Killtown's Val McClatchey photo analysis

Well the way you guys make it sound, it's hard to believe she had a camera with her in the first place, how did she HAPPEN to have a camera, I mean she was so worried and so quick to wanna get help and call the police and whoever else..

just curious

[rule8] off, Killtown. Thank you.
 
Well the way you guys make it sound, it's hard to believe she had a camera with her in the first place, how did she HAPPEN to have a camera, I mean she was so worried and so quick to wanna get help and call the police and whoever else..

just curious

Given that now you are claiming she shouldn't have had a camera based on your ridiculous abuse of basic probability, I think it's safe to say that this thread is over and you've lost.
 
...so he's saying that its unusual that someone would have a camera ? I dont know about you , but I thought cameras (digital) are so commonplace that every joe schmoe has some sort of camera in their possession (they even make DISPOSABLE digital camears btw!).

I keep a camera in my car just in case I get into a car accident and need to take photos of the damage, and where the accident occured...
 
Well the way you guys make it sound, it's hard to believe she had a camera with her in the first place, how did she HAPPEN to have a camera, I mean she was so worried and so quick to wanna get help and call the police and whoever else..

just curious
The camera was new to her. she had bought it to use in her real estate business. I remember when I got my first digital camera I kept it close at hand. And I used it a lot. But then as a troll you already knew this.
 
The camera was new to her. she had bought it to use in her real estate business. I remember when I got my first digital camera I kept it close at hand. And I used it a lot. But then as a troll you already knew this.

so it proves that she had a reason to have a camera around.
 
I have several cameras, digital and otherwise, and can't imagine why anyone would think it strange to have a camera nearby.
 
I thought she said she had her camera ready by her side or something? What did she have her camera "ready" for? Seems like she was anticipating something......When did she start her real estate career?
 
Last edited:
omg, now you're nitpicking.

she had a camera nearby , its not strange for people to have cameras
she had a camera because she works in real estate, mabye her "anticipation" was to expect a phone call from a client to have her take pictures of hteir property
she had a camera ready, mabye because she was about to leave for work and needed to take the camera with her?

THER's alot of good explanations for any comment as "having the camera ready". But please provide a direct source of your "assumption" that she did say she had the camera ready.
 
I thought she said she had her camera ready by her side or something? What did she have her camera "ready" for? Seems like she was anticipating something

Shut up, Killtown. You already know she was anticipating a fly-over that day, as one of her friends was going to make a helicopter pass, and she was going to photograph that. Gosh, how suspicious. Why don't you just lead us down the path of breadcrumbs some more...

You also know that you're the only -- and I mean the only person who's interested in your own crap, right? We get other addled Troofers here all the time, but not one of them ever says "Hey, did you read that Killfool whatever his name is's stuff, that guy's real sharp!" Not a single one! Boy, that must smart.
 
Last edited:
It's like this, everyone wants to forget what really happened on 9/11, look at all the people that died, and look at the families WHO ARE INVOLVED IN THE MOVEMENT, you people need to open your eyes about the facts, for one I'm not Killtown and I do not even know him, I've read some of his items and I do not support all of them but I support SOME... anyways back to Val... I just find it very BIZARRE how she happen to anticipate a HELICOPTER flight on the morning of the biggest one-to-billion "terrorist" attack in her back yard?
 
omg, now you're nitpicking.

she had a camera nearby , its not strange for people to have cameras
she had a camera because she works in real estate, mabye her "anticipation" was to expect a phone call from a client to have her take pictures of hteir property
she had a camera ready, mabye because she was about to leave for work and needed to take the camera with her?

THER's alot of good explanations for any comment as "having the camera ready". But please provide a direct source of your "assumption" that she did say she had the camera ready.




Because I'm on sites a lot, I nearly always have a fully charged and ready digital camera on me and could lay my hands on it in a few seconds.
 
Sorry, it looks more like telephoto to me. Definitely not wide angle.


It's taken on the wide end of the zoom. However in that particular comment I was talking about the composition, not the focal length. It's not taken at the long end of the zoom (telephoto).



Killtown complains that the smoke looks too big. An effect that is common in photos taken with telephoto lenses (or digitally zoomed in).


Zooming won't affect the actual physical size of the object (which is what KT was objecting to) it only affects the size of the object proportional to the frame.



Are you talking about the right photo?


No, we're not. That's a cropped version of the original.

The original photo is here. Not the drain in the top right. It's definately wide angle.



Here is a nice example to demonstrate the effects of different lenses, and why trying to guess distances and sizes from two dimensional photos is problematic to say the least:


Judging distance and size from a 2D image alone is next to impossible. However it's quite a simple process (within degrees of error) if you know precisely where the photo was taken and can correlate the image with a plan view (such as an aerial photograph) which is precisely what both KT and others such as myself and Arkan did.

KT and us don't really actually disagree about the size of the smoke column, or it's position (give or take). What we dispute is whether such a size and position is possible or not from an airliner crashing into the ground where UA93 hit.

-Gumboot
 
I just find it very BIZARRE how she happen to anticipate a HELICOPTER flight on the morning of the biggest one-to-billion "terrorist" attack in her back yard?


She didn't "happen to anticipate a helicopter flight". She very specifically expected one, because it had been ARRANGED IN ADVANCE. UA93 hardly crashed into her backyard, it was a good distance from her home, and many other people were much closer to the crash and WEREN'T expecting helicopter flyovers and DIDN'T have their cameras ready and DIDN'T take photos.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom