Francesca R
Girl
. . . Confirming again that your views in this thread are about redistribution of income and not about "more stimulus for the economy". Which is what I have been highlighting, and is the effective message in the thread title. No idea why you apparently deny this, nor attempt to pass off the challenge as "mind reading". It's text reading.If there are other methods of tax that distort the economy less, but still take the money from the people most capable of paying, then i'm all ears. I don't hold to the particular method of taxing on principle, rather the people who should taxed.
I suggest you learn about deadweight loss of taxation (already mentioned). As for whether the yacht or the turbine is more useful, that's not an objective statement that you can make. Some would say that a millionaire would not buy a yacht unless it was worth more to them than its price, but that a government agency would be less responsible with money that is not their personal spending but which has transferred into the public sector via taxation. Others (you probably) think that a millionaire is apt to fritter away money uselessly, that more civicly-minded public servants will spend far more productively and socially responsibly.How? If you pay $250,000 dollars and commit x materials to a project, and the result is a yacht, then you have succeeded in distributing money in exchange for labour with no useful gains. If you tax $250,000 from a rich person and use it to build a wind turbine, you have succeeded in distributing money in exchange for labour and contructed a source of energy with which to power the economy. I'm sure wind turbines cost more than that, but you see my point.
As far as the economy is concerned, $250K of fixed capital formation (turbine) and $250K of private consumption of durable goods (yacht) both affect national output/income the same (excluding any inventory effects, which are in any case merely timeshifts). But levying the tax very likely reduces national income before you buy the turbine, which puts the public spending at an (economic accounting) disadvantage.
The remainder of your post re-iterates that income redistribution is the matter of interest to you.