Majority Don't Want Tax Cuts For Rich

As I said already--if your mindset is starting with the top 0.1% then my response is that you're far more interested in more progressive tax / more redistribution of income, than you are about funding the government.

And that's fine, I just think it would be better if you, or anyone, would come clean about that.
Oh, I'm definitely a fan of progressive taxation for "promoting the general welfare", but I'm not really sure how that doesn't overlap with "funding the government"?
 
It does, but too much noise is made about whether the tax on the highest earners will impact growth (and the deficit). It will not impact either very much IMO.
 
As I said already--if your mindset is starting with the top 0.1% then my response is that you're far more interested in more progressive tax / more redistribution of income, than you are about funding the government.

And that's fine, I just think it would be better if you, or anyone, would come clean about that.

Apart from simply making taxes more progressive, there is another reason to consider higher tax rates on high incomes. A dollar spent on a tax break for the top 2% generates roughly 69 cents in economic activity. A dollar spent on tax breaks for the middle class generates over a dollar in economic activity. Extending unemployment insurance or building infrastructure generates several dollars in economic activity for each dollar spent.

Our goal right now should be to generate more economic activity and restore a more normal economic climate. Tax cuts for the wealthy are an ineffective way to achieve that goal.
 
A dollar spent on a tax break for the top 2% generates roughly 69 cents in economic activity. A dollar spent on tax breaks for the middle class generates over a dollar in economic activity. Extending unemployment insurance or building infrastructure generates several dollars in economic activity for each dollar spent.
if you've ever researched that you would have found that those views are vigorously contested (mostly depending on whether advocates are for or against redistribution, which again suggests that it is just a debate about redistribution masquerading as something else).

In general cutting tax for low income folks increases consumption, which hits GDP sooner but falls out of it sooner as well. In contrast reducing tax on high income folks increases consumption less but increases investment and saving more, which has a smaller impact on current GDP but a larger impact on potential ("permanent") growth rate.
 
In general cutting tax for low income folks increases consumption, which hits GDP sooner but falls out of it sooner as well. In contrast reducing tax on high income folks increases consumption less but increases investment and saving more, which has a smaller impact on current GDP but a larger impact on potential ("permanent") growth rate.

Isn't this basically what I said earlier?
 
A dollar spent on a tax break for the top 2% generates roughly 69 cents in economic activity. A dollar spent on tax breaks for the middle class generates over a dollar in economic activity.

How is a dollar spent on a tax break?
 
if you've ever researched that you would have found that those views are vigorously contested (mostly depending on whether advocates are for or against redistribution, which again suggests that it is just a debate about redistribution masquerading as something else).

In general cutting tax for low income folks increases consumption, which hits GDP sooner but falls out of it sooner as well. In contrast reducing tax on high income folks increases consumption less but increases investment and saving more, which has a smaller impact on current GDP but a larger impact on potential ("permanent") growth rate.

Right now large American businesses are sitting on immense reserves of cash waiting for consumption to pick up before hiring new workers. At that level, there is no shortage of capitol. This should give us a hint on how to proceed.
 
How? Influence them to spend or invest it against their better judgement and so unleash yet another unbalanced boom or bubble of some sort?

No thanks.
 
Did nobody pay attention to the landslide election?!?!? The People decided Congress was spending too much, not that it wasn't taxing enough.

And you come to the conclusion that this is the motivation for the election results, how?

As far as I can tell not even those who elected Republican candidates had across the board congressional spending cuts as the top priority on their list of reasons for electing those candidates.
 
Businesses hire new people and invest in new production facilities when sales pick up to the point that it's needed. If government spending generates demand, businesses will hire workers. The workers that are hired will then start spending, generate more economic activity and the need for other businesses to hire more workers. As employment and the economy picks up, government can back off on spending and let the private sector take over.
 
And you come to the conclusion that this is the motivation for the election results, how?

As far as I can tell not even those who elected Republican candidates had across the board congressional spending cuts as the top priority on their list of reasons for electing those candidates.

A more precise reason would be "the economy stinks, throw the bastards out".

The problem is that most of the bastards voted in during the last election still believe in the ideas that helped create the economic collapse two years ago.
 
if you've ever researched that you would have found that those views are vigorously contested (mostly depending on whether advocates are for or against redistribution, which again suggests that it is just a debate about redistribution masquerading as something else).

In general cutting tax for low income folks increases consumption, which hits GDP sooner but falls out of it sooner as well. In contrast reducing tax on high income folks increases consumption less but increases investment and saving more, which has a smaller impact on current GDP but a larger impact on potential ("permanent") growth rate.

When you are still on the downside of a cyclical adjustment, and inflation is low, the short-term takes precedence over longer term considerations. As the economy returns to a more sustainable state then longer-term growth considerations become more important.
 

it avoids trying to piecemeal adjust poor legislation into cobbled together acceptable legislation. Better to let them all expire as originally designed and be ready to move on tax relief legislation of independent design to address the issues felt strongly about. Let the Dems make their case for tax relief for the under $200K and Republicans can respond. Let Republicans make their case for the over $200K and Democratic candidates can respond.
 
so...how many jobs did the wealthy in America create last month?

how about in 2010? not that many.

what good is a tax-cut for the rich if unemployment in the USA keeps slowly going up?

looks like a wasted tax-cut. we might as well just raise taxes on the rich and use the extra tax revenue to help reduce the deficit or pay for more jobs, WPA style.
 
Last edited:
so...how many jobs did the wealthy in America create last month?

how about in 2010? not that many.

what good is a tax-cut for the rich if unemployment in the USA keeps slowly going up?

looks like a wasted tax-cut. we might as well just raise taxes on the rich and use the extra tax revenue to help reduce the deficit or pay for more jobs, WPA style.


Even for you, that's an amazingly stupid^H^H^H^H^H^Hthunderous argument.

Your argument makes as much sense as arguing that since a particular patient is still ill, in spite of the best medical treatments being used to treat him, that we should try giving him cyanide and hope that makes him better.

In fact, at this point, it's actually more like arguing that since very small doses of cyanide didn't make him better, that we need to try a much larger dose.

Raising taxes is poison to a weak economy.

Government is dragging the economy down. Your argument is that government needs to drag the economy down even more, in order to fix it.

STUPID, STUPID, STUPID!
 
Last edited:
so...how many jobs did the wealthy in America create last month?

how about in 2010? not that many.

what good is a tax-cut for the rich if unemployment in the USA keeps slowly going up?

looks like a wasted tax-cut. we might as well just raise taxes on the rich and use the extra tax revenue to help reduce the deficit or pay for more jobs, WPA style.

Sooo, by this logic tax them more and that'll teach them to refuse to create jobs?
 
Raising taxes is poison to a weak economy.

Government is dragging the economy down. Your argument is that government needs to drag the economy down even more, in order to fix it.

STUPID, STUPID, STUPID!

Raising taxes won't help reverse the down-cycle economy, but it will help the longer term debt and aggregate supply issues we face. I would prefer a replacement of these high-end targeted, debt-financed give-backs, with a more reasonable package of low-end breaks and discounts along with investment incentives, but would rather see them all expire and let the proponents wrangle for replacement legislation.

The only "stupid" issue I've seen raised are those who are advocating the reduction of government spending in the current economy. A return to taxation rates of the '90s (on its own) isn't going to significant alter the economy in the near term.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom