Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Please read my disclaimer in my signature before reading my post -

I said that to avoid skeptics gimmicky tactic of bogging people down in rhetoric. Some skeptics want to play like a lawyer so then I have to use lawerly tactics in return. Skeptics started this game.. then they whine about it.

Read it. It appears to claim the there is no science at all. It also appears to claim that any disagreement with your claims is "lawyerly" because being a lawyer is somehow relevant. And you flat out trash all lawyers, because something ,and you trash a mod, who actually is a real life lawyer.

Is there anyone you will not take a massive dump on?
 
Read it. It appears to claim the there is no science at all. It also appears to claim that any disagreement with your claims is "lawyerly" because being a lawyer is somehow relevant. And you flat out trash all lawyers, because something ,and you trash a mod, who actually is a real life lawyer.

Is there anyone you will not take a massive dump on?

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rule 6


Yes, people actually in search of information not trying to control information.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Read disclaimer in signature before reading post -

Yes, people actually in search of information not trying to control information.
I have read and signed such disclaimers and NDA's in a professional capacity. Your strange notion that such a thing is necessary here in this venue is beyond odd.
 
I have read and signed such disclaimers and NDA's in a professional capacity. Your strange notion that such a thing is necessary here in this venue is beyond odd.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rule 6


The only reason it is necessary is because I am tired of skeptics not realizing that I am not making scientific claims. This isn't a science paper. It's off the cuff conversation that I haven't parsed perfectly or analyzed every word to see how it can be interpreted to twist my argument.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
P.S. I listened to the Albert Einstein Documentary video to past Hermann Einstein's death in 1902 and no mention of him being disappointed in Albert. There is Albert being disappointed in himself.

I only watched the beginning of the video, but I noticed that near the beginning at 2:55 Michio Kaku states, "His father passes away thinking that young Albert is a total disgrace to the family." I agree that he isn't a great source for that information, but he does state that.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rule 6


The only reason it is necessary is because I am tired of skeptics not realizing that I am not making scientific claims. This isn't a science paper. It's off the cuff conversation that I haven't parsed perfectly or analyzed every word to see how it can be interpreted to twist my argument.

I read it. It's impossibly naive and unenforceable.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I read it. It's impossibly naive and unenforceable.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rule 6


It isn't supposed to be enforceable.. it's just so people can't claim I was making scientific claims - these are just opinions.

It's so I don't have to write a lengthy disclaimer before every comment.

What do you even mean by enforceable?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
...respectfully snipped...

Now, the point of the analogy, in case anyone missed it. To scientists and skeptics who are familiar with physics and its mathematical foundations, Mills' hydrino machines are not one iota more plausible than my free-apple machines, and for exactly the same reasons.

You are one up on Mills. Your incredibly insightful discovery has a solid mathematical foundation. The Banach–Tarski theorem.
 
I don't know what you mean by "certain groups failures" so I can't answer that. But your second question I can. Take for exampke the thread "stellar metamorphosis" that certainly goes against the mainstream theory of how *stars form into planets. What characterizes that thread is assertions without evidence. That is the hallmark of all pseudoscience. That is precisely what Mills does.

*There is no such theory. Stars don't become planets.

That is the issue. There were never "planets" to begin with. A star has always been the planet. They were never mutually exclusive to begin with. As well, all the evidence is pointing to this, so saying there is NO evidence is a bold-faced lie.

Not only that, but they can all fit into one graph, and we can determine their rough ages by simply placing them on the graph. All exoplanets fit on this graph. ALL of them.

Neptune%2BCommon.JPG


The REAL pseudoscience is ignoring the evidence that the accepted theory has been falsified. The angular momentum problem, by itself, falsifies the nebular hypothesis and all variants. Jupiter has the majority of the angular momentum of the solar system, yet ~1% of the mass. This is impossible according to the nebular hypothesis and ALL accepted theories.

Not only that but it is easy to explain to ANY LAYMAN AND PHYSICIST alive with a simple cup of coffee. Stir the coffee with a spoon. You will see that the mass of the fluid moves towards the edges of the coffee to conserve angular momentum.

It means that if the solar system formed in a big disk, then there would be NO MASS to form the Sun, the mass would have moved to Jupiter... which has the majority of the angular momentum to begin with. So why is the majority of the mass in the center? The nebular disk theory and all its variants violate a basic physical law of nature, the conservation of angular momentum.

It 100% falsifies the nebular disk theory, yet it is still taught in school. Why? Because educated folk do not have a suitable alternative due to dozens of false assumptions that have turned into dogma getting in the way. That is the definition of pseudoscience, accepting falsified theory as if it has never been falsified. ALL problems concerning explaining stellar evolution and planet formation can be solved instantaneously just by realizing it is THE EXACT SAME PROCESS.
 
Last edited:
I only watched the beginning of the video, but I noticed that near the beginning at 2:55 Michio Kaku states, "His father passes away thinking that young Albert is a total disgrace to the family."
I suspect that the disgrace is the disgrace of having a child a year before Albert and Mileva Marić married. That was Lieserl Einstein born January 1902, died sometime in 1903. Hermann Einstein died 10 October 1902 and the marriage was in January 1903.
 
Last edited:
That is the issue. ...
The issue really is derailing this thread with ignorant fantasies that have already been documented in your other thread, e.g. jeffreyw: 112 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015 :eye-poppi!
This thread is about mainstream and fringe science. These are based on the real world. Mainstream science is science backed up by enough evidence that the consensus is that it is correct. Fringe science is "an inquiry in an established field of study which departs significantly from mainstream theories in that field and is considered to be questionable by the mainstream".
Mainstream and fringe science are not someone's ignorant fantasies touted in forums and bad papers on a PDF upload site.
 
Last edited:
Thread closed pending moderatation. As always, do not restart this discussion in another thread. Thank you.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Loss Leader
 
Last edited:
Reopened.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jsfisher
 
Hmm, I've just perused pretty much the whole of this thread. Maybe I've got this wrong, but the claim of ST was that he, and possibly Einstein, were/ are on the autistic spectrum. I believe Dirac was strongly suspected of also being autistic (Asperger's). The claim then being that 'mavericks' who think in different ways to the 'norm', are capable of great things, and that the mainstream should not be quite so quick to knock such people.
Well, as has already been explained, autistic or not, Einstein was perfectly mainstream. As was Dirac. Both brilliant, but both mainstream.
Now, as it happens, I myself have been diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome (AS). Believe it or not, I actually had a bit of a period in my teens when both Von Daniken and Velikovsky seemed quite alluring (forgive me!). Now, the problem with AS is that one tends to like routines. Both physical and mental. And one is not easily persuaded to change them, and it can be upsetting and difficult to do so. However, it would appear that AS does also bestow certain abilities, whilst taking away others. Mine (not unusually for AS) was a fascination with numbers, patterns, etc. This led to an interest in physics, and from there into wider fields of astronomy, not to mention numerous other subjects.
The reason that I am now a critic of all things woo, is that interest in science that led me to see the aforementioned woo merchants for what they were. This, of course, includes the latter day Velikovskians, headed by the charlatan Thornhill, plus A. N. Other.
So, I could see how having AS could lead one to an interest in somewhat outlandish ideas, and how it would be hard to break the habit of believing such ideas. In my case it came down to a decent science education. In my experience, that is what the followers of cranks like Mills and Thornhill lack. Whether they have AS or not. For an AS sufferer to be told that they are just plain wrong, is not easy for them to take. However, when they lack the scientific knowledge to properly assess their beliefs, then I'm afraid that that is what ST is; just plain wrong.
 
Hmm, I've just perused pretty much the whole of this thread. Maybe I've got this wrong, but the claim of ST was that he, and possibly Einstein, were/ are on the autistic spectrum. I believe Dirac was strongly suspected of also being autistic (Asperger's). The claim then being that 'mavericks' who think in different ways to the 'norm', are capable of great things, and that the mainstream should not be quite so quick to knock such people.
Well, as has already been explained, autistic or not, Einstein was perfectly mainstream. As was Dirac. Both brilliant, but both mainstream.
Now, as it happens, I myself have been diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome (AS). Believe it or not, I actually had a bit of a period in my teens when both Von Daniken and Velikovsky seemed quite alluring (forgive me!). Now, the problem with AS is that one tends to like routines. Both physical and mental. And one is not easily persuaded to change them, and it can be upsetting and difficult to do so. However, it would appear that AS does also bestow certain abilities, whilst taking away others. Mine (not unusually for AS) was a fascination with numbers, patterns, etc. This led to an interest in physics, and from there into wider fields of astronomy, not to mention numerous other subjects.
The reason that I am now a critic of all things woo, is that interest in science that led me to see the aforementioned woo merchants for what they were. This, of course, includes the latter day Velikovskians, headed by the charlatan Thornhill, plus A. N. Other.
So, I could see how having AS could lead one to an interest in somewhat outlandish ideas, and how it would be hard to break the habit of believing such ideas. In my case it came down to a decent science education. In my experience, that is what the followers of cranks like Mills and Thornhill lack. Whether they have AS or not. For an AS sufferer to be told that they are just plain wrong, is not easy for them to take. However, when they lack the scientific knowledge to properly assess their beliefs, then I'm afraid that that is what ST is; just plain wrong.
Alrighty then. May I preface by saying that I have no prejudice in this? I say that because I may unintentionally insert foot in own mouth.

There are, it seems to me, multiple factors in play. The eggheads in the ivory towers move the goalposts. The frontline docs try to keep up and over-diagnose. The spectrum grows without discernable end. In thirty years time, all of us will be so diagnosed. If we all have it where the hell are we? Once the boundaries expand to include everyone, well it's useless.

Now, I have precisely no desire to belittle your affliction. Were I in hiring/firing mode, you would most certainly pass the test. Your affliction is to some extent psycho somatic. I have two simple criteria, can john/jane doe do the job and is john/jane doe reliable. After that i don't care if you are a leper. To be fair, I own a bespoke software company, making virtual working and home office stuff de riguer. It simply ain't so in other businesses. I could be all ego and say that AS, AD, ADHD and whatever were no bar to hiring (polishes halo) but it would be flat out dishonest for me to do so. It simply happens that my business naturally lends itself by default to ...well good programmers, really and whichever of those may or may not have something going on is really irrelevant. I have always operated on a meritocracy basis.

But that is just me and I have the leisure :rolleyes: to allow such slack time.

A friend of mine has a HVAC business. It runs around the clock, 24/7. Shift comes in, shift goes out, churn, churn and churn some more. There is welding, forming, bending and who knows what. The entire factory is a hard hat area. Every time I nip in in passing (it's on my route to my office) it is like Dante's Inferno.

Here is the thing. Imagine that both of us hired the same guy who had AS, AD or whatnot. Which environment would be more conducive to health? Nobody knows. Would it be the calm of a deskjob in my company? I have no idea
Would it be the honest toil of manual labour in my friends company? I don't know that either.
 
@Abaddon,
In my experience, it isn't the work; far from it. Many AS people would make brilliant programmers, estimators, QS, etc. Especially those things that need a flair for numbers, attention to detail, etc. Your main problem would come with the work environment. A diagnostic trait of AS is crap social skills and, quite often, an almost phobic reaction to being around other people. And then there is other people's reaction to them.
Let me work from home, and I'll be great. Better than most. Put me in a busy office, and I'll likely last a couple of months, hit the bottle, and eventually walk out. Doesn't matter how much you're paying me!
School was bad enough - I often didn't even bother going. It forever amazed my teachers that I still managed to finish in the top 5 in pretty much every subject.
However, AS is definitely a real condition, and there are genetic and brain studies that show that there are differences in those areas from typical subjects. Whether it should be lumped in with classic autism is another matter.

https://www.livescience.com/38630-autism-asperger-eeg-connectivity.html

http://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/study-confirms-a-gene-linked-to-asperger-syndrome-and-empathy
 
...
I'm sorry to burst your bubble, but the persecuted loner who is hounded by the evil mainstream scientists for overturning their theories while being right all along is a myth belonging to comic books and movies. There are literally no examples in actual science.
Leaving the 'evil' nonsense out, I can cite you three cases where good science was ignored for a decade or more by the established mainstream scientific community.

Dr Snow made a meticulous case with multiple avenues of evidence for the source of the 1800s London cholera epidemic centered around the Broad St Pump. It was 10 more years before the waterborne source of cholera was accepted.

And the evidence for plate tectonics was established:
in 1912 the meteorologist Alfred Wegener amply described what he called continental drift, expanded in his 1915 book The Origin of Continents and Oceans[32] and the scientific debate started that would end up fifty years later in the theory of plate tectonics.

H-Pylori
H. pylori was first discovered in the stomachs of patients with gastritis and ulcers in 1982 by Drs. Barry Marshall and Robin Warren of Perth, Australia. At the time, the conventional thinking was that no bacterium could live in the acid environment of the human stomach. In recognition of their discovery, Marshall and Warren were awarded the 2005 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine....

Some skepticism was expressed initially, but within a few years multiple research groups had verified the association of H. pylori with gastritis and, to a lesser extent, ulcers....
Few years is overly generous. A few physicians began to accept the evidence. It wasn't for well over a decade before the concept of bacterial etiology of gastric ulcers became the norm.
 
Last edited:
On the whole I think historically scientists have got the amount of evidence required before a new hypothesis is taken seriously about right. Yes, there have been a few cases where a correct one has taken a little longer to be accepted than seems necessary in hindsight, but that's a small price to pay for the time that would be wasted giving unwarranted credence to every crackpot indulging in unsupported speculation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom