Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Actual lesson . . .

Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept fantasy can be a piece of evidence fantasy leading him to know believe another thing fantasy.

Okay?

Yrreg

Okay?
 
Last edited:
Here is my example of the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe,

the nose in man's face.​
Haven't we done this one before?

That is just one example representing one kind of evidence but it illustrates perfectly the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe as:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​
We've done this before, too. You were shown to have misunderstood and misused the term "know" when you meant "believe".

Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.
So because I eat pasta, the Flying Spaghetti Monster is real?

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.
Pasta is an existing thing, an object thing; Flying is a process thing. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is real!

Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.
Man eating pasta leads him to know the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

Or, as you say:
Simple is as simple believes.

Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?




Yrreg

Okay! You've proved the Flying Spaghetti Monster exists!

Do you see any problems with misusing the word "know" when you mean "believe"?
 
You guys are impervious to genuine thinking, but to regurgitation of rancid slogans.

[...]

Pasta is an existing thing, an object thing; Flying is a process thing. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is real!


Man eating pasta leads him to know the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

[...]



Read below the texts in bold.
Here is my example of the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe,

the nose in man's face.​

That is just one example representing one kind of evidence but it illustrates perfectly the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe as:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​


Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.


Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.

Simple.


Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?

Spaghetti exists in objective reality, yes.

Flying spaghetti monster exists in objective reality, no.

But from spaghetti in objective reality you can contrive a concept of a flying spaghetti monster.

Then you can go forth with that concept as a blueprint and make a spaghetti that is flying and is a monster.

And that very product from you is itself the evidence of a flying spaghetti monster in objective reality -- if and when you do fabricate one as to exist in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in your mind.



You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!




Yrreg
 
Read below the texts in bold.


Spaghetti exists in objective reality, yes.

Flying spaghetti monster exists in objective reality, no.

But from spaghetti in objective reality you can contrive a concept of a flying spaghetti monster.

Then you can go forth with that concept as a blueprint and make a spaghetti that is flying and is a monster.

And that very product from you is itself the evidence of a flying spaghetti monster in objective reality -- if and when you do fabricate one as to exist in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in your mind.



You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!




Yrreg

It sounds as if you are saying that god concepts are simply mental constructs from imagination and they don't really exist. Is that correct?
 
yrreg said:
Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.


Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.
This is frequently true. In geology it's called Uniformitarianism--The present is the key to the past. In this specfic example, you're talking about comparative morphology, a subject near and dear to the heart of any paleontologist. However, there is a serious problem with this concept: it only provides you with correlations, NOT causal connections. What this means is that the conclusions drawn from this sort of thing are frequently wrong. For example, goats can climb trees.

Let's use your example, and this little mucrospirifer, an ubiquitous fossil from the Silica Shale of southern Ohio (in fact, I may actually know that fossil--it, and the paper towel it's on, look startilingly familiar). Man A knows that he has a nose. He knows that his nose is used for breathing. Looking at the fossil, it's obvious that this organism does NOT have a nose--therefore, it can't breath!

In reality, brachiopods "breath" (it's really not comperable with the active respiration mammals, reptiles, etc engage in) through a structure called a lophophore, something which is completely different from any other anatomical structure. It's described as gill-like, but as gills aren't used in feeding this is not correct.

When you get further outside the area you have experience with, it gets even wose.

Much worse.

And even if it's NOT completely outside your experience, you can easily be duped.

Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?
The lesson paleontology teaches us on this specific point (not that other fields dont' as well, just that all of my examples have been dead things, so I'm sticking with the theme) is that we are VERY easily fooled, and that those bits of objective reality and mental concepts can come together in ways that don't even come close to resembling reality. You're missing a few things here.

Edit 1: All links are to Wikipedia, for the purpose of showing the pretty pictures. If you want to know the details, I suggest "Wonderful Life", but S. J. Gould.

Edit 2:
You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!
Just to pre-empt you saying something this rediculous to me: I'm not rejecting your statement because I've ingested a slogan. I'm rejecting it because I've proven to my satisfaction that it DOES NOT WORK. Again, you're missing some key steps, steps which anyone with a good understanding of basic science should have learned in high school, if not earlier. I don't mean that to be insulting--it's just that I know the education standards in the USA, at least, and legally you were required to be taught this stuff by, at the latest, high school.
 
Last edited:
You talk too much from too much useless learning without genuine thinking.

This is frequently true. In geology it's called Uniformitarianism...

[...]




See? You don't know the distinction between evidence and proof.



Yrreg
 
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.
This is so vague See my prior post in this thread, where I predicted you would say that the moon in the sky (part of "anything") would lead you to believe in your god ("another thing"). You used the moon argument before, just as you used the nose argument and the penis argument.

You really went there again and thought you were being clever.

Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.
This is just so preschool. A nose is not evidence of breathing. If I see somebody that has a reconstructed nose, I may not know that it doesn't function as a breathing apparatus for that person. Other people have conditions which make nose breathing impossible. A nose is evidence of a nose. Unless I'm up close and personal, I have no idea whether that person uses it for breathing any more than I know that they use it for the ingestion of cocaine.

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.
Breathing is not an "existing thing." You are the only person on the planet who may call breathing a thing. This is another example of why your definition of evidence is utterly worthless. You can claim that anything is a thing.

Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.

Simple.
So simple that it's wrong. Not everybody with a nose is able to breathe through it. And not everybody with a nose is aware that it's commonly used for breathing.

Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?
Not okay. Not one person here has agreed with your definition, because it says absolutely nothing about what evidence is. Basically you want to say that anything you see that leads you to anything you can think of (e.g. God) is somehow evidence of that thing. It isn't.
 
See? You don't know the distinction between evidence and proof.
::facepalm

All right, you obviously don't want to talk about anything at any depth. Have fun without me.
 
Try to work on where and how do concepts in the mind of man come from?

Originally Posted by yrreg

Read below the texts in bold.
Spaghetti exists in objective reality, yes.

Flying spaghetti monster exists in objective reality, no.

But from spaghetti in objective reality you can contrive a concept of a flying spaghetti monster.

Then you can go forth with that concept as a blueprint and make a spaghetti that is flying and is a monster.

And that very product from you is itself the evidence of a flying spaghetti monster in objective reality -- if and when you do fabricate one as to exist in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in your mind.


You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!​


It sounds as if you are saying that god concepts are simply mental constructs from imagination and they don't really exist. Is that correct?



Try to work on where and how do concepts in the mind of man come from?

That requires genuine true solid pure thinking, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.



Yrreg
 
Try to work on where and how do concepts in the mind of man come from?

That requires genuine true solid pure thinking, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

Yrreg
(switches on “true solid pure thinking” mode) - Well there’s no credible evidence it comes from any form of invisible, magical sky-daddy as there‘s no credible evidence that such a thing even exists.

So in your “true solid pure thinking” mode where do you say “where and how do concepts in the mind of man come from“?

An answer would be appreciated but one is not anticipated to be provided.
 
Last edited:
Read below the texts in bold.


Spaghetti exists in objective reality, yes.

Flying spaghetti monster exists in objective reality, no.

But from spaghetti in objective reality you can contrive a concept of a flying spaghetti monster.

Then you can go forth with that concept as a blueprint and make a spaghetti that is flying and is a monster.

And that very product from you is itself the evidence of a flying spaghetti monster in objective reality -- if and when you do fabricate one as to exist in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in your mind.



You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!




Yrreg

So anything you can imagine is evidence? That is not how it works in the real world.
 
Try to work on where and how do concepts in the mind of man come from?

That requires genuine true solid pure thinking, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.



Yrreg

Is that your new catch phrase,rancid slogans? None of us have used a slogan yet in this thread. Try looking the word up in a dictionary.
 
Try to work on where and how do concepts in the mind of man come from?

That requires genuine true solid pure thinking, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.



Yrreg

If you were serious about this question you would cease the name-calling and establish a rational basis for the discussion to take place.

In the other thread that you appear to have abandoned, you were given a set of specifications upon which such a discussion could reasonably progress.

You are yet to achieve even one of them. You do not appear to be ready to undertake the task you have set yourself: if you are unable to comprehend your basis for discussion, how can we?
 
Try to work on where and how do concepts in the mind of man come from?

That requires genuine true solid pure thinking, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.



Yrreg

Your technique hasn't improved with your absence.

Now, really concentrate this time. Why do you think (here's your chance to do so) that people compare the various gods that humans have created to The Flying Spaghetti Monster?
 
It sounds like declaring truth by fiat rather than based on evidence is how you operate yrreg
 
It sounds like declaring truth by fiat rather than based on evidence is how you operate yrreg

It's more akin to him demanding that we prove an answer to a question he hasn't yet figured out.

I thought in the previous post he may have been genuine but struggling with the English language, but he's been avoiding any effort to set a basis for the discussion except for "do what I say".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom