Somehow I think I heard this argument before. Several times on this very thread, in fact. But I have admitted to being slow, so thank you for supplying this argument again in case I missed it. But then I feel as if I need to bring up a few more points already discussed:
The teachers, principal, and police all saw the inside as well as the outside of the box, right? And from the inside it looked like what it was- a clock, right? Which it was. And from the outside it looked like a pencil box with a wire tie, right? Which it was. And Ahmed when asked always stated it was a clock in a pencil box, right? Which it was. And he even identified it as such to his engineering teacher at the very beginning of the day, right? And none of the teachers, school administrators, or police thought it was a bomb, right?
But I already stated a willingness to leave aside this particular question because it then gets into the hopeless argument of how stupid does one have to be to think it was a bomb. Clearly none of the school teachers, etc. were that stupid. So (intentional) it becomes a clock that doesn't look like a bomb, which therefore must have been a hoax bomb because a bomb may not look like a bomb. Sorry to repeat this last concept- I promise to stop once I understand what the hoax bomb advocates are trying to mean by this.
On thinking about it, I will stipulate that his pencil box was a hoax, if very tiny, suitcase. Does this help?