Killtown's Val McClatchey photo analysis

I was wondering what the officials said about when the photo was taken... just curious

No offical time, not accurate to the second, as far as I know. Unlike the other impacts, seismometry and TV video was not available, so the crash time itself is also less precisely known.

Allegedly the FBI timed Ms. McClatchey to try to retrace her steps, and got an answer of slightly over 5 seconds. I haven't seen this in print, so this should be treated as a very rough estimate pending verification. Add to that the 7 or 8 seconds required for the sound of the crash to reach her, triggering the big BOOM that galvanized her onto her porch, and you get a minimum of 13 seconds post-impact. This compares well to the 16 second estimate derived above.

Personally I would expect that it took her slightly longer, but we are really splitting hairs here. There is definitely no reason to suspect the cloud couldn't have drifted that far, given so many uncertainties about when it crashed, when she took the picture, what the cloud looked like earlier in its evolution, and how fast the wind was blowing.
 
I thought I read it was taken only a couple seconds after impact and that's why the smoke doesn't show signs of drifting? The smoke looks like it's still going straight up
 
I thought I read it was taken only a couple seconds after impact and that's why the smoke doesn't show signs of drifting? The smoke looks like it's still going straight up
No, it doesn't.

There is absolutely no way to estimate what the smoke is doing from a single photograph. You would need two in order to correlate image features.

Killtown also failed to understand this concept, but it is really quite simple. The smoke cloud is not rising because it's being heated by an object fixed on the ground, like the plume emanating from a barbeque. On the contrary, the air itself is heated, and that latent (means "remaining") heat is what drives it to rise. We surmise that nearly all of the aircraft fuel burned in a flash-over rather than giving a lingering thermal plume attached to a stationary point. So the heated air bubble can be blown sideways and still give the appearance of a fixed cloud.

In other words, it takes its heat with it. So it can "appear" to go straight up while being blown sideways.

Think of traveling in a hot air balloon. Unless you're looking at the ground, you have no idea whether there's any wind or not, because you travel with it at all times. And neither does our smoke cloud, which, just like the balloon, isn't tethered to anything. The wind blows the whole thing at the same speed. No matter how fast the wind blows, the gondola at the bottom of the balloon will always be straight down from the envelope!

The "stem" that you see does not have to be attached to the impact site. It is, instead, the natural result of vortex formation. Also keep in mind that the cloud is quite large, and thus pretty far away from the ground, so the ground really isn't affecting it at all. This cloud is probably unlike any that you have ever seen before, appearances to the contrary.

Make sense?
 
Last edited:
I thought I read it was taken only a couple seconds after impact and that's why the smoke doesn't show signs of drifting? The smoke looks like it's still going straight up

:socks: (I'm calling this one early)
 
No, it doesn't.

There is absolutely no way to estimate what the smoke is doing from a single photograph. You would need two in order to correlate image features.

Killtown also failed to understand this concept, but it is really quite simple. The smoke cloud is not rising because it's being heated by an object fixed on the ground, like the plume emanating from a barbeque. On the contrary, the air itself is heated, and that latent (means "remaining") heat is what drives it to rise. We surmise that nearly all of the aircraft fuel burned in a flash-over rather than giving a lingering thermal plume attached to a stationary point. So the heated air bubble can be blown sideways and still give the appearance of a fixed cloud.

In other words, it takes its heat with it. So it can "appear" to go straight up while being blown sideways.

Think of traveling in a hot air balloon. Unless you're looking at the ground, you have no idea whether there's any wind or not, because you travel with it at all times. And neither does our smoke cloud, which, just like the balloon, isn't tethered to anything. The wind blows the whole thing at the same speed. No matter how fast the wind blows, the gondola at the bottom of the balloon will always be straight down from the envelope!

The "stem" that you see does not have to be attached to the impact site. It is, instead, the natural result of vortex formation. Also keep in mind that the cloud is quite large, and thus pretty far away from the ground, so the ground really isn't affecting it at all. This cloud is probably unlike any that you have ever seen before, appearances to the contrary.

Make sense?



Were there other photos taken by that lady or someone else that we can use to compare? Maybe those will help determine how the smoke is moving
 
Were there other photos taken by that lady or someone else that we can use to compare? Maybe those will help determine how the smoke is moving

There are none.

Frankly, I don't see the point. Seems to me that you are looking for excuses to call her photo a fake. The simple fact is that, given all of the evidence we have, not a single thing is the least bit suspicious. Nothing at all.
 
Were there other photos taken by that lady or someone else that we can use to compare? Maybe those will help determine how the smoke is moving

I don't recall ever having seen any, nor hearing of any.

Wonderful synopsis of that massive thread btw R. Mackey.
 
Wonderful synopsis of that massive thread btw R. Mackey.

Agreed, entirely. R. Mackey did a great job of distilling that waste-of-bandwidth-of-a-thread down to its incisive bits in short order.

I suspect that those efforts will be wasted upon "midwestzero", though.
 
So you all mean to tell me this lady didn't take anymore pictures?

I'm pretty new to this.. so please help me figure this out
 
That's right.

I'm impressed that she even took one, and the fact that it's centered, properly exposed, and in focus is even more surprising. Especially when you consider that she had other things on her mind -- such as, oh, a huge jetliner smashing into the ground at about 0.8 Mach just a few hundred meters away...

Really, what did you expect?
 
That's right.

I'm impressed that she even took one, and the fact that it's centered, properly exposed, and in focus is even more surprising.



Not really. She took it on a digital camera.

-Gumboot
 
well.. I can't figure out why she only took one, I sure would have taken as many would have filled up my camera/memory card.. so she only took one?!

that's kind of a shocker..
 
well.. I can't figure out why she only took one, I sure would have taken as many would have filled up my camera/memory card.. so she only took one?!

that's kind of a shocker..

yes, yes you're right, that is shocking...I think you may have just cracked the case...

...I mean any sensible person who hears an airplane pass overhead and then a huge boom, goes outside to investigate and sees a plume of black smoke is going to stand there clicking away (obviously knowing that more than one shot will be necessary to provide the kind of photographic record people will want to see) while never thinking of perhaps rushing back inside to call ....ooooo I dunno, maybe the police to report a terrible accident?

I'm just asking questions here
 
well.. I can't figure out why she only took one, I sure would have taken as many would have filled up my camera/memory card.. so she only took one?!

that's kind of a shocker..

If I remember correctly, she may well have dropped the camera.

Anyway, regardless of this, what does this indicate? How is it positive evidence for anything? Why should we care?
 
Just putting it on the record, for future reference, that I called :socks: when midwestzero was only at his/her post #3.
 
Not really. She took it on a digital camera.

-Gumboot
True dat. Though I've certainly botched up plenty of shots I've taken with a digital camera, especially those I've tried to hurry.

I also recall she dropped her camera shortly thereafter, dislodging the battery. Again, not surprising at all. She was literally seconds after being startled out of her wits by a tragedy of epic proportions. What would you do? Call emergency services? (She did -- in addition to capturing a quality photograph.) Grab a fire extinguisher and run for the crash site? Hide in the basement? Or just stand slack-jawed, trying to comprehend what just happened?

midwestzero, I really don't think it's your place to question her actions. Particularly in light of all the harassment she's had to endure thanks to Killtown. How about you let it go?
 
Just putting it on the record, for future reference, that I called :socks: when midwestzero was only at his/her post #3.

I called :socks: on natureboy at post #2. Note the absence of quotes (even though he is quoting other posters), misspellings, poor grammar and annoying use of exclamation points. Look familiar?
 
well.. I can't figure out why she only took one, I sure would have taken as many would have filled up my camera/memory card.. so she only took one?!

that's kind of a shocker..


Why would you do that? I'd find that kinda weird and obsessive.

One picture of a cloud of smoke isn't much different to another.

Or perhaps after taking the photo she realised what she'd just taken a photo of. Some people actually have a degree of humanity and compassion. Odd that.

-Gumboot
 
I called :socks: on natureboy at post #2. Note the absence of quotes (even though he is quoting other posters), misspellings, poor grammar and annoying use of exclamation points. Look familiar?

No, it couldn't be! I saw the math that natureboy did, and it was awful! RemovedBrain was an engineer! Really, he said! So, they couldn't be the same person! Otherwise, that would mean RemovedBrain lied to us!

Oh, wait...
 
I guess anyone could take a picture after a missile hit the ground..... hell yeah let sell it, just like the grilled cheese lady!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom