Majority Don't Want Tax Cuts For Rich

Is earning $249,999 "middle class"? What kind of nonsense is that? If you don't want tax cuts for the "rich", then tax should increase for everyone above about $50,000. Happy with that?

Which is why I say let all the tax cuts expire, and then let the parties argue for new tax cuts if that's what they want.

I remember the nineties quite well, and despite all the hand wringing, taxes weren't a horrible burden, especially on those at the lower end of the scale (of course, I don't consider the tax scales back in the 60s to have been that bad either, I worked, earned and made a living.)
 
I hate to break it to you, but he's already broken that no tax increase pledge. It's not like breaking it again will suddenly cause people to react with revulsion.

Are you speaking of the special taxes levied on investment bankers that got huge bonuses after receiving a government bailout? :rolleyes:

If not, please explain yourself.
 
Are you speaking of the special taxes levied on investment bankers that got huge bonuses after receiving a government bailout? :rolleyes:

If not, please explain yourself.

Some people (erroneously, I believe) refer to it as Obamacare.

ETA: Specifically, things like the 40% excise tax on "cadillac" health care plans. (Now that we know that UAW workers are "rich", we can factor that into how we view the government's intervention into the Chrysler bankruptcy, etc.) A new exicse tax on the importation of medical devices. A limit on the amount that people can put into a FSA to $2500/year. Reduce the number of things that people can purchase with money put into a HSA or FSA. Additional payroll taxes, etc. Many of the new taxes, while not targetted at people making $250,000/yr or less, will indeed hit those people. Taxes on medical devices and drugs will be passed on to consumers. Removing the tax deductability for companies providing prescription drug benefits to retirees will result in those companies not providing those benefits (several high profile cases of this have already happened, forcing Medicare to pick up the tab). Even a 10% excise tax on indoor tanning salons.

The most obvious and glaring break with his promise is the portion of the health care 'reform' bill that applies the HI payroll taxes to investment income. Firstly, I'm not sure how a payroll tax can be applied to something other than salary and still be called a payroll tax, and secondly, this will affect anyone who has investment income, of any type; capital gains, dividends, royalties, rents.
 
Last edited:
Did nobody pay attention to the landslide election?!?!? The People decided Congress was spending too much, not that it wasn't taxing enough.
 
CBS News Poll: Most Oppose GOP Tax Plan

Only 26% want tax cuts for the rich*.

53% want tax cuts for the middle class only, and 14% think all tax cuts should expire.

* I.E., tax cuts on marginal income over $250,000.

This would be a winning issue with the public if democrats would make a stand and refuse to compromise.
When has there ever been a time that the majority do not want tax cuts for the rich. I would bet few of the respondents even understand the tax situation.
 
Which is why I say let all the tax cuts expire, and then let the parties argue for new tax cuts if that's what they want.

I remember the nineties quite well, and despite all the hand wringing, taxes weren't a horrible burden, especially on those at the lower end of the scale (of course, I don't consider the tax scales back in the 60s to have been that bad either, I worked, earned and made a living.)

For the most part I agree with you. The middle class can carry a little more.
a married couple with 2 school age children gets a 2800 refund with 25,000 in wages , 37 dollar refund with 50,000 in wages, pays 3700 with 75,000 in wages (3.7%) and pays 8,063 with 100,000 in wages (8%) . The last two figures are without counting itemized deductions for mort interest , property taxes etc. This would lower their bills more.

Same scenario with 500,000 pays 136,208 (26%)
 
Some people (erroneously, I believe) refer to it as Obamacare.

ETA: Specifically, things like the 40% excise tax on "cadillac" health care plans. (Now that we know that UAW workers are "rich", we can factor that into how we view the government's intervention into the Chrysler bankruptcy, etc.) A new exicse tax on the importation of medical devices. A limit on the amount that people can put into a FSA to $2500/year. Reduce the number of things that people can purchase with money put into a HSA or FSA. Additional payroll taxes, etc. Many of the new taxes, while not targetted at people making $250,000/yr or less, will indeed hit those people. Taxes on medical devices and drugs will be passed on to consumers. Removing the tax deductability for companies providing prescription drug benefits to retirees will result in those companies not providing those benefits (several high profile cases of this have already happened, forcing Medicare to pick up the tab). Even a 10% excise tax on indoor tanning salons.

The most obvious and glaring break with his promise is the portion of the health care 'reform' bill that applies the HI payroll taxes to investment income. Firstly, I'm not sure how a payroll tax can be applied to something other than salary and still be called a payroll tax, and secondly, this will affect anyone who has investment income, of any type; capital gains, dividends, royalties, rents.

The health care bill provides care for far more Americans while lowering the deficit. But your real concern is that tanning salon sessions will cost a few bucks more. :rolleyes:
 
Is earning $249,999 "middle class"?

Amen!

I think the right has succeeded in selling a bill of goods to most of the U.S.

Median household income in the U.S. is well under $50K. Households earning $200K and up make more than over 90% of households.

And of course the numbers for individual income are even lower.
 
So, to sum up this thread: Class warfare rhetoric is still alive and well.

Sad.
 
Still getting your health care law information from Harry and Louise? :rolleyes:
It's going to make insurance more expensive (or already is.) It might end up pricing more people out than it lets into the system.
 
Anyone who favours large spending cuts (and who presumably believes the economy can withstand those) should not really be going on about how taxing the extremely rich will harm growth, because they are internally inconsistent (IE hypocrites who probably really believe something else)

Conversely [ . . . ] It is--for example--rather hypocritical for those who think the economy needs more stimulus to simultaneously favour any form of tax hike

Well there we go: already someone representing the left view that you can raise tax and raise spending and boost growth . . .
I disagree. While I will happily say that I am in favour of greater redistribution of income, I don't believe that tax hikes for the rich are incompatible with more stimulus for the economy. I believe there are better ways to stimulate the economy than to allow the rich to pay less tax, such as spending the money taxed from the rich on constructing homes, nuclear/renewable power sources, new schools/hospitals etc, and employing people to do so.
. . . closely followed by the right view that you can cut spending and cut tax and boost growth:
I both agree and disagree. Yes, the fundamental issue that determines which side of this debate a person supports is primarily their support or lack thereof for wealth redistribution. However, I strongly disagree with this:

"Anyone who favours large spending cuts (and who presumably believes the economy can withstand those) should not really be going on about how taxing the extremely rich will harm growth, because they are internally inconsistent (IE hypocrites who probably really believe something else)"

Government spending provides short term stimulus, primarily through consumption, at the expense of long term growth. Increased government debt creates a long term drag on economic growth through the crowding out effect and reduced private investment. It is investment that drives economic growth, not consumption. The question of which reduces growth more, higher tax rates (for those who create the majority of jobs) or greater public debt, is not something we can really answer with any degree of confidence yet. But it is certainly not inconsistent to want to try to minimize both. That obviously requires greater cuts in spending (minor, short term reduction in growth) than the amount of revenue lost to potential tax increases.
. . . Still, at least both accepted that this tax debate is actually about redistribution.

stokes234: You are on a sticky wicket claiming that levying higher tax and spending that on energy, housing, education or healthcare actually increases growth/output. Due to the deadweight loss ("excess burden") of taxation that is almost never true. The case for compulsory public funding of some of those things is usually that they are public or socially-desired goods that will be under-provided (relative to society's legislated preference) otherwise, not that it boosts growth to do so.

MikeMangum: You are being highly selective in your critique of what public spending is used for, and what private wealth is used for, in order to slant your conclusion to "government = waste; private = productivity-increasing". You do your normally comprehensive grasp of economics a dis-service.
 
Amen!

I think the right has succeeded in selling a bill of goods to most of the U.S.
What about the left too? If the mantra is "let the rich pay more tax", then raise tax for everyone earning over $50,000. Then see how many people change their mind about whether rich people (those well above median income) can really afford it without the economy blinking.
 
What about the left too? If the mantra is "let the rich pay more tax", then raise tax for everyone earning over $50,000. Then see how many people change their mind about whether rich people (those well above median income) can really afford it without the economy blinking.

I don't understand why we're not starting with (highly) taxing the top .1% and moving downward from there.:confused:
 
As I said already--if your mindset is starting with the top 0.1% then my response is that you're far more interested in more progressive tax / more redistribution of income, than you are about funding the government.

And that's fine, I just think it would be better if you, or anyone, would come clean about that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom