Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Prayer and God are beyond science, because science is from God

Unfounded assertion.

so you can't test God with his science

Non-sequitur from an unfounded assertion, is that a fallacy2?

you can only ask God for proof of his works through prayer which he judges to show personally.

Another unfounded assertion.

Doesn't look good for your case, edge...
 
This thread is not about proving God's existence.

Originally Posted by yrreg
I am trying to lay the foundation for the proof of God's existence.

Atheists don't want people to come to the proof of the existence of God, so it is to their interest to not cooperate in the laying of the foundation for the proof of God's existence.

So, dear readers, they will go into everything except contribute something positive toward the building of the foundation for the proof of the existence of God.

​


I have offered you a way to do this twice now. Both times you have ignored it.

You don't seem to want to know how to prove your god exists.



This thread is not about proving God's existence.


But about laying the foundation for the proof of God's existence, by setting up the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

And also setting up the fundamental concept of universe in relation to the universe from astrophysicists of the Big Bang theory, namely:

The totality of material existence that started with the Big Bang.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7275520&postcount=209​

I am inviting atheists who insist on evidence and proof to give their fundamental concept for evidence as for proof in not more than 20 words each, and then also 5 examples of each in not more than 100 words each.

You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.



Yrreg
 
This thread is not about proving God's existence.


But about laying the foundation for the proof of God's existence, by setting up the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith
.....Really? [eta] See post #245 [/eta]

I am inviting atheists who insist on evidence and proof to give their fundamental concept for evidence as for proof in not more than 20 words each, and then also 5 examples of each in not more than 100 words each.
Been done already, and on this thread.
You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.

You just said the same thing as above on that one.
 
Last edited:
'Focused energy' in prayer. What type of energy ( kinetic,potential.etc.) and how do you you focus it by talking to yourself?
Just by thinking. Just by focus. Talking has nothing to do with it?

Please explain the "scientific roots" of that.
Quantum physics.
Prayer and God are beyond science, because science is from God so you can't test God with his science you can only ask God for proof of his works through prayer which he judges to show personally.
Load of phooey. See Conjecture thread

Please explain how you mean it, does thought focus, what exactly?

You mean the reklease of ATP by organelles?

I don't know what either of those are? I'm mainly providing semi-unfounded assertions as to why I have that opinion, so asking me to prove it is going to be moot. :boxedin:
 
This thread is not about proving God's existence.


But about laying the foundation for the proof of God's existence, by setting up the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Hold it right there Gerry! You're attempting to move the goalposts again. If this thread is not about proving God's existence, then your OP makes the assumption of this god's existence to already exist. That is the thing you or other theists haven't proved, yet this is what we have been asking you to do. This tendency to ignore people with legitimate questions is the usual step you take on all your threads...It's predictable. Please respond to post #214
 
Larechar said:
'Focused energy' in prayer. What type of energy ( kinetic,potential.etc.) and how do you you focus it by talking to yourself?
Just by thinking. Just by focus. Talking has nothing to do with it?
Be specific. What energy are you "focusing" just by thinking about it?

Larechar said:
Please explain the "scientific roots" of that.
Quantum physics.
OK. I assume that if I asked you how that works, you would start spouting off some gibberish about observer effects in quantum mechanics. To pre-emptively burst your bubble, quantum mechanics does not work the way you think it does.

Larechar said:
Please explain how you mean it, does thought focus, what exactly?

You mean the reklease of ATP by organelles?

I don't know what either of those are? I'm mainly providing semi-unfounded assertions as to why I have that opinion, so asking me to prove it is going to be moot. :boxedin:
Well, maybe you will learn something from this thread. Stranger things have happened in a yyreg thread.
 
Hold it right there Gerry! You're attempting to move the goalposts again. If this thread is not about proving God's existence, then your OP makes the assumption of this god's existence to already exist.


I don't think that's necessarily the only way to interpret it. He appears to be offering a definition of God for the purpose of putting it to proof. Now, in defining the God he wants to prove, he has been absolutely unyielding. He has repeated many times exactly what definition of God he'd like to test.

He did say that he believes that God to exist. He also said that such a definition was a necessary part of whatever total definition of God that Christians have. But he has not yet asked us to assume that such a God exists. So far, all he's asked is that we assume that his definition is perfect.

I have no problem with this from a scientific perspective. He is offering a hypothesis up for testing.

His next step is to actually propose a test.

Here, he seems stuck. He refuses to acknowledge that "proof" is an indeterminate concept that can change upon usage. He mentioned proof to a scientific certainty once, then he backed off of it.

He wants us to give him different definitions of proof - either because he can't really think of any; or because he wants to cherry pick the one he thinks he can satisfy.

For my part, I have several times stated that, from a scientific perspective:

Proof is the aggregation of positive results in reliable, repeatable and valid experimentation where a negative result would be inconsistent with a falsifiable hypothesis.

Evidence is a positive result in a reliable, repeatable and valid experiment where a negative result would be inconsistent with a falsifiable hypothesis.

Evidence of the theory of gravity might be that a feather and a lead weight fall at the same time in a vacuum.

Proof of the theory of gravity might be that such experiment never leads to any different result.

etc.
 
Be specific. What energy are you "focusing" just by thinking about it?


OK. I assume that if I asked you how that works, you would start spouting off some gibberish about observer effects in quantum mechanics. To pre-emptively burst your bubble, quantum mechanics does not work the way you think it does.
Observer effects wouldn't translate as thought effects, in my mind. I was referring to the experiment of the Random Number Generator.

Well, maybe you will learn something from this thread. Stranger things have happened in a yyreg thread.

I don't doubt it! Maybe you can clear it up for me.
 
I don't think that's necessarily the only way to interpret it. He appears to be offering a definition of God for the purpose of putting it to proof. Now, in defining the God he wants to prove, he has been absolutely unyielding. He has repeated many times exactly what definition of God he'd like to test.

He did say that he believes that God to exist. He also said that such a definition was a necessary part of whatever total definition of God that Christians have. But he has not yet asked us to assume that such a God exists. So far, all he's asked is that we assume that his definition is perfect.

I have no problem with this from a scientific perspective. He is offering a hypothesis up for testing.

His next step is to actually propose a test.

Here, he seems stuck. He refuses to acknowledge that "proof" is an indeterminate concept that can change upon usage. He mentioned proof to a scientific certainty once, then he backed off of it.

He wants us to give him different definitions of proof - either because he can't really think of any; or because he wants to cherry pick the one he thinks he can satisfy.

Gerry's belief in God is a given, no doubt about it. When I say he's moving the goalposts, Gerry is trying to steer the direction into a box he would rather take from than answer really tough questions. Like you say; Cherry picking or just change his direction onto something else with an incredible amount of total word salad and then placing the blame on atheists for being shallow unbelievers, corrupted in our perspective. This is when frustration gets the best of him and the subsequent reaction. We'll see if the pattern continues.
 
Last edited:
You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.
I challenge you to diagram that sentence.
 
You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.
I challenge you to diagram that sentence.

You can contribute
Good, we're making progress.

from your part
There goes our progress.

as I presume as an atheist
He assumes you're an atheist who...

of the insistence attitude
...continues to have the attitude of...

that God must be proven to exist
...requiring proof and not assertions...

from evidence
...based on verifiable and not falsifiable claims...

contribute namely
...[nitpick]redundantly[/nitpick]primarily...

by giving your concepts and your examples
...by telling him what, "your," definition of...

on evidence as on proof.
...evidence and proof.

So, it could probably be restructured to say, "You can contribute, Atheists, who continue to require proof and not falsifiable claims, can contribute primarily by telling me your definition of evidence, as well as proof." ;)
 
I have myself considered an "idiot god" who's sole talent is the causation of "bang" events.
No planning, no design... Just, "Ooooh, pretty!"

This notion of a God that exists outside of the universe neatly avoids falsification. No evidence is available, and it could not be observed.
That is in fact the position a number of Christian apologists have taken of late. Instead of the anthromorphic God of the Old Testament, we get a nebulous god very much similar to the Hindu idea.... Totally devoid of any characteristics humans could appreciate.

This seems like nothing more than a logic trick to me.... "There! Disprove that!"


God moves a lot always changing his address. Every time you think you know where he is he moves his house to a new neighborhood and never leaves a forwarding address. This is what believers for the last 2000 years are implying. Go back to the OT and god was in the sky....somewhere....up there just beyond visible range. The farther our technology allowed us to see he just kept moving. Now? Well hes outside of the known universe in perhaps even another dimension...or something. Occasionally he sends telepathic messages to his followers about the end of the world and other such important events but theres too much static on the line to get a clear date.
 
I challenge you to diagram that sentence.

You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.


Subject Verb Object Nothing, really Dependent clause modifying "contribute"


The middle part defines the word "you," which is an odd thing to do after you've already sailed past the verb and the object. Properly written, it might be:

Presuming you are an atheist who insists that God must be proven to exist through evidence, you can contribute by setting out your definition of "evidence" and "proof".

It's sad because I've done so at least three times already in this thread.
 
Last edited:
You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.


Subject Verb Object Nothing, really Dependent clause modifying "contribute"


The middle part defines the word "you," which is an odd thing to do after you've already sailed past the verb and the object. Properly written, it might be:

Presuming you are an atheist who insists that God must be proven to exist through evidence, you can contribute by setting out your definition of "evidence" and "proof".

It's sad because I've done so at least three times already in this thread.
Yeah, but they're not the definitions Yrreg wants to hear, because he can't use them in his "proof".
 
You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.


Subject Verb Object Nothing, really Dependent clause modifying "contribute"


The middle part defines the word "you," which is an odd thing to do after you've already sailed past the verb and the object. Properly written, it might be:

Presuming you are an atheist who insists that God must be proven to exist through evidence, you can contribute by setting out your definition of "evidence" and "proof".

It's sad because I've done so at least three times already in this thread.

Gerry is happy you accepted the concept of the Christian God. Now he believes your conclusion can be just like his by pure reason in this manner:

In the meantime you can read the works of atheists who seek to prove the non-existence of God, to find out whether they do have in regard to the Christian God, the fundamental concept of God etc.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom