sts60
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jul 19, 2007
- Messages
- 4,107
In reality, for each spacecraft, there is 'reentry angle'. If the spacecraft reentries at this angle, it will safely decelerate before diving too deep into denser air.
Old style single use reentry modules … are built to have high drag coefficient (and high drag induced stability). Thus they will use much steeper reentry angle.
But old style reentry modules are not controlled at descent stage. So if they relied on shallow reentry angle, there would be danger that they slow down too much at high altitude, which will then change the reentry angle to deeper one, just to overheat at lower altitude.
By the way - most of the meteors that burn up on reentry are very small - the size of dust or sand. No thermal mass, no place for the heat to go, and they are gone. … Even slightly larger meteors survive, hit the surface with no engineered solution, and are called meteorites. I have a small one at home. Larger ones survive and can create a lot of damage.
Thanks! I remember (many years ago) a RPG scenario in a magazine that had a shuttle visiting an alien object that arrived in lunar orbit. I believe it used that as the basis for the mission profile.
In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.
No. Very little of the kinetic energy during reentry is lost to friction. Friction is not the main reason that heat is produced during reentry. You need a basic understanding of the physics involved before you attempt the kind of analysis that you are trying to do.
-- Roger
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface
Almost every sentence above is in some way wrong. It's hard to know where to start.It is only a myth resp. unfounded belief that every spacecraft has a save 'reentry angle'. The central problem is kinetic energy. If it substantially exceeds the energy of a stable orbit near terrestrial surface, then we have a problem. The speed of such a stable orbit at "reentry interface" altitude (120 km) is 7.83 km/s. The speed of the ISS is 7.7 km/s. (If we add the potential energy of ISS with respect to "reentry interface", we get a theoretical speed of 7.94 km/s.)
A spacecraft falling with 11 km/s (even at optimal angle) resembles rather Fig. 4.1.7-9. Meteor Re-entering the Atmosphere:
"Recall, its velocity is pretty much constant initially, while it is high in the thin atmosphere. But then, it hits a wall as the atmosphere thickens and it slows rapidly."
It is the other way round: The "steeper reentry angle" is the necessity resp. cause, and "high drag coefficient (and high drag induced stability)" is the solution resp. effect.
Rather the opposite happens in reality: The steeper the reentry angle is, the faster a lower altitude is reached and the more acute is the overheat problem. The real problem with a shallow angle is that the spacecraft cannot slow down enough: Instead of changing the reentry angle to a deep enough one, the landing module goes off again on an elliptical tangent. And slowing down from more than 11 km/s to around 7.8 km/s needs to remove almost 30 Mega-Joule of kinetic energy for each kilogram of the landing module. Also, the entry speed of 11 km/s ≈ g ∙ 1125 sec (4p11 m/s ≈ 0p98 m/s2 ∙ 3p1125 s) is so high that the effect of the Earth's acceleration on further development of reentry angle is rather marginal.
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface. In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.
Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
Given only this part was addressed to my post, I will restrict my response to it. The snipped part has multiple errors but I see that posters more knowledgeable than I in these areas have already begun to correct you.[snip]
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface. In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.
Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
That is a really ignorant statement, wogoga. Anyone who learns about space flight learns about reentry angles. Information is readily available about safe reentry angles - the ones that do not allow a spacecraft trajectory that heats it so much that astronauts die or an unmanned craft burns up.It is only a myth resp. unfounded belief that every spacecraft has a save 'reentry angle'.
Is it true that a spacecraft re-entering the atmosphere at too steep an angle will burn up, or is it just an old myth?
- question from James Wells
This behavior is no myth. Any object re-entering the atmosphere of Earth or that of another world must do so within a very small range of angles in order to reach the surface successfully. The upper and lower limits on this re-entry region are determined by a combination of three factors: the trajectory of the object, its rate of deceleration, and aerodynamic heating.
... the spacecraft can skip across the atmosphere, gaining heat with each bounce and burn up before actual reentry, wogoga.The real problem with a shallow angle is that ...
Not right, wogoga. Many meteors do burn up before reaching the surface. This rarely happens with spacecraft because rocket scientists existMeteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface.
!The average velocity of meteoroids entering our atmosphere is 10-70 km/second. The smaller ones that survive the trip to the Earth's surface are quickly slowed by atmospheric friction to speeds of a few hundred kilometers per hour, and so hit the Earth with no more speed than if they had been dropped from a tall building. For meteorites larger than a few hundred tons (which fortunately are quite rare), atmospheric friction has little effect on the velocity and they hit the Earth with the enormous speeds characteristic of their entry into our atmosphere.
In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.
No. Very little of the kinetic energy during reentry is lost to friction. Friction is not the main reason that heat is produced during reentry.
Old literature may still refer to scrubbing velocity off as friction heat but it's been a couple of decades now that analysis of fallen space trash has revealed that it's compression of air.
At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction, i.e. kinetic energy of an object is transformed into heat by more or less direct contact.
I used friction in the general sense of an interaction with the atmosphere leading to air drag, to air resistance. Whether a particle of the atmosphere directly interacts with the reentry module or indirectly via other particles having previously interacted directly or indirectly does not matter. At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction, i.e. kinetic energy of an object is transformed into heat by more or less direct contact.
At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction...
I cannot imagine that this knowledge was not state of the art also "a couple of decades" ago.