A simplified and less confusing notation for numbers
international mile = …0003p1609344000… m = 3p1609.344 m ≈ 3p16 meter
foot = 0.3048 m = …9999n3048000… m = 9n3048 m ≈ 9n3 meter
nautical mile = 1852 m = …0003p1852000… m = 3p1852 m ≈ 3p185 meter
Mary Bennett makes great play in her piece on 'Aulis' (which should in itself be a clue that it's all a complete crock) that Tom Stafford claimed in his autobiography that his re-entry speed was 28547 mph, which is faster than a return from Mars. Here are her exact words:
"Tom Stafford (Apollo 10 again) asserted in his own 2002 biography We Have Capture that his entry speed was 28,547mph, which works out at 41,869ft/sec – faster than a return from Mars!"
I have a copy of the book in front of me, and this is what it actually says:
Our trajectory was designed for the fastest return possible, allowing us to cover the 238,000 mile distance in 42 hours, rather than the usual 56 or more. This meant that at one point we reached a speed of 24,791.4 nautical miles (28547 statute miles) an hour, the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars.
Wolfgang - do you see the subtle difference there between what Bennett claimed was written and what was actually written?
Statute mile: 5280 feet
= 3p5280 ∙ 9n3048 m = 3p1609 meter =
international mile
According to Mary Bennett, Apollo 10 astronaut Tom Stafford "
claimed in his autobiography that his re-entry speed was 28547 mph". The unit
mph = miles per hour is based on
international mile (
3p1609 meter). In order to convert the value attributed by Bennett to Stafford to
International System of Units (i.e. to
meter per second), we must at first multiply this value
4p28547 mph with factor
3p1609 m/s per mph. The result
7p4594 meter/hour = 10
7 ∙ 4.594 m/s must then be divided by 3600 sec/hour:
7p4594 m/h / 3p36 s/h = 4p1276 m/s = 12.76 km/s
According to those who call Bennett a liar, maximum speed was "
24,791.4 nautical miles (28547 statute miles) an hour". So someone not being familiar with
nautical mile will simply use the
statute mile value
4p28547 which is what Mary Bennett seems to have done. And this value results in
4p1276 m/s = 12.76 km/s.
Obviously, such a speed v is highly unlikely. If we use unit
meter,
second and
kg then we directly get
Joule per kg (kinetic potential): pot
kin = ½ v
2 = 7p8143 Joule/kg. Kinetic potential corresponding to terrestrial escape velocity is only pot
esc = ½ v
esc2 = 7p6257 Joule/kg. To the difference Δpot = pot
kin - pot
esc = 7p1886 J/kg corresponds speed v = √(2 Δpot)
= 3p614 m/s. This means that the spacecraft would have already had a velocity of around 6 km/s before falling back on the Earth.
The value "
24,791.4 nautical miles" of Tom Stafford results in
4p1108 m/s = 11.08 km/s and is between the values given for Apollo 10 in
Entry, Splashdown, and Recovery: 36,314 ft/sec
= 4p1107 m/s = 11.07 km/s and 36,397 ft/sec
= 4p1109 m/s = 11.09 km/s.
Such a reentry speed
4p1108 m/s may seem not exceptional enough to justify Stafford's statement "
the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars".
Why all this confusion with foot, mile, nautical mile and statute mile resp. international mile? In my opinion part of the answer is given by Mary Bennett:
"[O]ne might also conclude that the intention is to confuse any layman examining Apollo."
Bennett is a self-proclaimed psychic. She has no training at all in aerospace matters, and no experience. I wish I could count the number of times I've caught her in bald-faced lies and fabricated "research." Naturally neither she nor her sometimes co-author David Percy will debate me directly. They know they're lying.
The fact that Mary Bennett considers herself a psychic is as irrelevant as my belief in
panpsychism. She also may have been misled into believing that
Albert Einstein was a plagiarist (#122). I
do believe in Einstein's honesty. Nevertheless I respect other opinions.
And the question whether Bennett has (officially recognized) training in aerospace matters seems less important to me than the question of whether she has common sense.
Please let me know what kind of dishonesty you are able to sense in
Bennett's article.
Cheers, Wolfgang