Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission


And not the first time she has lied about and misrepresented her sources. In Dark Moon there's a photo purporting to be from NASA film/video footage. It depicts the Surveyor spacecraft purportedly as seen from Apollo 12 as they were in the process of landing. Bennett argued it disagreed with other photography taken of the Surveyor. But her photo and footage was to be found nowhere at any NASA source. Naturally her claim is valid only if she could prove her photo was actually published by NASA. After a lengthy period of stalling and insisting her source was NASA, Bennett finally admitted it had instead come from a German documentary and she had just "assumed" it was official NASA footage. It was instead, as we discovered, a reconstruction produced by the German documentarians.

Elsewhere in Dark Moon it is claimed the newspaper West Australian had published articles in 1969 relating to allegations of hoaxed lunar surface footage. Bennett claims she contacted the newspaper to verify this and that her queries went unanswered. I contacted the archivist of the West Australian who answered immediately, confirmed that no such articles had been published within a two-week period of the Apollo 11 landing, and that to her knowledge no one had ever asked about them before

This is the kind of "scholarship" we're dealing with here. Bennett does not accurately represent her sources. She has no demonstrable expertise in space science or engineering.
 
Can anyone tell me why it is that wogoga considers Mary "the crank" Bennett to be in any way authoritative? Or anything posted on cluelessAulis for that matter?
 
Please let me know what kind of dishonesty you are able to sense in Bennett's article.
We can detect dishonesty, paranoia and bias in that article's first paragraph: David Orbell being "evicted" from a conference for asking questions based only on the evidence of David Orbell on that web site :jaw-dropp!
Read Orbell basically called Apollo astronauts liars, Thomas Stafford and Alfred Worden, at that conference when they told him that skip reentry was not used and being ejected by conference security on request of a event organizer (not the astronauts). Orbell calls this "undemocratic" which is delusional - a conference is not a democracy. There are different rules.

Putting the question to Alfred Worden was actually stupid because Alfred Worden was the Command Module Pilot for the Apollo 15 lunar mission in 1971, not Apollo 10 which Karft's alleged comment was about.

The dishonesty is in cherry picking one quote from Chis Kraft from a 2009 Popular Mechanics news article and not checking with Popular Mechanics or Kraft whether the quote was correct or not! Given that no manned mission has ever made a skip reentry (which Bennett and Orbell should know), the quote is probably incorrect. Entry and Splashdown: Apollo 11, The Untold Story is a list of quotes with no real sources - just names attributed to them.

We can detect ignorance in the article - Entry, Splashdown, and Recovery probably does not list both Velocity (ft/sec) and Maximum Entry Velocity (ft/sec) fro Apollo's greater than 10 because the Maximum Entry Velocity was the Velocity! For Apollo 7, 8 , 9 and 10 Maximum Entry Velocity > Velocity. Or paranoia - leaving out the numbers means nothing; the delusion that aerospace professionals know about a rather obscure NASA web page or need to correct imaginary 'mistakes'.

Mary Bennett is honest enough to state what happened - no skip reentry for manned Apollo missions. But then she goes on a rant about "In testing the CMs we find more discrepancies of data and method.", e.g. whining about a David Baker quote on AS 202 (unmanned CM test) "skipped back to a height of 264,000ft" when a graph shows ~258,000 ft. Mary Bennett is so ignorant or dishonest that she does not know about rounding of numbers in quotes and thinks a book written by Baker is NASA data (Space Flight and Rocketry: A Chronology, David Baker, 1996) :eek:!

Looks like Mary Bennett lies about "Back in 1968 NASA was still describing the Apollo entry as a skip within the atmosphere.". From before Apollo 4 (1968) the Apollo reentries were planned to be semi-ballistic.
Mary Bennett lies about "‘a semilifting entry’" being a skip entry. This is when the spacecraft has some lift due to its shape and trajectory.

Mary Bennett lies about CREW EXPLORATION VEHICLE (CEV) SKIP ENTRY TRAJECTORY thesis by Emre Kaya. This is the "Although total skip entry guidance ..." quote in the thesis
Significance of Research
In general, it is considered that the results of the research are quite successful. Although total skip entry guidance has been done before for the trajectories of unmanned vehicles, application of this concept is quite new for the manned space missions. One very important risk of trying a skip entry is skipping out of the atmosphere above orbital escape speed at that altitude and this can have disastrous results. Therefore, the accuracy in maintaining the parameters is very important as calculating the correct parameters.The skip entry guidance concept is going to be a part of the CEV reentry algorithm. Since the vehicle and its guidance system is still under development and no public displays or announcements have been made so far, any kind of different perspective and approach to the problem will be helpful in terms of putting more insight for the solution of the problem
Before that quote is
In addition, the Apollo CM guidance was designed to allow a maximum deceleration of 12g during nominal entry. Typical Apollo missions reached peak decelerations over 6.5g during entry with the help of “double dip reentry.” [13] Compared to non-skip entry conditions, lower g load values are reached in the skip entry trajectory due to the large energy dissipation during the first atmospheric flight segment. In a double dip entry, the vehicle does not complete a skip entry but loses its excess energy by accomplishing the first part of the skip but never leaving the atmosphere as seen in Figure 3.


Mary Bennett is paranoiac about the standard disclaimer in many theses - a thesis is the work of the author, not their affiliations so we expect a statement like "The views expressed in this thesis are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the United States Air Force, Department of Defense, or the U.S. Government.". Bennett thinks that part of the thesis was released - more paranoia or ignorance :eek:! Theses are fairly public records usually kept in university libraries in the deep dark recesses! It is common to have a thesis on the Internet. Parts of a thesis do appear in published papers.

Mary Bennett lies again about David Baker's book being NASA data when going on about Apollo 4. Anyone who can spell knows the difference between "'double dip" and "skip" reentry. Anyone who can read knows that a "double dip" is the lift of the spacecraft used to bring it a little higher in the atmosphere - not high enough to be a skip - as she writes!
Hitting the first loading of g-forces, (for Apollo 4 this was 7.3g) the trajectory was then manipulated through rolling the craft about its axis to raise it into a higher altitude – but all the while staying within the atmosphere...

Mary Bennett thinks the "1968 NASA film Reenty" contains NASA data about Apollo missions 4 and greater that were in the future! She stupidly highlights the word SKIP in her extract from the film.

A bit of stupidity: NASA deciding not to "land on dry land with pinpoint precision" is good because it would probably have killed the astronauts :eek:!

Mary Bennett lies about the Apollo 8 flightplan - it shows at least a double dip reentry (maybe a "triple dip").

"The Apollo 17 mission report doesn’t mention the method of entry" means that her ignorant assumptions will not make it appear from thin air!

Mary Bennett goes back to obsessing about a quote that may or may not come from Chris Kraft where "skip it out" could be a reference to the double dip :eek:!
 
Last edited:
Very informative video. I was unaware that there was a zero g condition after the first re-entry phase. The video implied that during the zero g condition there wasn't a communication blackout. Is this true? Was the video made prior to any actual Apollo spacecraft re-entries?

I don't recall any details about this phase of the landing from Lovell's book Lost Moon. In the movie Apollo 13 Swigert is shown switching to manual control during a re-entry simulation; going too steep resulting in a failed re-entry. So everything was automatic unless the crew saw something going wrong then took manual control?

Yes. There was a re-entry computer in the command module that automatically controlled the RCS based on the input course and the designed deceleration parameters. One of the fears on Apollo 13 was that this computer would malfunction during power-up - because they powered down nearly everything on the command module to save power and air for re-entry, they couldn't be certain of the condition of the CM systems when they finally arrived at Earth. I would imagine, though I have less direct knowledge of this than others here, that NASA probably accounted for a failure of the re-entry computer and simulated manual re-entry so as to communicate the needed parameters to the crew, just in case. Manual backup was used in an earlier spaceflight when the RCS control computer malfunctioned, and AFAIK, became a standard feature of American spacecraft.
 
Look up, wogoga. That thing flying over your head is the point.

Bennett claimed that Stafford said the re-entry speed was "faster than a return from Mars". Stafford actually said that the re-entry speed was "the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars." Honest people can see the difference between these statements. Why can't you?


What is "honest people"? threadworm even succeeded in confusing me, because I could not imagine such "bald-faced lies", and therefore I erroneously assumed that he and those backing him up must have a legitimate point. But they do not!

Both reentry speed values presented by Tom Stafford in his book "24,791.4 nautical miles (28547 statute miles)" result in 4p1276 m/s = 12.76 km/s = 41869 ft/sec ≈ 4p42 ft/sec. And nobody can deny that this is "faster than a return from Mars". [Sorry, superficial calculations I have just performed seem to suggest that reentry speed from a Mars trip is or can be substantially higher than 12.76 km/s.]

Once again Mary Bennett's words:

"Tom Stafford (Apollo 10 again) asserted in his own 2002 biography We Have Capture that his entry speed was 28,547mph, which works out at 41,869ft/sec – faster than a return from Mars!"​


People who make outrageous claims do not deserve the presumption of credibility you have given her.


According to my world view based on logical consistency and continuity, the claims made by the Apollo program are the ones being outrageous. I can honestly say that the Apollo program seems to me more a gigantic institutionalized lying program ala Richard Nixon than a gigantic technological achievement. History clearly shows that such huge conspiracies with corresponding disinformation programs are possible.

When around twenty years ago a former school mate told me that Apollo was faked, I could not believe and argued in favor of Apollo's reality. As an eight year old boy (then still very pious and religious) I had even prayed to God for the sake of the Apollo 13 astronauts. So it was a rather difficult process (over the last twenty years) to admit to myself that I had been fooled by a criminal government and collaborators.


We call Mary Bennett a liar because Mary Bennett lied as shown by threadworm in what you quoted :jaw-dropp!

And not the first time she has lied about and misrepresented her sources. In Dark Moon there's a photo purporting to be from NASA film/video footage. It depicts the Surveyor spacecraft purportedly as seen from Apollo 12 as they were in the process of landing. Bennett argued it disagreed with other photography taken of the Surveyor. But her photo and footage was to be found nowhere at any NASA source. Naturally her claim is valid only if she could prove her photo was actually published by NASA. After a lengthy period of stalling and insisting her source was NASA, Bennett finally admitted it had instead come from a German documentary and she had just "assumed" it was official NASA footage. It was instead, as we discovered, a reconstruction produced by the German documentarians.


What you address here is obviously a problem. A huge number of more or less officially manipulated or "reconstructed" documents exist (e.g. Earth on photo, 2013, 2015). This creates additional confusion which helps to defend the Apollo myths.

Quite similar is the situation with the moon rocks distributed all over the world (mainly as donations). Even here in Liechtenstein we have one in the Treasure Chamber of the National Museum:

"Further important objects include lunar rocks from the Apollo 11 and Apollo 17 missions as well as Liechtenstein national flags which were carried on the first and last manned flights to the Moon. These were given to the Principality as a token of gratitude for the help provided to NASA by the Liechtenstein-based company Balzers AG, which at the time specialised in vacuum technology and supplied protective coatings for the space rockets."​

When such a "moon rock" after having been examined turns out to be undoubtedly terrestrial, then a story that the original rock must have been stolen and replaced with a less valuable stone, or a similar tale can easily be served.

Cheers, Wolfgang
Our Sun is a huge, open nuclear reactor
 
Last edited:
Both reentry speed values presented by Tom Stafford in his book "24,791.4 nautical miles (28547 statute miles)" result in 4p1276 m/s = 12.76 km/s = 41869 ft/sec ≈ 4p42 ft/sec. And nobody can deny that this is "faster than a return from Mars".

What value are you using for the speed of a return from Mars, and given that no human-carrying craft has ever done such a thing, how do you justify that value?

A few years ago I coined the term "Unevaluated inequality fallacy" for the act of insisting that one of two numbers must be greater than the other when the value of one or both of those numbers is unknown. This seems to me a classic example of the first kind.

Dave
 
Once again Mary Bennett's words:

But not Stafford's words. Bennett misquoted him, and you still haven't addressed that. Nor have you explained why you insist on using such a proven dishonest source.

And nobody can deny that this is "faster than a return from Mars".

Look at me deny it. Which is to say, you haven't told us what you think a nominal return velocity would be from a transfer orbit from Mars, so you don't get to tell us what the quantitative relationship can or cannot be. There are many ways to get to Mars from Earth, and each entails a different set of velocities.

According to my world view based on logical consistency and continuity, the claims made by the Apollo program are the ones being outrageous.

Changing horses. You originally proposed an argument based on physics. You quickly demonstrated that you didn't know what you were talking about. Then you tried to tell us it was baesd on "common sense," ostensibly Bennett's. Now you're trying to tell us your argument is based on "logical consistency and continuity."

History clearly shows that such huge conspiracies with corresponding disinformation programs are possible.

Vague handwaving. The question is not what conceivably may be the case, but what actually is the case. The historical record of Apollo is one of the largest, most meticulously kept, and most freely available of any in history. It is nearly unanimously accepted by the relevant communities as probative.

Moreover, we can examine challenges to the authenticity of that record and see how factually bankrupt they are, how scientifically ignorant they are, and how fraught they are with blatantly illogical reasoning. Your argument is just such a challenge. You have an abysmally incorrect understanding of how the science works, and at this point you've devolved into the classic fringe argumentation patterns.

It isn't enough to suggest that vast conspiracies are possible. That suggests your critics have a burden not only to prove Apollo was not faked, but that it would be impossible to fake. We have no such burden, nor would such a burden be logically tenable. If you want to show Apollo was faked you have to show that it was faked, not merely that you can imagine that it may have been.

When around twenty years ago a former school mate told me that Apollo was faked, I could not believe and argued in favor of Apollo's reality. As an eight year old boy (then still very pious and religious) I had even prayed to God for the sake of the Apollo 13 astronauts. So it was a rather difficult process (over the last twenty years) to admit to myself that I had been fooled by a criminal government and collaborators.

Nope.

Every hoax claimant tells the same story, and it's just as unbelievable every time. They tell us how they were dragged kicking and screaming against their will to the conclusion that Apollo was faked, based on overwhelmingly convincing evidence. You would expect such people to respond with relief when told that the "convincing evidence" is just hogwash perpetuated by ignorant and self-serving authors, and that they could therefore go back to the cherished belief they once held. But no, we see that such people will defend the nonsensical hoax claims vigorously, embracing and entrenching themselves in positions that are at best uninformed and at worst flatly wrong. Look at you continually redefine what you want us to believe is the basis for your argument. When one line of reasoning is shot down, you just grasp for another one. At no time do you seem to consider that your desired outcome may not be true, and this is not credible behavior for someone who claims to have been convinced against his will.

What you address here is obviously a problem. A huge number of more or less officially manipulated or "reconstructed" documents exist...

If your explanation for the existence of evidence is that is it manipulated or fabricated, then that is your affirmative claim and you bear the burden to prove it. Otherwise you're just in denial of the evidence, not reasoning with logic.

When such a "moon rock" after having been examined turns out to be undoubtedly terrestrial, then a story that the original rock must have been stolen and replaced with a less valuable stone, or a similar tale can easily be served.

Now you're just spinning wishful tales. As a matter of fact, Apollo samples have been sent to geologists worldwide, not as display artifacts but as specimens for serious study. There is no question among the relevant scientific community that they are genuine material from the lunar surface. So it doesn't matter what hypothetical nonsense you come up with. The facts have already spoken, and they don't agree with your belief. Therefore no, you are not basing your argument on logic.
 
A few years ago I coined the term "Unevaluated inequality fallacy" for the act of insisting that one of two numbers must be greater than the other when the value of one or both of those numbers is unknown. This seems to me a classic example of the first kind.

That's a good name; I think I'll adopt it gratefully.

And yes, this sort of fallacy arises all the time in Apollo hoax claims.

Claimant: "The Apollo computer wasn't powerful enough"
Me: "How powerful did it need to be?"

Claimant: "There's too much radiation in space"
Me: "How much is there?"
Claimant: "I don't know, but it was too much."

etc.
 
The task of returning 170 gram = 9n17 kg of moon rock is incomparably easier than of returning humans whose net weight alone is 200 kg = 2p2 kg or more. Rocks are not sensitive to temperature and high g's (decelerations).

4. The weights of the samples/human beings are not relevant in terms of heat/energy to be dissipated - it is the weight of the total re-entry vehicle. Your use of the weights of samples vs human beings incorrectly greatly exaggerates the difference (for some reason).


Apart from Apollo, "Far Earth" reentry capsules have carried cargos only ranging from dust particles to a maximum of 170 gram of rock. In such a case, the only or at least the main purpose of the heat-shielded reentry capsule is to protect the small but valuable quantity of dust or stones. In this respect, the performance requirements for a save Apollo landing have a different quality.

Only by concrete calculations we can get a feel for the orders of magnitude involved (→ notation). Let us assume that all the kinetic energy of a car with a weight of one metric ton = 3p1 kg is released in the automotive brake as heat. If the car of our thought experiment stops from a speed v = 22.37 mph = 36 km/h = 10 m/s = 1p1 m/s by applying the brake, then the brake must absorb or conduct away thermal energy of E = mass ∙ v2 / 2 = 3p1 kg ∙ 1p1 m/s ∙ 1p1 m/s / 2 = 5p1 / 2 kg m2/s2 = 4p5 Joule = 50 kilo-Joule.

If we increase speed by factor 10 then we get v = 223.7 mph = 360 km/h = 100 m/s = 2p1 m/s with corresponding E = mass ∙ v2 / 2 = 3p1 kg ∙ 2p1 m/s ∙ 2p1 m/s / 2 = 7p1 / 2 kg m2/s2 = 6p5 Joule = 5 Mega-Joule. This is an increase by factor 100!

In order to get a speed close to Apollo reentry speed 4p11 m/s, we must multiply the previous speed by factor 110. We get 24600 mph = 39600 km/h = 11000 m/s = 4p11 m/s with corresponding heat energy E = mass ∙ v2 / 2 = 3p1 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ∙ 4p11 m/s / 2 = 11p121 / 2 kg m2/s2 = 10p605 Joule = 60.5 Giga-Joule. The speed increase by factor 110 leads to an energy increase by factor 12100 = 2p11 ∙ 2p11 = 4p121! The resulting theoretical brake energy has a TNT equivalent of 4p1446 kg = 14.46 tons TNT.

If we load up such a car with an additional ton, i.e. from 3p1 kg to 3p2 kg, then the break must absorb or conduct away twice the heat of the empty car. In the situation of the previous paragraph, the same automotive brake would have to absorb or conduct away the energy equivalent of 28.92 tons = 4p2892 kg TNT instead of 14.46 tons = 4p1446 kg TNT.

What is relevant is the ratio between total weight and brake capacity. In the case of Apollo return module, the relevant ratio is between surface and weight of the heat shield on the one hand, and total weight of the module on the other hand.

Cheers, Wolfgang

9/11 would not have been possible if the Apollo Program had not shown how easy it is to make honest enlighteners look like "conspiracy nuts" in the eyes of the naïve majority
 
Last edited:
Only by concrete calculations we can get a feel for the orders of magnitude involved....

You started here with "concrete calculations" and when those were shown to be wrong, you pled that "common sense" was the guiding factor so you could simply parrot the ignorance and deceit of Mary Bennett. Now that she's discredited, you're back to calculation again.

Let us assume that all the kinetic energy of a car with a weight of one metric ton = 3p1 kg is released in the automotive brake as heat.

Assume all you want, but what you're suggesting by assumption has nothing to do with how spacecraft actually manage the energy of re-entry.

If we increase speed by factor 10 then we get ... an increase by factor 100!

Yes, kinetic energy is proportional to the square of the velocity. That's basic dynamics.

If we load up such a car with an additional ton, i.e. from 3p1 kg to 3p2 kg, then the break must absorb or conduct away twice the heat...

Asked and answered. You are assuming the spacecraft is responsible for absorbing and/or conducting all the heat produced by re-entry. This is not how it works.

What is relevant is the ratio between total weight and brake capacity. In the case of Apollo return module, the relevant ratio is between surface and weight of the heat shield on the one hand, and total weight of the module on the other hand.

No, that's only marginally relevant. What has a greater effect is the mechanisms by which heat is managed by the Apollo thermal protection system. You don't understand them at all, and you're trying to make reality fit into your simplistic understanding of the problem.

9/11 would not have been possible if the Apollo Program had not shown how easy it is to make honest enlighteners look like "conspiracy nuts" in the eyes of the naïve majority

And there's the political argument I predicted.

Wogoga, you are a conspiracy nut. You're a perfect example. You have a proposition which you claim is based on science but which is now obviously based on a political belief. You think you have the engineering chops to prove your point, but you don't and won't fess up to that. You rely on unreliable and dishonest sources to which you have applied no critical thought. You apply that same gullibility to other conspiracy theories.

9/11 is off-topic here, but we have a whole subforum for it. If you believe Richard Gage is an "honest enlightener," go over there and have your head handed to you by the real engineers who post in the 9/11 subforum.
 
wogoga said:
What is relevant is the ratio between total weight and brake capacity. In the case of Apollo return module, the relevant ratio is between surface and weight of the heat shield on the one hand, and total weight of the module on the other hand.

Nope. That's not how it works, and this has already been explained to you by people who do understand the concepts. Repeating your erroneous claims won't help you. Waving around your clumsy personal notation in all its multicolored silliness won't help you. You simply don't know what you're talking about.

wogoga said:
9/11 would not have been possible if the Apollo Program had not shown how easy it is to make honest enlighteners look like "conspiracy nuts" in the eyes of the naïve majority

The first problem is that 9/11 had nothing to do with Apollo; you're just appealing to general conspiracism in lieu of having any valid technical points to make. The second problem is that you haven't demonstrated any sort of hoax with either the Apollo program or the events of 9/11/2001.

But the biggest problem is that you're not an "honest enlightener". You keep trying to assume the mantle of erudite analyst with your ridiculous made-up number system, keep ignoring the corrections to your fundamental mistakes and misunderstandings, and quote other dishonest and incompetent conspiracy pushers like Mary Bennett. You aren't even dimly aware of the vast scope of the scientific, programmatic, and technical record that is directly related to the field in which you are currently embarrassing yourself.

It's hilarious that you claim you are trying to "honestly enlighten" us, including but not limited to those of us who actually work in this field, when you have no idea what you're talking about. What you are is part of the naive minority that gets swindled by the Bennetts and Percys of this world, and think that somehow entitles you to strut and pose while proclaiming about topics you just don't understand and refuse to learn anything about.
 
wogoga: The dishonesty, stupidity, paranoia and bias in Mary Bennett's article

What is "honest people"? ...
Easy, wogoga: Someone who does not lie by proxy by quoting the deluded, liar Mary Bennett. Or someone who reads posts and acknowledges that they have been fooled by a liar.
8 September 2016 wogoga: The dishonesty, stupidity, paranoia and bias in Mary Bennett's article in the deluded Apollo hoax site that you cited.
12 September 2016 wogoga: threadworm pointed out Mary Bennett lied about a quote from Tom Stafford on 5 September 2015.

Your world view is based on the world view of ignorant and deluded liars such as Mary Bennett, not "logical consistency and continuity'.

The real world fact is that Apollo 10 has the record for the highest reentry speed as Tom Stafford stated "the fastest human beings have ever flown". It is possible that a future Mars mission will have a higher reentry speed.
 
Last edited:
Apart from Apollo, ....What is relevant...
What is relevant is the idiocy of
  • inane notation that makes people ignore your "calculations".
  • derailing into unmanned reentry when the conspiracy delusion is about Apollo reentry.
  • thinking that a car is a spacecraft reentering the atmosphere :p!
Adding the abysmal ignorance of 9/11 conspiracy theories with a stupid "enlightening" foreign language YouTube video is not wise.
 
Apart from Apollo, "Far Earth" reentry capsules have carried cargos only ranging from dust particles to a maximum of 170 gram of rock. In such a case, the only or at least the main purpose of the heat-shielded reentry capsule is to protect the small but valuable quantity of dust or stones. In this respect, the performance requirements for a save Apollo landing have a different quality.
In one short paragraph you claim it can be done, yet it cannot be done.

Only by concrete calculations we can get a feel for the orders of magnitude involved (→ notation). Let us assume that all the kinetic energy of a car with a weight of one metric ton = 3p1 kg is released in the automotive brake as heat. If the car of our thought experiment stops from a speed v = 22.37 mph = 36 km/h = 10 m/s = 1p1 m/s by applying the brake, then the brake must absorb or conduct away thermal energy of E = mass ∙ v2 / 2 = 3p1 kg ∙ 1p1 m/s ∙ 1p1 m/s / 2 = 5p1 / 2 kg m2/s2 = 4p5 Joule = 50 kilo-Joule.
Your quirky system has already been demonstrated to be an utter failure. Even you cannot use it. Why should anyone care about your broken maths?

If we increase speed by factor 10 then we get v = 223.7 mph = 360 km/h = 100 m/s = 2p1 m/s with corresponding E = mass ∙ v2 / 2 = 3p1 kg ∙ 2p1 m/s ∙ 2p1 m/s / 2 = 7p1 / 2 kg m2/s2 = 6p5 Joule = 5 Mega-Joule. This is an increase by factor 100!

In order to get a speed close to Apollo reentry speed 4p11 m/s, we must multiply the previous speed by factor 110. We get 24600 mph = 39600 km/h = 11000 m/s = 4p11 m/s with corresponding heat energy E = mass ∙ v2 / 2 = 3p1 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ∙ 4p11 m/s / 2 = 11p121 / 2 kg m2/s2 = 10p605 Joule = 60.5 Giga-Joule. The speed increase by factor 110 leads to an energy increase by factor 12100 = 2p11 ∙ 2p11 = 4p121! The resulting theoretical brake energy has a TNT equivalent of 4p1446 kg = 14.46 tons TNT.

If we load up such a car with an additional ton, i.e. from 3p1 kg to 3p2 kg, then the break must absorb or conduct away twice the heat of the empty car. In the situation of the previous paragraph, the same automotive brake would have to absorb or conduct away the energy equivalent of 28.92 tons = 4p2892 kg TNT instead of 14.46 tons = 4p1446 kg TNT.
Clearly, you are innocent of calculus.

What is relevant is the ratio between total weight and brake capacity. In the case of Apollo return module, the relevant ratio is between surface and weight of the heat shield on the one hand, and total weight of the module on the other hand.

Cheers, Wolfgang
Why are you asking anyone such questions? That's your job.You are proposing the nonsense.

9/11 would not have been possible if the Apollo Program had not shown how easy it is to make honest enlighteners look like "conspiracy nuts" in the eyes of the naïve majority
But you are the "naive hoi polloi" quite clearly
 
Let us assume that all the kinetic energy of a car with a weight of one metric ton = 3p1 kg is released in the automotive brake as heat.

This assumption is the key error. The kinetic energy of a spacecraft on re-entry is not released as heat within the spacecraft. It is released as heat in the atmosphere below the heat shield, much of which is then dissipated without transfer to the spacecraft. So the amount of energy you're claiming must be absorbed by the spacecraft is greatly over-estimated. Add to that the fact that your argument then descends to the level of "Whoah, that looks like a lot of energy to me!", and it's hardly surprising that your conclusions are absurd; your premises are wrong, and your syllogisms non-existent.

Dave
 
Most of us, even old farts like myself, have no issues with mks, English, or fsf units, as long as they are consistent. Please don't perpetuate that myth.

Agreed. The only people I've ever seen confused over units are Europeans baffled when NASA posts articles using miles and feet.
 
Bennett simply does exactly what she accuses others of doing, i.e. conflating and munging unrelated facts together into a kind of opaque pea soup of ignorance in the hope of confusing the reader. In fact, that is exactly what you yourself are doing with your non-standard notation and nautical mile red herring.

In your post linked above you have lobbed in units of feet, meters, statute miles, nautical miles, international miles, kilometers, miles per hour, international miles per hour, nautical miles per hour, statute miles per hour, feet per second, meters per second, seconds per hour, kilometers per second, Joules per kilogramme in a morass of incoherent stream of consciousness writing. Oddly, just like Bennett, you saw fit to include fabricated quotes as well.

There is not a bit of common sense in that. It is either wild delusion or abject ignorance of the subject matter at hand or intentional obfuscation.

I, for one, am disappointed that the officially-approved "furlongs per fortnight" standard was utterly omitted...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom