Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

1. her statement is not all we have learned about it, the school board confirmed it and offered to make the documents available.

That's the only valid point you make. We know she was suspended. We don't know that it was just. Therefore, we can't use this as evidence that she has experience or whatever is the argument for whatever skill she's supposed to have that let her make the police look so damn foolish.

2. "extra inconsistent"? :rolleyes: It is called an admission against self interest. The courts that created that exception assumed it unlikely that a person would make a statement against his own interest untruthfully.

Yes, extra inconsistent. What courts don't do is not give any statement any weight but those that could be against self interest (this statement actually isn't that either).

You on the other hand only believe statements against the family and then conclude that means they are lying superpeople able to trick the police with a clock.


3. The irony of accusing ME of speculation when your post is nothing but speculation makes me giggle. "perhaps"?

And I laugh back at you champ. Your post was speculation and poorly supported, like most of your posts in this thread. My perhaps statements were echoing your own argument. Thankfully this means you can recognize your argument as speculation when someone else says it back to you. Perhaps we can move on to your recognizing it as such when you advance it.


EDIT: If some breightbartesk tool had done what you think this family must have done to a liberal group, you'd be eating it up.
 
Last edited:
I guess I´ll have to repeat: I was asked to provide evidence about Ahmed´s sister´s record. She was suspended for in some incident revolving around an alleged bomb threat. I provided her own admission. I´m not claiming anything about her guilt, I don´t know and neither do you. But together with the rest of the information about Ahmeds family, the fact that she seems to have been telling Ahmed what to say to the press, his dad etc. makes one think that they are not as innocent and naive as they want us to believe.

That does not follow. If she was suspended without good reason, then that does not increase the likelihood that she masterminded some trick. Even further, even if it was with good reason that still doesn't make it likely! I'm reminded of the cop on the OJ Simpson case who made racist comments, and therefore must have planted evidence...of OJ's blood...that he couldn't have had access too... Having motivation doesn't make it likely that they, even as a family conspiracy, managed to make the police 'frame themselves'.

Even then, with that frankly crazy situation, the police took the bait and did wrong.


Ahmed admitted the clock looked suspicious, he knew of his sister´s issue, but kept putting the suspicious looking clock on everyone´s face?

Putting it in everyone's face? Until now I was trying to take your argument seriously. :(

Don´t you think there is a possibility that they wanted to stir up a reaction on purpose and then play the victims? I admit I could be wrong, at the moment we only have partial information, but I don´t understand how some people can so closed-mindedly dismiss the possibility of the hoax out of hand. Like that ranting guy said in the youtube video, this position cames from a different type of prejudice, you are assuming that the techers, police etc. behaved badly because it happened in Texas. And Texasphobia is an acceptable kind of prejudice in some leftist environments, it seems.


I find it extraordinarily unlikely and also irrelevant to criticizing what happened.
 
hey, when she gets back from the family's all expense paid trip to Qatar she can consent to release the documents.

Until then, you can put me solidly in the skeptic pile.

:thumbsup:

I thought skeptical meant not believing something without proof. You may have it turned around a bit.

But if you mean that you will suspect her of a crime in the meantime, that is of course your right as a private citizen. But it probably would be most fair to her to not a accuse her of a crime publicly until and unless you have evidence of it. Your call...

Frankly if there was a plausible case that she threatened to blown up the school, I suspect she would have been subjected to more repercussions than a one week suspension. I mean, her brother was suspended 3 days and arrested by the police for bringing in a clock and repeatedly not threatening the school.
 
What courts don't do is not give any statement any weight but those that could be against self interest (this statement actually isn't that either).

lolz, "perhaps" you wanna try that in English?

You weren't acting hypocritically, you were just "echoing" my arguments...

'k. :rolleyes:
 
lolz, "perhaps" you wanna try that in English?

You weren't acting hypocritically, you were just "echoing" my arguments...

'k. :rolleyes:

I literally repeated an argument you made and you dismissed it as invalid because it was speculation. That was one of my points so thanks for agreeing! The hypocrisy is all yours.

It is in English. Courts don't give statements that are not against self-interests no weight, as you have. You dismiss her denial that her suspension was just because it isn't against her interests as you see them.
 
It is in English. Courts don't give statements that are not against self-interests no weight, as you have.

"Courts don't give statements that are not against self-interests no weight, as you have."

Mmmm-mmmm, it is like the super bowl of double/triple negatives.

99% of the guys in the joint will tell you that they did not not do nothing.

:D
 
By the way, you seem unaware of the fact that the invention was dangerous and could have electrocuted anyone who reached in the case. The actual useful clock that we wrecked did not have that problem.

I still do not understand how folk here keep bringing up the allegedly unsafe construction of this clock as if it were in any way relevant (oh, you really got them now!). As far as I know, he was not arrested for possession of an electrocution hazard so how is this in any way relevant? I think someone quoted the law regarding hoax bombs for which he was arrested. Did it actually mention anything about electrical hazards? :shocked: I am guessing it did not.

Also, it is nice that you know that he wrecked a clock to make his project. The consensus seems to be that he rehoused the innards of a RadioShack clock but I have not seen a source anywhere speaking as to the initial condition of said clock. Maybe it was brand new and in perfect condition recently ordered from Ebay or maybe it was a stomped on non-working clock. If you could find a source that clarifies this that would be great (not that it has any relevance to the events, in any case). Otherwise, speaking about how he broke a perfectly useful clock to make a less useful clock (your opinion) is no more than speculation (and not relevant speculation at that).

I am also greatly amused with regard to the common attaching of overwhelming significance to his use of the word "invent" (and variations) as if suggesting that if only the kid hadn't used that word various folk might have been very sympathetic to his plight but the fact that he used the word is very suggestive that he might be a terrorist in training. :rolleyes: On contrary, this is no more than naked confirmation bias such that this is seen as evidence of something nefarious (even if it doesn't particularly make any sense to see it in this way).

I guess the idea is that he is obviously lying by his idiosyncratic use of that word. I really can't see that. No clock that he could ever produce (from scratch, even) could ever be considered an invention (in the way that word is commonly understood) because clocks were already invented a long time ago. It doesn't matter if he rehoused the guts of an electronic clock or if he painstakingly crafted the gears of a mechanical clock of entirely of his own design. Given that he is unlikely to be so profoundly stupid as to not know this (and as to not know that most people also know this), I can't see, for that reason alone, how he could ever have meant to use that word in that way.


P.S. And yup, I am also amused by the whole line of "reasoning" brought up earlier about how the fact that it looks nothing like a bomb proves it was a hoax bomb. :rolleyes:
 
you make a good case, although if you want anyone to take you seriously, you will want to drop the INCREDIBLY patronizing and therefore racist reference to a "brown" person
I was merely referring to the color brown - not anything or anyone else. It is you who made the connection to a person, therefore revealing your own true nature. Are you sure your not a liberal?
 
"Courts don't give statements that are not against self-interests no weight, as you have."

Mmmm-mmmm, it is like the super bowl of double/triple negatives.

99% of the guys in the joint will tell you that they did not not do nothing.

:D


No. Read it again and count what is modifying what.
 
You know I believe that ahmed has had his civil rights violated, and Dawkins went a little to far in the ISIS comparison, but he was right that the kid didn't invent anything.
 
That does not follow. If she was suspended without good reason, then that does not increase the likelihood that she masterminded some trick. Even further, even if it was with good reason that still doesn't make it likely! I'm reminded of the cop on the OJ Simpson case who made racist comments, and therefore must have planted evidence...of OJ's blood...that he couldn't have had access too... Having motivation doesn't make it likely that they, even as a family conspiracy, managed to make the police 'frame themselves'.

Even then, with that frankly crazy situation, the police took the bait and did wrong.

We don´t know the reason, we just know that she was suspended. But if the teachers knew about the incident it could explain why they thought Ahmed could be doing something similar.

It could go both ways, it could mean that the school tends to overreact towards muslims or it could show a pattern of behaviour from Ahmed´s family.



Putting it in everyone's face? Until now I was trying to take your argument seriously. :(

It´s a way of speaking. He was told to put it away, instead of that, he plugged it and set the alarm off in class.

I find it extraordinarily unlikely and also irrelevant to criticizing what happened.

Why irrelevant? All I´m saying is that we don´t know what happened, and that it is as wrong to assume closed mindedly that Ahmed was up to something dodgy as to assume closed mindedly that he was innocent and that it´s all the school´s fault. And that this last position is probably held by those who have a prejudice against Texans, and is not a reasonable, skeptical position.
 
But I thought that you couldn't see it was a clock from the outside? And that from the inside even a photo revealed to many posters that it was the guts of a Radio Shack clock with nothing that looked like a classical bomb or explosives. Probably because it was a clock. Maybe not a very good clock, but you should have seen my own projects at 14.

"It didn't look like actual bomb guts!"

This is incredibly weak, as few know what it looks like, as opposed to what Hollywood portrays, which is wires and a board and a timer display.

And btw some do look like his, sans display. This bizarre picture here with what looks like an entire computer motherboard is more distorting than useful, as a "counter" example, probably selected by rhetoriticians for that reason.

Some also approach this as if defending him in a court case. That isn't what this is about. It's about whether his ****-stirring sister drafted him into her efforts to create an incident, similar to the dentist in Florida who deliberately infected people with AIDS to accelerate fears people other than gays got the disease.
 
I am also greatly amused with regard to the common attaching of overwhelming significance to his use of the word "invent" (and variations) as if suggesting that if only the kid hadn't used that word various folk might have been very sympathetic to his plight but the fact that he used the word is very suggestive that he might be a terrorist in training. :rolleyes: On contrary, this is no more than naked confirmation bias such that this is seen as evidence of something nefarious (even if it doesn't particularly make any sense to see it in this way).
....

"amused." Obama and all the Lil Inventor's supporters told us what a wonderful example the Lil' Inventor was of STEM and he got all sorts of offers from MIT, etc, when in fact that clock was hot garbage even for a 14 year old.
 
"It didn't look like actual bomb guts!"

This is incredibly weak, as few know what it looks like, as opposed to what Hollywood portrays, which is wires and a board and a timer display.

And btw some do look like his, sans display. This bizarre picture here with what looks like an entire computer motherboard is more distorting than useful, as a "counter" example, probably selected by rhetoriticians for that reason.

Some also approach this as if defending him in a court case. That isn't what this is about. It's about whether his ****-stirring sister drafted him into her efforts to create an incident, similar to the dentist in Florida who deliberately infected people with AIDS to accelerate fears people other than gays got the disease.

Hi! I don't think you have posted much on this thread, or at least not lately. If you haven't the time to look back over this thread recently you may not have understood the context of my remarks, which in fact were just beyond the section of the same post of mine that you quoted above.

To save you some time in reviewing the current discussion I will re-iterate some of the main points I was making:

1. No one at the school or the police believed it was a bomb- the way they handled the situation and their statements since then make that clear.

2. If the intent was to make a hoax bomb, which is what is being proposed by some here, then it had to look like a bomb and the guilty party would have to convince people to believe it was a bomb.

3. Unfortunately for this conspiracy theory, it did not look like a bomb (see #1 above), and Ahmed from the very first when he brought it to school, even before he was questioned about it, identified it as a clock, which is what it was.

4. The fact that a bomb could be made to look like anything doesn't help here- the goal of a hoax bomb is to make it look like a real bomb, particularly in the eyes of a naive audience. Making a real bomb look like a soda can may be one way to bring down an airplane. Making a hoax bomb look like a soda can would not work, particularly if you tell everyone, including your engineering teacher before he asks, that it is a soda can. And indeed, it is a soda can.

This is the main problem in the "a bomb can be made to look like anything" argument in this context. A hoax bomb cannot. It must look like a bomb in the popular imagination. This is especially a problem when the proposed hoaxer actually from the very start identifies the device as a clock, even before they are asked if it is a hoax bomb. The fact it was indeed a clock only increases the obvious fallacy of the hoax bomb fallacy.

Glad to help summarize my view, but I must admit this is a very repetitive thread and I don't wish to bore people. I only responded to your post because you quoted mine directly.

If you wish to charge his sister with drafting him into some other conspiracy (given the hoax bomb one doesn't fly) you may wish to find some evidence for that. Are you accusing Ahmed of spreading AIDS, because otherwise the connection that you are trying to make in the last part of your post seems unclear to me. The dentist was really infecting people with AIDS. Was his sister involved?
 
Yes, it´s getting a bit boring and repetitive. I´ll give it a rest until more information comes up.
 
<snip>

To save you some time in reviewing the current discussion I will re-iterate some of the main points I was making:

1. No one at the school or the police believed it was a bomb- the way they handled the situation and their statements since then make that clear.

False, or at least unsupported. There were many people at the school, and some of them could have believed it had the potential to be a bomb, even if they thought it was unlikely to be an imminent threat. Also, it is not necessary to believe that something is on the verge of exploding to be worthy of investigation. On top of that, knowledge of who Ahmed is (i.e. a geeky, pleasant 14-year old freshman) may have dramatically mitigated the chance of there being an imminent threat in the minds of his teachers, but that shouldn't count as evidence that the device itself was innocuous.

2. If the intent was to make a hoax bomb, which is what is being proposed by some here, then it had to look like a bomb and the guilty party would have to convince people to believe it was a bomb.

In part true, but in a way which works against your argument, and in part false. A hoax bomb doesn't have to look like a real bomb (whatever that means); rather it has to look like what many people think a real bomb looks like (which is probably quite different from a real bomb, in most cases). The fact that many people look at that mess of wires and circuit boards inside a small briefcase-looking thing and think bomb is proof that Ahmed's "invention" did in fact satisfy that requirement.

As for your claim that a guilty party would have to convince people to believe it was a bomb, that is wrong. In fact, the guilty party would be advised to maintain plausible deniability and only tacitly allow people to believe that the device was a bomb (or at least a bomb in progress). As I've written before (which apparently went in one eye and out the other, as most of my posts do around here), you would not be able to get away with bringing a toy gun to school and waving it around and shouting loudly "This is a toy gun! This is not a real gun!" nor should you.

3. Unfortunately for this conspiracy theory, it did not look like a bomb (see #1 above), and Ahmed from the very first when he brought it to school, even before he was questioned about it, identified it as a clock, which is what it was.

It looked like a bomb to me, although admittedly I had little idea what a concealed bomb would look like (which perhaps strengthens my point). In any case, describing that thing as a clock was disingenuous at best. More accurately, it is an experiment, where Ahmed took the guts out of an alarm clock and stuffed them into a pencil box and actually mounted the LED display to the inside cover with a couple of sheet metal screws. If I brought a toaster to school and mounted it inside a briefcase so that it was no longer useful, I don't think it would be accurate to call the whole kit and kaboodle a toaster. Instead it is a toaster in a box. Perhaps this video will help you to understand the difference (NSFW):




4. The fact that a bomb could be made to look like anything doesn't help here- the goal of a hoax bomb is to make it look like a real bomb, particularly in the eyes of a naive audience. Making a real bomb look like a soda can may be one way to bring down an airplane. Making a hoax bomb look like a soda can would not work, particularly if you tell everyone, including your engineering teacher before he asks, that it is a soda can. And indeed, it is a soda can.

Right, a soda can does not look like a bomb, even though it can function as one. The guts of an alarm clock shoved into a box does look like a bomb, even though the major components are not necessary to create a functioning bomb.

This is the main problem in the "a bomb can be made to look like anything" argument in this context. A hoax bomb cannot. It must look like a bomb in the popular imagination. This is especially a problem when the proposed hoaxer actually from the very start identifies the device as a clock, even before they are asked if it is a hoax bomb. The fact it was indeed a clock only increases the obvious fallacy of the hoax bomb fallacy.

Nope, you're veering off into nonsense. It didn't look like a clock at all. The fact that Ahmed claimed it was a clock and nothing more would reasonably add to suspicion. If he had instead said that it was an experiment where he dismantled an alarm clock, then that would have gone a long way to defusing (no pun intended) the situation.

Glad to help summarize my view, but I must admit this is a very repetitive thread and I don't wish to bore people. I only responded to your post because you quoted mine directly.

We have indeed gone around in circles in this thread, which is a little frustrating. I don't personally subscribe to the theory that Ahmed's family planned this from the start. First of all, I don't think they're that smart. More importantly, I don't think the social media virality of the episode could be reasonably predicted. It happened, though, and they're milking it for all it's worth. They seem to have gone a bit too far, though, as most of the liberal blogosphere seems to have suddenly become uninterested in Ahmed and his alleged oppression by the rubes in Texas. Only the diehards in this thread continue to fight on his behalf, but that's probably more about saving face for themselves.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom