Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

Wogoga, I am not a rocket science and have only a rudimentary grasp of ablative heat shields. This is why I have stuck to using things I do understand to prove you wrong, which you are.

However even as a non-rocket scientist looking at the table from which you have derived your figures I can see that you have failed to account for:

The deceleration from the 11 km/s speed you claim within the first 463 seconds of re-entry as it reduces a maximum of mach 29.2 to mach 12.6 (let's skip over the debate about relative speed of sound at different altitudes).

The change in atmospheric density as Apollo 4 descends.

The change in spacecraft mass over the period of the descent.

If I look at the table you used, I can see that over 660 seconds the Apollo 4 CM lost an estimated 300 lbs of weight. That's 0.45 lbs a second, or around 200 grammes. This doesn't seem like an awful lot to me and makes a lot more sense than the imaginary numbers you are plucking from somewhere polite society prevents me from identifying.

(btw - I am more than happy for actual physicists and rocket scientists to correct my back of the envelope stuff)

Why is it unreasonable to suggest that a surface area designed to ablate when it gets hot did that, and as it did so it lost mass and kept the spacecraft cool. Yes, I'm using mass and weight interchangeably - sorry physics fans.

Are you constantly puzzled by how sweating works?
 
Last edited:
I don't claim this. The entire field of blunt-body aerodynamics claims this. And they're right. Not only do they have the math -- the correct math -- to prove their point, they have practical experience to demonstrate this. Your real problem seems to be that the fact of displaced shock waves, which are not any sort of secret, seems to shake the foundation of your belief in yourself as a genius. Not sorry about that. Real aerospace engineering does not tolerate the ill-prepared or the presumptuous.

http://wikiwebinfo.in/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/179CFFig2.gif
 
A material decomposing "at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven" is assumed to protect a heat-shield assumed to withstand temperatures up to 5000°F resp. 3000°C (Figure 2, NASA TN D-7564)!

Amazing as it seems, one can boil water in a paper cup. While the flames are well above the ignition temperature of paper, (flame typically 1200 C) the boiling water at only 100C protects the paper from being heated to ignition temp. because it carries away heat! Are you one of those who cannot fathom the difference between heat and temperature?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9gKzea3Cno

Momentum in the order of 5400 kg ∙ 11 km/s = 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ≈ 7p6 kg m/s must be taken away from the reentering spacecraft. And you claim that this happens without air particles impacting "the surface of reentry module". In case of Apollo 4, the total mass loss during reentry was 111 kg. In order to slow down the spacecraft from 11 km/s, these 111 kg would have to move away from the heat shield at a speed of around 11 km/s ∙ 5300 kg / 111 kg ≈ 530 km/s = 1,900,000 km/h = 1,200,000 mph = 5p53 m/s. Even the most efficient rocket engines reach exhaust gas velocity of only 4.5 km/s = 16,200 km/h = 10,100 mph = 3p45 m/s.


Sure wogoga, IF the only way to slow an object were to throw mass away in the opposite direction of travel, and this mass was the equivalent of the mass of the heat shield, then you'd be correct.
Where you got that idea from I am at a loss to say.
 
Last edited:
It strikes me that a better model for the ablative process, if one is to use the paper cup + water example, would be to aim the flame of the bunsen burner down into the cup at the surface of the water.

The effect will be exactly the same as the more common, use the paper cup as a pot above the flame, but is more analogous to the model of a capsule entering the atmosphere where heat of friction meets ablative material.

Better yet would be to have a layer of ice attached to a paper cup bottom and try it that way. (Firm attachment at the paper/ice interface will be an issue though)
 
...The picture is from your video at 20:22 when first water splashes become visible. Even this low speed water drop test resulted in "failure of the heat shield supporting structure", and water started penetrating into the capsule. In any case, only persons with no idea of orders of physical magnitudes can think that such tests and arguments are relevant to this discussion....


From your replies it seems you did not watch the video in its entirety?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvW03OYJ_1E&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy&index=10

@12:07 there is a heat shield sensor test with the ablative material attached and they heat it to above 4000˚ F.

The interesting point here is not that somebody makes a fool of himself ...<SNIP>



And apparently you watched none of this video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnH8wDmN_IA&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy

They go into some detail about the CM and Apollo Atmospheric Entry Phase. Approx. @9:55

You've been a bad student, Wogoga. For your punishment, I hereby sentence you to watch the NASA Toxic Propellant Hazards Safety Film !!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDRKeM9kKxs

Pay attention! There will be a test on it later ...
 
... heat of friction meets ablative material.

It doesn't invalidate the main point of your post, but the heat during reentry is not due to friction. The heat is created by the compression of the air in front of the capsule.

That's one of the things that wogaga seems to not understand. Most of the heat is dissipated some distance away from the capsule, so the heat shield doesn't have to carry away as much heat as it would if friction was the source.

Wikipedia has a good description of how ablative heat shields work. For a long time I assumed that it was just the material melting and flying off that carried away the heat. But, what's important is the gas that the heating of the shield produces. The gas creates a boundary layer in front of the spacecraft, causing most of the heat to flow around the capsule.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
That's one of the things that wogaga seems to not understand.

Indeed, he doesn't understand that the bow wave forms in front of the capsule, and that that's where the zone of peak heating occurs. He doesn't understand that ablation works not only by absorbing the heat needed to enact the ablation, but also in the creation of gas species that are both thermally decoupled from the shield and opaque enough to infrared to prevent overwhelming radiative transfer from the bow wave. As I said, we use a variant of this technique in film cooling of rocket nozzles. It's not a secret.
 
He doesn't understand that ablation works not only by absorbing the heat needed to enact the ablation, but also in the creation of gas species that are both thermally decoupled from the shield and opaque enough to infrared to prevent overwhelming radiative transfer from the bow wave.

I was editing my response to add a mention of that as you entered your post. I learned it from Wikipedia and other sources while doing research before making an earlier post to this thread.

I enjoy learning new things - even when the knowledge contradicts what I previously thought was right. :-)

-- Roger
 
From your replies it seems you did not watch the video in its entirety?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvW03OYJ_1E&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy&index=10

@12:07 there is a heat shield sensor test with the ablative material attached and they heat it to above 4000˚ F.




And apparently you watched none of this video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnH8wDmN_IA&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy

They go into some detail about the CM and Apollo Atmospheric Entry Phase. Approx. @9:55

You've been a bad student, Wogoga. For your punishment, I hereby sentence you to watch the NASA Toxic Propellant Hazards Safety Film !!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDRKeM9kKxs

Pay attention! There will be a test on it later ...

I'm finished with the safety film and I'm ready for the test. PM please.
 
Indeed, he doesn't understand that the bow wave forms in front of the capsule, and that that's where the zone of peak heating occurs. He doesn't understand that ablation works not only by absorbing the heat needed to enact the ablation, but also in the creation of gas species that are both thermally decoupled from the shield and opaque enough to infrared to prevent overwhelming radiative transfer from the bow wave. As I said, we use a variant of this technique in film cooling of rocket nozzles. It's not a secret.

As I understand it, the outgassing was exploited to create a film of protective gas, like from welding rod flux, that helped mitigate oxidation of the exposed spacecraft parts during reentry. There are so many different details they thought to cover for a hoax, innit?
 
heat of friction meets ablative material.
It doesn't invalidate the main point of your post, but the heat during reentry is not due to friction. The heat is created by the compression of the air in front of the capsule.

That's one of the things that wogaga seems to not understand. Most of the heat is dissipated some distance away from the capsule, so the heat shield doesn't have to carry away as much heat as it would if friction was the source.

Wikipedia has a good description of how ablative heat shields work. For a long time I assumed that it was just the material melting and flying off that carried away the heat. But, what's important is the gas that the heating of the shield produces. The gas creates a boundary layer in front of the spacecraft, causing most of the heat to flow around the capsule.

-- Roger

then:
some of the heat of friction re-entry meets interacts with the ablative material.
 
As I understand it, the outgassing was exploited to create a film of protective gas, like from welding rod flux, that helped mitigate oxidation of the exposed spacecraft parts during reentry. There are so many different details they thought to cover for a hoax, innit?

It wasn't really NASA or North American Aviation who thought of it. This is the technology developed to protect re-entry vehicles containing nuclear warheads from ICBMs. But yes, the choice of ablatant was made following lots of study and experimentation involving several modes of heat rejection.
 
It wasn't really NASA or North American Aviation who thought of it. This is the technology developed to protect re-entry vehicles containing nuclear warheads from ICBMs. But yes, the choice of ablatant was made following lots of study and experimentation involving several modes of heat rejection.

Good point.
Does wogoga also claim that ICBMs cannot work because the re-entering warheads could not survive re-entry?

In addition the Soviets put a man in space first.
Does wogoga also claim that Yuri Gargarin should have burned up in re-entry?
 
Good point.
Does wogoga also claim that ICBMs cannot work because the re-entering warheads could not survive re-entry?

In addition the Soviets put a man in space first.
Does wogoga also claim that Yuri Gargarin should have burned up in re-entry?

He seems to think other re-entry scenarios are more credible because their heating profiles are different and generally gentler. Not so ICBM warheads. You want an ICBM warhead to enter hot, fast, and as straight down as possible. I don't know what he thinks about those.
 
It doesn't invalidate the main point of your post, but the heat during reentry is not due to friction. The heat is created by the compression of the air in front of the capsule.

I seem to have conflated the lowering velocity with the ablative process.
The capsule slows because of friction forces even if that friction is creating a compression bow wave which then in turn exerts a force on the capsule acting against gravity.
right/wrong? (probably already answered earlier in the thread)
 
I seem to have conflated the lowering velocity with the ablative process.
The capsule slows because of friction forces even if that friction is creating a compression bow wave which then in turn exerts a force on the capsule acting against gravity.
right/wrong? (probably already answered earlier in the thread)

Basically, the capsule slows down because the air in front of it can't get out of the way quickly enough. As the capsule falls, the air in front of it is compressed. It's this compression that causes the heat (much like a bicycle pump gets hot as you use it).

-- Roger
 
Basically, the capsule slows down because the air in front of it can't get out of the way quickly enough.

-- Roger

Basically the same as is play for a parachute, or for that matter any falling object. A combination of drag coefficient and projected area in the air stream in calculating air friction force on a falling object. A falling sphere allows air to pass around itself better than a rectangular face into the air stream type object.
The convex shape of the parachute traps even more air.

ETA: Or perhaps even better, similar to "compression lift" as on the XB-70
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom