Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong speaking (especially at 12:11):

"Today we have with us a group of students, among America's best. To you we say we have only completed a beginning. We leave you much that is undone. There are great ideas undiscovered, breakthroughs available to those who can remove one of the truth's protective layers. There are many places to go beyond belief. Those challenges are yours – in many fields, not the least of which is space, because there lies human destiny." (Transcript)​

A reasonable video on Apollo with some quite convincing arguments: Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?

Cheers, Wolfgang
What is that quote from Armstrong supposed to prove?

There are no convincing arguments in that video, only ignorance.
 
Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong...

So now you're a brilliant psychoanalyst who can diagnose mental illness in people you've never met simply by watching them on a few seconds of video? Wow, this is a new low.

A reasonable video on Apollo with some quite convincing arguments: Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?

Wow, you're really bad at this.

This program aired fifteen years ago on the Fox network in the U.S. Keep in mind at that time that Fox News and Fox Entertainment were two separate companies who shared a distribution channel. Fox News was so embarrassed by their sibling's decision to air this program that it brought on its own experts to debunk it. The Fox Corporation got such a black eye from it that it compelled them to use their distribution apparatus to distribute actual space documentary footage from Spacecraft Films inc.

Since this program has been around for fifteen years, it has been roundly debunked many, many times. It isn't difficult at all to find easy rebuttals to your "convincing arguments." One of the non-flying astronauts they interviewed, for example, was Brian O'Leary. He told me that he told the interviewers several times that he believed the Moon landings were real, but that they used only edited footage that made it seem like he was expressing doubt.

Wogoga, it is simply inexcusable at this point that you could not have found answers to the challenges raised in that film, which was an essentially unopposed commercial for the quoted conspiracy theorists' claims.
 
Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong speaking (especially at 12:11):

"Today we have with us a group of students, among America's best. To you we say we have only completed a beginning. We leave you much that is undone. There are great ideas undiscovered, breakthroughs available to those who can remove one of the truth's protective layers. There are many places to go beyond belief. Those challenges are yours – in many fields, not the least of which is space, because there lies human destiny." (Transcript)​

A reasonable video on Apollo with some quite convincing arguments: Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?

Cheers, Wolfgang
You have some typos:
"long debunked" is not spelled "reasonable"
"thoroughly unbelievable" is not spelled "quite convincing"

As much as it's hard to believe, they are common mistakes. No need to thank me, all in a day's work.
 
Last edited:
Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong speaking (especially at 12:11):
A post with a lie of Neil Armstrong being a "tragic hero and liar against will" is not addressed by a lie about a "depressed" Neil Armstrong in a deluded video. The 1994 speech included Neil Armstrong encouraging a group of students to build upon the existing foundation of discoveries from the Apollo and other missions. Look at the happy Neil Armstrong in an actual video of his speech (beaming grin at 1:37 for the applause and a joke to start the speech :eek:!): Apollo 11 25th Anniversary - The White House (July 20th, 1994)

A "transcript" link that is basically a lie because the link is not a transcript of the 1994 speech - it is to a deluded web page. AULIS is the Apollo mission denial web site you have linked to before. In this case they have the inanity of highlighting jokes in the speech!

Another lie about a "reasonable video" does not help. A video (actually a Fox TV show) interviewing some idiot fantasizing that the Apollo landings did not happen is not being rational or reasonable. What is worse is that irrational, unreasonable conspiracy theorist was Bart Sibrel
Bart Winfield Sibrel (born 1964) is a conspiracy theorist who claims that the six Apollo Moon landings between 1969 and 1972 were hoaxes. He has produced four amateur films on the subject, and is mostly known for having been punched in the face by Buzz Aldrin for harassing and insulting him.


The show was a list of bad science that had been debunked for decades, e.g. the flag waving!
Fox TV and the Apollo Moon Hoax
On Thursday, February 15th 2001 (and replayed on March 19), the Fox TV network aired a program called ``Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?'', hosted by X-Files actor Mitch Pileggi. The program was an hour long, and featured interviews with a series of people who believe that NASA faked the Apollo Moon landings in the 1960s and 1970s. The biggest voice in this is Bill Kaysing, who claims to have all sorts of hoax evidence, including pictures taken by the astronauts, engineering details, discussions of physics and even some testimony by astronauts themselves. The program's conclusion was that the whole thing was faked in the Nevada desert (in Area 51, of course!). According to them, NASA did not have the technical capability of going to the Moon, but pressure due to the Cold War with the Soviet Union forced them to fake it.

Sound ridiculous? Of course it does! It is. So let me get this straight right from the start: this program is an hour long piece of junk.
DID WE LAND ON THE MOON? Debunking of the Moon Hoax Theory
On February 15, 2001 the FOX television network aired a program titled Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land On The Moon? This program showed alleged evidence that NASA faked the moon landings. This hoax theory has been around for several years, but this is the first time it has been presented to such a wide audience. Since this Website, Rocket and Space Technology, is dedicated to the men and women who brought the moon landings to fruition, I feel the time is right for me to speak out on this topic.

This TV program capitalizes on America's fixation with government conspiracies by sensationalizing the notion that NASA perpetrated a multi-billion dollar hoax on the world. In my opinion, the FOX network acted irresponsibly by airing this program. What they produced is a TV show filled with sloppy research, scientific inaccuracies and erroneous conclusions. To support such an absurd theory and to cast doubt in the minds of the American public is an insult to the courage of the astronauts and the brilliance of the engineers who worked to achieve mankind's greatest technological feat. FOX is apparently only concerned with ratings while exhibiting total disregard for the integrity of America's true heroes.
Conspiracy Theory: Did We Go to the Moon?
 
Last edited:
Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong speaking (especially at 12:11):

"Today we have with us a group of students, among America's best. To you we say we have only completed a beginning. We leave you much that is undone. There are great ideas undiscovered, breakthroughs available to those who can remove one of the truth's protective layers. There are many places to go beyond belief. Those challenges are yours – in many fields, not the least of which is space, because there lies human destiny." (Transcript)​

A reasonable video on Apollo with some quite convincing arguments: Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?

Cheers, Wolfgang

If you must use prose and poems the words you use should be your own, don't plagiarise or take on loan.
 
Please watch

Translation:
"My original claims have been shown extensively to be stupid and outrageously wrong, and if I had an ounce of decency I would admit it. However I am a Hoaxer so i will dishonestly switch the subject and hope that some of you will actually follow my starting gish gallop"
 
Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong speaking (especially at 12:11):

"Today we have with us a group of students, among America's best. To you we say we have only completed a beginning. We leave you much that is undone. There are great ideas undiscovered, breakthroughs available to those who can remove one of the truth's protective layers. There are many places to go beyond belief. Those challenges are yours – in many fields, not the least of which is space, because there lies human destiny." (Transcript)​

A reasonable video on Apollo with some quite convincing arguments: Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?

Cheers, Wolfgang
Wow, the stupidity in the videos presented is proof idiots are able to produce videos which prove some people can't do science due to overwhelming ignorance. What a bunch of lies, and idiotic claims. Guess the footprints on the moon, real evidence is ignored by people who can't think for themselves, the youtube conspiracy theorists.

There were no convincing arguments, there was a lot of BS.
 
There were no convincing arguments, there was a lot of BS.

In the fifteen years since that show was produced we've been able to discover a fair amount about how and why it was made. The "why" is fairly straightforward -- Fox Entertainment at the time was basically sensationalist tabloid nonsense. That genre is based upon making outrageous claims hoping to attract viewers and therefore higher ad rates, regardless of any sort of intellectual honesty. Most of Fox Entertainment was essentially harmless in that it sensationalized things people really didn't care much about. This show got them in trouble because people care about achievements.

The how took a little more effort to uncover. Most of the major conspiracy theorists at that time participated, and the show was basically just the claims from their various existing materials presented with little opposition, and framed in a way that made them look like expert investigators. None were, of course, in the sense that none had any sort of journalistic credentials or prior work that would normally be expected from people touted as such. The audiences these conspiracy theorists pandered to were generally not inquisitive or skeptical about their authority or background and didn't ask.

Sadly the NASA spokesman who appears on the film, Brian Welch, passed away before I could interview him. But he did make a public statement saying he regretted his poor performance on the show. He simply didn't know what it was going to be. This is a fairly common tactic in tabloid journalism: picking a stooge from the opposition and rewriting his personal failure as that of the organization he represents. Most of the hoax claims were obscure, having only been published in the fringe literature that frankly very few people, including Welch, knew of. Thus he didn't have ready answers for some of the claims. But that doesn't mean that others at NASA, NASA in general, or the aerospace community were similarly stumped. A PR guy from NASA doesn't personify NASA in all respects. But the end result of Welch's effort was that the show made viewers think NASA had no explanation.

But the best part was discovering, by contacting the original interviewees, just how frankly dishonest the editing was. As you can imagine, even if you don't work in film production, it is fairly easy to twist and spin people's words by selective editing and omission. The editors of program simply reworked the interviews to make it tell the story they wanted to tell, regardless of whether the interviewees agreed with the story.
 
That "Truth's protective layers" speech gets trotted out regularly by the hoax crowd - at least wogoga has focused on a different aspect for once.

By way of balance, here's part of Armstrong's speech to Congress after the mission. I read it recently in his biography and was struck by the similarity of the message:

In the next 20 centuries, the age of Aquarius of the great year, the age for which our young people have such high hopes, humanity may begin to understand its most baffling mystery—where are we going?

The earth is, in fact, traveling many thousands of miles per hour in the direction of the constellation Hercules—to some unknown destination in the cosmos. Man must understand his universe in order to understand his destiny.

Mystery however is a very necessary ingredient in our lives. Mystery creates wonder and wonder is the basis for man's desire to understand. Who knows what mysteries will be solved in our lifetime, and what new riddles will become the challenge of the new generations?

More of that speech, and those of the other crew members, here

https://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a11/A11CongressJOD.html
 
Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong speaking (especially at 12:11):

"Today we have with us a group of students, among America's best. To you we say we have only completed a beginning. We leave you much that is undone. There are great ideas undiscovered, breakthroughs available to those who can remove one of the truth's protective layers. There are many places to go beyond belief. Those challenges are yours – in many fields, not the least of which is space, because there lies human destiny." (Transcript)​

A reasonable video on Apollo with some quite convincing arguments: Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?

Cheers, Wolfgang

wogoga, you just jumped the shark.
Those are two of the worst references one could ever use.

Aulis is horrible, I have a copy of one of their books, "Dark Moon: Apollo and the Whistle-Blowers" and if it weren't so troubling it would be funny.
Perhaps next you will bring up Una's coke bottle tale.

"did we land on the Moon" You will notice the video contains no answers, nothing but JAQing off.
 
Almost half of the radiation emerging in this region is directed to the heat shield.

Evidence for this claim please.


Take a location close to the heat shield. How much of the world is hidden behind the heat shield? An infinitely extended or infinitely close plane would cover half of the world. Since thermal radiation goes in all directions, the probability that a photon emitted by a particle close to the heat shield travels in direction to the shield is not far below 50%.


This one shows the heat shield honeycomb being fitted, filled (all 370,000 of 'em) machined and tested @ 11:29.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvW03OYJ_1E&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy&index=10

@ 20:20 shows heat shield failing a drop test.


heatshield_test.JPG


The picture is from your video at 20:22 when first water splashes become visible. Even this low speed water drop test resulted in "failure of the heat shield supporting structure", and water started penetrating into the capsule. In any case, only persons with no idea of orders of physical magnitudes can think that such tests and arguments are relevant to this discussion.
Cheers, Wolfgang
The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?
 
Take a location close to the heat shield. How much of the world is hidden behind the heat shield? An infinitely extended or infinitely close plane would cover half of the world. Since thermal radiation goes in all directions, the probability that a photon emitted by a particle close to the heat shield travels in direction to the shield is not far below 50%.

Gibberish.

The picture is from your video at 20:22 when first water splashes become visible. Even this low speed water drop test resulted in "failure of the heat shield supporting structure", and water started penetrating into the capsule. In any case, only persons with no idea of orders of physical magnitudes can think that such tests and arguments are relevant to this discussion.

Gee, d'ya think there might have been a reason for testing them?

Did you miss the part where this was to test how well it performed as it landed in the ocean, not as it performed on re-entry?

Did you miss the words "resulted in design changes"?
 
...the probability that a photon emitted by a particle close to the heat shield travels in direction to the shield is not far below 50%.

Given the design factors incorporating radiative heat transfer, what is the probability that photon will reach the heat shield?

Even this low speed water drop test resulted in "failure of the heat shield supporting structure", and water started penetrating into the capsule.

Yes, this happened several times until they got the structural design right. The forces of water impact are very different from the forces of aerodynamic braking. The strain rates are many orders of magnitude higher in a water landing.

In any case, only persons with no idea of orders of physical magnitudes can think that such tests and arguments are relevant to this discussion.

You haven't shown the slightest bit of competence in this discussion. You have no idea how the heat shield was designed, how it was meant to operate, and how to analyze its performance. You have got it in your head that your straw-man model "must be" how it was done, and you accept no statement to the contrary.
 
Take a location close to the heat shield. How much of the world is hidden behind the heat shield? An infinitely extended or infinitely close plane would cover half of the world. Since thermal radiation goes in all directions, the probability that a photon emitted by a particle close to the heat shield travels in direction to the shield is not far below 50%.





[qimg]http://www.pandualism.com/upload/heatshield_test.JPG[/qimg]

The picture is from your video at 20:22 when first water splashes become visible. Even this low speed water drop test resulted in "failure of the heat shield supporting structure", and water started penetrating into the capsule. In any case, only persons with no idea of orders of physical magnitudes can think that such tests and arguments are relevant to this discussion.

Shall we cut to the chase?

Please show testing of the heat shield (the type and model used, not preliminary models) that fail in either physical strain rate testing (such as the drop test into water) or in ability to protect the capsule from heat transfer.


It strikes me that this is not dissimilar to the protection that race car drivers receive from the design of their vehicles.
A NASCAR vehicle crashes and things are flying off. It 'looks' like the vehicle is failing to stand up to a crash when in fact it is transferring energy of the impacts to the pieces it is shedding rather than to the driver's compartment. It is a mechanical equivalent, in part, to the thermodynamic actions involved in the re-entry of the Apollo capsule.

Taking this analogy further: the space shuttle is completely different. It protected the cabin by different means. It's mechanical equivalent would be more akin to surrounding a NASCAR vehicle in pillows and mattresses (constructed of Kevlar and steel braid) designed to insulate the vehicle from impact without destroying the mattresses.
 
Did you miss the part where this was to test how well it performed as it landed in the ocean, not as it performed on re-entry?

That particular test was a worst-case scenario in terms of attitude, impact angle (i.e., incurring substantial lateral velocity), and speed. It would be akin, say, to failure of a main parachute combined with bad weather.

Did you miss the words "resulted in design changes"?

And how. That was a Block I boilerplate, b/p 009 if memory serves. This test occurred early in the testing and evaluation period, probably late 1965 to early 1966.
 
I've attempted to tell this to wogoga upthread but it was apparently overlooked: air particles do not impact the heat shield.

The heat shield is ablative, meaning it burns away during use, like brake pads, which are made of similar organic resin binders. The resin decomposes at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven. As it decomposes the gasses outflow. It's this boundary layer of gas that actual air molecules are impacting, and it's these gasses flowing out of the heat shield that carry the heat away. The plume of reentry gasses are very hot.


The interesting point here is not that somebody makes a fool of himself in trying to defend what in reality is only huge hoax. The interesting point is that the (other) forum pundits do not correct such obvious disinformation resp. nonsense.
A material decomposing "at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven" is assumed to protect a heat-shield assumed to withstand temperatures up to 5000°F resp. 3000°C (Figure 2, NASA TN D-7564)!


The bottom of the heat shield is like the bottom of a pot of beans. As long as the water is boiling off it's able to keep the pot bottom at the boiling temp of water. The flame is very hot, but the beans don't burn because hot gasses on the bottom of the pot form a temperature boundary layer, and carry incoming heat away.


Since water vaporization energy is 2257 kJ/kg = 6p2257 Joule per kg, "cooling" capacity of water is not unlimited. The same is valid for the heat shield. In #196 I calculate an upper limit for heat absorption if all the 111 kg mass loss during reentry of Apollo 4 was due to vaporization.


The total energy dissipation budget of Apollo reentry cannot be discussed accurately until you acknowledge the energy consumption of the ablative material decomposing, and realize that these gasses prevent ANY air from impacting the surface of the reentry module.


Momentum in the order of 5400 kg ∙ 11 km/s = 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ≈ 7p6 kg m/s must be taken away from the reentering spacecraft. And you claim that this happens without air particles impacting "the surface of reentry module". In case of Apollo 4, the total mass loss during reentry was 111 kg. In order to slow down the spacecraft from 11 km/s, these 111 kg would have to move away from the heat shield at a speed of around 11 km/s ∙ 5300 kg / 111 kg ≈ 530 km/s = 1,900,000 km/h = 1,200,000 mph = 5p53 m/s. Even the most efficient rocket engines reach exhaust gas velocity of only 4.5 km/s = 16,200 km/h = 10,100 mph = 3p45 m/s.

Cheers, Wolfgang
As long we are able to change our minds we are mentally young
 
Last edited:
The interesting point here is not that somebody makes a fool of himself in trying to defend what in reality is only huge hoax.

Well, no. What's interesting is that the entire world's scientific and engineering community accept Apollo as real. This includes countries that have no interest in protecting and defending the reputation of the United States. And this is no passive acceptance either; papers are still being written and designs are still being based on these principles.

It's not as if there's any controversy over this. If you had a single technical leg to stand on, you might convince someone that Apollo is worth another look. But every post you make reveals some new major deficiency in your understanding. You simply don't know what you're talking about, and more than once you've resorted simply to parroting the standard conspiracy mongers.
 
And you claim that this happens without air particles impacting "the surface of reentry module".

I don't claim this. The entire field of blunt-body aerodynamics claims this. And they're right. Not only do they have the math -- the correct math -- to prove their point, they have practical experience to demonstrate this. Your real problem seems to be that the fact of displaced shock waves, which are not any sort of secret, seems to shake the foundation of your belief in yourself as a genius. Not sorry about that. Real aerospace engineering does not tolerate the ill-prepared or the presumptuous.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom