Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

You are right: Missing kinetic energy for one 80 kg astronaut is 4.7 Giga-Joule and not 4.7 Tera-Joule.

Nevertheless 4.7 GJ = 4.7 billion Joule = 4.7 ∙ 109 J = 9p47 Joule is actually enough to heat up ten tons (10000 kg = 4p1 kg = 7p1 gram) of steel by 1000 Kelvin (3p1 Kelvin).

In the context of computers, the use of giga = 9p = nine-po of some years ago has been replaced more and more by tera = 1012 = 12p = twelve-po. Therefore I confused Tera-Joule with Giga-Joule. Yet my calculation is not affected by this mistake:

Specific heat capacity of steel is 0.47 Joule per gram per Kelvin = 9n47 J/g/K = nine-ne four seven J/g/K. With 0.47 kJ = 4.7 ∙ 102 J = 2p47 J = two-po four seven Joule we can heat up 1 kg = 3p1 gram by one degree Kelvin. For ten metric tons = 7p1 g we need 7p1 g ∙ 9n47 J/g/K = 6p47 Joule/Kelvin. In order heat up these ten tons (7p1 gram) of heat capacity 9n47 J/g/K by 1000 Kelvin (3p1 K), we need 9p47 Joules.

Summary: 9n47 J/g/K ∙ 7p1 g ∙ 3p1 K = 9p47 J

Cheers, Wolfgang
Efficient Concept-Formation for Languages of the Future

Swing and a miss.
 
You are right: Missing kinetic energy for one 80 kg astronaut is 4.7 Giga-Joule and not 4.7 Tera-Joule.

Nevertheless 4.7 GJ = 4.7 billion Joule = 4.7 ∙ 109 J = 9p47 Joule is actually enough to heat up ten tons (10000 kg = 4p1 kg = 7p1 gram) of steel by 1000 Kelvin (3p1 Kelvin).

In the context of computers, the use of giga = 9p = nine-po of some years ago has been replaced more and more by tera = 1012 = 12p = twelve-po. Therefore I confused Tera-Joule with Giga-Joule. Yet my calculation is not affected by this mistake:

Specific heat capacity of steel is 0.47 Joule per gram per Kelvin = 9n47 J/g/K = nine-ne four seven J/g/K. With 0.47 kJ = 4.7 ∙ 102 J = 2p47 J = two-po four seven Joule we can heat up 1 kg = 3p1 gram by one degree Kelvin. For ten metric tons = 7p1 g we need 7p1 g ∙ 9n47 J/g/K = 6p47 Joule/Kelvin. In order heat up these ten tons (7p1 gram) of heat capacity 9n47 J/g/K by 1000 Kelvin (3p1 K), we need 9p47 Joules.

Summary: 9n47 J/g/K ∙ 7p1 g ∙ 3p1 K = 9p47 J

Cheers, Wolfgang
Efficient Concept-Formation for Languages of the Future

Put it this way. Even if you eventually correct your calculations, 4.7x109 Joules is sufficient to heat 18076923 cups of coffee to 90 C from room temperature.

Did you have a point?
 
So the question becomes even more acute: How could Apollo reduce its speed from 11 km/s to less than 1 km/s before or when entering the atmosphere (at an altitude of around 120 km)?
Cheers, Wolfgang

It would help if you paid attention to your own links and figures. The Apollo CM did not start slowing appreciably until it reached the atmosphere. The period of greatest energy shedding is clearly the portion of the flight which is temperature limited, from roughly 300 to 1000 seconds. At 5500 kg, the kinetic energy of the CM at reentry is about 340 GJ. Shedding this energy over 700 seconds requires a power level of about 500 MW, more or less.

This is a pretty impressive figure, and represents something of a triumph of engineering. The simple answer is that the heat shield gets hot, in the vicinity of 1500 K. This temperature rise is controlled by 3 phenomena: convection, radiation, and ablation.

Convection: You might want to consider that there is, by the nature of reentry, an enormous wind velocity blowing across the surface of the heat shield, although shock waves and stagnation effects do come into play. In the case of any reentering body, an enormous amount of heat is transferred to the surrounding atmosphere. They don't call it a fireball for nothing. In the case of reentering spacecraft the surrounding air gets so hot that it ionizes, and prior to the Space Shuttle the ionization would produce a radio blackout that would last for 10 minutes or so.

Radiation: Although minor, you might want to do the calculations. The Apollo CM had a diameter of 3.9 meters, for a heat shield area of about 12 $m^2$. Blackbody radiation from such a surface at 1500 K runs about 7 MW.

Ablation: You've made much of the temperature rise if the available energy were transferred to, for instance, steel. This is a perfectly valid concern, and the response was to make sure that that didn't happen. As I 'm sure you're aware, phase changes can absorb far more energy than a simple temperature change - look at the difference between heating water from 99 to 100 degrees, and from 100 degrees to 101 degrees. For Apollo, the heat shield actually burned off due to pyrolysis, limiting the maximum temperature.

If you do a bit of Googling, you can find NASA engineering reports which deal with the concerns and issues which were addressed during mission planning and spacecraft construction. I really advise you to do a minimal amount of research on a question before you ask it.
 
Last edited:
It would help if you paid attention to your own links and figures. The Apollo CM did not start slowing appreciably until it reached the atmosphere. The period of greatest energy shedding is clearly the portion of the flight which is temperature limited, from roughly 300 to 1000 seconds. At 5500 kg, the kinetic energy of the CM at reentry is about 340 GJ. Shedding this energy over 700 seconds requires a power level of about 500 MW, more or less.

This is a pretty impressive figure, and represents something of a triumph of engineering. The simple answer is that the heat shield gets hot, in the vicinity of 1500 K. This temperature rise is controlled by 3 phenomena: convection, radiation, and ablation.

Convection: You might want to consider that there is, by the nature of reentry, an enormous wind velocity blowing across the surface of the heat shield, although shock waves and stagnation effects do come into play. In the case of any reentering body, an enormous amount of heat is transferred to the surrounding atmosphere. They don't call it a fireball for nothing. In the case of reentering spacecraft the surrounding air gets so hot that it ionizes, and prior to the Space Shuttle the ionization would produce a radio blackout that would last for 10 minutes or so.

Radiation: Although minor, you might want to do the calculations. The Apollo CM had a diameter of 3.9 meters, for a heat shield area of about 12 $m^2$. Blackbody radiation from such a surface at 1500 K runs about 7 MW.

Ablation: You've made much of the temperature rise if the available energy were transferred to, for instance, steel. This is a perfectly valid concern, and the response was to make sure that that didn't happen. As I 'm sure you're aware, phase changes can absorb far more energy than a simple temperature change - look at the difference between heating water from 99 to 100 degrees, and from 100 degrees to 101 degrees. For Apollo, the heat shield actually burned off due to pyrolysis, limiting the maximum temperature.

If you do a bit of Googling, you can find NASA engineering reports which deal with the concerns and issues which were addressed during mission planning and spacecraft construction. I really advise you to do a minimal amount of research on a question before you ask it.

Yes, one (not all) of the problems with wogogo's interpretation is the concept that all the the heat produced must be absorbed by the CM, neglecting the enormous dissipation of this heat as superheated air and as the ablation of the heatshield. As you stated, a huge amount of engineering went into making certain that this all worked to keep the heating of the CM itself within acceptable limits.

I also seem to recall that one of the reasons for using a relatively blunt surface (the bottom of the CM) during Apollo reentry was to create a shockwave in front of the heatshield itself, moving the point of maximum heating into the air and further away from the capsule itself. Therefore much of the heat generated was not in direct contact with the CM. Is my memory correct?
 
Since it has been scientifically proven that re-entry is impossible, low Earth orbit must be crowded with Astronauts. QED.


The International Space Station is at an altitude of around 350 km (5p35 m = five-po three five meter) in the thermosphere. This is less than 3% (8n3 = eight-ne three) of the Earth's diameter. Due to atmospheric friction, the ISS must be regularly accelerated. Otherwise it would fall on the Earth.

The distance to the Moon with around 380,000 km (8p38 meter) is around 30 times (1p3) the Earth's diameter and around 1000 times (1p3 / 8n3 = 3p1) the distance from the Earth's surface to the ISS. This makes a huge difference!

It is true that kinetic and potential energy which has to be converted by atmospheric friction into thermal energy during re-entry is only twice as high in the lunar-mission case. But these additional 30 MJ/kg (7p3 Joule per kg) make a huge difference. From the ISS even a sailplane (glider aircraft) could safely reach the Earth, at least in principle.

Cheers, Wolfgang
 
Last edited:
The International Space Station is at an altitude of around 350 km (5p35 m = five-po three five meter) in the thermosphere. This is less than 3% (8n3 = eight-ne three) of the Earth's diameter. Due to atmospheric friction, the ISS must be regularly accelerated. Otherwise it would fall on the Earth.

The distance to the Moon with around 380,000 km (8p38 meter) is around 30 times (1p3) the Earth's diameter and around 1000 times (1p3 / 8n3 = 3p1) the distance from the Earth's surface to the ISS. This makes a huge difference!

It is true that kinetic and potential energy which has to be converted by atmospheric friction into thermal energy during re-entry is only twice as high in the lunar-mission case. But these additional 30 MJ/kg (7p3 Joule per kg) make a huge difference. From the ISS even a sailplane (glider aircraft) could safely reach the Earth, at least in principle.

Cheers, Wolfgang
Did you have a point to make?

Different energies are different. And........
 
The International Space Station is at an altitude of around 350 km (5p35 m = five-po three five meter) in the thermosphere. This is less than 3% (8n3 = eight-ne three) of the Earth's diameter. Due to atmospheric friction, the ISS must be regularly accelerated. Otherwise it would fall on the Earth.

The distance to the Moon with around 380,000 km (8p38 meter) is around 30 times (1p3) the Earth's diameter and around 1000 times (1p3 / 8n3 = 3p1) the distance from the Earth's surface to the ISS. This makes a huge difference!

It is true that kinetic and potential energy which has to be converted by atmospheric friction into thermal energy during re-entry is only twice as high in the lunar-mission case. But these additional 30 MJ/kg (7p3 Joule per kg) make a huge difference. From the ISS even a sailplane (glider aircraft) could safely reach the Earth, at least in principle.

Cheers, Wolfgang

Here is a good article for you to begin to re-channel your thinking into a better understanding of how it works:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_entry

Best regards!
 
The International Space Station is at an altitude of around 350 km (5p35 m = five-po three five meter) in the thermosphere. This is less than 3% (8n3 = eight-ne three) of the Earth's diameter. Due to atmospheric friction, the ISS must be regularly accelerated. Otherwise it would fall on the Earth.

The distance to the Moon with around 380,000 km (8p38 meter) is around 30 times (1p3) the Earth's diameter and around 1000 times (1p3 / 8n3 = 3p1) the distance from the Earth's surface to the ISS. This makes a huge difference!

It is true that kinetic and potential energy which has to be converted by atmospheric friction into thermal energy during re-entry is only twice as high in the lunar-mission case. But these additional 30 MJ/kg (7p3 Joule per kg) make a huge difference. From the ISS even a sailplane (glider aircraft) could safely reach the Earth, at least in principle.

Cheers, Wolfgang

Can't see a point being made here Wolfgang, sorry.
 
Did you have a point to make?

No. I don't really know what the point was either.

Can't see a point being made here Wolfgang, sorry.


Here again the sarcastic comment from Gord in post #5:

"Since it has been scientifically proven that re-entry is impossible, low Earth orbit must be crowded with Astronauts. QED."​

Gord's comment implies that the many astronauts from the times of Gagarin to our days having visited the thermosphere could not have returned if a major difficulty existed in returning from a lunar mission. Thus, in #25 I explained that a huge difference prevails between returning from a stable orbit very close to the Earth's surface and coming back from an orbit around the moon.

The historic evolution of flights to orbits in the thermosphere is the normal one: After a first astronaut had visited this outer region of the atmosphere, this achievement has been repeated with increasing ease. Other example: After the first person(s) succeeded in climbing Mount Everest, more and more people have repeated this achievement with increasing ease. The same has been happening all the time with achievements in technology (e.g. automobile, airplane, computer), in science and in sports.

There is only one prominent exception to the rule that a first achievement can be repeated with increasing ease: the Apollo program! Interestingly, the "increasing ease" effect even worked normally during the Apollo program itself, culminating in driving a rover and singing on the moon. The big discontinuity only occurred after the Apollo program.

Cheers, Wolfgang
 
Last edited:
[snip]
Gord's comment implies that the many astronauts from the times of Gagarin to our days having visited the thermosphere could not have returned if a major difficulty existed in returning from a lunar mission. Thus, in #25 I explained that a huge difference prevails between returning from a stable orbit very close to the Earth's surface and coming back from an orbit around the moon.[snip]

Cheers, Wolfgang

Perhaps you would be willing to present as numbers this "huge" difference in energy that is represented by the higher re-entry speeds from a lunar mission versus an orbital one? I believe you have the information as to the re-entry speeds. There is no doubt that the former is higher than the latter, but I find the term "huge" to not quite fit my calculations, which suggest a less than two-fold difference and why, by slightly modifying the same basic approaches, the former would be impossible whereas the latter you acknowledge has been achieved routinely for decades.
 
Here again the sarcastic comment from Gord in post #5:

"Since it has been scientifically proven that re-entry is impossible, low Earth orbit must be crowded with Astronauts. QED."​

Gord's comment implies that the many astronauts from the times of Gagarin to our days having visited the thermosphere could not have returned if a major difficulty existed in returning from a lunar mission. Thus, in #25 I explained that a huge difference prevails between returning from a stable orbit very close to the Earth's surface and coming back from an orbit around the moon.

The historic evolution of flights to orbits in the thermosphere is the normal one: After a first astronaut had visited this outer region of the atmosphere, this achievement has been repeated with increasing ease. Other example: After the first person(s) succeeded in climbing Mount Everest, more and more people have repeated this achievement with increasing ease. The same has been happening all the time with achievements in technology (e.g. automobile, airplane, computer), in science and in sports.

There is only one prominent exception to the rule that a first achievement can be repeated with increasing ease: the Apollo program! Interestingly, the "increasing ease" effect even worked normally during the Apollo program itself, culminating in driving a rover and singing on the moon. The big discontinuity only occurred after the Apollo program.

Cheers, Wolfgang
First, quoting post # is pointless. Violations get shuffled of to AAH and whatnot, threads get merged and variously divide up. Citing post numbers without links is either ignorance of how things actually work, or an intentional tactic. Pick one.

Re-entry is not disproven, it is proven. we do it all the time.

You do not understand orbits, nor the velocities involved.

You don't understand atmospheric layers and the meaning thereof.

You don't understand that climbing Everest is a different challenge to travelling to the Moon.

You don't understand what the thermosphere actually is.

Frankly, at this point, I am sort of wondering what it might be that you actually understand? If anything?
 
There is only one prominent exception to the rule that a first achievement can be repeated with increasing ease: the Apollo program! Interestingly, the "increasing ease" effect even worked normally during the Apollo program itself, culminating in driving a rover and singing on the moon. The big discontinuity only occurred after the Apollo program.

There was no discontinuity in "ease". The Apllo program ended. It ended early, because there was no political $upport to keep it up. In fact, the Apollo workforce was already ramping down well before the first landing.

So what, exactly, is your point?
 
Last edited:
Bonus question: Suppose manned lunar exploration was officially set to be an active goal of the U.S. civil space program. Do you expect a monotonic decrease in "ease" to apply, nearly half a decade after the last active manned exploration program ended? Why, or why not?
 
Here is a good article for you to begin to re-channel your thinking into a better understanding of how it works:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_entry



Best regards!



Here again the sarcastic comment from Gord in post #5:



"Since it has been scientifically proven that re-entry is impossible, low Earth orbit must be crowded with Astronauts. QED."​



Gord's comment implies that the many astronauts from the times of Gagarin to our days having visited the thermosphere could not have returned if a major difficulty existed in returning from a lunar mission. Thus, in #25 I explained that a huge difference prevails between returning from a stable orbit very close to the Earth's surface and coming back from an orbit around the moon.



The historic evolution of flights to orbits in the thermosphere is the normal one: After a first astronaut had visited this outer region of the atmosphere, this achievement has been repeated with increasing ease. Other example: After the first person(s) succeeded in climbing Mount Everest, more and more people have repeated this achievement with increasing ease. The same has been happening all the time with achievements in technology (e.g. automobile, airplane, computer), in science and in sports.



There is only one prominent exception to the rule that a first achievement can be repeated with increasing ease: the Apollo program! Interestingly, the "increasing ease" effect even worked normally during the Apollo program itself, culminating in driving a rover and singing on the moon. The big discontinuity only occurred after the Apollo program.



Cheers, Wolfgang



One great big chunk of irrelevance. If you want to discuss the actual science, start by following Giordano's link above and focus on the heat transfer discussions. Until you do, any further discussion will be pointless.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
You mean like the Space Shuttle?

Exactly like the space shuttle. Which, I will point out, was never flown to the moon. The question of why has been answered over the years in a variety of ways, but the energy required to decelerate to earth orbit and reentry speeds exceeds the amount of fuel that a shuttle can carry.
 
Exactly like the space shuttle. Which, I will point out, was never flown to the moon. The question of why has been answered over the years in a variety of ways, but the energy required to decelerate to earth orbit and reentry speeds exceeds the amount of fuel that a shuttle can carry.


I've often wondered about that - even if you filled the cargo bay with as much hypergolic propellant as it could take and piped it through to the oms?

I mean, I've always guessed the answer was no and that re-entry frrom a lunar trajectory would be, erm, bad, but that cargo bay could hold a lot of fuel.


ETA: I am aware that there are about a million other technical reasons that make this impractical. :)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom