Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

John Jones Johnson is right. Not only was it authentic frontier gibberish, but it expressed a courage that is little seen in this day and age.

And I'm particularly glad that these children were here to hear it.
 
Your technique hasn't improved with your absence.

Now, really concentrate this time. Why do you think (here's your chance to do so) that people compare the various gods that humans have created to The Flying Spaghetti Monster?

If you can work that one out Yrreg,then you will be enlightened.
 
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

What do you guys say?

I find this interesting but to be sure you must give five examples, each in no more than 329 words and no less than 327.

At least three of the five examples must include cats.

Once you have done this, we will be ready to move on with the discussion in further threads.
 
Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

What do you guys say?


This is an absolutely terrible definition of evidence. Why? It presupposes that something has been proven. It presupposes that someone can "know" something true. Neither is necessarily true.

Imagine if your definition of evidence was acceptable in a Court.

"Officer, who killed that girl?"
- "Well, I know the killer drove a red car. The defendant drives a red car. So, I know that the defendant killed her."

At least one of the many, many problems is that your definition doesn't account for how knowing one fact might lead to knowing another. What level of certainty must there be? What process must occur? You've just yada-yada-ed right over it.

In the other thread, I had talked to you about scientific evidence being repeatable, valid experiments of a falsifiable hypothesis.

It seems to me quite obvious why you prefer your definition to mine. Your definition doesn't require any fact checking. It doesn't require any testing. And it doesn't even allow someone to disagree with you. It's all an automatic process that takes place entirely within your own mind.

Sadly, this is the exact opposite of the definition of evidence - ensuring that a belief is in accord with the observable world.

I had also previously commented that your entire proof of God in all of your other threads consisted of little more than saying that God's existence is obvious to anyone who thinks about it. Now you propose a definition of evidence that allows you to make that argument.

It's just wrong.
 


Gerry doesn't have schizophasia. He's able to stay on topic during a conversation and from one conversation to the next. He doesn't have an affinity for alliteration.

He uses language to try to appear smarter than he is, both to others and to himself. He's a narcisist. His ego is in pieces. He appears to be in a state of constant war with some sort of authority figure that he has to shout down. He may have some form of psychosis. But he's not schizophrenic.


Still, give Yrreg credit. His definition for evidence is not self-referentia


I believe it is. He defines evidence as knowledge which, by deduction, begets other knowledge. But he doesn't define how the first bit of knowledge was obtained. Either the whole thing regresses to nothing, or eventually one needs yet another definition of evidence that allows us to collect the first bit.


Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.


Your example is wrong, you know. The importance of breathing was poorly understood long, long after the observation was made that we all have noses.
 
Here is my example of the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe,

the nose in man's face.​

That is just one example representing one kind of evidence but it illustrates perfectly the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe as:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​


Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.


Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.

Simple.


Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?



Yrreg

Not Okay! Gibberish!


English good! Gibberish bad. Jones talk like Frankenstein Monster so Yrreg understand! Aarrgghh!
 
Here you are Yrreg,
Here is my example of the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe,


the nose in man's face.​

That is just one example representing one kind of evidence but it illustrates perfectly the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe as:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​


Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.


Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.

Simple.


Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?




Yrreg
Here Yrreg,I arranged it so that it makes a bit more sense. No need to thank me.

Explanation:Nose is an existing objective reality leading him to know. Man knowing the fundamental concept leading him to know example of of evidence for man in relation to the universe, wherefore it leads him to know. Here is my example representing an object thing, the nose in man's face. His nose leads him to know the fundamental concept as a concept. Anything man knows another thing. Man knows existence that is just one one kind of evidence of his nose relation to the universe as a process thing. The of evidence for man in breathing in another living thing can be a piece of evidence but it illustrates perfectly what he does with it. Anything at all that exists about breathing or in man's mind and in a living thing in leading him to know another thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face. Breathing is an existing thing,
Simple lesson:

Okay?
Yrreg
 
Last edited:
Not Okay! Gibberish!


English good! Gibberish bad. Jones talk like Frankenstein Monster so Yrreg understand! Aarrgghh!

They has International Talk Like Pirate Day. Why not have talk Like Yrreg Day? Fun,lots of.
 
I believe it is. He defines evidence as knowledge which, by deduction, begets other knowledge. But he doesn't define how the first bit of knowledge was obtained. Either the whole thing regresses to nothing, or eventually one needs yet another definition of evidence that allows us to collect the first bit.


I hadn't thought of it as begging the question. You might be right...





And Yrreg: Be careful!
You are slipping back into your self-superior condescension. It has gotten you suspended before (more than once). Please don't let that happen again.
 
They has International Talk Like Pirate Day. Why not have talk Like Yrreg Day? Fun,lots of.


Did you hear the one about the Three Pirates playing Wheel of Fortune?

Bluebeard, pick a letter

"Arrr!"

Oh, Sorry Bluebeard, that letter is already taken. Blackbeard, pick a letter.

"Arrr!"

No. that letter is taken. You lose a turn. Yellowbeard, pick a letter

"Arrr!"
 
Last edited:
Read below the texts in bold.
Here is my example of the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe,

the nose in man's face.​

That is just one example representing one kind of evidence but it illustrates perfectly the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe as:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​


Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.


Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.

Simple.


Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?




Yrreg


Spaghetti exists in objective reality, yes.

Flying spaghetti monster exists in objective reality, no.

But from spaghetti in objective reality you can contrive a concept of a flying spaghetti monster.
Indeed. And according to the highlighted portion of your own statement, that would now be evidence.
Then you can go forth with that concept as a blueprint and make a spaghetti that is flying and is a monster.

And that very product from you is itself the evidence of a flying spaghetti monster in objective reality -- if and when you do fabricate one as to exist in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in your mind.
Totally unnecessary, according to your own parameters.

You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!
Oh, dear, you aren't wanting a holiday from this place already, are you?
 
You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!




Yrreg

Once again the arrogance appears
 
I have no idea why anyone responds to Yrreg with anything other than scorn or humour. He isn't interested in any thoughts or ideas other than his own. if you don't give him the answer he wants he will ignore you. if you try to counter his argument with logic and intelligence he will accuse you of being unable to think for yourselves.

He isn't interested in anything but hearing his own ideas echoed back to him. To Yrreg only his ideas are right, and anything else is stupid.

He can't be reasoned with, he can't be bargained with, he doesn't feel pity, or remorse, or fea....., no, hang on, that was the terminator. But the point still stands, he absolutely will not stop, ever, until you all agree with him.
 
I have no idea why anyone responds to Yrreg with anything other than scorn or humour. He isn't interested in any thoughts or ideas other than his own. if you don't give him the answer he wants he will ignore you. if you try to counter his argument with logic and intelligence he will accuse you of being unable to think for yourselves.

He isn't interested in anything but hearing his own ideas echoed back to him. To Yrreg only his ideas are right, and anything else is stupid.

He can't be reasoned with, he can't be bargained with, he doesn't feel pity, or remorse, or fea....., no, hang on, that was the terminator. But the point still stands, he absolutely will not stop, ever, until you all agree with him.

Not entirely true. yrreg used to have a definition of God as "the maker of everything". However, he has changed that. It now is if I recall correctly "the maker of everything that is not God Himself".

:p
 
I have no idea why anyone responds to Yrreg with anything other than scorn or humour. He isn't interested in any thoughts or ideas other than his own. if you don't give him the answer he wants he will ignore you. if you try to counter his argument with logic and intelligence he will accuse you of being unable to think for yourselves.

He isn't interested in anything but hearing his own ideas echoed back to him. To Yrreg only his ideas are right, and anything else is stupid.

He can't be reasoned with, he can't be bargained with, he doesn't feel pity, or remorse, or fea....., no, hang on, that was the terminator. But the point still stands, he absolutely will not stop, ever, until you all agree with him.

And you can rearrange the words of his posts in any order and they make just as much sense.
 
Not entirely true. yrreg used to have a definition of God as "the maker of everything". However, he has changed that. It now is if I recall correctly "the maker of everything that is not God Himself".

:p

As I said before,the bible thumper at my school told us that god is everywhere and in everything therefore there is nothing that is not god. Can't these Christians agree on anything?
 
Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.



Yrreg

Can I get an amen!!!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom