Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

Look at the table again; four missions, three successful or partially successful since your arbitrary cutoff of Luna 24.
Nope. he wont. In hindsight, it occurs to me that hatloads of spy sats returned actual film cartridges as a matter of course. Wogoga must perforce claim all of those are fake too.
 
Let us assume that the survival of "tortoises and other biological specimens" was faked, ...
Rational people do not resort to ignorance or conspiracy theories, wogoga.
Skip reentry is basic orbital mechanics. The highlighting of a Wikipedia article stating it is uncommon does not make it imaginary or impossible or support delusions of "killing tortoises and other biological specimens".

Re-Entry Matters A Detailed Investigation into Apollo Command Module Returns by Mary DM Bennett is an irrelevant, slightly paranoid and ignorant rant. The rant is based on one unattributed quote from Chris Kraft (Director of Flight Operations) in Poplar Mechanics :jaw-dropp! Mary DM Bennett is a Moon hoax conspiracy nut. Her web site includes idiocy such as the Face On Mars. uts claiming that Albert Einstein was a plagiarist, support for the psychologist/medium Stan Gooch, etc.

A skip reentry is not a skip "out of the atmosphere" as she says or even "off the atmosphere" as in the Wikipedia article. It is a reentry where the attitude of the spacecraft is used to push it higher so that it can lose heat before falling back and perhaps repeating the process. It has only been used for the Zond series of spacecraft. The Apollo command modules were designed to do one skip reentry but this was never used. The space shuttles could theoretically do skip reentry but this was never used. The reason is probably that out of the 4 Zond skip entries attempted, Zond 5 had a failure of the guidance system, which is not acceptable for manned missions. It is likely that Zond 5 generated 10-16 G's of deceleration - something that two Russian tortoises did survive but maybe not human beings.
 
Last edited:
Nope. he wont. In hindsight, it occurs to me that hatloads of spy sats returned actual film cartridges as a matter of course. Wogoga must perforce claim all of those are fake too.

To be fair, he's talking about returns from cislunar space.
 
I would rather call it over-documented. One gets almost the impression that a reporter team was already on the Moon in order to document arrival and departure of Apollo 11.

You have no idea what you are talking about. There was a camera in the Ascent Module looking out the window, and a camera attached to the Descent Module to relay the first step onto the surface. That's it. Apollos 15-17 were able, with varying success, to use a camera on the LRV to relay the Ascent Module takeoff.

With modern technology it would probably be a child's play to analyze the original documentations (especially the films). Yet essential parts of the original documentations are unavailable for independent analysis, have disappeared, or have maybe even been preventively destroyed (Apollo 11 missing tapes).

You have no idea what you're talking about, again. There is an enormous amount of detailed design, test, performance, and analysis data available, freely available - more than you even imagine exists. The "missing tapes" contained nothing uniquely important to investigating Apollo, and in any case there were missions after Apollo 11.

In past days I have become astonished at learning how many people do not even know that mega corresponds to million. At least according to what you write here, also you seem to get confused by orders of magnitude and measurement units with auxiliary numbers such as kilo. 170 gram = 0.17 kg is neither 0.17E-3 kg nor 170E-5 kg:

0.17E-3 = 0.17 ∙ 10-3 = 9n17 ∙ 7n1 = 6n17 = 0.00017 kg
170E-5 = 170 ∙ 10-5 = 2p17 = 5n1 = 7n17= 0.0017 kg​

I've understood the metric system and its various prefixes since grade school. What I don't understand is the point of your ugly abortion of a numbering system. It's as if you are trying to appear clever at the expense of being obfuscatory. Whatever your motivation, it doesn't help your argument at all.

Let us assume that the survival of "tortoises and other biological specimens" was faked, and the Americans knew that.

Begging the question. There is no reason to assume either.

WIn any case, the majority of the Soviet Space Program has not been faked, such as e.g. the first photographs of the dark side of the moon by Luna 3.

Nor has the American space program, which by stark contrast to the then-Soviet space program was open and thoroughly and publicly documented. You're undercutting your own argument.


The fact that you are confused, and that the incompetent and mendacious Mary Bennett is confused, does not mean that anyone who actually knows what they're talking about is confused.

You started out by not understanding how reentry energy is managed, and have assiduously managed not to absorb the corrections offered you during this discussion. Now you're waving your hands about other things you don't understand, rather than taking a deep breath and deciding to learn something.
 
Last edited:
You have no idea what you are talking about. There was a camera in the Ascent Module looking out the window, and a camera attached to the Descent Module to relay the first step onto the surface. That's it. Apollos 15-17 were able, with varying success, to use a camera on the LRV to relay the Ascent Module takeoff.



You have no idea what you're talking about, again. There is an enormous amount of detailed design, test, performance, and analysis data available, freely available - more than you even imagine exists. The "missing tapes" contained nothing uniquely important to investigating Apollo, and in any case there were missions after Apollo 11.



I've understood the metric system and its various prefixes since grade school. What I don't understand is the point of your ugly abortion of a numbering system. It's as if you are trying to appear clever at the expense of being obfuscatory. Whatever your motivation, it doesn't help your argument at all.



Begging the question. There is no reason to assume either.



Nor has the American space program, which by stark contrast to the then-Soviet space program was open and thoroughly and publicly documented. You're undercutting your own argument.



The fact that you are confused, and that the incompetent and mendacious Mary Bennett is confused, does not mean that anyone who actually knows what they're talking about is confused.

You started out by not understanding how reentry energy is managed, and have assiduously managed not to absorb the corrections offered you during this discussion. Now you're waving your hands about other things you don't understand, rather than taking a deep breath and deciding to learn something.

The only good thing about these space program hoax threads is that I learn so much from your posts.
 
The only good thing about these space program hoax threads is that I learn so much from your posts.

Icketards once insisted the Lunar Rover batteries were insufficient, an excuse learn all about them so I could toss accurate pearls before swine.

Knowledge Is Power.
 
Very informative video. I was unaware that there was a zero g condition after the first re-entry phase. The video implied that during the zero g condition there wasn't a communication blackout. Is this true? Was the video made prior to any actual Apollo spacecraft re-entries?

I don't recall any details about this phase of the landing from Lovell's book Lost Moon. In the movie Apollo 13 Swigert is shown switching to manual control during a re-entry simulation; going too steep resulting in a failed re-entry. So everything was automatic unless the crew saw something going wrong then took manual control?
 
Last edited:
Nope. he wont. In hindsight, it occurs to me that hatloads of spy sats returned actual film cartridges as a matter of course. Wogoga must perforce claim all of those are fake too.
Literally hundreds of such recoveries.
 
A simplified and less confusing notation for numbers

international mile = …0003p1609344000… m = 3p1609.344 m ≈ 3p16 meter
foot = 0.3048 m = …9999n3048000… m = 9n3048 m ≈ 9n3 meter
nautical mile = 1852 m = …0003p1852000… m = 3p1852 m ≈ 3p185 meter



Mary Bennett makes great play in her piece on 'Aulis' (which should in itself be a clue that it's all a complete crock) that Tom Stafford claimed in his autobiography that his re-entry speed was 28547 mph, which is faster than a return from Mars. Here are her exact words:

"Tom Stafford (Apollo 10 again) asserted in his own 2002 biography We Have Capture that his entry speed was 28,547mph, which works out at 41,869ft/sec – faster than a return from Mars!"​

I have a copy of the book in front of me, and this is what it actually says:

Our trajectory was designed for the fastest return possible, allowing us to cover the 238,000 mile distance in 42 hours, rather than the usual 56 or more. This meant that at one point we reached a speed of 24,791.4 nautical miles (28547 statute miles) an hour, the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars.​

Wolfgang - do you see the subtle difference there between what Bennett claimed was written and what was actually written?


Statute mile: 5280 feet = 3p5280 ∙ 9n3048 m = 3p1609 meter = international mile

According to Mary Bennett, Apollo 10 astronaut Tom Stafford "claimed in his autobiography that his re-entry speed was 28547 mph". The unit mph = miles per hour is based on international mile (3p1609 meter). In order to convert the value attributed by Bennett to Stafford to International System of Units (i.e. to meter per second), we must at first multiply this value 4p28547 mph with factor 3p1609 m/s per mph. The result 7p4594 meter/hour = 107 ∙ 4.594 m/s must then be divided by 3600 sec/hour:

7p4594 m/h / 3p36 s/h = 4p1276 m/s = 12.76 km/s​

According to those who call Bennett a liar, maximum speed was "24,791.4 nautical miles (28547 statute miles) an hour". So someone not being familiar with nautical mile will simply use the statute mile value 4p28547 which is what Mary Bennett seems to have done. And this value results in 4p1276 m/s = 12.76 km/s.

Obviously, such a speed v is highly unlikely. If we use unit meter, second and kg then we directly get Joule per kg (kinetic potential): potkin = ½ v2 = 7p8143 Joule/kg. Kinetic potential corresponding to terrestrial escape velocity is only potesc = ½ vesc2 = 7p6257 Joule/kg. To the difference Δpot = potkin - potesc = 7p1886 J/kg corresponds speed v = √(2 Δpot) = 3p614 m/s. This means that the spacecraft would have already had a velocity of around 6 km/s before falling back on the Earth.

The value "24,791.4 nautical miles" of Tom Stafford results in 4p1108 m/s = 11.08 km/s and is between the values given for Apollo 10 in Entry, Splashdown, and Recovery: 36,314 ft/sec = 4p1107 m/s = 11.07 km/s and 36,397 ft/sec = 4p1109 m/s = 11.09 km/s.

Such a reentry speed 4p1108 m/s may seem not exceptional enough to justify Stafford's statement "the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars".

Why all this confusion with foot, mile, nautical mile and statute mile resp. international mile? In my opinion part of the answer is given by Mary Bennett:

"[O]ne might also conclude that the intention is to confuse any layman examining Apollo."​


Bennett is a self-proclaimed psychic. She has no training at all in aerospace matters, and no experience. I wish I could count the number of times I've caught her in bald-faced lies and fabricated "research." Naturally neither she nor her sometimes co-author David Percy will debate me directly. They know they're lying.


The fact that Mary Bennett considers herself a psychic is as irrelevant as my belief in panpsychism. She also may have been misled into believing that Albert Einstein was a plagiarist (#122). I do believe in Einstein's honesty. Nevertheless I respect other opinions.

And the question whether Bennett has (officially recognized) training in aerospace matters seems less important to me than the question of whether she has common sense.

Please let me know what kind of dishonesty you are able to sense in Bennett's article.

Cheers, Wolfgang
 
Last edited:
Look up, wogoga. That thing flying over your head is the point.

Bennett claimed that Stafford said the re-entry speed was "faster than a return from Mars". Stafford actually said that the re-entry speed was "the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars." Honest people can see the difference between these statements. Why can't you?

As for confusing laymen, one of the best ways is to make up a new, non-standard, mathematical notation and intersperse it with a modified usage of normal mathematical notation. I see you're expressing numbers in scientific form now, but with the exponent preceding the mantissa. Since scientific notation is perfectly workable, universally used, and functionally equivalent to the two modifications of it that you're using indiscriminately, why would you do such a thing except to confuse?

The inability of the USA to use the metric system, by the way, is a well-known irritation to scientists of all countries. It apparently serves mainly to confuse Americans.

Dave
 
<snip for brevity>

Bennett simply does exactly what she accuses others of doing, i.e. conflating and munging unrelated facts together into a kind of opaque pea soup of ignorance in the hope of confusing the reader. In fact, that is exactly what you yourself are doing with your non-standard notation and nautical mile red herring.

In your post linked above you have lobbed in units of feet, meters, statute miles, nautical miles, international miles, kilometers, miles per hour, international miles per hour, nautical miles per hour, statute miles per hour, feet per second, meters per second, seconds per hour, kilometers per second, Joules per kilogramme in a morass of incoherent stream of consciousness writing. Oddly, just like Bennett, you saw fit to include fabricated quotes as well.

There is not a bit of common sense in that. It is either wild delusion or abject ignorance of the subject matter at hand or intentional obfuscation.
 
The fact that Mary Bennett considers herself a psychic is as irrelevant...

No. People who make outrageous claims do not deserve the presumption of credibility you have given her.

ETA: It is important to realize that Bennett does not consider her alleged psychic powers and mystical knowledge irrelevant. A great deal of Dark Moon is taken up in her efforts to connect faked Apollo missions to a whole grab-bag of mystical beliefs and claims. While she may not specifically mention the alleged mystical connections in her article in question, insofar as the article is meant to support her claim that Apollo was faked it is meant to support her specific claims about psychic powers and mysticism.

And the question whether Bennett has (officially recognized) training in aerospace matters seems less important to me than the question of whether she has common sense.

That's just wrong. You have cited Bennett as if she has some sort of expertise we should recognize. She does not. You inserted the parenthetical "(officially recognized)," which was not part of my argument. She has no expertise in aerospace whatsoever, "official" or not. She has been invited to demonstrate any expertise she may have in a setting outside her control. She has refused. This is indicative of deliberate deception.

Common sense is irrelevant. When you're sick, do you go to a trained and licensed physician, or just someone who has "common sense" but no expertise in medicine? Further, even if common sense were relevant and even if Bennett could demonstrate common sense, she has demonstrated her willingness to lie for the sake of her publications. When someone is untrained, dishonest, and makes outrageous claims, that is not a trustworthy source.

Please let me know what kind of dishonesty you are able to sense in Bennett's article.

Asked and answered. She is professing that her inability to understand a difficult subject in a field she knows nothing about, and reconcile two apparently contradictory positions, should be attributed to something wrong with Apollo instead of her own incompetence. So are you.
 
Last edited:
Look up, wogoga. That thing flying over your head is the point.

Bennett claimed that Stafford said the re-entry speed was "faster than a return from Mars". Stafford actually said that the re-entry speed was "the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars." Honest people can see the difference between these statements. Why can't you?

As for confusing laymen, one of the best ways is to make up a new, non-standard, mathematical notation and intersperse it with a modified usage of normal mathematical notation. I see you're expressing numbers in scientific form now, but with the exponent preceding the mantissa. Since scientific notation is perfectly workable, universally used, and functionally equivalent to the two modifications of it that you're using indiscriminately, why would you do such a thing except to confuse?

The inability of the USA to use the metric system, by the way, is a well-known irritation to scientists of all countries. It apparently serves mainly to confuse Americans.

Dave

American scientists and engineers are perfectly happy to use metric. Ronald Reagan (spit!) discontinued Pres. Carter's metrification (modernization) of the US, for which I hope he burns in imaginary hell forever.
 
Look up, wogoga. That thing flying over your head is the point.

Bennett claimed that Stafford said the re-entry speed was "faster than a return from Mars". Stafford actually said that the re-entry speed was "the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars." Honest people can see the difference between these statements. Why can't you?

As for confusing laymen, one of the best ways is to make up a new, non-standard, mathematical notation and intersperse it with a modified usage of normal mathematical notation. I see you're expressing numbers in scientific form now, but with the exponent preceding the mantissa. Since scientific notation is perfectly workable, universally used, and functionally equivalent to the two modifications of it that you're using indiscriminately, why would you do such a thing except to confuse?

The inability of the USA to use the metric system, by the way, is a well-known irritation to scientists of all countries. It apparently serves mainly to confuse Americans.

Dave
Most of us, even old farts like myself, have no issues with mks, English, or fsf units, as long as they are consistent. Please don't perpetuate that myth.
As for wogoga using his ********** up notation, it's part of the new idea of self-defining of terms that allows backtracking and 180 degree turns without changimg anything you have written!
 
Wogoga, your "simplified and less confusing" scheme is neither. It's just a rearrangement and relabeling of existing notations, but more complicated. No amount of colored fonts will rescue your scheme from irrelevance. Nor will crowding your posts with endless and pointless conversions from one system to another. I think it's hilarious that you approvingly quote Bennett about "intention to confuse" when you pile up pointless stuff like this in your posts, and she bounces around incoherently from secondary to tertiary source and dishonestly misstates Stafford's point about entry speeds.

None of this should be construed as forgetting that you don't understand how the blunt-body entry works, have avoided being educate on it, and have no clue as to the actual scientific and technical Apollo record - not just the superficial mess of secondary and tertiary accounts, and statements made decades after the events, the incompetent and mendacious Bennett uses to whip up false "controversy" for the gullible.
 
Most of us, even old farts like myself, have no issues with mks, English, or fsf units, as long as they are consistent. Please don't perpetuate that myth.

Agreed. Consistent usage is, in my opinion, far more important than which system you work in, and I'm happy to work in any units you hand me. But EES vs. SI is always a rancorous debate, especially where interoperability is concerned, and serves only to ruffle feathers, so I'm not going to make any noise like I want to start that debate up.

As for wogoga using his ********** up notation, it's part of the new idea of self-defining of terms that allows backtracking and 180 degree turns without changimg anything you have written!

No disagreement there, but additionally wogoga's argument fits a pattern in Apollo hoax argumentation to which I've alluded before. Some claimant dusts off his long-forgotten high school physics and pretends he's "proven" by his own simplistic means that Apollo can't have come off as advertised. The cobbled-up notation derives from the claimant's utter ignorance of how the field actually notates its knowledge, contrasted with his need to sound credible. A good idea of how well someone knows a field can be gained from seeing whether the claimant knows the language of the field or has to make up his own terms to represent it.

Unless the claimant is in favorable company, sooner or later he'll be in over his head. Once his personal expertise and Googled-up sources are exhausted, he switches to claiming expertise is irrelevant and only common sense is needed to see Apollo's alleged folly. That's usually followed by devolving into a political discussion: "whom do you trust?" etc.
 
simplified and less confusing notation for numbers
A deluded (because the notation is more confusing :eye-poppi!) person advertising their personal notation for numbers is irrelevant to this thread, wogoga.

According to the ignorant and deluded Mary Bennett the Apollo missions did not happen, wogoga, so citing a Moon hoax crank is not good.

We call Mary Bennett a liar because Mary Bennett lied as shown by threadworm in what you quoted :jaw-dropp!
The assertion "faster than a return from Mars" is not what Tom Stafford wrote in his book which was "the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars". The latter statement was that the reentry was slower than a future return from Mars.

We call your post an argument from an ignorant and deluded source. And an argument from ignorance. A rational person would not trust a Moon hoax crank web site. They would learn about actual figures for reentry velocities and thus "such a speed v is highly unlikely" is a ignorant statement.

A smart person would learn that feet, mile, nautical mile and statute mile are all units of length. They would learn the basic arithmetic to convert between them. The usage of nautical miles is probably because some astronauts had Navy backgrounds , e.g. Tom Stafford earned a Bachelor of Science degree with honors in 1952 from the United States Naval Academy, Annapolis, Maryland.

The idiotic "notation" and crazy colors hide that you do cite a credible source, wogoga. Entry, Splashdown, and Recovery lists the Maximum Entry Velocity for Apollo 7 to 17 and shows that Tom Stafford was telling the truth. 36,397 feet/second = 24,816.136 miles per hour = 39,937.7 kilometers per hour. It took to the 1970's to get the flight airspeed record past 3500 kilometers per hour. That is a tenth of the reentry velocity. Likewise List of vehicle speed records supports Tom Stafford.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom