I believe in that case it would be you killing the patient, not the reviewer who can only go by what you've presented.

skepticdoc said:
The patient received both Avelox and Rocephin, but he is so debilitated from the Alzheimer's ( he can only tolerate Namenda BTW, with no significant improvement ) that he cannot clear his secretions effectively, he cannot stand by himself, he barely recognizes his daughter. Pneumonia has been called the old man's friend in the past, because it ends the suffering from other medical problems. You have revealed yourself as another antibiotic pusher that cures an infection but prolongs suffering from other causes. The primary focus in my judgement is to CURE when a cure is available, and relieve suffering always. I have discussed with my spouse that if I reach a point that I don't know I have to wipe my butt, please pull the plug!
Then why didn't you discuss with this family not giving those antibiotics? I certainly would have. And here you are saying you ordered the antibiotics while accusing me of hypothetically choosing to order them. Once again, my post is there for anyone to see. I pointed out a DNR order wasn't what was needed, a 'comfort measures only' order was. I would think a physician would know the difference.

skepticdoc said:
Now you are completely delusional and intoxicated by Scientism, SHOW ME THE EVIDENCE!! Take Breast cancer, the capitalist system patented the gene, most insurance plans do not cover the cancer gene test, and the women that find out they have the gene, struggle with the decision of having a "prophyllactic mastectomy" or just waiting with the sword swinging on top of their heads.
Can't you discuss with a patient ordering outside of their insurance coverage should they choose to pay for a test? It really is no different than a copay or deductible. I have an HMO insurance plan. I go outside the system for second opinions if needed and just pay for them. If I had another insurance plan there would be equivalent charges in deductibles.

And don't you keep up on the progress of medical research? Just in the breast cancer filed alone there has been excellent progress.
Estrogen receptor, progesterone receptor, and HER-2/neu protein in breast cancers from pregnant patients.
New Advances in Breast Cancer Treatment Fueled by Breast Cancer Research Foundation Support!
A large, multi-center study over five years led by Mayo Clinic medical oncologist Edith Perez, MD, sponsored by the National Cancer Institute and conducted by the North Central Cancer Treatment Group (NCCTG) gave important new data about the effectiveness and safety of a breast cancer treatment combining chemotherapy and a drug called trastuzumab (Herceptin). The NCCTG trial offers new data comparing whether Herceptin is more effective in preventing recurrence when given during (concurrently) or after (sequentially) chemotherapy.

Another breast cancer study investigated the use of bevacizumab (Avastin) in combination with paclitaxel (Taxol) chemotherapy in patients who had not yet received treatment for their breast cancer which had spread to other parts of the body. Interim results of this large clinical trial, sponsored by the National Cancer Institute and supported by BCRF, showed that Avastin in combination with Taxol is effective in slowing the progress of untreated recurrent or metastasized breast tumors. Avastin is a monoclonal antibody that targets tumors through an anti-angiogenic effect, by starving them of the blood they need to grow
Advances in Hormonal Therapy for Postmenopausal Women
Tamoxifen has been available for the treatment of early-stage breast cancer since the 1980s; but, more recently, a new class of drugs called aromatase inhibitors has been found to produce better results when compared directly with tamoxifen. Aromatase inhibitors, indicated for use in postmenopausal women, act by blocking the formation of estrogen, which fuels the growth of "hormone receptor-positive" breast cancers.

The three aromatase inhibitors approved in the U.S. include Femara, Aromasin, and Arimidex.
In recent years, there's been an explosion of life-saving treatment advances against breast cancer, bringing new hope and excitement.
Instead of only one or two options, today there's an overwhelming menu of treatment choices that fight the complex mix of cells in each individual cancer.
Options
* hormone therapy
* chemotherapy
* HER2/neu
* overexpress
* Anti-angiogenesis
Latest Advances in Breast Cancer Treatment to be Presented at Annual "Power of Knowledge" Luncheon
Breast Cancer (PDQ®): Treatment
Targeted Cancer Treatments
Perhaps the most important breakthrough in cancer treatment over the past few years has been the introduction of so-called "targeted" therapies. Rather than the sledgehammer effect achieved by traditional therapies, the newer targeted therapies are designed to home in on cancer cells like a missile while leaving the healthy cells untouched. As a result, these agents lack many of the severe side effects associated with chemotherapy.

Herceptin, an effective targeted therapy for breast cancer, attaches to a protein on the surface of breast cancer cells called HER2 that transmits growth-stimulating signals to cells. By blocking the actions of HER2, Herceptin slows or stops the growth of tumor cells. Herceptin is effective in tumors that express large amounts of the HER2 protein (described as HER2-positive), which is the case in about 25% of patients.
Oral Chemotherapy Agents
A recently approved drug for kidney and stomach cancer is emerging as a potential treatment for breast cancer. Sutent, like Avastin, also stops the development of the tumor's blood supply but is given orally. This agent has demonstrated its effectiveness when used alone, without additional chemotherapy or hormonal therapy, in patients with previously treated metastatic breast cancer. In one study of 64 patients treated, 16% responded favorably.

Findings about an experimental oral drug, lapatinib, were also presented at the meeting. Like Herceptin, lapatinib targets HER2, but it also targets a related protein called EGFR, meaning that it could have a broader range of effectiveness or could be especially effective when added to Herceptin. One small study evaluated the combination of lapatinib and Herceptin in patients with metastatic breast cancer. The researchers reported no additional or unexpected side effects with the combination. Moreover, a good percentage of this difficult-to-treat population responded to the treatment.

"We are very excited about the results of all of these studies with these new agents, and they clearly demonstrate a role for this type of therapy in the treatment of metastatic breast cancer," Miller says. "We also expect an even greater benefit for these therapies when used for earlier-stage disease as opposed to the metastatic setting."

skepticdoc said:
We do not need new discoveries in sanitation or Public Health, we have to put in practice what we do know everywhere in the world. The pollution from China reaches the West Coast, and the pollution from Mexico the Southern US; we do not need new diagnostic or treatment methods, we have to practice prevention in a Global Scale.
I noted this. But this is using what we already know. What you said was advances come in areas of sanitation and nutrition, not new medical treatments. Sanitation and nutrition are not where "advances" are being made.

Skepticdoc, you just don't impress me as a doctor. If you are one you don't present yourself as being very knowledgeable or articulate. Everyone else can judge for themselves.
 
[Sylvia Browne precognition mode]
skepticdoc will completely ignore skeptigirl's post and all the points that were put forth so that he may continue to pretend that the mass of this forum agrees with him and that those who point out his faulty reading/understanding are merely aberent blips on the radar of reality.
So let it be written.
[/Sylvia Browne precognition mode]

----------------------

Someone on these fora used to have a sigline to the effect of: "The most devastating intellectual knockouts often fly completely over the head of the defeated party".

(Please correct my wording if this is not an accurate quote! Also, please supply the proper attributation, so I can get it right in the future.) :D

Cheers,
Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom