Killtown's Val McClatchey photo analysis

Are you kidding me? She runs out, takes a perceftly lined up shot, drops her camera after only that one shot, can't put the battery back in, and didn't know what she just took??? Who writes this stuff?

Is it that important why she made only one picture since
we all know that it was a planecrash?
 
Are you kidding me? She runs out, takes a perceftly lined up shot, drops her camera after only that one shot, can't put the battery back in, and didn't know what she just took??? Who writes this stuff?
Well, I was giving you the benefit of the doubt. However, given your last few posts, it appears some edification is in order.
Fallacy: Appeal to Ridicule



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Also Known as: Appeal to Mockery, The Horse Laugh.

Description of Appeal to Ridicule
The Appeal to Ridicule is a fallacy in which ridicule or mockery is substituted for evidence in an "argument." This line of "reasoning" has the following form:


X, which is some form of ridicule is presented (typically directed at the claim).
Therefore claim C is false.
This sort of "reasoning" is fallacious because mocking a claim does not show that it is false. This is especially clear in the following example: "1+1=2! That's the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard!"

It should be noted that showing that a claim is ridiculous through the use of legitimate methods (such as a non fallacious argument) can make it reasonable to reject the claim. One form of this line of reasoning is known as a "reductio ad absurdum" ("reducing to absurdity"). In this sort of argument, the idea is to show that a contradiction (a statement that must be false) or an absurd result follows from a claim. For example: "Bill claims that a member of a minority group cannot be a racist. However, this is absurd. Think about this: white males are a minority in the world. Given Bill's claim, it would follow that no white males could be racists. Hence, the Klan, Nazis, and white supremists are not racist organizations."

Since the claim that the Klan, Nazis, and white supremists are not racist organizations is clearly absurd, it can be concluded that the claim that a member of a minority cannot be a racist is false.

Examples of Appeal to Ridicule

"Sure my worthy opponent claims that we should lower tuition, but that is just laughable."

"Support the ERA? Sure, when the women start paying for the drinks! Hah! Hah!"

"Those wacky conservatives! They think a strong military is the key to peace!"
http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/appeal-to-ridicule.html

The argument from personal incredulity, also known as argument from personal belief or argument from personal conviction, refers to an assertion that because one personally finds a premise unlikely or unbelievable, the premise can be assumed not to be true, or alternately that another preferred but unproven premise is true instead.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_personal_incredulity
 
uh....

A scams, a scam no matter what crashed where. If her photo is fake which as been alleged (and looks that way by her unbelievable story so far), then plane crashes are irrelevant. The photo would still be fake. You guys are against scams, right?
 
Why should i make one if you´re on his list tommorow or the day after? :D

You should make me one because he keeps failing to put me on his ignore list for weeks now even though I continue to go against his self-imposed "rules" that get everyone else on his ignore list.

So, I figure that if you make me a new anti-badge, he will take sufficient offence to it that he will, finally, put me on his ignore list along with all of the other cool kids :D

So, yeah, technically, I'm just using you for your badge making abilities, but what the heck, it's all for a good cause. I think it should say something like "Sheesh, what do I have to do to get on 28th's IGNORE list already?"

Either that or "Come on, put me on your ignore list already, 28th!"

Or, as another alternative, ":( why oh why am I not on 28th's ignore list?"

Or, just make up one of your own applicable to the situation :D
 
Last edited:
Are you kidding me? She runs out, takes a perceftly lined up shot, drops her camera after only that one shot, can't put the battery back in, and didn't know what she just took??? Who writes this stuff?

:socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks:
 
A scams, a scam no matter what crashed where. If her photo is fake which as been alleged (and looks that way by her unbelievable story so far), then plane crashes are irrelevant. The photo would still be fake. You guys are against scams, right?

:socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks: :socks:
 
A scams, a scam no matter what crashed where. If her photo is fake which as been alleged (and looks that way by her unbelievable story so far), then plane crashes are irrelevant. The photo would still be fake. You guys are against scams, right?

You got that wrong. If there was a plane crash (and there was)
then it´s irrelevant if the foto is faked or not. ;)
 
You should make me one because he keeps failing to put me on his ignore list for weeks now even though I continue to go against his self-imposed "rules" that get everyone else on his ignore list.

So, I figure that if you make me a new anti-badge, he will take sufficient offence to it that he will, finally, put me on his ignore list along with all of the other cool kids :D

So, yeah, technically, I'm just using you for your badge making abilities, but what the heck, it's all for a good cause. I think it should say something like "Sheesh, what do I have to do to get on 28th's IGNORE list already?"

Either that or "Come on, put me on your ignore list already, 28th!"

Or, as another alternative, ":( why oh why am I not on 28th's ignore list?"

Or, just make up one of your own applicable to the situation :D

You´re right, this is pretty funny - so wear it proudly... :D

11107459f3cf70ad76.gif
11107459f3e86aaef6.gif

11107459f3c78666db.gif
 
Last edited:
You´re right, this is pretty funny - so wear it proudly... :D

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/11107459f3cf70ad76.gif[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/11107459f3c78666db.gif[/qimg]

Woooooooooo damn hoooooooooooo!

Thanks, Oliver!!

(psst... now, how do I make it into an avatar sized picture?)
 
Oh no! Now we won't be able to tell anyone apart! It's hard enough as it is with Architect and JimBenArm! :eek:

LOL. I'm not going to change my avatar at present, but I'm delighted to have the option, thanks to Oliver's skills and quick response time with his badge work. :D
 
A scams, a scam no matter what crashed where. If her photo is fake which as been alleged (and looks that way by her unbelievable story so far), then plane crashes are irrelevant. The photo would still be fake. You guys are against scams, right?

I am completely against scams. Unfortunately, all the evidence points to this photo being legitimate. It's in the right place, at the right time, and shows what it should show. It confirms a hypothesis that has hundreds, if not thousands, of corrobarating data points. It's pretty rock solid, as best as I can tell.
 
How is the picture being fake irrelevant if a plane crashed.. and I never said anything about the crash, I am just asking questions about the photo...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom