Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

That would seem to be one logical - nitpicky? lawyerly? - conclusion ... :)

Performance art should be like the third act of a great date: Naked and weird. Anything else is anticlimactic.

If I want performance art I'll hunt up the good ones:
https://www.theguardian.com/artandd...s-vagina-paintings-performance-art-milo-moire


Mind, I can appreciate watching a train wreck. I'm an MST3K fan for crying out loud, a franchise all about mocking bad film, but inviting people to a showing of "Casablanca" and instead playing "Reptilicus," isn't art or a prank, it's just being a jerk.
 
It's an opinion. You could be lawerly and ignore that it is an opinion and nitpick it to death because of the wording. But then you turn a discussion into a hellish court debate.

Hello ST!
Again a language usage that is idiomatic to the ISF, any statement you make is a 'claim' and very often you will be asked to support it and demonstrate it. Now if you sate clearly 'this is my opinion' then that is less likely to be called out.

But again this is a discussion board where people argue about almost everything. So if you state 'it is my opinion that X are brainwashed', that will not be called out for lack of data. If you simply state 'X are brainwashed' then it is fair game on the ISF to ask for support for said statement.

Then there would likely be a discussion to define 'brainwashed'.

Welcome to the ISF!
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited for rule 6. Please put this link into your signature if you want your 'disclaimer' to be referenced in every post.


Have you considered your fellow posters might be responsible for that?

Also, I can assure you I won't be posting about it now so the point is moot. That bridge has been burned. I wish I could see the people who blew this opportunity when this info comes to light eventually..

:id:

Well had you presented your ideas and evidence that would have been more convincing.
 
Here's an analogy that might make the "skeptic" and "mainstream scientist" position more understandable.

I've invented a method of obtaining free apples, without having to grow them on trees. And it doesn't involve any complex biotechnology either. It's based on my discovery that what we think of as one apple—that is, an apple in its least possible discrete unary quantity state—is actually more than one apple in a state of superposition.

(But not quantum superposition. No Q word! Strictly classical!)

Our eyes, hands, and apple counting machines can't detect this hidden inherent plurality, but the right conditions and catalysts can cause the apple in its normal superimposed state to collapse into two or more apples (up to a theoretical maximum of 137). Each of the new apples is in a deeper unary state. Note that this is a change of quantity, not a change in mass, density, chemical composition, or any other significant measure (although, minor differences such as are normal between one apple and another do seem to occur). All of the un-superimposed apples are just as large, massive, delicious, and nutritious as the original(s).

To exploit this hitherto unknown property of apples, I've developed a series of prototype free-apple machines that convert apples into more apples. They're large opaque boxes in a variety of shapes and materials, but they all have an intake port at the top, a delivery port near the bottom, and a large crank on the side. You put in some number of apples, turn the crank, and after a slight delay and some funny noises, a greater number of apples comes out the bottom.

(As a note on terminology, "free apple machine" is not really an accurate description, as the machine does not actually create additional apples. As I've explained, it converts existing apples to actualize their previously undetectable but already inherent multiplicity, using a secret process. (Did I mention it's secret?) But people who don't know the secret operating principle which I refuse to reveal because it's secret persist in associating this technology with claimed methods of making apples appear from nothing, such as conjuring them out of hats or wishing for them from a genii, and as a result, the description has stuck. I understand the difference, so do not be misled.)

I've had several models of these machines independently verified by third parties. In one case, they reported that they observed eight apples coming out after seven were put in, for two trials each day for a 20-day period, after which the machine broke down and the test was declared a triumphant success. In another case, the apples multiplied ninefold, from five apples to forty-five, though in that run the stress of the transformation understandably caused the machine to break down immediately. Of course, the independent third parties were not permitted to examine the inner workings of any of the machines, in order to protect my trade secrets.

Closed-minded so-called skeptics have argued that what I am claiming is impossible, but their arguments are all based on mere mathematics. They have not studied and do not accept my superior mathematics that shows it is indeed possible. They cling to 1 + 1 = 2, even though it took Whitehead and Russell 378 pages of nearly incomprehensible and highly speculative mathematics to supposedly "prove" that dubious assertion. Today, first graders who dare to opine that three apples plus four apples equals eight apples, or that five apples equals forty-five apples, are ruthlessly suppressed and punished until they toe the party line. No wonder you doubt a priori that my free apple machines can possibly work, without even having done a thorough assessment of them (which I will under no circumstances permit you to do)!

Now, I know what you're thinking. "My gosh, if this principle works for apples, it should also work for gold bars, or barrels of oil, or Lamborghinis! You are the greatest scientific genius in the history of the world!" And my advanced math suggests that all of that is indeed the case, and the solution for all of the world's materials shortage problems is at hand, once I get around to revealing it. Maybe after I've perfected the free apple machine and sold one to every greengrocer in the world. I like apples.


Now, the point of the analogy, in case anyone missed it. To scientists and skeptics who are familiar with physics and its mathematical foundations, Mills' hydrino machines are not one iota more plausible than my free-apple machines, and for exactly the same reasons.
Bingo!:thumbsup::thumbsup:
 
"Spacetime tells matter how to move; matter tells spacetime how to curve."

The late great John Archibald Wheeler.

Yes, but, but. If I were a physicist, I'd be thinking this is incomplete. I'm wild guessing some further relation between matter/energy/quantum fields and spacetime that could use some rummaging about. Maaaybe something helping with early inflation and dark energy. If I were a physicist. (Yes, this is also an invitation to wax eloquent on how dumb saying any or all of that is, and showing some major chops to hammer the point... should the mood take one. Seems I have a thing for rampaging physicists in a huff, go figure.:o)
 
Why won't you backup your claim? Hypocrisy I have responded to this and you had no response.
Now I've responded too. Ha! You lose!



Do you guys realize you talk out of both sides of your mouths? You claim mainstream science is the be all end all then you show no faith in your own religion when it suits you.
Maybe you're wrong about your assertions here then?



I countered his claim with your own authority in Kaku.. I countered his own claim with his own source on D-K.

You guys make all the rules and don't follow them yourselves. You don't backup any of your own claims then say the opposition must backup their claims.

You are the epitome of bullies.

And you call yourselves skeptics.... You show the nature of your own dogma...

There is no greater example of D-K than someone accusing others of D-K and not even knowing what it means...! Even trying to refute their definition of D-K with a source that refutes their own claim and then pretending it never happened!

This is intellectual terrorism! This is a Jihad.
Oh, yeah. This little gem of trollery really increases the respect you've earned here. Or is that the opposite?

Guys! Guys! Help! My brainwashing is slipping!



Again, I warned you about debating an Aspie.

Some people never learn though... Darwin-kaku - in effect.
Yup. Macchu-Picchu Effect, in a nutshell folks. Whimsy-Baggins and Fairwhether-Trollope Syndrome thrown in for good measure.

Poor fellow.



To aspies arguing is like an art form... NTs - neurotypicals - are amateurs.

And you guys think I don't question my beliefs... aspies argue with themselves too. This is how we hone our arguing edge...
Sounds like you're way overcompensating for something. I bet in real life, you feel miserable, picked on, socially ostracized... so online, you try and hide how you feel about yourself, but it really shows through, dude.



Reality Check just got reality checked and he still ignores it.

Wow.. unbelievable.
I think you missed saying, BOOM! HEADSHOT! But in really, really large letters.



Well... I'm not going to. I am not going to be involved in this. I can't imagine a worse place for discussing important topics.
And when were you going to start discussing... anything?



I don't think you all realize what you are doing to your minds here. I find it funny so many have accused me of not questioning my beliefs...
Is this the extent of your schtick? Just trying to point to everyone else and how bad they are and how wonderful you are? How everyone else is wrong and you're the only one who "sees" it?



Also, I can assure you I won't be posting about it now so the point is moot. That bridge has been burned. I wish I could see the people who blew this opportunity when this info comes to light eventually..
You never even had any intention of telling anyone because you really have nothing at all. It's just a con to try and convince people of how "important" you are, probably because you feel that you're really unimportant in real life.


Trust me.. they will know.. I have given enough hints that when it comes out they will know. And it likely won't be pleasant by the time it comes out. I think people see the indications right now... I think people like you may be upset because you have painted yourself into a corner of disbelief and you can sense you were wrong now.
Yup. The old, "you'll be sorry you ignored/mocked/laughed at meeee!!!!" gambit. Only said by people who got nothin'.



No, I won't be here long. Unless people continue to harass me. Narcissists are amazing at finding ways to keep people in the quagmire with them.
It's funny how you're projecting with almost every "critique" of people here. You'll deny it, of course, but I know it's clear to everyone reading your posts.



Yeah, the whole 'I won't talk about it but won't stop talking about how and why I'm not talking about it' gets old fast. I guess that wasn't getting enough traction so then we get the assertions of narcissism in others from someone who apparently just can't stop talking about themselves and how important something is that they have found that they won't be talking about.
Yeah. As others have said, it's starting to become pretty boring.



Unless the person is hilariously, catastrophically wrong and refuses to present any evidence, choosing to instead hide behind conspiracy theories and their alleged Asperger's status. In which case they'll be handily defeated in the debate.

Asperger's is not a superpower and it certainly doesn't mean you're right or wrong any more or less often than anyone else.

Notice to fellow forum members: I have a lot of friends with Asperger's and I have NEVER heard ANY of them say something as daft about Asperger's as SkepticalTheorist's claim of being undefeatable in a debate.
I'm glad you said something because I think he's giving legitimate Asperger's sufferers a bad name.
 
I'm glad you said something because I think he's giving legitimate Asperger's sufferers a bad name.

He was essentially blaming his disingenuous conduct upon Asperger's. I want to make it crystal clear that, based upon the people with Asperger's I know, his behavior and attitude has NOTHING to do with Asperger's.

The closest I ever saw to anyone using Asperger's the way SkepticalTheorist is attempting was a friend who was a teacher studying human communication. She commented to me, privately, that she found her Asperger's useful in her field because it forced her into an "outsider's point of view" in studying communication. She also theorized that this might reduce the ethnocentric bias in her work.

She then ended, "But I could just be ********ting and not know it. That's why you publish, so people can call you on your ******** if you're wrong."
 
He was essentially blaming his disingenuous conduct upon Asperger's. I want to make it crystal clear that, based upon the people with Asperger's I know, his behavior and attitude has NOTHING to do with Asperger's.

The closest I ever saw to anyone using Asperger's the way SkepticalTheorist is attempting was a friend who was a teacher studying human communication. She commented to me, privately, that she found her Asperger's useful in her field because it forced her into an "outsider's point of view" in studying communication. She also theorized that this might reduce the ethnocentric bias in her work.

She then ended, "But I could just be ********ting and not know it. That's why you publish, so people can call you on your ******** if you're wrong."

See disclaimer in signature before reading post -

Arguing is a well known trait in young aspies especially. I was being a bit hyperbolic but there is definite truth to aspies and arguing.. look it up. We are good at arguing probably just from practice alone.. and an obsessive tendency. We know subjects better than anyone.. which is why Einstein said he was so successful..
 
Last edited:
Reality check's....
You should read what you write before you write what are ignorant insults. There is no such thing as the "Darwin-Kaku effect". There is the Dunning–Kruger effect which you misunderstand.
15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Fails to understand the Dunning–Kruger effect Wikipedia article.

You need to learn what confirmation bias is. We have been in debate for a few days and you think that you know what my "preexisting beliefs or hypotheses" about the Dunning–Kruger effect are :eek:?
FYI: My knowledge of the Dunning–Kruger effect comes mainly from the Wikipedia article and discussions of it in this and other forums. All that is needed is the ability to comprehend English
In the field of psychology, the Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias, wherein persons of low ability suffer from illusory superiority when they mistakenly assess their cognitive ability as greater than it is. The cognitive bias of illusory superiority derives from the metacognitive inability of low-ability persons to recognize their own ineptitude. Without the self-awareness of metacognition, low-ability people cannot objectively evaluate their actual competence or incompetence.[1]
 
Arguing is a well known trait in young aspies especially. I was being a bit hyperbolic but there is definite truth to aspies and arguing.. look it up. We are good at arguing probably just from practice alone.. and an obsessive tendency.

"Arguing," "Being Right," and "Winning an argument" do not necessarily correlate, especially when one is as consistently wrong as you are. I suspect, however you count people losing interest in the discussion because you keep repeating the same ignorant nonsense to be a "victory."

We know subjects better than anyone..

Based on your performance here, I'm going to say you're flat out wrong on that claim, assuming you even HAVE Asperger's, which I doubt.

which is why Einstein said he was so successful..

If you actually read about the man's life instead of just projecting your fantasies onto him you'd see his successes had to do with a lot more than a theoretical mild case of Asperger's.

Besides, after your confession that this is all just an act for you, I have no reason to believe you when you claim to have Asperger's. Given your behavior, I'm starting to suspect that there's someone you know with Asperger's whom you're trying to cruelly and viciously mock with your behavior here.
 
Besides, after your confession that this is all just an act for you, I have no reason to believe you when you claim to have Asperger's. Given your behavior, I'm starting to suspect that there's someone you know with Asperger's whom you're trying to cruelly and viciously mock with your behavior here.

Please read my disclaimer in my signature before reading my post -

I said that to avoid skeptics gimmicky tactic of bogging people down in rhetoric. Some skeptics want to play like a lawyer so then I have to use lawerly tactics in return. Skeptics started this game.. then they whine about it.
 
He was essentially blaming his disingenuous conduct upon Asperger's. I want to make it crystal clear that, based upon the people with Asperger's I know, his behavior and attitude has NOTHING to do with Asperger's.

The closest I ever saw to anyone using Asperger's the way SkepticalTheorist is attempting was a friend who was a teacher studying human communication. She commented to me, privately, that she found her Asperger's useful in her field because it forced her into an "outsider's point of view" in studying communication. She also theorized that this might reduce the ethnocentric bias in her work.

She then ended, "But I could just be ********ting and not know it. That's why you publish, so people can call you on your ******** if you're wrong."
Interesting, thanks.

You know, I totally get the desire to turn supposedly negative traits into positive ones, but I think that's based on a mis-apprehension some have of what are those traits in question. I have certain physical disabilities and I call them such; I am not as able in some respects as normal, healthy individuals. I don't, however, go around crowing about how smart I am just because I can't run across the yard. I don't feel the need to "compensate" for anything. I think it's a sign of maturity and dignity; acceptance of who I am includes my abilities and sometimes lack thereof.

And I personally also don't care a whit about a person's age, gender, politics, or anything in order for me to learn from them. Just facts. Hell, I still learn from my daughter all the time; she's now twenty-one, but even when she was a toddler and child and teen, I could learn. Were that some trait that others could share...



See disclaimer in signature before reading post -

Arguing is a well known trait in young aspies especially. I was being a bit hyperbolic but there is definite truth to aspies and arguing.. look it up. We are good at arguing probably just from practice alone.. and an obsessive tendency. We know subjects better than anyone.. which is why Einstein said he was so successful..
It's really kind of bizarre how Einstein is such a Heroic figure for so many fringe thinkers.



Why do you say "read" specifically?
Well, okay... when was the last time you and Einstein had lunch together and talked over family matters?


I said that to avoid skeptics gimmicky tactic of bogging people down in rhetoric. Some skeptics want to play like a lawyer so then I have to use lawerly tactics in return. Skeptics started this game.. then they whine about it.
Again, you're the only one whining about it. You're the one standing in the rain; it's not our fault you're getting wet. And here, the umbrella you could use is spelled, e-v-i-d-e-n-c-e.
 
Please read my disclaimer in my signature before reading my post
You did not present any evidence to support your claims since the thread began. Now the "disclaimer" added in the last day says you will post only opinions from now and apparently never support them with any evidence.

When talking about science, even an opinion needs evidence to support it. An opinion is a belief formed by the evidence that you have collected. Otherwise what you write is a personal anecdote, fairy story, fantasy, religion, dogma, etc.
An opinion that the Sun orbits the Earth is a fantasy unless you have evidence.
An opinion that the Earth orbits the Sun is a fantasy unless you have evidence (easy to provide - cite Wikipedia!).

Your existing claims and miscomprehension:
  1. 15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: List the posts where I used argument from authority.
  2. 15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Fails to understand the Dunning–Kruger effect Wikipedia article.
  3. 15 June 2017: A documented case of moving the goalposts or ignorance of what you have posted over the last couple of days, etc.
  4. 14 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your evidence that the universe is infinite (the probable answer is there is none).
  5. 14 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Give your sources for "observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited".
  6. 13 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your evidence that "our gravity model" (GR) has been shown to be false.
    GR is not MOND.
  7. 13 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your sources stating that his father considered Albert Einstein a failure.
    It is not a long video with no historian cited.
    It is not a book on the scientific discoveries of Albert Einstein that you have not read (no quote)
    Part 2 on the book
P.S. I listened to the Albert Einstein Documentary video to past Hermann Einstein's death in 1902 and no mention of him being disappointed in Albert. There is Albert being disappointed in himself.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom