Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

A material decomposing "at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven" is assumed to protect a heat-shield assumed to withstand temperatures up to 5000°F resp. 3000°C (Figure 2, NASA TN D-7564)!
One word makes that sentence into a lie, wogoga.
A material decomposing "at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven" is assumed selected and tested to protect a heat-shield assumed to withstand temperatures up to 5000°F resp. 3000°C (Figure 2, NASA TN D-7564).
This is explicitly stated in what you cite.

This is a display of ignorance of science .An ablative heat shield ablates and forms a layer of cooler gas :jaw-dropp.
 
One word makes that sentence into a lie, wogoga.
A material decomposing "at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven" is assumed selected and tested to protect a heat-shield assumed to withstand temperatures up to 5000°F resp. 3000°C (Figure 2, NASA TN D-7564).
This is explicitly stated in what you cite.

This is a display of ignorance of science .An ablative heat shield ablates and forms a layer of cooler gas :jaw-dropp.
Wogoga almost exclusively posts carefully worded or out of context statements that give the appearance of a reasonable scientific argument to someone who does not understand any of the science, but which are totally irrelevant and/or simply scientifically wrong in regard to his actual arguments/claims. Oddly, I give wogoga sufficient credit that I have concluded (IMHO) that he probably actually knows enough science to realize this. Which is why I am uncertain if there is much point to try to convince him that his facts are wrong. But it is probably worth rebutting his posts for any other people viewing this thread. Certainly I have learned a great deal about the real science of re-entry from these rebuttals in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Wogoga almost exclusively posts carefully worded or out of context statements that give the appearance of a reasonable scientific argument to someone who does not understand any of the science, but which are totally irrelevant and/or simply scientifically wrong in regard to his actual arguments/claims. Oddly, I give wogoga sufficient credit that I have concluded (IMHO) that he probably actually knows enough science to realize this. Which is why I am uncertain if there is much point to try to convince him that his facts are wrong. But it is probably worth rebutting his posts for any other people viewing this thread. Certainly I have learned a great deal about the real science of re-entry from these rebuttals in this thread.
You may be wrong. Much like Jabba, wogoga is rearranging all of our posts on his own site in a most dishonest manner (excluding the ones he doesn't like).
 
Good point.
Does wogoga also claim that ICBMs cannot work because the re-entering warheads could not survive re-entry?

At this point i would not even be surprised if his denial of reality extended to denying the existence of nukes while at the same time supporting the WTC-Mininukers...
 
I'm talking about the source of the heat during reentry.

Please see: https://www.quora.com/Why-does-a-spacecraft-heat-up-during-reentry

-- Roger
Yes, and I get that. I have no problem understanding that the shock wave/bow wave is not attached to the spaecraft and that this creates a situation in which heat of re-entry is not being transmitted to the craft.

There is another effect going on too though, the vehicle slows down. I note that your link refers to coefficient of drag. That same parameter comes into play in describing air friction.
I see now that at high altutudes, friction is not the driving force in play . Sort of,,, more later.

Work is being done, energy is being transferred. The movement of the craft in the atmosphere gives the craft kinetic energy, that is transferred into compression of the bow wave, that in turn is transferred into heat energy which is carried away from the craft by convection, ablation, and radiation.
In short then, the heat energy should account for part of the loss of kinetic energy.

However, why dies compresdion of a gas heat that has? Molecules have less distance to travel between collisions, there are then more collisions between molecules aka,,, friction.
 
Rather a tortured use of the word friction, and totally not germain.

It used to be said that objects, i.e. spacecraft and rocks, entering our atmosphere are heated by "friction" in the same way as rubbing your hand on a rug. About 10 or 12 years ago, an article in ScinceNews discussed the new understanding of reentry heat as exclusively due to compression, not friction at all, based on analysis of satellite debris recovered intact on the ground and modern computing capabilities to run simulations.
 
However, why dies compresdion of a gas heat that has? Molecules have less distance to travel between collisions, there are then more collisions between molecules aka,,, friction.

I have never seen an explanation of the pressure/temperature relationship in a gas that attributed it to friction.
 
While it isn't friction in the classic mechanical sense, in the case of reentry it works in a manner that makes the term at least usable and somewhat comprehensible.
"It is very graphic analogy that aids in understanding wonderfully, while, strictly speaking, being wrong in every possible way" Terry Pratchett
 
While it isn't friction in the classic mechanical sense, in the case of reentry it works in a manner that makes the term at least usable and somewhat comprehensible.

No, friction is not the primary cause of the extreme heat generated during reentry. Suggesting that it is leads to the kind of misunderstanding that inspired this thread. It's a bad analogy in this case.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
No, friction is not the primary cause of the extreme heat generated during reentry. Suggesting that it is leads to the kind of misunderstanding that inspired this thread. It's a bad analogy in this case.

-- Roger
Read my *********** post, please. Your know it all attitude turns people off science Completely. So back off a bit.
99% of people hear the reality and your explanation as " bla blabla magic bla magic"
At least the bad analogy (as i stated) gets the idea of energy transfer across.
 
To this non-engineer one thing is quite obvious, the air below the capsule is not static, it heats up and flows away to be replaced by cooler air.
Yes, there is a convective component to the model.


This exemplifies one central error of my opponents.

Hot air and/or gaseous heat-shield particles are assumed to be replaced by "cooler air". Yet in the decisive deceleration phase of the Apollo module, such air particles have a typical speed of 10 km/s = 4p1 m/s relative to the heat shield. Averaged thermal velocity of nitrogen is ~470 m/s = 2p47 m/s at room temperature (293°K). Temperature is essentially proportional to the square of particle speed. This roughly means that e.g. an increase in particle speed by factor 10 leads to a temperature increase by factor 100. Since our typical interaction speed is around 20 times higher than the nitrogen thermal speed at 300°K (10 km/s versus 500 m/s resp. 4p1 m/s versus 2p5 m/s), we can attribute a theoretical temperature of 300°K ∙ 20 ∙ 20 = 2p3 ∙ 1p2 ∙ 1p2 Kelvin = 5p12°K = 120 thousand degrees Kelvin to the nitrogen molecules interacting (directly or indirectly) with the heat shield. Up to an altitude of around 100 km = 5p1 m, around 80% = 9n8 of the atmosphere consists of nitrogen (source; see also stagnation enthalpy).

Thus, the assumption that bombardment of the spacecraft by high-speed air particles represents "cooler air" for the heat shield is completely absurd.
It is true that we can cool something by blowing air on it. The main reason is that air heated by the object is replaced by still unheated air. Convective heat transfer is simply more efficient than purely conductive. Yet such a cooling process is only possible if the kinetic energy of the air particles is lower than the thermodynamic energy of the surface particles of the object. Both energy and momentum are simply redistributed between colliding particles, and neither energy nor momentum can disappear in the process.


There is also a radiant component whereby the heated atmospheric gas applies heat to the heat shield via infrared. That's part of the brilliance of the design: the gases produced in the ablation process are substantially opaque to infrared. This principle is also applied in ablative linings for rocket nozzles.


Two devastating objections can be raised against this disinformation:

Since air particles colliding with the shock layer in front of the heat shield (see #308) have theoretical temperatures in the order of tens of thousands degrees Kelvin (see above), their collisions with shock layer particles lead in the first place rather to ultraviolet than to infrared radiation.

The Apollo heat shield is assumed to generally work substantially below 5000 Fahrenheit resp. 3000°K, and thermal radiation in this temperature range lies primarily in the infrared (see Wien's displacement law). So "gases produced in the ablation process" which are "substantially opaque to infrared" would prevent the heat shield from performing its main task, namely from radiating off heat.
​


Cheers, Wolfgang
The believer (e.g. in Apollo or 9/11), instead of questioning his faith with arguments, feels entitled to judge arguments with his faith

A chatroom-chat-free version of this thread nevertheless taking into account all relevant counter-arguments: Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission
 
Last edited:
This exemplifies one central error of my opponents.

Hot air and/or gaseous heat-shield particles are assumed to be replaced by "cooler air". Yet in the decisive deceleration phase of the Apollo module, such air particles have a typical speed of 10 km/s = 4p1 m/s relative to the heat shield. Averaged thermal velocity of nitrogen is ~470 m/s = 2p47 m/s at room temperature (293°K). Temperature is essentially proportional to the square of particle speed. This roughly means that e.g. an increase in particle speed by factor 10 leads to a temperature increase by factor 100. Since our typical interaction speed is around 20 times higher than the nitrogen thermal speed at 300°K (10 km/s versus 500 m/s resp. 4p1 m/s versus 2p5 m/s), we can attribute a theoretical temperature of 300°K ∙ 20 ∙ 20 = 2p3 ∙ 1p2 ∙ 1p2 Kelvin = 5p12°K = 120 thousand degrees Kelvin to the nitrogen molecules interacting (directly or indirectly) with the heat shield. Up to an altitude of around 100 km = 5p1 m, around 80% = 9n8 of the atmosphere consists of nitrogen (source; see also stagnation enthalpy).
What is the velocity of those air particles?
 
This exemplifies one central error of my opponents.

Hot air and/or gaseous heat-shield particles are assumed to be replaced by "cooler air". Yet in the decisive deceleration phase of the Apollo module, such air particles have a typical speed of 10 km/s = 4p1 m/s relative to the heat shield. Averaged thermal velocity of nitrogen is ~470 m/s = 2p47 m/s at room temperature (293°K). Temperature is essentially proportional to the square of particle speed. This roughly means that e.g. an increase in particle speed by factor 10 leads to a temperature increase by factor 100. Since our typical interaction speed is around 20 times higher than the nitrogen thermal speed at 300°K (10 km/s versus 500 m/s resp. 4p1 m/s versus 2p5 m/s), we can attribute a theoretical temperature of 300°K ∙ 20 ∙ 20 = 2p3 ∙ 1p2 ∙ 1p2 Kelvin = 5p12°K = 120 thousand degrees Kelvin to the nitrogen molecules interacting (directly or indirectly) with the heat shield. Up to an altitude of around 100 km = 5p1 m, around 80% = 9n8 of the atmosphere consists of nitrogen (source; see also stagnation enthalpy).

Thus, the assumption that bombardment of the spacecraft by high-speed air particles represents "cooler air" for the heat shield is completely absurd.
It is true that we can cool something by blowing air on it. The main reason is that air heated by the object is replaced by still unheated air. Convective heat transfer is simply more efficient than purely conductive. Yet such a cooling process is only possible if the kinetic energy of the air particles is lower than the thermodynamic energy of the surface particles of the object. Both energy and momentum are simply redistributed between colliding particles, and neither energy nor momentum can disappear in the process.





Two devastating objections can be raised against this disinformation:

Since air particles colliding with the shock layer in front of the heat shield (see #308) have theoretical temperatures in the order of tens of thousands degrees Kelvin (see above), their collisions with shock layer particles lead in the first place rather to ultraviolet than to infrared radiation.

The Apollo heat shield is assumed to generally work substantially below 5000 Fahrenheit resp. 3000°K, and thermal radiation in this temperature range lies primarily in the infrared (see Wien's displacement law). So "gases produced in the ablation process" which are "substantially opaque to infrared" would prevent the heat shield from performing its main task, namely from radiating off heat.
​


Cheers, Wolfgang
The believer (e.g. in Apollo or 9/11), instead of questioning his faith with arguments, feels entitled to judge arguments with his faith

A chatroom-chat-free version of this thread nevertheless taking into account all relevant counter-arguments: Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

The shock layer actually moves air around the capsule out of the capsules way, forcing the air itself to move reduces the heat imparted to the shielding but also causes particle to particle collision that produce heat.

Compression heating as well as friction heating both play a role, but compressive heating is far more powerful given the speed and work involved in slowing the capsules.

The decent angle is also developed do to the crafts structural dynamics less rigid craft like the shuttle have to decelerate slower so can not tolerate a steep decent.
 
This exemplifies one central error of my opponents.

Hot air and/or gaseous heat-shield particles are assumed to be replaced by "cooler air". Yet in the decisive deceleration phase of the Apollo module, such air particles have a typical speed of 10 km/s = 4p1 m/s relative to the heat shield. Averaged thermal velocity of nitrogen is ~470 m/s = 2p47 m/s at room temperature (293°K). Temperature is essentially proportional to the square of particle speed. This roughly means that e.g. an increase in particle speed by factor 10 leads to a temperature increase by factor 100. Since our typical interaction speed is around 20 times higher than the nitrogen thermal speed at 300°K (10 km/s versus 500 m/s resp. 4p1 m/s versus 2p5 m/s), we can attribute a theoretical temperature of 300°K ∙ 20 ∙ 20 = 2p3 ∙ 1p2 ∙ 1p2 Kelvin = 5p12°K = 120 thousand degrees Kelvin to the nitrogen molecules interacting (directly or indirectly) with the heat shield. Up to an altitude of around 100 km = 5p1 m, around 80% = 9n8 of the atmosphere consists of nitrogen (source; see also stagnation enthalpy).

Thus, the assumption that bombardment of the spacecraft by high-speed air particles represents "cooler air" for the heat shield is completely absurd.
It is true that we can cool something by blowing air on it. The main reason is that air heated by the object is replaced by still unheated air. Convective heat transfer is simply more efficient than purely conductive. Yet such a cooling process is only possible if the kinetic energy of the air particles is lower than the thermodynamic energy of the surface particles of the object. Both energy and momentum are simply redistributed between colliding particles, and neither energy nor momentum can disappear in the process.





Two devastating objections can be raised against this disinformation:

Since air particles colliding with the shock layer in front of the heat shield (see #308) have theoretical temperatures in the order of tens of thousands degrees Kelvin (see above), their collisions with shock layer particles lead in the first place rather to ultraviolet than to infrared radiation.

The Apollo heat shield is assumed to generally work substantially below 5000 Fahrenheit resp. 3000°K, and thermal radiation in this temperature range lies primarily in the infrared (see Wien's displacement law). So "gases produced in the ablation process" which are "substantially opaque to infrared" would prevent the heat shield from performing its main task, namely from radiating off heat.
​


Cheers, Wolfgang
The believer (e.g. in Apollo or 9/11), instead of questioning his faith with arguments, feels entitled to judge arguments with his faith

A chatroom-chat-free version of this thread nevertheless taking into account all relevant counter-arguments: Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission


You do realize that the same physics that governs re entry, also governs diesel, Compression ignition diesel engines and if you were actually correct then diesel engines are magic because
Diesel engines couldn't possibly work.:D

So you have proven diesel engined BMWs are a myth.:D
 
This exemplifies one central error of my opponents.

Hot air and/or gaseous heat-shield particles are assumed to be replaced by "cooler air". Yet in the decisive deceleration phase of the Apollo module, such air particles have a typical speed of 10 km/s = 4p1 m/s relative to the heat shield. Averaged .............

Wait, are you saying that the velocity/temp of air molecule interaction with the compression zone is greater than the velocity/temperature of the compressed gasses?

There is a plasma exiting off the edge of the capsule. That MUST be carrying off heat, right? That would be considered a convective heat transfer, right? Plasma out, compression zone stays the same size therefore........?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom