Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

In reality, for each spacecraft, there is 'reentry angle'. If the spacecraft reentries at this angle, it will safely decelerate before diving too deep into denser air.


It is only a myth resp. unfounded belief that every spacecraft has a save 'reentry angle'. The central problem is kinetic energy. If it substantially exceeds the energy of a stable orbit near terrestrial surface, then we have a problem. The speed of such a stable orbit at "reentry interface" altitude (120 km) is 7.83 km/s. The speed of the ISS is 7.7 km/s. (If we add the potential energy of ISS with respect to "reentry interface", we get a theoretical speed of 7.94 km/s.)

A spacecraft falling with 11 km/s (even at optimal angle) resembles rather Fig. 4.1.7-9. Meteor Re-entering the Atmosphere:

"Recall, its velocity is pretty much constant initially, while it is high in the thin atmosphere. But then, it hits a wall as the atmosphere thickens and it slows rapidly."​


Old style single use reentry modules … are built to have high drag coefficient (and high drag induced stability). Thus they will use much steeper reentry angle.


It is the other way round: The "steeper reentry angle" is the necessity resp. cause, and "high drag coefficient (and high drag induced stability)" is the solution resp. effect.


But old style reentry modules are not controlled at descent stage. So if they relied on shallow reentry angle, there would be danger that they slow down too much at high altitude, which will then change the reentry angle to deeper one, just to overheat at lower altitude.


Rather the opposite happens in reality: The steeper the reentry angle is, the faster a lower altitude is reached and the more acute is the overheat problem. The real problem with a shallow angle is that the spacecraft cannot slow down enough: Instead of changing the reentry angle to a deep enough one, the landing module goes off again on an elliptical tangent. And slowing down from more than 11 km/s to around 7.8 km/s needs to remove almost 30 Mega-Joule of kinetic energy for each kilogram of the landing module. Also, the entry speed of 11 km/s ≈ g ∙ 1125 sec (4p11 m/s ≈ 0p98 m/s2 ∙ 3p1125 s) is so high that the effect of the Earth's acceleration on further development of reentry angle is rather marginal.


By the way - most of the meteors that burn up on reentry are very small - the size of dust or sand. No thermal mass, no place for the heat to go, and they are gone. … Even slightly larger meteors survive, hit the surface with no engineered solution, and are called meteorites. I have a small one at home. Larger ones survive and can create a lot of damage.


Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface. In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
 
In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.

No. Very little of the kinetic energy during reentry is lost to friction. Friction is not the main reason that heat is produced during reentry. You need a basic understanding of the physics involved before you attempt the kind of analysis that you are trying to do.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
No. Very little of the kinetic energy during reentry is lost to friction. Friction is not the main reason that heat is produced during reentry. You need a basic understanding of the physics involved before you attempt the kind of analysis that you are trying to do.

-- Roger

Old literature may still refer to scrubbing velocity off as friction heat but it's been a couple of decades now that analysis of fallen space trash has revealed that it's compression of air. Spherical pressure cans are one of the most common to survive because they can withstand/flow through the compression loading of the object pushing air out of the way.
 
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface

That's not true at all. Most meteorites that reach the surface do so by falling at terminal velocity, not with "huge kinetic energy". They don't hit any harder than they would if you tossed them off a tall building.
 
It is only a myth resp. unfounded belief that every spacecraft has a save 'reentry angle'. The central problem is kinetic energy. If it substantially exceeds the energy of a stable orbit near terrestrial surface, then we have a problem. The speed of such a stable orbit at "reentry interface" altitude (120 km) is 7.83 km/s. The speed of the ISS is 7.7 km/s. (If we add the potential energy of ISS with respect to "reentry interface", we get a theoretical speed of 7.94 km/s.)

A spacecraft falling with 11 km/s (even at optimal angle) resembles rather Fig. 4.1.7-9. Meteor Re-entering the Atmosphere:

"Recall, its velocity is pretty much constant initially, while it is high in the thin atmosphere. But then, it hits a wall as the atmosphere thickens and it slows rapidly."​





It is the other way round: The "steeper reentry angle" is the necessity resp. cause, and "high drag coefficient (and high drag induced stability)" is the solution resp. effect.





Rather the opposite happens in reality: The steeper the reentry angle is, the faster a lower altitude is reached and the more acute is the overheat problem. The real problem with a shallow angle is that the spacecraft cannot slow down enough: Instead of changing the reentry angle to a deep enough one, the landing module goes off again on an elliptical tangent. And slowing down from more than 11 km/s to around 7.8 km/s needs to remove almost 30 Mega-Joule of kinetic energy for each kilogram of the landing module. Also, the entry speed of 11 km/s ≈ g ∙ 1125 sec (4p11 m/s ≈ 0p98 m/s2 ∙ 3p1125 s) is so high that the effect of the Earth's acceleration on further development of reentry angle is rather marginal.





Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface. In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
Almost every sentence above is in some way wrong. It's hard to know where to start.
 
[snip]
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface. In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
Given only this part was addressed to my post, I will restrict my response to it. The snipped part has multiple errors but I see that posters more knowledgeable than I in these areas have already begun to correct you.

As to meteorites: it depends on the size, of course, but the average pea sized meteorite one might collect probably had a terminal velocity of 200 mph or somewhat higher at impact As noted by phunk above, the same speed as if someone threw it off of a tall building (terminal velocity, right?). Essentially the same speed as the Apollo capsule after its atmospheric braking and just prior to the release of its drogue parachutes (200 to 300 mph). So they both shed most of their velocity through atmospheric braking, released as heat.

But I am not really certain what your overall point is here. My point was that objects traveling much, much faster than Apollo when they enter the atmosphere can reach the Earth's surface without being destroyed, even in the absence of the many engineering and tactical solutions that were employed in Apollo to control the effects of the re-entry and to ensure the safety of the crew.
 
It is only a myth resp. unfounded belief that every spacecraft has a save 'reentry angle'.
That is a really ignorant statement, wogoga. Anyone who learns about space flight learns about reentry angles. Information is readily available about safe reentry angles - the ones that do not allow a spacecraft trajectory that heats it so much that astronauts die or an unmanned craft burns up.
Every spacecraft has a small range of safe reentry angles.

Atmosphere & Spacecraft Re-entry
Is it true that a spacecraft re-entering the atmosphere at too steep an angle will burn up, or is it just an old myth?
- question from James Wells

This behavior is no myth. Any object re-entering the atmosphere of Earth or that of another world must do so within a very small range of angles in order to reach the surface successfully. The upper and lower limits on this re-entry region are determined by a combination of three factors: the trajectory of the object, its rate of deceleration, and aerodynamic heating.
 
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface.
Not right, wogoga. Many meteors do burn up before reaching the surface. This rarely happens with spacecraft because rocket scientists exist :jaw-dropp!
Meteorite "fragments" actually move relatively slowly due to atmospheric friction and so have small kinetic energy: Meteorite Impact Velocities
The average velocity of meteoroids entering our atmosphere is 10-70 km/second. The smaller ones that survive the trip to the Earth's surface are quickly slowed by atmospheric friction to speeds of a few hundred kilometers per hour, and so hit the Earth with no more speed than if they had been dropped from a tall building. For meteorites larger than a few hundred tons (which fortunately are quite rare), atmospheric friction has little effect on the velocity and they hit the Earth with the enormous speeds characteristic of their entry into our atmosphere.
 
In case of controlled reentry, all the kinetic energy must be converted by friction into heat, yet without burning the object being the primary cause of this friction.

No. Very little of the kinetic energy during reentry is lost to friction. Friction is not the main reason that heat is produced during reentry.


I used friction in the general sense of an interaction with the atmosphere leading to air drag, to air resistance. Whether a particle of the atmosphere directly interacts with the reentry module or indirectly via other particles having previously interacted directly or indirectly does not matter. At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction, i.e. kinetic energy of an object is transformed into heat by more or less direct contact.


Old literature may still refer to scrubbing velocity off as friction heat but it's been a couple of decades now that analysis of fallen space trash has revealed that it's compression of air.


Deceleration by interaction with air obviously leads to compression of the air in front of the decelerating object. I cannot imagine that this knowledge was not state of the art also "a couple of decades" ago.


By the way, the fuel with the highest energy content seems to be the combination of liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen. Combustion energy of pure hydrogen is 8p14 Joule per kg (i.e. 108 ∙ 1.4 J/Kg = 140 MJ/Kg) if oxygen is taken for granted. As we need 8 times more oxygen (atomic weight: 16) than hydrogen (atomic weight: 2 times 1), we get an energy content of only 8p14 ∙ 2/(16+1+1) = 7p155 = 15.5 MJ/kg for a fuel consisting of hydrogen and oxygen.

I'm actually astonished at this result which makes understandable that it is rather impractical to use fuels for reentry: In order to transport one kilogram of rocket fuel to an orbit around the moon, we need around 60 Mega-Joule. The energy content of 1 kg of fuel itself however is only around 15 MJ and even cannot be transformed into kinetic energy without losses.

Cheers, Wolfgang
 
Last edited:
At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction, i.e. kinetic energy of an object is transformed into heat by more or less direct contact.

And there's another critical error in your thinking. It seems fairly clear to me that, because adiabatic compression takes place at greater distances from the falling object, the process of heat transfer into the falling object must be much less efficient than viscous drag. As a result, a much larger proportion of the energy loss goes into heating the air around the falling object, and a much smaller proportion into heating the object itself, than one would expect from viscous drag. Your unspoken suggestion that all the kinetic energy lost is converted into thermal energy in the falling body, as embodied in your calculation of what you expect its heating to be, is therefore completely specious.

Dave
 
I used friction in the general sense of an interaction with the atmosphere leading to air drag, to air resistance. Whether a particle of the atmosphere directly interacts with the reentry module or indirectly via other particles having previously interacted directly or indirectly does not matter. At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction, i.e. kinetic energy of an object is transformed into heat by more or less direct contact.

No, that is wrong. Drag and friction have little to do with the heat produced during reentry.

Here is a link to some (mostly) good explanations:

https://www.quora.com/Why-does-a-spacecraft-heat-up-during-reentry

We use blunt shaped reentry vehicles (ones with high coefficients of drag) to keep much of the heat of reentry away from the spacecraft.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
I haven't considered it carefully, but if friction was the cause of the heat during reentry, I am not sure we could build spacecraft that could survive reentry - at least not without huge shields or a massive amount of fuel to slow the spacecraft throughout most of its descent.

-- Roger
 
I've returned from vacation to find this thread. I won't have the time immediately to address the myriad of misconceptions and errors it contains. But a few stand out sorely and can be addressed immediately, if not yet with appropriate rigor.

First, escape velocity has nothing to do with the problem. We are talking about orbital velocities, and a proper understanding of the orbital nature of the problem is essential. The diagram in the OP showing altitude over time is useless. Even the oft-reproduced diagram showing geodetic altitude over range is misleading as the range is merely a graphical convention and not the curved surface of the earth that actually exists. An atmospheric entry is an orbital maneuver at first, and the changes in altitude that result from increased transition to atmospheric flight need to be addressed in terms of their departure from the still-significant orbital-flight regime.

Second, yes it very much does matter whether we're talking about compression versus friction. The fluid dynamics involved are significantly different and result in different aerodynamic and heating models. Especially in Apollo's case, the bow-wave heating was offset by boundary-layer outgassing of heat-shield components, which marks a significant qualitative difference between it and the other thermal protection system examples mentioned.

These points are not merely a difference in terminology, but a difference in conceptual understanding. That they occurred in the popular literature then and continue in some popular literature today doesn't matter. The mark of expert versus popular analysis is in the correct use of terminology and the correct references to concepts. That is lacking in this presentation.

Third, the suggestion that Apollo is a technological anomaly stands in gross ignorance of the relevant factors in history out of which Apollo arose and into whose sunset it rode.

Until I delve into details, I'll have to pause with the judgment that the OP and subsequent attempts to wreak controversy constitute a fairly off-base and simplistic formulation of the problem of atmospheric reentry. There been some merciful corrections and some quite correct and valuable commentary in the meantime.
 
At least in everyday language, the whole process can be called friction...

But in engineering it cannot -- especially for purposes of thermal analysis. Please use proper concepts and proper terminology.

I cannot imagine that this knowledge was not state of the art also "a couple of decades" ago.

It was state of the art as of several decades ago, as the principles were used to design and test the first ballistic missile warhead re-entry vehicles. And it was properly named, discussed, and treated in the relevant literature. You seem to be relying upon popular sources which, despite some rigor in their mathematical description, seem to rely upon simplified language and presentation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom