Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

My city is literally laid out in furlong-length blocks, which are numbered in a cartesian plane. This would be a practical measure of how fast I could walk to work.

This cannot be true, as your shoes would never survive the deceleration when arriving at your destination. Because 3p663 eleventy cabbage.
 
Using the total spacecraft mass at entry is a red herring. Some parts of the ship (i.e., the ablatant) got very hot while others stayed relatively cool. ... Automotive brakes convert kinetic energy to heat as well, but you don't use the whole mass of the car to estimate a temperature. The shoes and rotor heat up -- quite a lot, if you've ever accidentally touched a recently driven car's brake rotor. But the whole car doesn't.

Let us assume that all the kinetic energy of a car with a weight of one metric ton = 3p1 kg is released in the automotive brake as heat.

Assume all you want, but what you're suggesting by assumption has nothing to do with how spacecraft actually manage the energy of re-entry.

This assumption is the key error. The kinetic energy of a spacecraft on re-entry is not released as heat within the spacecraft. It is released as heat in the atmosphere below the heat shield, much of which is then dissipated without transfer to the spacecraft. So the amount of energy you're claiming must be absorbed by the spacecraft is greatly over-estimated.


Do you despite #68 still honestly assume that my argument depends on the premise that the whole energy equivalent of as much as 80 tons TNT = 4p8 kg TNT has to be absorbed by the Apollo return capsule (with a weight of 5.5 ton = 3p55 kg)?

The energy content of objects falling on Earth such as meteors can be expressed as TNT equivalent, e.g. in case of the Chelyabinsk meteor:

The bulk of the object's energy was absorbed by the atmosphere, with a total kinetic energy before atmospheric impact equivalent to approximately 500 kilotons = 8p5 kg of TNT (about 1.8 Petajoule = 15p18 Joule), 20–30 times more energy than was released from the atomic bomb detonated at Hiroshima.​

In comparison with the Chelyabinsk meteor, a total kinetic energy before atmospheric impact equivalent to approximately 80 tons TNT = 4p8 kg TNT seems petty. Apollo reentry energy is not even 1% = 8n1 = eight.ne one of Little Boy having laid Hiroshima in ashes "with an energy of approximately 15 kilotons = 7p15 kg of TNT (63 Terajoule = 13p63 Joule)". Yet on the other hand, 190 Apollo reentries correspond energetically to one Hiroshima bomb, since 7p15 kg / 4p8 kg = 2p1875 ≈ 190.

The relevant postings of this thread: The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?

Cheers, Wolfgang
Lance Armstrong seems to be representative of those having seized the control of the United States, whereas Neil Armstrong who died three days after the irretrievable fall on 2012-10-22 of Lance was rather a tragic hero and liar against will
 
Do you despite...
We do not agree with repeated arguments from incredulity and ignorance in crazy colors and incoherent notation, wogoga :p!

Pointing to your equally incoherent web page does not make your arguments any better. A lie of calling Neil Armstrong a "tragic hero and liar against will" is even worse. Neil Armstrong was a hero before Apollo (a test pilot) and a hero during Apollo because he was the first man on the Moon. Neil Armstrong did not lie.
 
Last edited:
Do you despite #68 still honestly assume...

Your argument has several fatal flaws, the most notable of which is your complete ignorance for the principles of spacecraft design and operation that mitigate thermal loading during re-entry. Complete ignorance. You do not consider them at all in your model. The next most fatal flaw is your complete ignorance of the regime of hypersonic flight.

Simply repeating your simplistic formulation doesn't cure your ignorance.

The relevant postings of this thread: The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?

Like a few other conspiracy nuts, you've cherry-picked posts from this thread and created a whole new fanciful debate out of them on your web page so that it can be completely under your control. No links back here, so that readers can see the debate in context. No opportunity for those whom you have quoted to respond to your comments where they can be seen next to yours.

That is the depth of dishonesty. You cannot abide a true debate, so you have to invent one where you are the "winner." Also don't think the obvious anti-American digs at your web site have gone unnoticed. And don't think it doesn't raise in the mind of your readers an ulterior motive for you to ignorantly question America's space program.
 
Last edited:
Do you despite
The relevant postings of this thread: The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?

If you have replies to questions put to you in this thread, why not put them in this thread rather than somewhere else?

e2a: Your page is not an 'article', it is not 'scientific', but we are peer reviewing it - it's tripe.


Lance Armstrong seems to be representative of those having seized the control of the United States, whereas Neil Armstrong who died three days after the irretrievable fall on 2012-10-22 of Lance was rather a tragic hero and liar against will

This is utter nonsense. Stop trying to sneak BS under the radar with small print. If you have something to say, say it.
 
Last edited:
It's also worth pointing out that your linking of people by the coincidence of their surname is also completely wrong. Neil Armstrong died on August 25, 2012. This is some way off the 'three days' you claim for the time lapse to Lance Armstrong's fall from grace in October, which is merely the date that the cycling body ratified a decision made as a result of a story that broke in June of that year. The nearest you can get for your manufactured story is the date Armstrong stopped contesting the charges against him.

Do you have your own unique method of working out calendars as well as maths, or are you just bad at copying from Wikipedia?
 
Do you despite #68 still honestly assume that my argument depends on the premise that the whole energy equivalent of as much as 80 tons TNT = 4p8 kg TNT has to be absorbed by the Apollo return capsule (with a weight of 5.5 ton = 3p55 kg)?

What argument? All you're saying is "Wow, that's a big number." So what? That simply makes it a bigger engineering problem, and nobody was ever pretending it was a small one.

Dave
 
Wogoga, why are you simply repeating your claims, when you understand neither the mechanisms involved nor the scope of the documentation?

I've been in aerospace for a quarter-century, and worked for some of the people that made Apollo happen. But there are plenty of non-aerospace, non-engineer types here who understand perfectly well the fundamental concepts you keep missing. What's your excuse? Don't you want to learn?
 
While we're waiting for wolfy to do us the common courtesy of not discussing this thread behind our backs, let's repond to his whispered responses.

Quite similar is the situation with the moon rocks distributed all over the world (mainly as donations). Even here in Liechtenstein we have one in the Treasure Chamber of the National Museum:

"Further important objects include lunar rocks from the Apollo 11 and Apollo 17 missions as well as Liechtenstein national flags which were carried on the first and last manned flights to the Moon. These were given to the Principality as a token of gratitude for the help provided to NASA by the Liechtenstein-based company Balzers AG, which at the time specialised in vacuum technology and supplied protective coatings for the space rockets."

When such a "moon rock" after having been examined turns out to be undoubtedly terrestrial, then a story that the original rock must have been stolen and replaced with a less valuable stone, or a similar tale can easily be served.

The statement in the last paragraphs never happened. It is a complete fabrication.

Then there's this reposnse to Jay's comment about Bennett's fraudulent use of documentary footage:

What you address here is obviously a problem. A huge number of more or less officially manipulated or "reconstructed" documents exist (e.g. Earth on photo, 2013, 2015). This creates additional confusion which helps to defend the Apollo myths.

If Wolfy had actually read the pages he linked to, he would know that his statement is false. They or not 'more or less official', someone has taken two genuine images to make a new one to illustrate a question. There is no Apollo myth and the only confusion is in the mind of the woefully undereducated and the wilfully misinformed.
 
When such a "moon rock" after having been examined turns out to be undoubtedly terrestrial, then a story that the original rock must have been stolen and replaced with a less valuable stone, or a similar tale can easily be served.

The statement in the last paragraphs never happened. It is a complete fabrication.


Wikipedia on Goodwill Moon rocks:

In 1970, US president Richard Nixon gave presentation samples of Moon rock brought back by Apollo 11 as gifts to 135 countries and 50 US states.

Near the end of their third and final moonwalk, and what would be the last moonwalk of the Apollo program, Apollo 17 astronauts Eugene Cernan and Harrison Schmitt "picked up a very significant rock, typical of what we have here in the valley of Taurus-Littrow... composed of many fragments, of many sizes, and many shapes, probably from all parts of the Moon, perhaps billions of years old" and made a special dedication to the young people of Earth. This rock was later labeled sample 70017. President Nixon ordered the distribution of fragments of the rock to 135 foreign heads of state and the 50 U.S. states. These gifts were distributed in 1973. The fragments were presented encased in an acrylic sphere, mounted on a wood plaque which included the recipients' flag which had also flown aboard Apollo 17.

Many of the presentation Moon rocks are now unaccounted for, having been stolen or lost.
​

"Attempt at subtle bribery rocks" would probably have been a better name for Richard Nixons "Goodwill Moon rocks".

Quote from 'Moon rock' given to Holland by Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin is fake:

"Curators at Amsterdam's Rijksmuseum, where the rock has attracted tens of thousands of visitors each year, discovered that the "lunar rock", valued at £308,000, was in fact petrified wood.

Xandra van Gelder, who oversaw the investigation, said the museum would continue to keep the stone as a curiosity."
​

By the way, the Fake Moon Rock Hypothesis could resolve the Lunar Isotopic Crisis. Abstract from New approaches to the Moon's isotopic crisis, 2014:

"Recent comparisons of the isotopic compositions of the Earth and the Moon show that, unlike nearly every other body known in the Solar System, our satellite's isotopic ratios are nearly identical to the Earth's for nearly every isotopic system. The Moon's chemical make-up, however, differs from the Earth's in its low volatile content and perhaps in the elevated abundance of oxidized iron. This surprising situation is not readily explained by current impact models of the Moon's origin and offers a major clue to the Moon's formation, if we only could understand it properly. Current ideas to explain this similarity range from assuming an impactor with the same isotopic composition as the Earth to postulating a pure ice impactor that completely vaporized upon impact. Several recent proposals follow from the suggestion that the Earth–Moon system may have lost a great deal of angular momentum during early resonant interactions. The isotopic constraint may be the most stringent test yet for theories of the Moon's origin."​

My postings of this thread: The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?

Cheers, Wolfi
 
Last edited:
Wikipedia on Goodwill Moon rocks

Thanks, I don't need educating on the Goodwill rocks, Clearly you do.

In 1970, US president Richard Nixon gave presentation samples of Moon rock brought back by Apollo 11 as gifts to 135 countries and 50 US states.

[snip - not needed]

Many of the presentation Moon rocks are now unaccounted for, having been stolen or lost

Some of the presentation rocks are unaccounted for. This is not the same as stolen and replaced with terrestrial rocks. They are encased in lucite. See if you can work out how that shows your claim is nonsense.

"Attempt at subtle bribery rocks" would probably have been a better name for Richard Nixons "Goodwill Moon rocks".

The political motivations of Nixon are a) well known and b) no proof of anything other than his political motivations.

Curators at Amsterdam's Rijksmuseum, where the rock has attracted tens of thousands of visitors each year, discovered that the "lunar rock", valued at £308,000, was in fact petrified wood.

Xandra van Gelder, who oversaw the investigation, said the museum would continue to keep the stone as a curiosity.

And here we get to it, your puking up of a nonsense story with no evidence to it.

Here are the facts wolfy:

There is not one tiny piece of evidence, anywhere, from any source, that lunar rocks were given out by anyone on the post Apollo 11 Giant Leap tour, let alone to someone who was asleep in bed during the Apollo 11 visit.

There is ample evidence to support the idea that the petrified wood was an art stunt by the people who displayed it in the Rijksmuseum.

Look it up.

New approaches to the Moon's isotopic crisis, 2014:

Recent comparisons of the isotopic compositions of the Earth and the Moon show that, unlike nearly every other body known in the Solar System, our satellite's isotopic ratios are nearly identical to the Earth's for nearly every isotopic system.[/B] The Moon's chemical make-up, however, differs from the Earth's in its low volatile content and perhaps in the elevated abundance of oxidized iron. This surprising situation is not readily explained by current impact models of the Moon's origin and offers a major clue to the Moon's formation, if we only could understand it properly. Current ideas to explain this similarity range from assuming an impactor with the same isotopic composition as the Earth to postulating a pure ice impactor that completely vaporized upon impact. Several recent proposals follow from the suggestion that the Earth–Moon system may have lost a great deal of angular momentum during early resonant interactions. The isotopic constraint may be the most stringent test yet for theories of the Moon's origin."

Very good. See if you can explain that in your own words. Don't forget to tell us what data and samples they are using to come up with their conclusiosn.
 
Last edited:
Quote from 'Moon rock' given to Holland by Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin is fake:

"Curators at Amsterdam's Rijksmuseum, where the rock has attracted tens of thousands of visitors each year, discovered that the "lunar rock", valued at £308,000, was in fact petrified wood.

Xandra van Gelder, who oversaw the investigation, said the museum would continue to keep the stone as a curiosity."
​
The lunar rock sample given by Armstrong and Aldrin are still displayed in the Rijksmuseum. The misidentified rock was far too large: The rock donations from Apollo 11 were just tiny specks of 0.01 grams where you needed a magnifying glass to look at them, but this piece of rock was "plum-sized", and it was given to a former prime minister, a private person, who thought it was a lunar sample, and the Rijksmuseum inherited it from his estate.

This story has nothing to do with faking anything, but sad misunderstandings, and anybody with any knowledge about the Apollo 11 lunar samples would immediately have known that something was wrong.
 
The lunar rock sample given by Armstrong and Aldrin are still displayed in the Rijksmuseum.

The actual Goodwill rocks were sent out some time after Apollo 11's visit at Nixon's request.

The misidentified rock was far too large: The rock donations from Apollo 11 were just tiny specks of 0.01 grams where you needed a magnifying glass to look at them, but this piece of rock was "plum-sized", and it was given to a former prime minister, a private person, who thought it was a lunar sample, and the Rijksmuseum inherited it from his estate.

There isn't even any evidence that that happened. The rock was in a drawer of personal effects donated to the museum by his family. Also in the drawer was a card from the US Ambassador relating to the Apollo 11 visit. 2+2 = 5. My personal belief is that the juxtaposition was done by the artists reponsible for the original exhibition of the rock. Quotes attributed to the Ambassador are ambiguous about which rock is under discussion, as genuine lunar samples for a public display were also toured around in addition to the goodwill rocks.

This story has nothing to do with faking anything, but sad misunderstandings, and anybody with any knowledge about the Apollo 11 lunar samples would immediately have known that something was wrong.

Which is exactly what happened :)
 
Quotes attributed to the Ambassador are ambiguous about which rock is under discussion, as genuine lunar samples for a public display were also toured around in addition to the goodwill rocks.
I suspect that Middendorp actually remembered THIS event from 1970.
The high-ranking Dutch dignitary studying the moon rock is Royal Consort prince Bernhard, not Drees.
This sample was a loaner, not a gift. It later went to Osaka for Expo 70.
 
Wogoga, you posted some long-debunked meme about a supposed "moon rock" official gift being a piece of wood (not true), trying to push the notion that there is some expert disagreement about the provenance of lunar samples (not true). You added without comment an abstract of a scholarly article about isotopic ratios, as if that somehow supported the notion that the Apollo samples weren't gathered by Apollo crews on the Moon (also not true); but like the rest of the things you quote, you really don't understand what you're talking about.

Do you think you can distract from your failure to understand how reentry works by throwing out random bits of urban legends and scientific papers by people who don't agree with your fantasy that Apollo was a hoax? How is that supposed to work?
 
Last edited:
"Attempt at subtle bribery rocks" would probably have been a better name for Richard Nixons "Goodwill Moon rocks".

Your thinly veiled anti-American vitriol is not evidence.


This media report contains a number of factual errors.

By the way, the Fake Moon Rock Hypothesis could resolve the Lunar Isotopic Crisis. Abstract from New approaches to the Moon's isotopic crisis, 2014:

You don't understand the first thing about engineering and don't seem to care. Are you now going to pretend to be a geologist?
 
We do not agree with repeated arguments from incredulity and ignorance in crazy colors and incoherent notation, wogoga :p!

Pointing to your equally incoherent web page does not make your arguments any better. A lie of calling Neil Armstrong a "tragic hero and liar against will" is even worse. Neil Armstrong was a hero before Apollo (a test pilot) and a hero during Apollo because he was the first man on the Moon. Neil Armstrong did not lie.

In 1969 my father was a Sky Marshal and was designated primary escort/bodyguard for Neil Armstrong and his wife Janet during the "Giant Leap" world publicity tour the Apollo 11 Astronauts and wives embarked on in August of '69.

Both men were avid glider pilots, and through that common interest, they became friends. I got to meet and spend a bit of time with Neil at various soaring competitions and meets my father and I participated in.

He was brilliant, yet down to earth and incredibly humble. It really angers me to see people like this wogoga person telling outrageous lies about the good man that my late father and I knew.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom