threadworm
Master Poster
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2012
- Messages
- 2,212
Wogoga, I am not a rocket science and have only a rudimentary grasp of ablative heat shields. This is why I have stuck to using things I do understand to prove you wrong, which you are.
However even as a non-rocket scientist looking at the table from which you have derived your figures I can see that you have failed to account for:
The deceleration from the 11 km/s speed you claim within the first 463 seconds of re-entry as it reduces a maximum of mach 29.2 to mach 12.6 (let's skip over the debate about relative speed of sound at different altitudes).
The change in atmospheric density as Apollo 4 descends.
The change in spacecraft mass over the period of the descent.
If I look at the table you used, I can see that over 660 seconds the Apollo 4 CM lost an estimated 300 lbs of weight. That's 0.45 lbs a second, or around 200 grammes. This doesn't seem like an awful lot to me and makes a lot more sense than the imaginary numbers you are plucking from somewhere polite society prevents me from identifying.
(btw - I am more than happy for actual physicists and rocket scientists to correct my back of the envelope stuff)
Why is it unreasonable to suggest that a surface area designed to ablate when it gets hot did that, and as it did so it lost mass and kept the spacecraft cool. Yes, I'm using mass and weight interchangeably - sorry physics fans.
Are you constantly puzzled by how sweating works?
However even as a non-rocket scientist looking at the table from which you have derived your figures I can see that you have failed to account for:
The deceleration from the 11 km/s speed you claim within the first 463 seconds of re-entry as it reduces a maximum of mach 29.2 to mach 12.6 (let's skip over the debate about relative speed of sound at different altitudes).
The change in atmospheric density as Apollo 4 descends.
The change in spacecraft mass over the period of the descent.
If I look at the table you used, I can see that over 660 seconds the Apollo 4 CM lost an estimated 300 lbs of weight. That's 0.45 lbs a second, or around 200 grammes. This doesn't seem like an awful lot to me and makes a lot more sense than the imaginary numbers you are plucking from somewhere polite society prevents me from identifying.
(btw - I am more than happy for actual physicists and rocket scientists to correct my back of the envelope stuff)
Why is it unreasonable to suggest that a surface area designed to ablate when it gets hot did that, and as it did so it lost mass and kept the spacecraft cool. Yes, I'm using mass and weight interchangeably - sorry physics fans.
Are you constantly puzzled by how sweating works?
Last edited: