Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

Rather the opposite happens in reality: The steeper the reentry angle is, the faster a lower altitude is reached and the more acute is the overheat problem.

Correct. For the steeper end of the Apollo entry angle, the flight profile called for descent into denser atmosphere until maximum safe heating was attained, followed by an ascent into rare air to allow the heat shield to cool down before the next descent.

Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface.

No. As stated, meteors are at terminal velocity. While meteors tend to be dense objects, engineered spacecraft by comparison are not, nor are many other things we have recovered from accidental entry, including human remains.

In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.

As others have stated, you seem to be wrongly assuming the entirety of the heat generated by atmospheric entry must be borne and rejected by the entrant, and only be certain specific means. There are a variety of means available for preventing heat generated by motion through a compressible fluid from damaging or destroying an engineered object.
 
... the spacecraft can skip across the atmosphere, gaining heat with each bounce and burn up before actual reentry, wogoga.

But be careful. The "skipping across the atmosphere" analogy is bad. It is not really like skipping a stone across a still pond surface. That misconception arises because we habitually plot trajectories on graphs in terms of geodetic altitude versus geodetic distance downrage omitting that in fact range is around the curved surface of the Earth, not the flat domain of the x-axis.

The entry trajectory is simply an orbit that intersects the sphere of the atmosphere at certain angles for certain densities, forming a smooth transition from orbital flight to atmospheric flight. The intersection with a drag medium may fail to slow the velocity enough to fully transition, but the path out the other side is still governed principally by orbital dynamics, not fluid dynamics. The path looks like an orbit in true 3D geometry. It only looks like "skipping out" of the air on the geodetic altitude graph, which is not a true picture of the actual trajectory.

If the drag medium is not sufficiently dense, and orbital mechanics prevails, then the effect naturally is to lower the orbital apogee. But in practical terms it is not likely that the next perigee will occur any time soon.
 
Correct. For the steeper end of the Apollo entry angle, the flight profile called for descent into denser atmosphere until maximum safe heating was attained, followed by an ascent into rare air to allow the heat shield to cool down before the next descent.

I did not know this. (To be fair, I did not know a lot of what you've posted, I just wanted to pick this one out :))

It did this aerodynamically? I seem to recall the COG being offset so they could rotate the capsule and change the angle of attack?
 
It did this aerodynamically?

Yes. The Apollo CM is a blunt-cone lifting body.

I seem to recall the COG being offset so they could rotate the capsule and change the angle of attack?

Yes, the c.g. and COP are separated by about 30 cm in order to create the angle of attack that generates lift. In a nominal descent the spacecraft rotates slowly so that the lift vector averages around the nominal track in a corkscrew fashion. Held constant by roll commands, the angle of attack could produce the lift necessary for the steep-entry profile.
 
This might be an interesting read.

I was looking for the reentry diagram with the bump in it, but this one shows the shuttle one as well for comparison.
 
As stated, meteors are at terminal velocity. While meteors tend to be dense objects, engineered spacecraft by comparison are not, nor are many other things we have recovered from accidental entry, including human remains.

Having toured the Columbia Recovery Room, which is in the Vehicle Assembly Building at KSC, I can attest to this; although aerodynamic forces caused the disintegration of the Orbiter, many subassemblies and components were recovered largely intact. (The recovery, by teams of dedicated NASA team members and volunteers in often miserable conditions, is a rather heroic story in its own right.)

As others have stated, you seem to be wrongly assuming the entirety of the heat generated by atmospheric entry must be borne and rejected by the entrant, and only be certain specific means. There are a variety of means available for preventing heat generated by motion through a compressible fluid from damaging or destroying an engineered object.

An example not mentioned in this thread is that of the heat sources used in RTGs. The aeroshells use a 3D graphitized carbon weave material, similar to that used in ICBM reentry vehicles, for ablation, but are also designed to tumble during reentry to smear the heat load evenly. They are designed to contain the isotope fuel in a terminal-velocity impact.
 
At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction, i.e. kinetic energy of an object is transformed into heat by more or less direct contact.

No, that is wrong. Drag and friction have little to do with the heat produced during reentry. Here is a link to some (mostly) good explanations: https://www.quora.com/Why-does-a-spacecraft-heat-up-during-reentry


Quotes from Why does a spacecraft heat up during reentry? concerning the use of "friction":

"When a spacecraft reenters, very little heat is generated by friction."

"Many people think that it's due to friction with air passing over the surface of the re-entering vehicle, but that's actually a relatively minor component. Most of the heating comes from the fact that, when you slam into a column of air really hard, really fast, it compresses; and when you compress air, it heats up. And that heat will be transferred, by direct conduction, to the object doing the compressing – i.e., the spacecraft."

"It has nothing to do with friction."

"This speed is reduced entirely through friction (drag) of the atmosphere. The thicker the atmosphere, the more the friction."

"The important thing is the above simulation is run without considering any friction (no viscous effects)."

"The compression friction heats the air."

"If the vehicle is slowed down by an ablating heat shield, it is friction with the air that heats up the shield."
​

A reasonable answer seems to me the second one:

"The reason why objects without a heat shield or entering the atmosphere uncontrolled incinerate is simply due to the fact air can't get out of their way fast enough. … As an object encounters the atmosphere, air cannot move out of the way due to the hypersonic velocity, and instead it piles up ahead of the object and compresses into a shock wave. The gases there are compressed rapidly enough to heat up to 20,000 degrees or more [Fahrenheit?], and because of that the radiant heat from the shock wave starts to heat up the incoming object. The heat will either melt or vaporize any material exposed to the shock wave, and since aluminum is used heavily in the construction of spacecraft, the spacecraft tears apart and the pieces melt or vaporize."​

Yet the first answer (of a "NASA engineer that has worked spacecraft operations design), seems rather illogical to me. Here two quotes:

"Through making the reentry vehicle blunt, air can't 'get out of the way' quickly enough, and acts as an air cushion to push the shock wave and heated shock layer forward. Since most of the hot gases are no longer in direct contact with the vehicle, the heat energy would stay in the shocked gas and simply move around the vehicle to later dissipate into the atmosphere."

"Plasma, known as the fourth state of matter, does not conform to the gas laws of conventional thermodynamics, although it does share one familiar property, – a proportionality between pressure and temperature in a contained system. The formation of the pressure wave, therefore, also creates extreme temperatures. The plasma stream is electrostatically-charged too, and so it concentrates at acute surface contours. The resultant effect is particularly intense local heating at the airframe's leading edges.
​

If we have proportionality between pressure and temperature, then why isn't temperature highest, where pressure is highest? And pressure obviously is the higher, the closer to the heat shield, isn't it?


And there's another critical error in your thinking. It seems fairly clear to me that, because adiabatic compression takes place at greater distances from the falling object, the process of heat transfer into the falling object must be much less efficient than viscous drag. As a result, a much larger proportion of the energy loss goes into heating the air around the falling object, and a much smaller proportion into heating the object itself, than one would expect from viscous drag. Your unspoken suggestion that all the kinetic energy lost is converted into thermal energy in the falling body, as embodied in your calculation of what you expect its heating to be, is therefore completely specious.


Once again: All Apollo modules re-entered atmosphere with a speed quite close to escape velocity from Earth: v = 11.186 km/s ≈ 4p11 m/s, corresponding to a kinetic energy of Ekin = v2 /2 ≈ 62.6 Mega-Joule per kg ≈ 7p6 J/kg. If we assume an average heat capacity of 1 kJ/kg/K (and 100% efficient heat transfer) then the heat released during atmospheric deceleration would be enough to heat up the return module of 5.5 tons = 3p55 kg by around 60 000 Kelvin = 4p6 K.

Thus, even if as much as 99.9% = 9n999 of the energy were used to heat up only the atmosphere and the vaporizing heat shield, the remaining 0.1% = 7n1 = 9n001 would still be enough to heat the whole return module on average by 60 Kelvin = 1p6 K.

So the reproach that my argument is based on "assuming the entirety of the heat generated by atmospheric entry must be borne and rejected by the entrant" (#61) is rather unfounded.

Please imagine concretely: Every single kilogram of the return module releases as much heat as 4 kg rocket fuel do, if it is simply burned! And no action-at-a-distance can heat the atmosphere without affecting the landing module at the same time.

Cheers, Wolfgang
Nitpicking often results from lack of genuine objections
 
Not Apollo 7 and 9.

Ranb

I guess he has to bridge the gaffe of using escape velocity where it doesn't belong. Yes, all the Apollo vehicles entered at a certain velocity and a certain trajectory particular to each mission. Any correspondence between the entry velocity and Earth's escape velocity is purely coincidental. I honestly fail to grasp the mystique that "escape velocity" seems to play in lay literature. It has almost no practical application in real-life astrodynamics. Velocities are flown according to orbital principles, not by some toy-problem flight of fancy.

And yes, wogoga has grasped the concept that not all heat theoretically generated in the entry is generated in or transferred to the spacecraft. But why all the "If we assume..." ? It's not as if the TPS design for the command module is a national security secret. Nor are the qualitative advantages of ablation-type shielding a mystery. The number of times Apollo TPS principles have been reverse-engineered in the classroom boggles the mind.

Using the total spacecraft mass at entry is a red herring. Some parts of the ship (i.e., the ablatant) got very hot while others stayed relatively cool. Thermal design is all about controlling heat conduction paths in an engineered object. In designs for entry vehicles it's about insulating the shield from structure. In contrast, in designs for comm satellites it's about conveying the heat from the lit side to the dark side so that it can radiate away effectively.

Automotive brakes convert kinetic energy to heat as well, but you don't use the whole mass of the car to estimate a temperature. The shoes and rotor heat up -- quite a lot, if you've ever accidentally touched a recently driven car's brake rotor. But the whole car doesn't. If you run the numbers for airliner brakes you come up with enough heat to melt the rotor. Does that mean airliner brakes are suspicious? No, it means that your model is inaccurate -- airliners in fact use multiple rotors per shaft. And to continue the qualitative difference, the rotors are designed to continue to provide braking effect even at the point of thermal failure. This is how the worst-case scenario (a rejected takeoff) is handled. The brakes will stop the plane short of runway end, but they're useless thereafter as brakes and must be replaced. Apollo's TPS was sacrificial. The STS orbiter's was not. When you accept that qualitative change in design goals, you can reap different rewards.

Throwing around gross numbers and estimating coefficients works well for elementary education, but doesn't describe the actual problem. Proper engineering is the devil in the details. As a matter of fact, a typical payload fairing may reach 90 C from aerodynamic heating during the boost. Not that this presents any special engineering problem, but it illustrates that you don't use the entire launch vehicle mass. The fairing is 90 C or so at the tip, 30 C or so along the side, and 0 C (at altitude) at the ring.

I struggle to see what point, if any, wogoga is trying to make. He seems to be dancing around the idea that Apollo atmospheric entries are suspicious for some reason having to with thermal loading. Arguments by analogies to other entrants are not really valid, as the devil is in the details that differ. Arguments by gross aggregation are not really valid, as the devil is in the details that defy averaging and aggregation.
 
Quotes from Why does a spacecraft heat up during reentry? concerning the use of "friction":
This is what you wrote: In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat.... You have cited sources that say that you were wrong, wogoga!

What heats up the air is the compression of the air by the spacecraft. This is the basic physics of the ideal gas law (PV=nRT) where if V is decreased then P and/or T have to increase. This is not friction. Heat radiates in all directions - some of the radiant heat heats up the spacecraft.

Please imagine concretely that you learn the physics of reentry :p.
 
Last edited:
Wogoga,

Your cooker produces prodigious amounts of heat.

Why can you not use it to heat your home?

Because refrigerated food is cold and absorbs the fire. That's why you don't leave meat on the counter to warm before cooking. If the meat cannot absorb the fire you can burn your house down.



:boxedin:
 
Forty years anniversary LUNA-24 returning 170 gram lunar rock on 22 Aug 1976

Luna 24 with launch date 9 Aug 1976 and recovery data 22 Aug 1976 was the last successful lunar sample return mission. According to Wikipedia, this was the third success in eleven attempts of the Soviets to bring down small amounts of moon rock to Earth. The task of returning 170 gram = 9n17 kg of moon rock is incomparably easier than of returning humans whose net weight alone is 200 kg = 2p2 kg or more. Rocks are not sensitive to temperature and high g's (decelerations). And we can take into consideration that the Soviets had been leading in space technology over many years.

In the four decades after Luna 24, only four "Far Earth" sample return missions have been completed, and only one single succeeded in safely landing an extremely small cargo (i.e. dust particles):

  • Stardust: It successfully reentered in 2006 with a peak deceleration of 34 g = 333 m/s2 = 2p333 m/s per sec = 1200 km/s per sec = 745 mph/s.
  • Genesis: "Genesis was launched on August 8, 2001, and crash-landed in Utah on September 8, 2004, after a design flaw prevented the deployment of its drogue parachute."
  • Hayabusa: "The reentry capsule and the spacecraft reentered Earth's atmosphere on 13 June 2010 at 13:51 UTC. The heat-shielded capsule made a parachute landing in the South Australian outback while the spacecraft broke up and incinerated in a large fireball."
  • Phobos-Grunt: "It was launched on 8 November 2011, 20:16 UTC from the Baikonur Cosmodrome, but subsequent rocket burns intended to set the craft on a course for Mars failed, leaving it stranded in low Earth orbit."
It is true that in case of return from "really" outside the Earth's gravitation, reentry velocity is higher than terrestrial escape velocity vesc = 4p112 m/s, whereas in the lunar-mission case, it is normally slightly less than vesc. Nevertheless this difference in kinetic energy has not been substantial.

In meanwhile the Chinese have successfully landed their Chang'e 5 test return-vehicle after coming back from a short lunar orbit:

Chang_e_5_T1.JPG

Xinhua/Ren Junchuan

Interestingly, I did not hear about this Chinese success when it actually happened on Oct 31, 2014. Maybe, Western media were then primarily covering the launch and crash of Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo happening on exactly the same day.

Unlike Apollo, no confusion prevails on how the Chinese succeeded in landing the return module on Earth (and in resolving other challenges, see). In comparison to Apollo, the Chinese had not only the advantage of 45 years of technological progress, but also of an economy much stronger than in the United States of the 1960s.

If US landing of humans on the moon actually were a hoax then it would have been an incredibly ingenious way to steal from the "evil communists" the honor of having first landed on a celestial body. By redefining "landing on the moon" by "landing men on the moon" with their propaganda machine, the leading capitalist nation then faked not only one landing, but several landings. The organizers would have dwarfed even Joseph Goebbels by making the falsehood so preposterously exaggerated that nobody could imagine such an audacity in deception.

Cheers, Wolfgang
In the long run TRUTH has the best chance
 
... If US landing of humans on the moon actually were a hoax then it would have been an incredibly ingenious way to steal from the "evil communists" the honor of having first landed on a celestial body. By redefining "landing on the moon" by "landing men on the moon" with their propaganda machine, the leading capitalist nation then faked not only one landing, but several landings. The organizers would have dwarfed even Joseph Goebbels by making the falsehood so preposterously exaggerated that nobody could imagine such an audacity in deception.

Let me just try to clarify what you are saying here: You are speculating that the moon landings might have been faked because the audacity of such a deception means that nobody would ever believe that they were faked.

How likely do you think that is to be true, though? For example, how likely do you think it is that nobody will ever believe the moon landings were faked? :confused:
 
Unlike Apollo, no confusion prevails on how the Chinese succeeded in landing the return module on Earth...

There is no confusion regarding Apollo. Your analysis is deficient for the reasons already stated, some of which you have addressed but most you have not.

If US landing of humans on the moon actually were a hoax then it would have been an incredibly ingenious way to steal from the "evil communists" the honor of having first landed on a celestial body.

If the U.S. landing of humans on the Moon were genuine then it would have been a proper way to claim from the "evil communists" the honor having first landed on a celestial body. The only minds in which that scenario seems in doubt are those who cannot demonstrate competence in the means by which it was done.

I have entertained these theories for nearly two decades. At least once a year someone comes up with some homegrown engineering "analysis" that supposedly proves it cannot have happened as advertised. And as soon as the inevitable deficiency of that analysis is revealed, the claimant quickly switches to a social or political argument.
 
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface. In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.

Kinetic energy per mass??

That doesn't make any sense.
KE=0.5mv2
KE/m=0.5v2 Basically acknowledging that KE is proportional to velocity squared.

It would be better stated that the object would retain a large component of velocity.
well d'uh!
 
Last edited:
Luna 24 with launch date 9 Aug 1976 and recovery data 22 Aug 1976 was the last successful lunar sample return mission. According to Wikipedia, this was the third success in eleven attempts of the Soviets to bring down small amounts of moon rock to Earth. The task of returning 170 gram = 9n17 kg of moon rock is incomparably easier than of returning humans whose net weight alone is 200 kg = 2p2 kg or more. Rocks are not sensitive to temperature and high g's (decelerations). And we can take into consideration that the Soviets had been leading in space technology over many years.

In the four decades after Luna 24, only four "Far Earth" sample return missions have been completed, and only one single succeeded in safely landing an extremely small cargo (i.e. dust particles):

  • Stardust: It successfully reentered in 2006 with a peak deceleration of 34 g = 333 m/s2 = 2p333 m/s per sec = 1200 km/s per sec = 745 mph/s.
  • Genesis: "Genesis was launched on August 8, 2001, and crash-landed in Utah on September 8, 2004, after a design flaw prevented the deployment of its drogue parachute."
  • Hayabusa: "The reentry capsule and the spacecraft reentered Earth's atmosphere on 13 June 2010 at 13:51 UTC. The heat-shielded capsule made a parachute landing in the South Australian outback while the spacecraft broke up and incinerated in a large fireball."
  • Phobos-Grunt: "It was launched on 8 November 2011, 20:16 UTC from the Baikonur Cosmodrome, but subsequent rocket burns intended to set the craft on a course for Mars failed, leaving it stranded in low Earth orbit."
It is true that in case of return from "really" outside the Earth's gravitation, reentry velocity is higher than terrestrial escape velocity vesc = 4p112 m/s, whereas in the lunar-mission case, it is normally slightly less than vesc. Nevertheless this difference in kinetic energy has not been substantial.

In meanwhile the Chinese have successfully landed their Chang'e 5 test return-vehicle after coming back from a short lunar orbit:

[qimg]http://www.pandualism.com/upload/Chang_e_5_T1.JPG[/qimg]
Xinhua/Ren Junchuan

Interestingly, I did not hear about this Chinese success when it actually happened on Oct 31, 2014. Maybe, Western media were then primarily covering the launch and crash of Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo happening on exactly the same day.

Unlike Apollo, no confusion prevails on how the Chinese succeeded in landing the return module on Earth (and in resolving other challenges, see). In comparison to Apollo, the Chinese had not only the advantage of 45 years of technological progress, but also of an economy much stronger than in the United States of the 1960s.

If US landing of humans on the moon actually were a hoax then it would have been an incredibly ingenious way to steal from the "evil communists" the honor of having first landed on a celestial body. By redefining "landing on the moon" by "landing men on the moon" with their propaganda machine, the leading capitalist nation then faked not only one landing, but several landings. The organizers would have dwarfed even Joseph Goebbels by making the falsehood so preposterously exaggerated that nobody could imagine such an audacity in deception.

Cheers, Wolfgang
In the long run TRUTH has the best chance
The Apollo moon landings and returns were BY FAR the most documented explorations and returns of lunar samples (plus astronauts) of any that you cite. Far, far more through multiple independent documentations than any of the other missions you cite.

Your only basis for arguing that the Apollo missions did not take place as documented is your severe mis-understanding of the issues of re-entry, which multiple posters have kindly attempted to explain to you but which you have not yet incorporated into your conclusion-before-the-facts thinking.

Given that you claim to be willing to believe that somehow these re-entry issues were resolved for unmanned missions when your math indicates that even these lighter re-entry vehicles should have melted or even been vaporized, I am uncertain as to what you really believe and what not. I only believe that you are not going to explore the actual facts that have been presented to you for whatever reason.

Just a few things for you to ponder only from your last post, quoted above:
1. Would a more severe g-force re-entry, such as the Stardust mission, reduce the total heat of re-entry releases versus the same mission with a less severe g-force?

2. The Hayabusa mission separated the heat-shielded return capsule from the remainder of the mission modules, which burned up in the atmosphere. Did the Apollo mission do anything similar so far as you can recall?

3. Did any of the unmanned sample-return missions allow their samples to heat up to very high temperatures, as you are implying?

4. The weights of the samples/human beings are not relevant in terms of heat/energy to be dissipated - it is the weight of the total re-entry vehicle. Your use of the weights of samples vs human beings incorrectly greatly exaggerates the difference (for some reason). Also I have some trouble understanding your nomenclature: 170 grams is 0.17 E-3 kilograms, or 170 E-5 kilograms. What is the 2n17 kilograms in your nomenclature? The 2p2 kilograms works out for the human calculation.

5. If the Chinese benefited from all the progress since Apollo (progress you have recently claimed never occurred) then perhaps you can explain what these changes in the re-entry procedure as used by the Chinese versus Apollo have been (your posts have indicated that absolutely enormous changes would have been absolutely required-what were they)?

Forgive me, but I can no longer take your posts seriously.
 
Last edited:
170 gram = 9n17 kg
No. It doesn't.

If you wish to use non-standard notation, fine. What do I care.

But you cannot even get that correct, so what does that tell us?

170 gram is plainly not 9n17 kg no matter how you slice it.

is incomparably easier than of returning humans whose net weight alone is 200 kg = 2p2 kg or more.
Easier? No, not at all. Impossible? No, not at all.

Rocks are not sensitive to temperature
WTF?

Care to visit a volcano or two?

the Soviets had been leading in space technology over many years.
Nope.
They were ahead in the early sixties, then they fell behind, now they are ahead again. It isn't the binary situation you suggest.

Different players are ahead or behind as technology develops.

In meanwhile the Chinese have successfully landed their Chang'e 5 test return-vehicle after coming back from a short lunar orbit:
Which destroys your argument that it is not possible. They didn't use anything that was not available in the sixties for that in terms of materials.

Interestingly, I did not hear about this Chinese success when it actually happened
Try to pay attention in future.

but also of an economy much stronger than in the United States of the 1960s.
Like it was in the '60s? Really?

By redefining "landing on the moon" by "landing men on the moon" with their propaganda machine, the leading capitalist nation then faked not only one landing, but several landings. The organizers would have dwarfed even Joseph Goebbels by making the falsehood so preposterously exaggerated that nobody could imagine such an audacity in deception.
Okay. Now you are engaging in fantasy.

ETA: And you have Godwinned the thread.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom