Majority Don't Want Tax Cuts For Rich

If there are other methods of tax that distort the economy less, but still take the money from the people most capable of paying, then i'm all ears. I don't hold to the particular method of taxing on principle, rather the people who should taxed.
. . . Confirming again that your views in this thread are about redistribution of income and not about "more stimulus for the economy". Which is what I have been highlighting, and is the effective message in the thread title. No idea why you apparently deny this, nor attempt to pass off the challenge as "mind reading". It's text reading.

How? If you pay $250,000 dollars and commit x materials to a project, and the result is a yacht, then you have succeeded in distributing money in exchange for labour with no useful gains. If you tax $250,000 from a rich person and use it to build a wind turbine, you have succeeded in distributing money in exchange for labour and contructed a source of energy with which to power the economy. I'm sure wind turbines cost more than that, but you see my point.
I suggest you learn about deadweight loss of taxation (already mentioned). As for whether the yacht or the turbine is more useful, that's not an objective statement that you can make. Some would say that a millionaire would not buy a yacht unless it was worth more to them than its price, but that a government agency would be less responsible with money that is not their personal spending but which has transferred into the public sector via taxation. Others (you probably) think that a millionaire is apt to fritter away money uselessly, that more civicly-minded public servants will spend far more productively and socially responsibly.

As far as the economy is concerned, $250K of fixed capital formation (turbine) and $250K of private consumption of durable goods (yacht) both affect national output/income the same (excluding any inventory effects, which are in any case merely timeshifts). But levying the tax very likely reduces national income before you buy the turbine, which puts the public spending at an (economic accounting) disadvantage.

The remainder of your post re-iterates that income redistribution is the matter of interest to you.
 
Originally Posted by TShaitanaku
I suggest a full reading of the paper for those interested in the topic, it isn't quite as slanted as the spin from the "Reason" article.

http://www.frbsf.org/publications/ec.../wp10-17bk.pdf
So with a full reading, how is the claim of no permanent jobs created, and $400,000 per temporary job, incorrect?...

•slant - a biased way of looking at or presenting something
•spin - twist and turn so as to give an intended interpretation
 
. . . Confirming again that your views in this thread are about redistribution of income and not about "more stimulus for the economy". Which is what I have been highlighting, and is the effective message in the thread title. No idea why you apparently deny this, nor attempt to pass off the challenge as "mind reading". It's text reading.

I have principles regarding who I believe should be taxed, and I simultaneously believe that taxing rich people and spending the money on useful things would be good for the economy. If you want to call me a liar, go ahead, but these are my opinions and no amount of you telling me what I really think is going to change that. Rational debate can and has swayed me in the past, and I urge you to stick to it when attempting to change my opinion.

I suggest you learn about deadweight loss of taxation (already mentioned). As for whether the yacht or the turbine is more useful, that's not an objective statement that you can make. Some would say that a millionaire would not buy a yacht unless it was worth more to them than its price, but that a government agency would be less responsible with money that is not their personal spending but which has transferred into the public sector via taxation. Others (you probably) think that a millionaire is apt to fritter away money uselessly, that more civicly-minded public servants will spend far more productively and socially responsibly.

Yes, those are the available options. I believe the second one.

As far as the economy is concerned, $250K of fixed capital formation (turbine) and $250K of private consumption of durable goods (yacht) both affect national output/income the same (excluding any inventory effects, which are in any case merely timeshifts).

They do not produce the same amount of use. One results in entertainment for a rich person, and the other results in an amount of energy that can be used to power the country.

But levying the tax very likely reduces national income before you buy the turbine, which puts the public spending at an (economic accounting) disadvantage.

The main arguement here appears to be that if you tax rich people, they go abroad and store their money elsewhere, so that they can buy luxuries but cannot be taxed. Firstly, this is a race-to-the-bottom scenario, and the moral highground is to tax highly. The total wealth in the world is not reduced, but the total wealth in your country is. The end goal should be to convince the whole world to have high tax, or at least the appealing parts of it, not to out-bid other countries for the lowest possible tax rates. Secondly, this is a form of withdrawing your labour, and while I am typically supportive of strikes, I don't believe that people in the $250k and above category really qualify as an oppressed minority.

If you want to show that higher tax rates for rich people somehow reduce the total wealth created by a nation and thus the poorest members of society are poorer than they would be with lower tax rates for rich people, go ahead, so long as you're careful not to include emigration and the use of tax havens as a factor. This kind of arguement would interest me, though as i've said before, I consider equality itself to have value as well, along with my preference for living in a culture that promotes co-operation over competition.

The remainder of your post re-iterates that income redistribution is the matter of interest to you.

Both are of interest to me, and they are not mutually exclusive. You are of course welcome to continue to tell me that I actually believe only one of two opinions I give, but you are wrong.
 
Just curious why legislation that would keep tax rates at what they've been for years and years is a tax cut? Seems to me it is dishonest to repeatedly refer to them as tax "cuts". And dishonest to suggest, as Obama did, that keeping the rates the same would have a further stimulative effect and create millions of new jobs. But not unsurprising considering the source. :D
 
Is there some length of time after which a tax cut is no longer a cut?
 
Just curious why legislation that would keep tax rates at what they've been for years and years is a tax cut? Seems to me it is dishonest to repeatedly refer to them as tax "cuts". And dishonest to suggest, as Obama did, that keeping the rates the same would have a further stimulative effect and create millions of new jobs. But not unsurprising considering the source. :D

Because the legislation in question was a temporary cut of tax rates and was only passed because they were designed to be temporary in a time of prolonged recession - they were a plan to borrow against the future to stimulate a weak economy. Despite design, they failed to produce stimulus. Now, even though they are bad for the economy and had a large role in precipitating the current downside economy, some wish to pass new legislation extending or making these bad for most cuts, permanent. The default state is to allow taxation to return to the rates that led to the largest economic expansion in the last fifty years under Clinton. An extension now imparts significant ownership of these extended cuts and the harms they impart upon our nation onto the Dems and Obama (what's worse, is the only ones who will actually give them any credit for this, are those who will hold them to account for it as the flawed policy it is).
 
What cut?

All they are doing is keeping the tax rates the same.

You do know what that word means, don't you?

Yes, the same as the tax cut introduced under Bush.

You do know what that word means, don't you?
 
Despite design, they failed to produce stimulus. Now, even though they are bad for the economy and had a large role in precipitating the current downside economy

Liar, liar, pants on fire. You people are simply shameless in your ability and willingness to lie. :rolleyes:
 
Yes, the same as the tax cut introduced under Bush.

You do know what that word means, don't you?

Expanding on your logic, why don't you propose cutting the tax rate to what it was in Carter's Presidency? Wouldn't that be even more stimulative and "fair"? :D
 
Um, if he's against a tax cut, why would he be against an even bigger one? That's not his logic, that's you applying your logic to his position. I really doubt that he thinks tax cuts are stimulative in the first place.

ETA: This, I think, is highly indicative of the effects of word association in political rhetoric. BAC is perfectly correct in saying that you cannot call it a tax cut since it's been in place for nearly a decade. Grizzly is perfectly correct in saying that it's a tax cut since it is, after all, a rate that is lower than the previous one. Tax cut sounds nice, tax hike sounds bad. Unless you're talking about giving a lower tax rate to the rich, in which case (to most people, and there are exceptions, I understand) "tax cut" sounds like a bad thing.

So as a result, you get conflation of meaning from politicians desperate to make their position sound like the right one. In turn, you get people arguing over what to call something instead of whether or not the thing in question is good or bad.
 
Last edited:
What cut?

All they are doing is keeping the tax rates the same.

You do know what that word means, don't you?


And the tax CUTS were sold to the US by Bush as TEMPORARY
to quote you

You do know what that word means, don't you?

and they were based on running a surplus! NOT financing 2 unnecessary wars and a deficit
while those who can most afford it get more free money and the rest of us get the shaft.
 
And the tax CUTS were sold to the US by Bush as TEMPORARY

In 2001 Senate republicans were not certain they could reach the 2/3rd majority to make the tax cuts permanent. So they chose the reconcillation route. And the reconciliation rule forbid a bill altering federal revenue for more than 10 years. That's the only reason the cuts were not made permanent. Not because Bush wouldn't have liked to see the cuts permanent. And not because the American people wouldn't have liked to see permanent cuts, too. You may not realize it but poll after poll shows the American public think taxes are too high and government too big. The ONLY sure way to restrain government spending is give the government less money. History proves that the Federal government ALWAYS spends more than it gets in tax revenue. So lower the taxes to reduce the spending. Make the tax cuts permanent if you really want to make Americans happy. :D

while those who can most afford it get more free money and the rest of us get the shaft.

:rolleyes:

http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/2007/10/09/tax-shares-for-rich-and-poor/

The Bush tax cuts substantially reduced tax rates for people in every income group. Indeed, those at the bottom had the largest relative reductions in their tax rates.

http://www.heritage.org/research/taxes/bg2001.cfm

Ten Myths About the Bush Tax Cuts—and the Facts

… snip ...

Myth #10: The Bush tax cuts were tilted toward the rich.

Fact: The rich are now shouldering even more of the income tax burden.

And here are some more sources in the same vein:

http://libertyworks.com/bush-tax-cut-myths-and-fallacies-1/

http://libertyworks.com/bush-tax-cut-myths-and-fallacies-2/

http://libertyworks.com/bush-tax-cuts-myths-and-fallacies-3/

http://libertyworks.com/compare-results-obama-stimulus-vs-bush-tax-cuts/

http://libertyworks.com/beyond-those-bush-deficits/

http://online.wsj.com/article/NA_WSJ_PUB:SB10001424052748704738404575347302831199046.html

You still haven't learned these lessons yet? :D
 
The problem is grotesque spending

not deficient taxing.


How does this sound?
He votes for me to take from you to give to him.
He wants more.
I will promise more people that I will take from you and give to them if they will vote for me.
They will vote for me.
And so on and so on
and the country is killed.
 
Last edited:
How does this sound?
He votes for me to take from you to give to him.
He wants more.
I will promise more people that I will take from you and give to them if they will vote for me.
They will vote for me.
And so on and so on
and the country is killed.

It's Beggars and Choosers.
 
So, to sum up this thread: Class warfare rhetoric is still alive and well.

Sad.

Exactly. I asked my kids and they are totally on board with borrowing billions of dollars from the Chinese so that I can have a slightly lower tax burden next year. In fact, they were clamoring to be the one who got to pay for it. If only everyone's kids would see it the way mine do . . .
 
I have principles regarding who I believe should be taxed, and I simultaneously believe that taxing rich people and spending the money on useful things would be good for the economy.
And you are incorrect on the second point, as has been explained. Note that "good" / "stimulus" to the economy has a specific meaning, which is to increase measured output relative to the counterfactual.

Rational debate can and has swayed me in the past, and I urge you to stick to it when attempting to change my opinion.
It's of no import if your opinion changes. Your opinion that increasing tax/public spending increases output remains at odds with almost all observations regardless. Put simply you would benefit from dropping that as a reason for tax/spend and concentrate on the more accepted reasons which are (i) to provide public goods, and (ii) to redistribute income.

They do not produce the same amount of use. One results in entertainment for a rich person, and the other results in an amount of energy that can be used to power the country.
Irrelevant except insofar as this relates to your value preferences (already explained)

The main arguement here [ . . . ]
The argument is that if you tax something (unless it is something involuntary like breathing), the marketplace supplies/demands a bit less of it than if you don't. This reason has already been given to you.

The end goal should be to convince the whole world to have high tax, or at least the appealing parts of it, not to out-bid other countries for the lowest possible tax rates.
This end goal is not currently within reach so it does not help your (erroneous) belief statement: "I don't believe that tax hikes for the rich are incompatible with more stimulus for the economy"

Again, the remainder of your post I have no particular issue with.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom