Majority Don't Want Tax Cuts For Rich

There was probably a time in the history of the United States that a majority didn't want those uppity blacks to be free and equal to everyone else.

The fact they were a majority didn't make them right then, either.

I actually giggled at seeing you try to equate the most privileged upper crust of society with people who didn't even own themselves.
 
Last edited:
I actually giggled at seeing you try to equate the most privileged upper crust of society with people who didn't even own themselves.
I'm making the point that the majority isn't right simply because they are the majority.

Any other implications are figments of the reader's imagination.
 
I actually giggled at seeing you try to equate the most privileged upper crust of society with people who didn't even own themselves.
He didn't do that he only pointed out that just because a majority want something doesn't mean it is the right thing.

ETA
Sorry I should have read the next couple of posts Grizzley said the same thing already. Did you really think it was equated slaves with the rich?
 
Last edited:
He didn't do that he only pointed out that just because a majority want something doesn't mean it is the right thing.

And he pointed that out by drawing a line between taxing the rich and keeping blacks in slavery. I weep for the millionaires being oppressed by the cruel will of the majority, I really do, but perhaps a less laughable comparison would have been in order.
 
Last edited:
And he pointed that out by drawing a line between taxing the rich and keeping blacks in slavery. I weep for the millionaires being oppressed by the cruel will of the majority, I really do, but perhaps a less laughable comparison would have been in order.

If the intention is to point out the fact that a majority opinion isn't right simply because it's the majority opinion, how is any example of the majority being wrong somehow not in order?
 
stokes234: You are on a sticky wicket claiming that levying higher tax and spending that on energy, housing, education or healthcare actually increases growth/output. Due to the deadweight loss ("excess burden") of taxation that is almost never true. The case for compulsory public funding of some of those things is usually that they are public or socially-desired goods that will be under-provided (relative to society's legislated preference) otherwise, not that it boosts growth to do so.

My point is that an unneccessary amount of money stacked at the top is spent on wasteful luxuries. By taxing a portion of this wasted money away, you continue to spend it on people's wages that would otherwise have been paid for the production of luxuries, but instead of sports cars and yachts, you end up with renewable energy sources, nuclear power plants, an improved education system and an improved health system. In this way you're using the money to improve future growth in a few ways:

1. You reduce the severity of climate change, preventing the government from having to shell out to repair damage from natural disasters, domestic and abroad.

2. You increase public health, resulting in a more productive workforce.

3. You increase educational standards, resulting in a more skilled workforce.

It would be particularly difficult to prove these useful results, especially no. 1, but I would rather see tax spent on these three, than left in the hands of the richest in society.

As to your claim that if you tax $250,000 and above, you may as well tax $50,000 and above more as well, I disagree. There are shades of grey, but to me, $50,000-$100,000 a year for a household is not excessive. Over $250,000 is.
 
Last edited:
My point is that an unneccessary amount of money stacked at the top is spent on wasteful luxuries.
That's your value judgement born of your own idiosyncratic preferences. As far as economics is concerned, what people spend money on is not subject to such biases. I think you are also missing the point that by levying a tax of $100, pretty much any way you do it unless it is a tax on breathing, you almost always reduce aggregate pre-tax income, because tax influences (distorts) economic behaviour. Some taxes are more distortionary than others. Land tax--for example--is often regarded as the least distortionary. Consumption tax is also generally less distortionary. Top marginal income tax rates are, on the other hand more highly distortionary which means they tend to reduce national income by more than if the same $ of tax was raised in other ways.

Your list of spending preferences do not necessarily--as you indicate--result in "stimulus for the economy", particularly relative to leaving the income untaxed. The purchase of a yacht could certainly add more to national income than money misallocated to a failure-bound project at a public agency that was not competent at picking winning ideas on which to spend public money, however distasteful that might be to you.

It would be particularly difficult to prove these useful results, especially no. 1, but I would rather see tax spent on these three, than left in the hands of the richest in society.
Then I think your argument is based on the morality of income/wealth inequality, not what maximises economic growth/output. (Many people think that less inequality is better for social welfare in ways that economic metrics do not capture, but that is a separate topic, and not what you argued.)

As to your claim that if you tax $250,000 and above, you may as well tax $50,000 and above more as well, I disagree. There are shades of grey, but to me, $50,000-$100,000 a year for a household is not excessive. Over $250,000 is.
Yes well I was pointing out the use of the word "rich". You won't be surprised to know that plenty of people earning $200K don't think they are rich either. Often, such assessments are made on the basis of economic jealousy, and a desire that someone else should pay, than anything else.
 
That's your value judgement born of your own idiosyncratic preferences. As far as economics is concerned, what people spend money on is not subject to such biases. I think you are also missing the point that by levying a tax of $100, pretty much any way you do it unless it is a tax on breathing, you almost always reduce aggregate pre-tax income, because tax influences (distorts) economic behaviour. Some taxes are more distortionary than others. Land tax--for example--is often regarded as the least distortionary. Consumption tax is also generally less distortionary. Top marginal income tax rates are, on the other hand more highly distortionary which means they tend to reduce national income by more than if the same $ of tax was raised in other ways.

If there are other methods of tax that distort the economy less, but still take the money from the people most capable of paying, then i'm all ears. I don't hold to the particular method of taxing on principle, rather the people who should taxed.

Your list of spending preferences do not necessarily--as you indicate--result in "stimulus for the economy", particularly relative to leaving the income untaxed. The purchase of a yacht could certainly add more to national income than money misallocated to a failure-bound project at a public agency that was not competent at picking winning ideas on which to spend public money, however distasteful that might be to you.

How? If you pay $250,000 dollars and commit x materials to a project, and the result is a yacht, then you have succeeded in distributing money in exchange for labour with no useful gains. If you tax $250,000 from a rich person and use it to build a wind turbine, you have succeeded in distributing money in exchange for labour and contructed a source of energy with which to power the economy. I'm sure wind turbines cost more than that, but you see my point.

Then I think your argument is based on the morality of income/wealth inequality, not what maximises economic growth/output. (Many people think that less inequality is better for social welfare in ways that economic metrics do not capture, but that is a separate topic, and not what you argued.)

You're welcome to think whatever you like, but telling me what I think is not a particularly effective method of swaying my opinion.

Yes well I was pointing out the use of the word "rich". You won't be surprised to know that plenty of people earning $200K don't think they are rich either. Often, such assessments are made on the basis of economic jealousy, and a desire that someone else should pay, than anything else.

Again, I believe this discussion will be more productive if you hold back on the mind-reading attempts. I base my opinion of what is a reasonable amount of money for a household to earn off the average earnings in that country. Average household earnings in america are around $50,000, and i'm happy to accept that some professions such as medical, academic, advanced engineering etc should earn a reasonable amount more than that. But there comes a point where I do not believe you can argue that you need the money to sustain a reasonable standard of living, compared to your country and culture.

From the wiki on american household income (and you're welcome to challenge the source if you don't like me quoting wiki) - "In 2006, there were approximately 116,011,000 households in the United States. 1.93% of all households had annual incomes exceeding $250,000." I do not believe that the top two percent need to be protected. As i've said before, there are shades of grey and if someone were to argue that in fact, those earning over $100,000 should be taxed more as well, i'd listen to their arguement. But the difference between $50,000 and $250,000 is stark to me.
 
Again, I believe this discussion will be more productive if you hold back on the mind-reading attempts. I base my opinion of what is a reasonable amount of money for a household to earn off the average earnings in that country. Average household earnings in america are around $50,000, and i'm happy to accept that some professions such as medical, academic, advanced engineering etc should earn a reasonable amount more than that. But From the wiki on american household income (and you're welcome to challenge the source if you don't like me quoting wiki) - "In 2006, there were approximately 116,011,000 households in the United States. 1.93% of all households had annual incomes exceeding $250,000." I do not believe that the top two percent need to be protected. As i've said before, there are shades of grey and if someone were to argue that in fact, those earning over $100,000 should be taxed more as well, i'd listen to their arguement. But the difference between $50,000 and $250,000 is stark to me.

Who are you to dictate how much money people can make? Tell me the difference in 250K in New York, Nebraska, Califonia and Montana. Do you think that amount of money is the same no matter where you live?

there comes a point where I do not believe you can argue that you need the money to sustain a reasonable standard of living, compared to your country and culture.

Do tell. What is that point?
 
Who are you to dictate how much money people can make? Tell me the difference in 250K in New York, Nebraska, Califonia and Montana. Do you think that amount of money is the same no matter where you live?

No, of course it can vary by area. If you read my post more carefully, you'll notice I am focusing on the difference between taxing the top 2% of society, and taxing the top 50%. There are shades of grey, and states and districts can be part of what influences those, but my overriding point is that the richest 2% cannot complain that they need their money after that point as much as a family earning under $100k needs their money, or needs public services.

Do tell. What is that point?

My point is that money is better spent on useful infrastructure and services for society than it is on luxuries, and the top 2% are far more likely to be wasting substantial amounts of money on luxuries than the lower earning members of society, and so in order to improve the economy as well as promote fairness and equality, money earned over this threshold, or whatever threshold can be rationally argued to be fair, should be taxed at a higher rate.
 
so...how many jobs did the wealthy in America create last month?

how about in 2010? not that many.
How many permanent jobs did the $814 billion stimulus create? None.

looks like a wasted tax-cut. we might as well just raise taxes on the rich and use the extra tax revenue to help reduce the deficit or pay for more jobs, WPA style.
At $400,000 per temporary job. No thanks.
 
How many permanent jobs did the $814 billion stimulus create? None.

At $400,000 per temporary job. No thanks.

Is any job permanent anymore?

ETA: I bet you'd be surprised to find out how much money it takes the private sector to create jobs on average too. That is, once you factor in all the costs. I don't know exactly what that number is, but it may be out there somewhere.

How much initial investment does it take to start a company that employs 100 people I wonder? How much annual sales are required to keep those 100 people employed permanently?
 
Last edited:
A more precise reason would be "the economy stinks, throw the bastards out".

The problem is that most of the bastards voted in during the last election still believe in the ideas that helped create the economic collapse two years ago.

What ideas would those be? Care to attempt to explain what caused the economic collapse? BTW, if you use the word "deregulation" without actually explaining what specific relaxation of regulation contributed and how, you lose 20 points.

Hint: it wasn't really caused directly by any elected branch of government (at least not recently), although the legislative committees that had oversight of the GSEs had a minor hand in it.
 
ETA: I bet you'd be surprised to find out how much money it takes the private sector to create jobs on average too. That is, once you factor in all the costs. I don't know exactly what that number is, but it may be out there somewhere.

It takes less money to create a job in the private sector than the person recieves in total compensation plus payroll taxes. If the employer is not making more money from the labor of the employee than it costs to employ him/her, the employee will soon find himself looking for work.
 
It takes less money to create a job in the private sector than the person recieves in total compensation plus payroll taxes. If the employer is not making more money from the labor of the employee than it costs to employ him/her, the employee will soon find himself looking for work.

Well then you are applying a different standard because here we are only talking about the cost of inputs, not the value of outputs.

It is more difficult to measure the value of a policeman than a widget-maker. The market puts a quantifiable value on widgets, but how do you quantify the value of an apprehended criminal or a prevented crime? And yet these things have real value to society.

The $400,000 figure is just the cost of inputs. It does not subtract the value of fixed potholes or repaired bridges or whatever the case may be.

How much, for example, does it cost a car company to build a plant that employs 1000 people, plus the cost of actually paying the employees?
 
I suggest a full reading of the paper for those interested in the topic, it isn't quite as slanted as the spin from the "Reason" article.

http://www.frbsf.org/publications/economics/papers/2010/wp10-17bk.pdf
So with a full reading, how is the claim of no permanent jobs created, and $400,000 per temporary job, incorrect?

Is any job permanent anymore?
So you're arguing that hiring up for census workers is the equivalent to employing someone in a full time position with no defined project completion date?

ETA: I bet you'd be surprised to find out how much money it takes the private sector to create jobs on average too. That is, once you factor in all the costs. I don't know exactly what that number is, but it may be out there somewhere.

How much initial investment does it take to start a company that employs 100 people I wonder? How much annual sales are required to keep those 100 people employed permanently?
And this has to do with the failure of the stimulus to establish permanent jobs how? Do you think that $400,000 per temporary job created a good return, regardless of the output?
 
What ideas would those be? Care to attempt to explain what caused the economic collapse? BTW, if you use the word "deregulation" without actually explaining what specific relaxation of regulation contributed and how, you lose 20 points.

Hint: it wasn't really caused directly by any elected branch of government (at least not recently), although the legislative committees that had oversight of the GSEs had a minor hand in it.

The Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000WP which made Credit Default Swaps legal would be a good candidate. It took about eight years for Wall Street investment banks to create a house of cards large enough to bring the world economy to it's knees.
 
How? If you pay $250,000 dollars and commit x materials to a project, and the result is a yacht, then you have succeeded in distributing money in exchange for labour with no useful gains.


The workers who were employed to build that yacht would disagree, I think.

In fact, I am reminded of something from some years ago. Back in the late 1980s or early 1990s, we had a “luxury tax” imposed, as a means of taxing “The Rich!!!”. It was originally promoted as a way to let “The Rich!!!” bear a heavy share of the government burden, without hurting the “little people”.

However, the impact of this tax ended up hitting one particular industry quite hard, which was the boatbuilding industry. “The Rich!!!” just bought and registered their yachts overseas, while many American workers who were employed in the boatbuilding industry suffered.

This tax ended up being repealed some time in the 1990s.

Efforts to target “The Rich!!!” with excessive taxation don't always produce unintended consequences that are as obvious as they were this time, but the same principle nearly always applies, albeit less obviously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom