Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

Unlike Apollo, no confusion prevails on how the Chinese succeeded in landing the return module on Earth (and in resolving other challenges,...
Your inability to understand and your confusion does not prevail, wogoga. :jaw-dropp!.

Anyone who can read knows that there is no confusion in how Apollo missions succeeded in landing their missions.
 
Last edited:
wogoga said:
Unlike Apollo, no confusion prevails on how the Chinese succeeded in landing the return module on Earth (and in resolving other challenges, see).

There is no confusion about how Apollo command modules landed on Earth. You may not understand it, but please do not project your ignorance onto everyone else.

wogoga said:
In comparison to Apollo, the Chinese had not only the advantage of 45 years of technological progress, but also of an economy much stronger than in the United States of the 1960s.

You have no idea what you're talking about.

Leaving aside your dubious economic claim, I will first point out that the Chinese also had the heavily-documented engineering history of Apollo and its precursors (not to mention Soyuz and its precursors) on which to draw. The pioneering work had already been done in this regard, which takes nothing away from the Chinese engineers, scientists, and technicians.

That said, your comparison makes it sound like they solved a problem which couldn't have been solved before, which is ridiculous. I used to work for the guys who designed the Apollo command module. That design drew upon knowledge gained from Mercury and Gemini. (I still have a lithograph, signed by Caldwell Johnson, of his original Mercury concept drawing.)

wogoga said:
If US landing of humans on the moon actually were a hoax then it would have been an incredibly ingenious way to steal from the "evil communists" the honor of having first landed on a celestial body. By redefining "landing on the moon" by "landing men on the moon" with their propaganda machine,...

A manned lunar landing was always going to carry the most prestige, and the Soviets killed a lot of people trying to achieve that before they finally gave up. You can beat up that strawman all you like, but the fact is that a successful program had the desired effect, and unlike a fake program could actually be done.

The rest of your sociopolitical screed is immaterial, because the landings actually happened. Handwaving about capitalist this and propaganda that won't rescue your fundamentally broken claims. Instead, I recommend aying attention to the people trying to educate you.
 
The Apollo moon landings and returns were BY FAR the most documented explorations and returns of lunar samples (plus astronauts) of any that you cite.


Indeed. There are thousands of still image photographs, and dozens of hours of motion picture footage and recorded television broadcasts, of the missions.



A manned lunar landing was always going to carry the most prestige, and the Soviets killed a lot of people trying to achieve that before they finally gave up.


After the fact the Russians said they were never really going for the Moon, but that wasn't actually true. They most certainly had ambitions to score a manned lunar landing, but their attempt suffered from a shortage of resources, competing programs, and a lack of focus. The site Encyclopedia Astronautica has a wealth of information on the various Soviet lunar landing programs, including photographs of the hardware. This page at the site gives an overview of the Russian lunar programs that were considered.
 
<gibber snip?
If US landing of humans on the moon actually were a hoax then it would have been an incredibly ingenious way to steal from the "evil communists" the honor of having first landed on a celestial body.
Except any such fakery would have been utterly obvious to said "evil communists"; that's why no-one outside of a few scientifically illiterate cranks belies in such nonsense.
 
Except any such fakery would have been utterly obvious to said "evil communists"...

The Soviets even captured one of the boilerplate CMs that landed off-target, used specifically to test the re-entry system. Obviously it was eventually repatriated to the United States, but not before the Soviets got a good look at how NASA planned to re-enter the atmosphere at cislunar transfer speeds.
 
In the four decades after Luna 24, only four "Far Earth" sample return missions have been completed, and only one single succeeded in safely landing an extremely small cargo (i.e. dust particles):

Bonus points for following this with a list of four missions, only three of which left Earth orbit, (even the ESA wouldn't claim that a Mars probe stranded in LEO was "completed") and where samples were recovered from all three.

You seem to have a basic reading comprehension problem.
 
The Soviets even captured one of the boilerplate CMs that landed off-target, used specifically to test the re-entry system. Obviously it was eventually repatriated to the United States, but not before the Soviets got a good look at how NASA planned to re-enter the atmosphere at cislunar transfer speeds.
Plus they monitored communications and telemetry, and tracked the progress of the missions. It's utter nonsense to suggest that the missions were fakes, not that mere reality even stopped a woo with an obsession.
 
Plus they monitored communications and telemetry, and tracked the progress of the missions.

No question about that. The Soviets employed myriad techniques to spy on Apollo during development and flight.

But in the special context of this thread, the capture of an actual boilerplate CM is irrecoverable. If the plan was to build a spacecraft and tell everyone it could withstand a return from the Moon, the last thing you should allow is for your opponent to capture a specimen of the spacecraft. The Soviet engineers were quite capable of determining whether the heat shield on the BP CM would live up to U.S. claims.
 
The Apollo moon landings and returns were BY FAR the most documented explorations and returns of lunar samples (plus astronauts) of any that you cite. Far, far more through multiple independent documentations than any of the other missions you cite.


I would rather call it over-documented. One gets almost the impression that a reporter team was already on the Moon in order to document arrival and departure of Apollo 11. With modern technology it would probably be a child's play to analyze the original documentations (especially the films). Yet essential parts of the original documentations are unavailable for independent analysis, have disappeared, or have maybe even been preventively destroyed (Apollo 11 missing tapes).


Also I have some trouble understanding your nomenclature: 170 grams is 0.17 E-3 kilograms, or 170 E-5 kilograms.


In past days I have become astonished at learning how many people do not even know that mega corresponds to million. At least according to what you write here, also you seem to get confused by orders of magnitude and measurement units with auxiliary numbers such as kilo. 170 gram = 0.17 kg is neither 0.17E-3 kg nor 170E-5 kg:

0.17E-3 = 0.17 ∙ 10-3 = 9n17 ∙ 7n1 = 6n17 = 0.00017 kg
170E-5 = 170 ∙ 10-5 = 2p17 = 5n1 = 7n17 = 0.0017 kg​

What is the 2n17 kilograms in your nomenclature?


2n17 = 10-10+2 ∙ 1.7 = 10-8 ∙ 1.7


If you wish to use non-standard notation, fine. What do I care.
But you cannot even get that correct, so what does that tell us?
170 gram is plainly not 9n17 kg no matter how you slice it.


The sequence "100, 10, 1, 0.1, 0.01, 0.001" in A simplified and less confusing notation for numbers: "2p1, 1p1, 0p1, 9n1, 8n1, 7n1".

Rocks are not sensitive to temperature and ...

Care to visit a volcano or two?


Do you suggest that difference in sensitivity to temperature is not relevant between humans and rocks?

Cheers, Wolfgang
 
I would rather call it over-documented.
That is one hell of a shift of goalposts. Now there is too much documentation therefore it is fake? Really?

One gets almost the impression that a reporter team was already on the Moon in order to document arrival and departure of Apollo 11.
Camera deployed before egress by NA. Attached to the LM externally. Why do you not know the basics?

With modern technology it would probably be a child's play to analyze the original documentations (especially the films).
Decades of further development will do that. Did you have a point to make?

Yet essential parts of the original documentations are unavailable for independent analysis, have disappeared, or have maybe even been preventively destroyed (Apollo 11 missing tapes).
Were the Apollo 12 tapes destroyed? How about Apollo 13? 14? 15? 16? 17?

Even then the notion is stupid. Plenty of copies exist.


In past days I have become astonished at learning how many people do not even know that mega corresponds to million.

At least according to what you write here, also you seem to get confused by orders of magnitude and measurement units with auxiliary numbers such as kilo. 170 gram = 0.17 kg is neither 0.17E-3 kg nor 170E-5 kg:

0.17E-3 = 0.17 ∙ 10-3 = 9n17 ∙ 7n1 = 6n17 = 0.00017 kg
170E-5 = 170 ∙ 10-5 = 2p17 = 5n1 = 7n17 = 0.0017 kg​
A pretty rich claim given that you have been several times corrected for that very error in this very thread. You claimed it was 1.7E-9


The sequence "100, 10, 1, 0.1, 0.01, 0.001" in A simplified and less confusing notation for numbers: "2p1, 1p1, 0p1, 9n1, 8n1, 7n1".
As I said, using non-standard notation is simple obfuscation. It can be nothing but intentional. That said, I reserve the right to point out the egregious mathematical errors.


Do you suggest that difference in sensitivity to temperature is not relevant between humans and rocks?
The temperature of what, precisely?

Cheers, Wolfgang
Faux politeness does not cut the mustard.
 
I would rather call it over-documented. One gets almost the impression that a reporter team was already on the Moon in order to document arrival and departure of Apollo 11. With modern technology it would probably be a child's play to analyze the original documentations (especially the films). Yet essential parts of the original documentations are unavailable for independent analysis, have disappeared, or have maybe even been preventively destroyed (Apollo 11 missing tapes).





In past days I have become astonished at learning how many people do not even know that mega corresponds to million. At least according to what you write here, also you seem to get confused by orders of magnitude and measurement units with auxiliary numbers such as kilo. 170 gram = 0.17 kg is neither 0.17E-3 kg nor 170E-5 kg:

0.17E-3 = 0.17 ∙ 10-3 = 9n17 ∙ 7n1 = 6n17 = 0.00017 kg
170E-5 = 170 ∙ 10-5 = 2p17 = 5n1 = 7n17 = 0.0017 kg​




2n17 = 10-10+2 ∙ 1.7 = 10-8 ∙ 1.7





The sequence "100, 10, 1, 0.1, 0.01, 0.001" in A simplified and less confusing notation for numbers: "2p1, 1p1, 0p1, 9n1, 8n1, 7n1".






Do you suggest that difference in sensitivity to temperature is not relevant between humans and rocks?

Cheers, Wolfgang

1. Sure- it is suspicious because it is too documented (which is the 180 degree twist you are now executing). The more evidence, the more people who participated, the more people who saw it live, the more photos, the more audio recordings, the more physical artifacts the LESS likely it actually happened. And despite the stupid loss of some of the Apollo 11 tapes, many copies remain and the original materials for the subsequent Apollos have been well preserved.

Whereas secretive programs by notoriously unforthcoming governments with virtually no actual documentation are convincing to you. Okay...

2. Your nomenclature is absolutely bonkers, completely confusing and inherently illogical. Why on Earth (pun intended) do you persist when the remainder of the world agrees on a very clear and highly adaptable nomenclature?

I agree, 170 g is 0.17 kg which is 170 x 10^-3 kg (of course it makes more sense to express kg as 10^3 grams and sorry for the error in my rapid reply to you). But that was a hasty mistake on my part in trying to link standard scientific notation to and make any sense of your own nomenclature.

Reread my point- I never implied that people and rocks have the same sensitivity to temperature- only that even rocks were recovered so as to not exceed temperatures that would have changed their properties to render them scientifically useless. And your scenario would have the rocks, as well as the recovery vehicle itself, not just altered but vaporized.

I return to a statement in my prior post- I very much doubt you are actually not understanding these points and my conclusion is that seeking to "correct" your views by providing this type of actual information is meaningless.
 
Last edited:
I would rather call it over-documented. ....
The Apollo and other missions up to including the ISS are documented mainly because they are publically funded. Moon hoax woo about the fact that some tapes were "lost" (actually thought to have been reused) does not impress anyone.

Your personal notion for numbers is useless because you are the only person using it here. All it does is make irrelevant math even more irrelevant.
 
It seems fairly clear to me that, because adiabatic compression takes place at greater distances from the falling object, the process of heat transfer into the falling object must be much less efficient than viscous drag.


"The peak g stage will occur once it hits the thick part of the atmosphere at around 65 km altitude." (GPIS 6: Reentry)

Pressure at around 65 km = 4p65 m altitude: 10 Pascal = 1p1 Newton/m2.

Mean free path at 10 Pascal (medium vacuum): in the order of 1 mm = 0.001 m = 7n1 meter. For comparison mean free path at ambient pressure: 68 nm = 68 ∙ 1n1 m = 2n68 m ≈ 2n7 m ≈ 3n1 m ≈ 10-7 m.

"As an object encounters the atmosphere, air cannot move out of the way due to the hypersonic velocity, and instead it piles up ahead of the object and compresses into a shock wave." (#68).

An air particle colliding with the heat shield of the reentry module gets a huge impulse (off the shield). Yet the particle cannot leave the region close to the 12 m2 heat shield easily, because mean free path even in front of the highly compressed shock wave is only 1 mm = 7n1 meter.

Cheers, Wolfgang
Many prefer being further duped to admitting to themselves that they have been duped
 
"The peak g stage will occur once it hits the thick part of the atmosphere at around 65 km altitude." (GPIS 6: Reentry)

Pressure at around 65 km = 4p65 m altitude: 10 Pascal = 1p1 Newton/m2.

Mean free path at 10 Pascal (medium vacuum): in the order of 1 mm = 0.001 m = 7n1 meter. For comparison mean free path at ambient pressure: 68 nm = 68 ∙ 1n1 m = 2n68 m ≈ 2n7 m ≈ 3n1 m ≈ 10-7 m.

"As an object encounters the atmosphere, air cannot move out of the way due to the hypersonic velocity, and instead it piles up ahead of the object and compresses into a shock wave." (#68).

An air particle colliding with the heat shield of the reentry module gets a huge impulse (off the shield). Yet the particle cannot leave the region close to the 12 m2 heat shield easily, because mean free path even in front of the highly compressed shock wave is only 1 mm = 7n1 meter.

Cheers, Wolfgang
Many prefer being further duped to admitting to themselves that they have been duped
Breathtakingly wrong. You are not even trying, are you?
 
An air particle colliding with the heat shield of the reentry module gets a huge impulse (off the shield). Yet the particle cannot leave the region close to the 12 m2 heat shield easily, because mean free path even in front of the highly compressed shock wave is only 1 mm.

"An air particle colliding with the heat shield" is therefore an event that can only occur for air particles within that mean free path once the shock wave forms, and much of the momentum transfer is therefore due to collisions between atoms elsewhere, spreading out the region is which heat generated. You may also like to consider what mechanisms exist for heat loss from that region other than conductive transfer into the falling body. Looking at some pictures may suggest one of them; the glowing streak that precedes the capsule at re-entry clearly shows considerable energy loss due to radiation, most of which is not directed back into the capsule.

Dave
 
First they whine that there isn't enough information, then they whine that there's too much....
 
An air particle colliding with the heat shield of the reentry module gets a huge impulse (off the shield).

This does not describe the actual flow regime.

Many prefer being further duped to admitting to themselves that they have been duped

Many people prefer to cling to their individual delusions of grandeur than admit the rest of the world has been right all along.
 
Air particles would not impact the heat shield.

Evaporation/degradation gasses cooking off of the heat shield:
a)blanket the surface with a layer of outflowing gasses, like arc welding rod coating, preventing hot, compressed atmosphere from transferring heat to the shield and oxidizing the capsule beyond limits, and
b)prevent the temperature of the heat shield itself from rising above the evaporation temperature of the epoxy, like water keeping the soup from scorching.


It's called an ablative heat shield for a reason, wogoga. And that reason is that the heat shield ablates.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom