Majority Don't Want Tax Cuts For Rich

Originally Posted by TShaitanaku
Despite design, they failed to produce stimulus. Now, even though they are bad for the economy and had a large role in precipitating the current downside economy
Liar, liar, pants on fire. You people are simply shameless in your ability and willingness to lie. :rolleyes:


The 2001 and 2003 tax cuts were responsible for about 23 percent of the deficit this year and will account for 41 percent of likely deficits from 2009 through 2019. From 2001 to 2007, the country experienced the weakest job growth since the end of World War II. While the nation's millionaires and billionaires got rich, average household income fell for the first time on record.
According to the Tax Policy Center's William Gale: "Economic research over the past decade can explain why extending the original Bush tax cuts is not good stimulus policy. After the tax rebates in 2001, 2003, and 2008, households appear to have spent in relatively short order somewhere between 25 and 67 cents more for each dollar of tax cut. This makes tax cuts in general - even the parts of those tax bills that were intended to stimulate - a relatively weak way to help the economy compared to increases in government purchases, for which each dollar of increased deficit turns into an additional dollar of spending. According to a report by the Center for American Progress, the Bush tax cuts failed to deliver jobs and income growth: "This period registered the weakest jobs and income growth in the post-war period. Overall monthly job growth was the worst of any cycle since at least February 1945, and household income growth was negative for the first cycle since tracking began in 1967. Women reversed employment gains of previous cycles. And for African Americans, the worst job growth on record was matched by an unprecedented increase in poverty."

"Final grade on the Bush tax cuts:" http://www.jobwatch.org/email/jobwatch_20050107.html
 

Just curious. Your source, http://www.jobwatch.org/email/jobwatch_20050107.html , has a chart and figure showing projected and actual job growth … without policy change and with the impact of the Bush tax cut. And it lists all the jobs that were actually created from June 2003 to December 2004 (2,407,000 jobs) as being jobs that would have occurred with no policy change, and it indicates the tax cut impact had zero impact on job growth. But how do they know that? How do they know that if the tax cuts hadn't taken place that 2,407,000 jobs would have been created? Perhaps only 1 million would have been created. Perhaps none. Hmmmmmm? :D
 
Why would the majority want tax cuts for the rich? The whole thing is absolutely ludicrous, and I'm amazed nobody has simply said it

INRM
"No matter how I die, it was murder"
SNL Parody of Julian Assange
 
. You may not realize it but poll after poll shows the American public think taxes are too high and government too big.

SO WHAT ?! Most Americans believe in a make believe bearded guy in the sky, that ID is science and that astrology works - I can never remember which fallacy is which. I am sure someone will tell me. Just because most Americans are wholly uneducated about how what their govt. does and get their "education" from the likes of Hannity and Limbough doesn't mean they're right.

The ONLY sure way to restrain government spending is give the government less money. History proves that the Federal government ALWAYS spends more than it gets in tax revenue.
HORSESH8! HOW about having an educated public that actually engages in politics beyond bumper stickers and the likes of the Palin bimbo.?! Oh but that's just too much to ask from Mr. Joe 6 pack - I mean god forbid we interrupt his fantasy football league to discuss stuff like the fact that our infrastructure is collapsing. that our school systems rank lower than countries like Bangladesh. It's just much easier to scream EEVVVIILL big Gubmint.

So lower the taxes to reduce the spending. Make the tax cuts permanent if you really want to make Americans happy. :D
Yup this is kind of like give an alcoholic another drink or a heroin addict another shot.

http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/2007/10/09/tax-shares-for-rich-and-poor/

You will NOT get an argument from me that our govt is inn-efficient and that the way it works - with pork barrel and earmarks - is corrupt.
My personal solution - which I have discussed for years is that any person running for office should have to pass a test about how our gov works and it's laws - sow we don't get retards like that teatard from WV(?) I can't think of her name. Second that things like pork barrel should be treated as a crime. But this is off topic here,


But the solution is MOST DEFINATELY NOT to have less govt and more money for the rich - that leads to nothing good and the examples are all over, generally referred to as banana republics where the rich own the govt. there is no middle class and the poor are F8ked! I guess if your part of the $250K crowd or you still believe that the US is the land of opportunity, contrary to evidence then it's much easier to believe this meme even if it's wrong.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/17/social-immobility-climbin_n_501788.html


The reality is that we are paying for 2 wars that are costing this country billions
Our infrastructure is a JOKE
Out public transportation is a JOKE
the state of our public education (I am talking about structure and resources here, teacher accountability and the union is a whole other topic) is a JOKE

In every one of these areas we are fast falling to levels generally thought as 3rd world nations.
And those who are most able to pay are acting like spoiled rich brats who at the slightest suggestion that they act like grown ups throw a temper tantrum and threaten to take their ball and go home.

This whole meme with the "poor rich people, they have more of tax burden blah blah blah" and "if we just gave them more money" sounds JUST LIKE the buybull thumpers that come to this forum cherry picking their sky daddy's book spouting on about "the TRUE word"

Like the buybull thumpers, the republicans whining on about "lower taxes for the rich because that's how capitalism will save us" display the same lack of knowledge most religious people do about their book. Most republican/capitalist attribute
"each according to his ability" to Marx, but they, like the buybull thumpers who know nothing about what is in their book, know nothing about the concept/creator of capitalism - Smith because they read all the "good stuff" he wrote and conveniently forget the hard parts

“The subjects of every state ought to contribute towards the support of the government, as nearly as possible, in proportion to their respective abilities; that is, in proportion to the revenue which they respectively enjoy under the protection of the state.”

You MAY agrue that it is not the fault of the rich that we are in the state that we are in, I may even agree with you. BUT that is just too damend bad!


The reality is that people who make under $100K have, in real dollars ahve been getting pay cuts and losing standard of living for the last 30 years. If you count nothing but raw dollars in wage raises, vs cost of health care, child care and food costs the middle class has been losing ground HUGE. At the same time the rich have been getting richer in every aspect!

Instead of acting like grown ups they are willing to sink the country, because THEY can afford to leave it, thus showing that the ONLY loyalty they have is their pocket book!

Cause GOD forbid that they would have to step up and take for the nation they claim is the greatest place in thw world.
 
Congrats on figuring out that one is less than fifty.

What your post was meant to do besides show off your fancy math skills is a mystery.

I'm just pointing out how you really want to help out the poor, impoverished billionaires who are a minority.
 
Is earning $249,999 "middle class"? What kind of nonsense is that?

That is well below the income of the greedy schmucks who ran the ecconomy into the ditch with hare-brained investment instruments.

It is within the range of people who can actually start a small business that employs a few people.

Give them a break, and take it out of the hides of the people who can buy an established manufacturing business and move production to China. Both have it coming.
 
Just curious. Your source, http://www.jobwatch.org/email/jobwatch_20050107.html , has a chart and figure showing projected and actual job growth … without policy change and with the impact of the Bush tax cut. And it lists all the jobs that were actually created from June 2003 to December 2004 (2,407,000 jobs) as being jobs that would have occurred with no policy change, and it indicates the tax cut impact had zero impact on job growth. But how do they know that? How do they know that if the tax cuts hadn't taken place that 2,407,000 jobs would have been created? Perhaps only 1 million would have been created. Perhaps none. Hmmmmmm? :D

If you are really curious, try going to the actual studies and researching the methodolgy employed, and comparing it to accepted standards and practices. Your lack of understanding and incredulity are neither interesting nor substantive challenges, however, my presentation and support do effectively refute you assertions of "lies." Admit your mistake and retract your comment and I will be happy to carry on this discussion to your next point of contention. So are you intelligent enough to admit you were wrong, or are you simply going to shift the goalposts and move on to a new angle of attack?
 
Give them a break, and take it out of the hides of the people who can buy an established manufacturing business and move production to China. Both have it coming.

And increasing the ultra-richs' taxes will slow this movement to China just how then?


"If you don't come back and let us kick you in the balls, we'll kick you in the balls."
 
Last edited:
Most Americans believe in a make believe bearded guy in the sky, that ID is science and that astrology works - I can never remember which fallacy is which.

So that makes it ok for government to take their money and spend it as the elite leftists now running the government think it should be spent? Is believing in socialism or marxism fundamentally any different than believing in Santa Claus? :D

Quote:
The ONLY sure way to restrain government spending is give the government less money. History proves that the Federal government ALWAYS spends more than it gets in tax revenue.

HORSESH8!

Actually, that's the unvarnished truth. But perhaps they didn't teach you that in whatever school you got your *education*. :D

I mean god forbid we interrupt his fantasy football league to discuss stuff like the fact that our infrastructure is collapsing.

Ever stop to think why our infrastructure is collapsing? Contrary to what you think, it's not from the government not having enough money. It's from the government not spending that money on infrastructure. It's from liberals advocating things (like illegal immigration) that have stressed that infrastructure to the max.

that our school systems rank lower than countries like Bangladesh.

Again, whose fault is that? Liberal controlled institutions. Democrats/liberals have essentially controlled the US public school system and university system for half a century. It's not lack of money that's the cause. Spending has never been higher in real dollars per pupil than it is now. The problem is that liberals have turned the system into a joke. Where union power and social engineering are more important than education.

You will NOT get an argument from me that our govt is inn-efficient and that the way it works - with pork barrel and earmarks - is corrupt.

And yet you want to give them more money?

My personal solution - which I have discussed for years is that any person running for office should have to pass a test about how our gov works and it's laws - sow we don't get retards like that teatard from WV(?) I can't think of her name.

LOL! That would mean Biden, who I bet YOU voted for, wouldn't now be one heartbeat away from the Presidency. Shall I list some of the stupidity Biden has uttered about the way our government works? Remember when he said this?

Article I of the Constitution defines the role of the Vice President of the United States. That's the executive. He works in the executive branch. He should understand that. Everyone should understand that.

Do I need to tell you that Article I defines the Legislative Branch's composition and the scope of its powers and that of its members. Article II concerns the Executive Branch.

And then he said this?

and as the Vice President to preside over the senate only in a time when in fact there is a tie vote.

Article I, Sec. 3, Clause 4 is the first time the Vice President is mentioned in the Constitution. It states this:

The Vice President of the United States shall be President of the Senate, but shall have no Vote, unless they be equally divided.

That doesn't say the Vice President is the President of the Senate only when there is a tie vote. He is President of the Senate ANY time he chooses to be.

So are we in agreement that Biden is unqualified? Then why'd you vote for him? :D

But the solution is MOST DEFINATELY NOT to have less govt and more money for the rich

Well, you are entitled to your opinion. But that's all it is … an opinion by someone who apparently doesn't look at things very clearly. :D

In every one of these areas we are fast falling to levels generally thought as 3rd world nations.

Yes, but to think that the answer is giving more money to the same group of people who let things decline to that state, while already spending more on government per capita then ever before, seems a tad foolish. :p

And those who are most able to pay are acting like spoiled rich brats

So you think someone making $250,000 is a spoiled rich brat? You realize, don't you, that you are talking about most of the small business owners in this country? The folks who employ most of the people in this country. You realize that you are talking about a group that has to work very hard and take great risks to be a small business owner? You think they deserve no reward for working hard and taking those risks? You realize that you are talking about a group that already pays most of the taxes in this country? And you call them "spoiled"? :rolleyes:

No, I think the word "spoiled" is far more applicable to the group of people, mostly democrats, who earn basically nothing or earn nothing at all but have been the recipients of trillions and trillions and trillions of dollars in government aid taken from those "spoiled rich" small businessmen/women. Spoiled are the folks who would rather stay on unemployment and the government dole than take an honest job that might earn a little less.

Do you know the number of jobs in America that are now going unfilled? It's in the MILLIONS. A lot of that is because people (most of whom are democrats) decided to major in social *science*, ethnic studies, law, psychology, media, political science or become actors, musicians, artists and community activists … rather than do the hard thing and learn to be an engineer or nurse, or learn a less glamorous but useful trade.

This whole meme with the "poor rich people, they have more of tax burden blah blah blah" and "if we just gave them more money" sounds JUST LIKE the buybull thumpers that come to this forum cherry picking their sky daddy's book spouting on about "the TRUE word"

LOL! You sure you aren't lefty's cousin? :rolleyes:

Most republican/capitalist attribute
"each according to his ability" to Marx, but they, like the buybull thumpers who know nothing about what is in their book, know nothing about the concept/creator of capitalism - Smith because they read all the "good stuff" he wrote and conveniently forget the hard parts

“The subjects of every state ought to contribute towards the support of the government, as nearly as possible, in proportion to their respective abilities; that is, in proportion to the revenue which they respectively enjoy under the protection of the state.”

LOL! First, Marx said "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need.” Smith didn't say anything about "need".

In fact, you completely overlooked what Adam Smith said was the proper role of government. Now I wonder why you did that? Well here's why.

Smith wrote that the proper role of government was to facilitate commerce (i.e., enforce contracts and secure property rights), provide for the national defense, regulate banking, provide for certain public goods that individuals would never be able to repay (specifically, large transportation infrastructure such as roads, bridges, canals and harbours), provide a basic education (and he warned against the sort of education democrats are now providing students), and administer justice.

In regard to the latter, Smith stated

"Wherever there is great property, there is great inequality. For one very rich man there must be at least five hundred poor, and the affluence of the few supposes the indigence of the many. The affluence of the rich excites the indignation of the poor, who are often both driven by want, and prompted by envy, to invade his possessions. It is only under the shelter of the civil magistrate that the owner of that valuable property, which is acquired by the labour of many years, or perhaps of many successive generations, can sleep a single night in security. - - - The acquisition of valuable and extensive property, therefore, necessarily requires the establishment of civil government."

and wrote:

"Civil government, so far as it is instituted for the security of property, is in reality instituted for the defense of the rich against the poor, or of those who have some property against those who have none at all."

So the reality is that Smith believed it was job of government to protect the "rich" from people like you.

He never once suggested that government's legitimate role was to provide free medical care or the sort of social welfare that liberals/socialists/democrats favor. He'd be rolling over in his grave if he saw the sort of nanny state they still want to create. He'd be rolling over in his grave if he heard what democrats desire in the way of inheritance taxes (which he opposed). And he'd insensed if he heard uneducated or dishonest leftists like you were now trying to use him to support their socialist/communist views.

Furthermore, the Adam Smith statement you quoted merely says that the wealthy should support government in proportion to the income they make. And if the wealthy did pay taxes in proportion to their income now? Well then, the top 1% would now be paying about 20% of taxes, instead of about 38%. The bottom 50% earn 13% of the income but they pay only 3% of the taxes. Following Smith's beliefs, perhaps we should quadruple the taxes on the bottom 50% and halve them on the top 1%? Hmmmmm?

Oh … so all of a sudden you don't really think so highly of Adam Smith? Can we assume you won't be citing him again or pretending you know more about him then conservatives? :D
 
Originally Posted by BeAChooser
... snip ... it lists all the jobs that were actually created from June 2003 to December 2004 (2,407,000 jobs) as being jobs that would have occurred with no policy change, and it indicates the tax cut impact had zero impact on job growth. But how do they know that? ... snip ...

If you are really curious, try going to the actual studies and researching the methodolgy employed, and comparing it to accepted standards and practices.

So in other words, you don't know. Wouldn't it be more honest to just admit that? :D
 
I don't care what "the majority" wants. The majority doesn't seem to have any limit on how much of other people's money they would take.

Maybe poor and middle-class people would be more careful with their voting if they were voting on spending their own money.
 
I don't care what "the majority" wants. The majority doesn't seem to have any limit on how much of other people's money they would take.

Maybe poor and middle-class people would be more careful with their voting if they were voting on spending their own money.


It's worse than you think.

Nearly half of all American households paid no income tax in 2009. A substantial portion of those, of course, would be on the receiving end of government handouts.

Think about what this means. We are very close to a tipping-point—if we haven't crossed it already—where a majority of American voters have no motive to support financial restraint and responsibility on the part of government. Depending on government for handouts, and not being responsible for paying taxes to support these handouts, creates a growing parasite class of voters who will support politicians who will increase taxes on those still paying them in order to pay for these handouts. As the tax burden grows greater on those still paying, more will fall into the parasite class. Fewer and fewer taxpayers supporting more and more parasites.

If this trend is not stopped, it will lead to a collapse. There will come a point when it will not be possible to get enough tax revenue from the shrinking taxpayer class to support the growing parasite class. What will happen then?
 
It's worse than you think.

Nearly half of all American households paid no income tax in 2009. A substantial portion of those, of course, would be on the receiving end of government handouts.

Think about what this means. We are very close to a tipping-point—if we haven't crossed it already—where a majority of American voters have no motive to support financial restraint and responsibility on the part of government. Depending on government for handouts, and not being responsible for paying taxes to support these handouts, creates a growing parasite class of voters who will support politicians who will increase taxes on those still paying them in order to pay for these handouts. As the tax burden grows greater on those still paying, more will fall into the parasite class. Fewer and fewer taxpayers supporting more and more parasites.

If this trend is not stopped, it will lead to a collapse. There will come a point when it will not be possible to get enough tax revenue from the shrinking taxpayer class to support the growing parasite class. What will happen then?

Well, once again you are going with the distribution of Federal income tax rather than combined tax burden of Income, payroll, sales tax, etc. This makes the distirbution seem worse than it really is. But aside from all that, there are a couple of reason for this distribution of income tax.

First, the top one percent are making more and more of the income, and end up paying a larger portion of federal income taxes. In the past thirty years, their share of the income tax burden has doubled, but their share of the income has tripled.

Second, GOP efforts to cut taxes for the rich usually fall flat unless they include a tax cut for the poor as well, so they can sell it as a tax cut for everybody. When you add up all the numbers however, most of the benefit of these cuts go to the rich.

Last but no least, the lousy economy has hurt the poor and working class a lot more than the rich. This leads to years like this where huge portions of the population are not making enough money to pay income taxes.
 
In regard to the latter, Smith stated

shalala

and wrote:

ladeda

So the reality is that Smith believed it was job of government to protect the "rich" from people like you.

I think you may have jumped the gun in assuming smith actually supported those positions, rather than was simply stating he believed they were currently the case. Chomsky once said that "the country was founded on the principle that the primary role of government is to protect property from the majority", but you'd be hard pressed to show that he actually supported government assuming that role.

Furthermore, the Adam Smith statement you quoted merely says that the wealthy should support government in proportion to the income they make. And if the wealthy did pay taxes in proportion to their income now? Well then, the top 1% would now be paying about 20% of taxes, instead of about 38%. The bottom 50% earn 13% of the income but they pay only 3% of the taxes. Following Smith's beliefs, perhaps we should quadruple the taxes on the bottom 50% and halve them on the top 1%? Hmmmmm?

If you look at actual financial assets of each percentage tier, the position is reversed - the poorer parts of society actually pay more tax compared to their financial assets than the richer parts.
 
Well, once again you are going with the distribution of Federal income tax rather than combined tax burden of Income, payroll, sales tax, etc. This makes the distirbution seem worse than it really is. But aside from all that, there are a couple of reason for this distribution of income tax.

First, the top one percent are making more and more of the income, and end up paying a larger portion of federal income taxes. In the past thirty years, their share of the income tax burden has doubled, but their share of the income has tripled.

Second, GOP efforts to cut taxes for the rich usually fall flat unless they include a tax cut for the poor as well, so they can sell it as a tax cut for everybody. When you add up all the numbers however, most of the benefit of these cuts go to the rich.

Last but no least, the lousy economy has hurt the poor and working class a lot more than the rich. This leads to years like this where huge portions of the population are not making enough money to pay income taxes.

Another issue that seems to elude many is that fed and state tax rates are marginal, which means that we all pay the same rates portions of our earnings. IOW, in the US for fed earnings, we all pay:
10% on the first $8,375 we earn
15% on the next $25,625 we earn
25% on the next $48,400 we earn
28% on the next $89,450 we earn
33% on the next $201,800 we earn
35% on anything over $373,650 we earn in a year.

The largest inequality from my perspective are the deductions and writeoffs available to higher income earners and wealth holders. I paid a much higher percentage of my earnings into federal taxes when I was in the military and in the middle income tax brackets, than I do currently in the higher tax brackets even though my marginal rate is much higher. The reason, is that I can now write-off, exempt and deduct my earnings much more than I could when I was earning much less (I could have probably taken some of these deductions then, but it didn't become as important to find out about them and how to take them, until I started earning a lot more money)
 
If you are really curious, try going to the actual studies and researching the methodolgy employed, and comparing it to accepted standards and practices. Your lack of understanding and incredulity are neither interesting nor substantive challenges, however, my presentation and support do effectively refute you assertions of "lies." Admit your mistake and retract your comment and I will be happy to carry on this discussion to your next point of contention. So are you intelligent enough to admit you were wrong, or are you simply going to shift the goalposts and move on to a new angle of attack?

So in other words, you don't know. Wouldn't it be more honest to just admit that? :D

You seem to rely awfully much on mind-reading to be posting on a skeptical messageboard. Wouldn't it have been more honest to actually have admitted your mistake and followed up on your "curiosity" by actually researching the material or presenting a legitimate contention/argument rather than simply trying to shift the goalposts and angle of attack?
 
I paid a much higher percentage of my earnings into federal taxes when I was in the military and in the middle income tax brackets, than I do currently in the higher tax brackets even though my marginal rate is much higher.

Would that be true with todays tax structure also. Most lower and lower middle income pay a very small percentage. Although if you were single with no children maybe even with todays structure.
 
Think about what this means. We are very close to a tipping-point—if we haven't crossed it already—where a majority of American voters have no motive to support financial restraint and responsibility on the part of government. Depending on government for handouts, and not being responsible for paying taxes to support these handouts, creates a growing parasite class of voters who will support politicians who will increase taxes on those still paying them in order to pay for these handouts. As the tax burden grows greater on those still paying, more will fall into the parasite class. Fewer and fewer taxpayers supporting more and more parasites.

There's an interesting science fiction book that looks at that called "Beggars and Choosers". Where do you think I got my screenname?
 
I had always assumed it was from the (much more widely known) colloquialism "beggars can't be choosers," but hey, you learn something every day. Tell us more about how you base your entire ideology around a science fiction book. I personally base mine around "The World Inside."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom