Is that an honest question?
skepticdoc said:
...how can I justify even the concept of Medical Care?
Do you honestly want a good answer to that question?
Are you really going to read my response and consider my suggestions?
If you are willing to read, and I mean REALLY read, two (of four) very short, very inexpensive books, then I can make a recommendation that may help you.
Ayn Rand.
Yeah, THAT Ayn Rand. The Devil incarnate to many people.
Two of her books, both of them collectoins of essays, each about 7/16" thich in paperback, findable in used-book stores and libraries.
The two I recommend to help you out of your philosophical conundrum are:
Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology 1979
and
The Virtue of Selfishness 1964
If you can get through these, I recommend two others:
For the New Intellectual 1961
and
The Romantic Manifesto 1969
These books are each comprised of a dozen or two fairly brief essays, most by her, but several written by others who shared her POV.
Now, I will give you fair warning: if you try try to use the Evelyn Wood Speed Reading method (which, judging by the evident difficulty you have had comprehending complex, nuanced sentences in this thread so far, you may have been using), you will doubtless come away without a clue about what she was attempting to impart. I strongly recommend that you only attempt to read these when you have time, without interruption, to fully read at least one entire essay, and you should have a dictionary at hand so that you can avoid misunderstanding her meaning. (She wrote with *extreme* precision and nuance in her choice of words, and _close_ won't cut it.)
Since I seriously doubt that you will actually take my advice on this (after all, who am I but a lower-caste grease-monkey and "barbershop philosopher", in your esteemed eyes?), maybe some other lurker or poster will be inspired to investigate these profound works.
Will s'doc deign to take my advice and read these?
We'll see.
Won't we?
Cheers
Dave
edit: punctuation