Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

We only appear to be experts (or Dunning-whatevers) because this forum has a way of spanking those that go too far astray. Chances are, if you sense some expertise on offer, it's actually from those with some expertise. At least here in the SMMT section.
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited for rule 6. Please put this link into your signature if you want your 'disclaimer' to be referenced in every post.


and that's why I can't post it here... you all obviously don't care. If you did you would already know about this.. it's not like you haven't had clues being skeptics and all.

Well, that puts you in a catch 22. You can't tell people who don't care and there is no need to tell people who do care as they would already know. Looks like you have eliminated your own need or desire to tell anyone.
 
Well, that puts you in a catch 22. You can't tell people who don't care and there is no need to tell people who do care as they would already know. Looks like you have eliminated your own need or desire to tell anyone.


Clearly this thread shows that's not the whole story. There appears to also be a desire to annoy the people he doesn't want to tell.
 
Clearly this thread shows that's not the whole story. There appears to also be a desire to annoy the people he doesn't want to tell.

Yeah, the whole 'I won't talk about it but won't stop talking about how and why I'm not talking about it' gets old fast. I guess that wasn't getting enough traction so then we get the assertions of narcissism in others from someone who apparently just can't stop talking about themselves and how important something is that they have found that they won't be talking about.
 
I was just expressing my view that it seems there is a lot of bias against ideas that are out of the mainstream and the mainstream is much more critical of those ideas than the "popular" mainstream ideas. It seems to be a dogma issue to me.
We've explained why there's bias against fringe ideas. Fringe ideas of the type argued over on this forum do not and have not produced independently verified evidence. Fringe ideas... start from a point of belief rather than evidence. Fringe ideas... start from a point of something that appears odd and from that starting point a narrative explanation is born. I'll give you one example, crop circles. The simple explanation is people are making them. The fringe thinks it's aliens. All in all fringe science is emotive thinking rather than scientific thinking.

Its far from dogma. At any time what we think is scientifically true about anything could be turned on its head, but as time goes on scientists keep devising new ways to test what we think we know and so far nothing has brought into question our understanding of how nature works. What you see as dogma is nothing more than a very high, but not absolute confidence we have it right.
 
Last edited:
I have stated I am not an expert..does that sound like someone with Dunning Kruger?

I have studied Mills work and related information for almost a decade - full time. Yet people here assume they know more than me and most haven't researched Mills at all.. so again who is more likely to be displaying D-K?

Wait, so after just saying "I am not an expert" you then try to assert some expertise about "Mills work" over others?
 
Why would someone with less time to gather knowledge be superior?
They wouldn't. Good thing I didn't say that.

Besides not being what you said. "someone with less time to gather knowledge" can actually end up more knowledgeable. As they can have better, more accurate, reference sources. A larger base knowledge of related subjects to draw from or relate to or just be a faster learner. While more time of study would generally lead to a more knowledgeable individual that's not always the case. I'm sure most here can at least recall from their past someone (if not themselves) in some subject given the same time and information as everyone else who still just weren't getting it. Sometimes some subjects just don't 'click' with some people. Simple knowledge doesn't do much good if you can't put it together and use it effectively.
 
<snip>

I have stated I am not an expert..does that sound like someone with Dunning Kruger?

I have studied Mills work and related information for almost a decade - full time. Yet people here assume they know more than me and most haven't researched Mills at all.. so again who is more likely to be displaying D-K?

<snip>
Are you the same person who thanked me for pointing out Mills et. al. had published quite a few papers on hydrinos, papers you were apparently unaware of at the time?

If so, would you care to comment on why nearly a decade of full time study of Mills failed to uncover their existence?
 
Guys... a word of warning.. don't ever try to out-argue an Aspie... it can only lead to your defeat.

Unless the person is hilariously, catastrophically wrong and refuses to present any evidence, choosing to instead hide behind conspiracy theories and their alleged Asperger's status. In which case they'll be handily defeated in the debate.

Asperger's is not a superpower and it certainly doesn't mean you're right or wrong any more or less often than anyone else.

Notice to fellow forum members: I have a lot of friends with Asperger's and I have NEVER heard ANY of them say something as daft about Asperger's as SkepticalTheorist's claim of being undefeatable in a debate.
 
Much to discuss in this post; thanks!

Disclaimer -

SkepticalTheorist's post is SkepticalTheorist's own and should never be taken as scientific claim/s
Opinions stated in this post are SkepticalTheorist's own and not the views of any cited source unless specifically stated in writing and notarized by SkpeticalTheorist
This post is based on SkepticalTheorist's opinions and personal experience and a composite of many sources which SkepticalTheorist has no intention of citing so read at your own risk
All views stated should be viewed as artistic interpretation and not a strict interpretation of reality
The views, opinions, positions or strategies expressed by SkepticalTheorist and his comments are SkepticalTheorist's alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, positions or strategies of SkepticalTheorist, SkepticTheorist or any employee thereof. Makes no representations as to accuracy, completeness, correctness, suitability, or validity of any information on this post and will not be liable for any errors, omissions, or delays in this information or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use.
SkepticTheorist reserves the right to delete, edit, or alter in any manner SkepticalTheorist sees fit comments that SkepticalTheorist, in SkepticalTheorists sole discretion, deems to be obscene, offensive, defamatory, threatening, in violation of trademark, copyright or other laws, or is otherwise unacceptable.

<snip>
(my bold)

If so, then why are you posting here, in the SMMT section?

In particular, if you are not prepared to defend Mills' ideas at all, here, why post here?

(Comments on the rest of your great post later)
 
Much to discuss in this post; thanks!

(my bold)

If so, then why are you posting here, in the SMMT section?

In particular, if you are not prepared to defend Mills' ideas at all, here, why post here?

(Comments on the rest of your great post later)

Jesus Christ, have we been wasting our time on a *********** performance artist?
 
(Continued)
<snip>

https://www.google.com/search?q=sci...0j69i57j0l4.2712j0j8&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8

the intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment.
So, in your earlier post you were being, what, terse?

I would say Einstein's method is a lot like my method... I hadn't really realized that until thinking about it now. But I am a very visual person... and I absorb information constantly and visualize everything. Creativity is also a huge part of it. I have an endless amount of ideas and I test these in my mind like Einstein's thought experiments.
Interesting ... but it is not an answer to my question, is it?

The question again: what, in your opinion, is the definition of the scientific method?

“Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we now know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand.”

https://youtu.be/UKhg68QJlo0?t=2m41s

This is how Einstein thought too.

To learn more about this in relation to aspergers watch this video -

https://youtu.be/NyK5SG9rwWI?t=6m40s
Interesting, but kinda irrelevant, wouldn't you say?

After all, I asked for a definition ... (chain of logic, etc)

That's like saying any activity is studying nature. It's true but it would be considered the lowest form of science.

The more unique the study I would think the more important the scientific work.
Not sure I'm following you here ... per the definition (or perhaps it's something else?) your posted earlier, how can there be lower and higher forms of science?

Also, an exceedingly technical study of an obscure part of the anatomy of some rainforest bug would surely be rather unique, wouldn't you say? Not sure that alone would qualify it to be important :D
 
Someday you all are going to realize what you have done here. I doubt you will admit it to yourselves though.


Plural? Who all are included in this group of 'yourselves'?

Be that as it may, I am still waiting for you to support your accusations of things you said I did or claimed.

They weren't lies, were they?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom