Killtown's Val McClatchey photo analysis

How is the picture being fake irrelevant if a plane crashed.. and I never said anything about the crash, I am just asking questions about the photo...

Who cares about the Photo. It is a fake ... so what?
 
A scams, a scam no matter what crashed where. If her photo is fake which as been alleged (and looks that way by her unbelievable story so far), then plane crashes are irrelevant. The photo would still be fake. You guys are against scams, right?


OK explain this. How would she be able to fake the photo with any degree of accuracy as to the plume location? she would have had to visit the crash site and line up the buildings in the photo with that location. Don't you see how the possibility of a faked photo in the time frame avalable to her is an impossibility?
 
How is the picture being fake irrelevant if a plane crashed.. and I never said anything about the crash, I am just asking questions about the photo...

You are trying to dissasociate the photo with the plane crash for reasons that I can't hope to understand. The photo is a tiny tiny shred of the evidence that flight 93 hit in Shankesville, and yet it is an unnatural obsession with CTists because they think it's anomalous. The problem is all of their anomalies are based on gross ignorance.

Absolutely nothing about that photo is even slightly curious. It's exactly as it should be, and unlike every single CT arguments I've ever encountered, the photo stands up to quite a bit of scrutiny.
 
If anyone has any lingering doubts about just how toxic Killtown is... he's back.

You'll all note that I answered "midwestzero"'s questions, naive but properly asked, to the best of my ability -- informational and polite.

And this is the thanks we get.

Buzz off, Killtown. You're holding back the human race.
 
You´re right, this is pretty funny - so wear it proudly... :D

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/11107459f3cf70ad76.gif[/qimg][qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/11107459f3e86aaef6.gif[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/11107459f3c78666db.gif[/qimg]

I think "Kingdom #28 want's its ID10 Tango* back" would be better, but that'l do.

*Forum rules, but for the curious this something every village has.
 
He's only trolling here in a lame attempt to get his patently ridiculous and arguably libellous nonsense posted on as many sites as he can. He thinks it gives him some sort of legitimacy and he doesn't care one whit about disparaging innocent victims in the process.

He uses numerous sockpuppets on numerous websites to make it appear as though someone - anyone- other than himself actually buys into his nonsensical and unsupported nonsense enough to promote it. Make no mistake, though, nobody but shillclown goes to internet forums other than the loosewiththetruth forum starting threads about shillclown and his BS.

(And yes, I used shillclown deliberately instead of his other name because he doesn't care how much his name is used, even derogatorily, since his purpose is only to get his other name to come up in google searches and such and I, for one, will not contribute to his masturbatory fantasies)
 
Hey "midwestzero", you seem to be a complete doofus, but there is one question I'm sure you can answer expertly:

What is a "Killtown," anyway? What the heck is that handle supposed to even mean?

The only rational theory I've heard was that it's a German-to-English transliteration of the surname Kurzburg, the alleged name of one of the supposed "dancing Israelis" (WARNING -- Link includes flagrant antisemitism and extreme stupidity) invented by one of you nutballs.

Is that it?

Is there any facet of your --er, I mean "Killtown"'s Internet persona that isn't based on irrational hatred and vendetta against other people?

Anything else you'd care to add before you get rebanned?
 
Just to point out a technical issue...

Most consumer brand digital cameras are fairly automatic. They automatically have focus set to infinity, which picks up anything more than about 20ft away. They also adjust exposure for daylight automatically, and the standard LCD display instead of a viewfinder means the photographer knows exactly what their frame is.

What this means is the general frame, exposure, and focus of a photo taken by an amateur will always turn out fine if the photo is taken in bright light conditions and is directed at a subject that's far away.

However, a closer inspection of Val's photo reveals its amateur opportunity-taken nature. Note the dutch tilt to the image, and the extreme wide angle - the subject of the imagine - the smoke plume - is too small in the frame, and sloppy composition puts the guttering of the roof into the top right of the frame.

Altogether a pretty average photo, and EXACTLY what I'd expect from a regular person grabbing an opportunity photo of a frightening and sudden event.

Translation? Val's photo isn't "too perfect", it's just perfectly amateurish. It's not a fake, and neither is her story. Let it go.

-Gumboot
 
If anyone has any lingering doubts about just how toxic Killtown is... he's back.

You'll all note that I answered "midwestzero"'s questions, naive but properly asked, to the best of my ability -- informational and polite.

And this is the thanks we get.

Buzz off, Killtown. You're holding back the human race.

Agreed, but I'll add that it's better not to serve the clown's purposes (by using the name that he is desperately trying to get onto google) any more than is absolutely necessary, because that is what he's after - google rules the world for twoofers, after all.

Better to refer to him as shillclown or nutjob or "the clueless one" or whatever other appropriate names that get the message across, without contributing to his pathetic and hopeless delusions of grandeur.

In fact, we could probably run a poll or take a vote on what name to address him by that doesn't get him any of the publicity that he craves so desperately, and I've no doubt that some of the regulars here could come up with some pretty terrific options :D

ETA: I tried to post this a couple of hours ago but hit the witching hour when the JREF board goes down for a while; then I got sidetracked with other things like real life; then I came back; thus the delay.

No kittens or bunnies were used in this experiment.
 
Last edited:
A scams, a scam no matter what crashed where. If her photo is fake which as been alleged (and looks that way by her unbelievable story so far), then plane crashes are irrelevant. The photo would still be fake. You guys are against scams, right?

How is the picture being fake irrelevant if a plane crashed.. and I never said anything about the crash, I am just asking questions about the photo...

Lies, damn lies, and twoofer comments.

How is "no matter what crashed where" not a comment on the crash? It's clearly tries to set up the argument that it wasn't a plane that crashed there (even though it's done in an entirely cowardly "I never actually said that" way), so as to support the contention that the photo is faked.

And now we've either finally found someone who is as bad at understanding normal human reactions as KT is:


Are you kidding me? She runs out, takes a perceftly lined up shot, drops her camera after only that one shot, can't put the battery back in, and didn't know what she just took??? Who writes this stuff?

Or LashL is completely right:



So what is it, MW0? Are you an insensitive, ignorant, non-empathic social reject, or are you a sock for an insensitive, ignorant, non-empathic social reject?
 
Hey "midwestzero", you seem to be a complete doofus, but there is one question I'm sure you can answer expertly:

What is a "Killtown," anyway? What the heck is that handle supposed to even mean?

The only rational theory I've heard was that it's a German-to-English transliteration of the surname Kurzburg, the alleged name of one of the supposed "dancing Israelis" (WARNING -- Link includes flagrant antisemitism and extreme stupidity) invented by one of you nutballs.
Unlikely for that to be the source of the name, unless Killtown's German knowledge is as poor as his knowledge of everything else in the world.

Kurz= short
Burg=castle

Kill=ermorden from Mord=murder
Town=Stadt

Mordstadt would be a German transliteration for Killtown.
 
Note the dutch tilt to the image, and the extreme wide angle
Sorry, it looks more like telephoto to me. Definitely not wide angle.

- the subject of the imagine - the smoke plume - is too small in the frame
Killtown complains that the smoke looks too big. An effect that is common in photos taken with telephoto lenses (or digitally zoomed in).

sloppy composition puts the guttering of the roof into the top right of the frame.
Are you talking about the right photo?

Here is a nice example to demonstrate the effects of different lenses, and why trying to guess distances and sizes from two dimensional photos is problematic to say the least:
 

Attachments

  • venicesmall.jpg
    venicesmall.jpg
    89.4 KB · Views: 5
Who writes this stuff?
In this case it appears that you did.
879045627a2870bd1.jpg
 
Unlikely for that to be the source of the name, unless Killtown's German knowledge is as poor as his knowledge of everything else in the world.
Thanks for the correction... my wife is fluent in German, but I try not to get her involved with these wretched people. It does indeed look like a mistake made by a total hack who's only experience with German is re-runs of Hogan's Heroes.

Still, I'd wager his grasp of German really is that bad. He's shown no expertise in anything. Remember when he claimed Val couldn't have started a BBQ for the emergency crews, because the electricity was out? :p
 
He's shown no expertise in anything. Remember when he claimed Val couldn't have started a BBQ for the emergency crews, because the electricity was out? :p

Oh, yes. I'd almost forgotten about that particular piece of idiocy.

:dl:
 
Well the way you guys make it sound, it's hard to believe she had a camera with her in the first place, how did she HAPPEN to have a camera, I mean she was so worried and so quick to wanna get help and call the police and whoever else..

just curious
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom