yrreg said:
Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.
Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.
Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.
This is frequently true. In geology it's called Uniformitarianism--The present is the key to the past. In this specfic example, you're talking about comparative morphology, a subject near and dear to the heart of any paleontologist. However, there is a serious problem with this concept: it only provides you with correlations, NOT causal connections. What this means is that the conclusions drawn from this sort of thing are frequently wrong. For example, goats can climb trees.
Let's use your example, and
this little mucrospirifer, an ubiquitous fossil from the Silica Shale of southern Ohio (in fact, I may actually know that fossil--it, and the paper towel it's on, look startilingly familiar). Man A knows that he has a nose. He knows that his nose is used for breathing. Looking at the fossil, it's obvious that this organism does NOT have a nose--therefore, it can't breath!
In reality, brachiopods "breath" (it's really not comperable with the active respiration mammals, reptiles, etc engage in) through a structure called a lophophore, something which is completely different from any other anatomical structure. It's described as gill-like, but as gills aren't used in feeding this is not correct.
When you get further outside the area you have experience with, it gets even wose.
Much worse.
And even if it's NOT completely outside your experience, you can easily be duped.
Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.
Okay?
The lesson paleontology teaches us on this specific point (not that other fields dont' as well, just that all of my examples have been dead things, so I'm sticking with the theme) is that we are VERY easily fooled, and that those bits of objective reality and mental concepts can come together in ways that don't even come close to resembling reality. You're missing a few things here.
Edit 1: All links are to Wikipedia, for the purpose of showing the pretty pictures. If you want to know the details, I suggest "Wonderful Life", but S. J. Gould.
Edit 2:
You guys are not accustomed to genuine thinking, but only to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.
So, when you find yourselves outside your ingested but not digested slogans, you are lost!
Just to pre-empt you saying something this rediculous to me: I'm not rejecting your statement because I've ingested a slogan. I'm rejecting it because I've proven to my satisfaction that it DOES NOT WORK. Again, you're missing some key steps, steps which anyone with a good understanding of basic science should have learned in high school, if not earlier. I don't mean that to be insulting--it's just that I know the education standards in the USA, at least, and legally you were required to be taught this stuff by, at the latest, high school.