Killtown's Val McClatchey photo analysis

I guess anyone could take a picture after a missile hit the ground..... hell yeah let sell it, just like the grilled cheese lady!
I guess anyone can post stupid stuff without proof. Hell, yeah, let's make a DVD and sell it, just like Loser Change!
 
well.. I can't figure out why she only took one, I sure would have taken as many would have filled up my camera/memory card.. so she only took one?!

that's kind of a shocker..
Lets assume she filled up her camera/memory card then...

[tin-foil hat]well.. I can't figure out why she took so many photo's, surely she would have been more concerned about what happened or have been more concerned about getting help or calling 911?!

that's kind of a shocker..[/tin-foil hat]

:boggled:
 
I guess anyone could take a picture after a missile hit the ground..... hell yeah let sell it, just like the grilled cheese lady!

And it's inconceivable to you that some people aren't as classlessly exploitive as the grilled cheese lady?

It must suck to be you.
 
I guess anyone could take a picture after a missile hit the ground..... hell yeah let sell it, just like the grilled cheese lady!
midwestzero, you've made a very poor start here. I have been in touch with Val McClatchey. What evidence of wrongdoing do you have that you'd like me to present to her?

Post that evidence today, or shut the hell up. Got it?
 
I guess anyone could take a picture after a missile hit the ground..... hell yeah let sell it, just like the grilled cheese lady!
Ms. McClatchey doesn't profit from the picture. All proceeds go here.

There is no proof that a missile had anything to do with the events around flight 93.

Furthermore, Killtown subscribes to the "Three Stooges" conspiracy theory:

He has at various times pointed out the original crash site, a proposed site that he thinks is where some explosives were set off, and another site where some trees were burned. Whoever was to carry out the deception set off the explosives at one site, burned the trees at a second site, and scattered debris at a third site. Three sites, completely inept and bumbling execution, could only be the three stooges.

Care to join Killtown in watching the old reruns for clues?
 
There wasn't an "official" time. UAL93 crashed around 10:03 am, and Val snapped the picture shortly thereafter. How shortly? That was the subject of some conjecture and educated guessing in that other thread. My best guess was one or two minutes, putting it at 10:04 or 10:05. Others thought it could have been as many as five IIRC.
There is an official time of the crash:

United 93 crashed in Pennsylvania at 10:03:11, 125 miles from Washington, D.C. The precise crash time has been the subject of some dispute. The 10:03:11 impact time is supported by previous National Transportation Safety Board analysis and by evidence from the Commission staff's analysis of radar, the flight data recorder, the cockpit voice recorder, infrared satellite data, and air traffic control transmissions. (9/11 Commission report, page 30.)
Footnote 168 to chapter 1:

We also reviewed a report regarding seismic observations on September 11, 2001, whose authors conclude that the impact time of United 93 was "10:06:05±5 (EDT)." Won-Young Kim and G. R. Baum, "Seismic Observations during September 11, 2001,Terrorist Attack," spring 2002 (report to the Maryland Department of Natural Resources). But the seismic data on which they based this estimate are far too weak in signal-to-noise ratio and far too speculative in terms of signal source to be used as a means of contradicting the impact time established by the very accurate combination of FDR, CVR, ATC, radar, and impact site data sets. These data sets constrain United 93's impact time to within 1 second, are airplane- and crash-site specific, and are based on time codes automatically recorded in the ATC audiotapes for the FAA centers and correlated with each data set in a process internationally accepted within the aviation accident investigation community.
Furthermore, one of the study's principal authors agrees that
"seismic data is not definitive for the impact of UA 93." Email from Won-Young Kim to the Commission,"Re: UA Flight 93," July 7, 2004; see also Won-Young Kim,"Seismic Observations for UA Flight 93 Crash near Shanksville, Pennsylvania during September 11, 2001," July 5, 2004 Source
 
Last edited:
I guess anyone could take a picture after a missile hit the ground..... hell yeah let sell it, just like the grilled cheese lady!

There was no "missile" involved.

The photograph is Val's personal property. She can sell it if she wants to.

As we've already explained to you, she doesn't profit from her photograph. Money received goes to a charity.

I've already asked you once, nicely, to stop these insinuations. The fact that you still carry on, despite admitting your total lack of knowledge about this subject, is deeply disappointing. I hereby ordain you into the Order of the Tinfoil Hat.
 
The fundamental flaw in Killtown's analysis is that he completely and totally neglects the horizontal velocity of the plane. In that particular picture, UA93 would have been traveling right to left, at the time of impact (40 degree angle downards). 600 mph * cos(40-deg) is alot of horizontal velocity to completely ignore.

Killtown claims the smoke plume is "too far" to the left, which is exactly the direction the plane was traveling. I've asked Killtown's for months to address this and he responds by asking me to "prove" that there was horizontal velocity. The horizontal velocity of the fuel at the time of impact would, in fact, shift the plume to the left in that image. How much? Impossible to say. But some. Killtown has and will continue to ignore this, assuming the plume is directly above the crash site -- drifting only with the wind.
 
Last edited:
I've asked Killtown's for months to address this and he responds by asking me to "prove" that there was horizontal velocity.

Is that why he's always going on about the 40degree impact vs. 90degree?

Or is it that he thinks trigonometry is part of the cover up?

Is it even possible to answer these questions?
 
Is that why he's always going on about the 40degree impact vs. 90degree?

Or is it that he thinks trigonometry is part of the cover up?

Is it even possible to answer these questions?

Yes, exactly. It's a preposterous argument, anyway. On one hand we have scientific equipment whose job it is to record this information, on the other hand we have passerbys who use precise language like "the plane was pointing, like, straight down".

Plus, he then whips out the old "The FBI found the FDR" canard. At this point I ask him what evidence he has that the FDR was fabricated or tampered with, and I don't ever get an answer. The conspiracy doesn't fit together unless you first assume there is a conspiracy. He is the master of circular logic in this regard. He's also the master of the "prove me wrong" school of proving your point -- but that's another story.
 
quote : If I remember correctly, she may well have dropped the camera.

She dropped her camera?!?! what?
 
quote : If I remember correctly, she may well have dropped the camera.

She dropped her camera?!?! what?

I also read this somewhere but i can´t remember where. :(
Oh, and welcome on Board, Midwestzero. :)
 
"Killtown" has had numerous sockpuppets at the DU board (his most recent of many is "bushatbooker" there) and I have no doubt that he is continuing in that tradition here, on this very thread, in fact.

:socks:
 
"Killtown" has had numerous sockpuppets at the DU board (his most recent of many is "bushatbooker" there) and I have no doubt that he is continuing in that tradition here, on this very thread, in fact.

:socks:

Damn, get out of my head, Lash. :D
 
"I didn't even aim. I was just like, 'Oh, my God,' " she said. She dropped the camera, jolting the battery loose, then tried in vain to call her husband, son and daughter. She had no idea what she'd captured until the state police put a call out to people in the area, asking for photos, debris and other evidence. She took a printout of her photo to the police, she said, and, within an hour, FBI agents were at her house.
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/06218/711239-85.stm
 
Damn, get out of my head, Lash. :D

Lol, Oliver!

Hey, by the way, since you are the undisputed resident badge master...

I need a badge. Apparently, I'm one of the very few skeptics here who is NOT on 28th's ignore list. I think this calls for an anti-badge! :D
 
Are you kidding me? She runs out, takes a perceftly lined up shot, drops her camera after only that one shot, can't put the battery back in, and didn't know what she just took??? Who writes this stuff?
 
Lol, Oliver!

Hey, by the way, since you are the undisputed resident badge master...

I need a badge. Apparently, I'm one of the very few skeptics here who is NOT on 28th's ignore list. I think this calls for an anti-badge! :D

Why should i make one if you´re on his list tommorow or the day after? :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom