Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

:eye-poppi

That makes no sense at all

I'll try to explain. A hoax would be if Ahmed claimed it was a bomb or planted it in a location where and when he was not available to ask about its identity. But he never did. In fact , no one who saw it believed it was a bomb, so even if Ahmed had claimed it was a bomb it was a poor hoax at that. And it is totally irrelevant how you imagine his sister or father might have be involved, unless they phoned in a bomb threat. Which they did not.

It was not a hoax because Ahmed never claimed it was a bomb or even created a situation where someone would mistake it for a bomb without Ahmed immediately denying this. It is like someone claiming that my radio is a hoax TV despite all my identifications of it as a radio.

It would have been a hoax if one of the authorities had gotten secretly together with Ahmed to knowingly create a false charge against him to then later split the money. This would be a hoax because the participant intentionally made a statement that they knew was incorrect to collect cash. Ahmed and his family only made truthful statements.

The very worse accusation you can make against Ahmed is that he brought into school a clock hoping that it would be mistaken for a bomb and he would be punished, allowing him to sue later. In which case (1) there is no evidence he did have that motivation; at this point it is just pure imagination (2) in fact he brought in a very unconvincing prop in his scheme (in fact many posters here including you have complained that it looked too much like a commercial Radio Shack clock to give Ahmed any credit for science skill), (3) he showed it to a teacher early on explaining it was a clock, and (4) when asked by anyone else, he said it was a clock. I don't understand why anyone intending to create a hoax bomb would go to so much trouble to make certain everyone knew it was not a bomb.

Once again, the hoax, hoax bomb idea. Sorry- I am still having a lot of trouble understanding the concept.
 
Last edited:
I'll try to explain. A hoax would be if Ahmed claimed it was a bomb or planted it in a location where and when he was not available to ask about its identity. But he never did. In fact , no one who saw it believed it was a bomb, so even if Ahmed had claimed it was a bomb it was a poor hoax at that. And it is totally irrelevant how you imagine his sister or father might have be involved, unless they phoned in a bomb threat. Which they did not.

It was not a hoax because Ahmed never claimed it was a bomb or even created a situation where someone would mistake it for a bomb without Ahmed immediately denying this. It is like someone claiming that my radio is a hoax TV despite all my identifications of it as a radio.

It would have been a hoax if one of the authorities had gotten secretly together with Ahmed to knowingly create a false charge against him to then later split the money. This would be a hoax because the participant intentionally made a statement that they knew was incorrect to collect cash. Ahmed and his family only made truthful statements.

The very worse accusation you can make against Ahmed is that he brought into school a clock hoping that it would be mistaken for a bomb and he would be punished, allowing him to sue later. In which case (1) there is no evidence he did have that motivation; at this point it is just pure imagination (2) in fact he brought in a very unconvincing prop in his scheme (in fact many posters here including you have complained that it looked too much like a commercial Radio Shack clock to give Ahmed any credit for science skill), (3) he showed it to a teacher early on explaining it was a clock, and (4) when asked by anyone else, he said it was a clock. I don't understand why anyone intending to create a hoax bomb would go to so much trouble to make certain everyone knew it was not a bomb.

Once again, the hoax, hoax bomb idea. Sorry- I am still having a lot of trouble understanding the concept.

that had nothing to do with my post or the part of the post i was replying to...

It was a commercially manufactured clock that he took apart and stuck in a briefcase shaped pencil case. It did not look like a clock at all....
 
The Student Code of Conduct prohibits students from possessing, among other items, “any articles not generally considered to be weapons, including school supplies, when the principal or designee determines that a danger exists.”

And the principal did. And does, still, even after the *********:

In the letter to parents, MacArthur High School principal Dan Cummings appeared to defend the decision to take the student into custody. “We will always take necessary precautions to protect our students,” wrote Cummings.

The letter says police found responded to a “suspicious-looking item” on Monday, but police found that the item posed no threat. An investigation remained ongoing, according to Cummings’ letter.

The principal added that parents should use Mohamed’s arrest as a teachable moment. “I recommend using this opportunity to talk with your child about the Student Code of Conduct and specifically not bringing items to school that are prohibited,” Cummings says in the letter. “Also, this is a good time to remind your child how important it is to immediately report any suspicious items and/or suspicious behavior they observe to any school employee so we can address it right away.”


From http://time.com/4036240/ahmed-mohamed-bomb-clock-principal-letter/

This means, of course, that any item is prohibited if the principal later determines that a danger exists. Seems pretty broad to me, and to violate the usual concept that the rules and laws must be written to clarify what is allowed and what is not. It is a lot like writing a law, "All actions are considered a felony if the governor of the State later looks at it and decides it was bad." I am not comfortable with this idea even in a school and can result in a suspension, arrest, or worse. What if, looking at the ISIS photo, the principal decided that a can of soda and a tampon were "dangerous?" Would we feel comfortable if he suspended a student on that basis?

More so, the rule you state requires the principal to determine that the object is "dangerous" not suspicious. The clock was not in fact dangerous and no one at the school seemed to believe that it was. Sure, perhaps the principal was thinking that if, somehow, someone thought it was a bomb that fright might be itself dangerous. But if they had just confiscated the clock for the day then I don't see how it was dangerous in any way.
 
Last edited:
that had nothing to do with my post or the part of the post i was replying to...

It was a commercially manufactured clock that he took apart and stuck in a briefcase shaped pencil case. It did not look like a clock at all....

But other people identified it (from the photo!) as the guts of a Radio Shack clock. To say it didn't look like a clock at all seems quite a reach.

But okay- subtract one point from my previous list if you wish. But it still was not a hoax. Even if you copy a Rubens painting to make it look exactly like a Rubens painting, it is not a hoax unless you try to pass it off as a Rubens, not if you keep denying it is a Rubens. It would be an even greater non-hoax if you made a painting of your 2013 Honda, and you keep telling everyone that it was your painting of your Honda, but others accused you of trying to pass it off as a Rubens.
 
I didn´t actually post the link to that video, it was some other poster. What I pointed out was that one can´t pretend to refute an argument without actually listening to the video that contains it. That would be inpolite, in my opinion.

Saying that the video is hard to listen to because of the tone, that it´s too long etc. is perfectly valid, but dismissing the argument without even hearing it? come on..

If I posted a link to a 430 page document, claiming it supported my position without providing any specifics as to the argument or my own views, is it an obligation of anyone seeking to refute my position to read the 430 page document?

I believe that a poster is obligated to provide the core of their argument here in their post. If they wish to cite another source to supply the corresponding evidence for their argument, fine. But the argument itself, IMHO, should be here in the post. It is unreasonable to expect posters to review every citation that might be made here, especially if the specifics of the argument itself are not clearly provided in the actual post. Can you imagine the citation wars that would break out otherwise. Nothing would be discussed here, just warring hyperlinks.

My own standard/hope is that any poster new to a thread should at least read the remainder of the thread before attempting to add their own view. But sadly this appears to be routinely violated. So on many threads I see an argument debunked for specific and convincing reasons, the arguer typically moves on to something else, and then weeks later another poster newly arrives on the thread and proudly reposts using the original, debunked argument as if this is a new and undiscussed idea.
 
But other people identified it (from the photo!) as the guts of a Radio Shack clock. To say it didn't look like a clock at all seems quite a reach.

But okay- subtract one point from my previous list if you wish. But it still was not a hoax. Even if you copy a Rubens painting to make it look exactly like a Rubens painting, it is not a hoax unless you try to pass it off as a Rubens, not if you keep denying it is a Rubens. It would be an even greater non-hoax if you made a painting of your 2013 Honda, and you keep telling everyone that it was your painting of your Honda, but others accused you of trying to pass it off as a Rubens.

I do not think you are getting the picture here. It was the guts of the clock stuffed into a briefcase, and to tell what time it was you have to unlatch the box and open it up.
 
I do not think you are getting the picture here. It was the guts of the clock stuffed into a briefcase, and to tell what time it was you have to unlatch the box and open it up.

Somehow I think I heard this argument before. Several times on this very thread, in fact. But I have admitted to being slow, so thank you for supplying this argument again in case I missed it. But then I feel as if I need to bring up a few more points already discussed:

The teachers, principal, and police all saw the inside as well as the outside of the box, right? And from the inside it looked like what it was- a clock, right? Which it was. And from the outside it looked like a pencil box with a wire tie, right? Which it was. And Ahmed when asked always stated it was a clock in a pencil box, right? Which it was. And he even identified it as such to his engineering teacher at the very beginning of the day, right? And none of the teachers, school administrators, or police thought it was a bomb, right?

But I already stated a willingness to leave aside this particular question because it then gets into the hopeless argument of how stupid does one have to be to think it was a bomb. Clearly none of the school teachers, etc. were that stupid. So (intentional) it becomes a clock that doesn't look like a bomb, which therefore must have been a hoax bomb because a bomb may not look like a bomb. Sorry to repeat this last concept- I promise to stop once I understand what the hoax bomb advocates are trying to mean by this.

On thinking about it, I will stipulate that his pencil box was a hoax, if very tiny, suitcase. Does this help?
 
Last edited:
Somehow I think I heard this argument before. Several times on this very thread, in fact. But I have admitted to being slow, so thank you for supplying this argument again in case I missed it. But then I feel as if I need to bring up a few more points already discussed:

The teachers, principal, and police all saw the inside as well as the outside of the box, right? And from the inside it looked like what it was- a clock, right? Which it was. And from the outside it looked like a pencil box with a wire tie, right? Which it was. And Ahmed when asked always stated it was a clock in a pencil box, right? Which it was. And he even identified it as such to his engineering teacher at the very beginning of the day, right? And none of the teachers, school administrators, or police thought it was a bomb, right?

But I already stated a willingness to leave aside this particular question because it then gets into the hopeless argument of how stupid does one have to be to think it was a bomb. Clearly none of the school teachers, etc. were that stupid. So (intentional) it becomes a clock that doesn't look like a bomb, which therefore must have been a hoax bomb because a bomb may not look like a bomb. Sorry to repeat this last concept- I promise to stop once I understand what the hoax bomb advocates are trying to mean by this.

On thinking about it, I will stipulate that his pencil box was a hoax, if very tiny, suitcase. Does this help?

to the uninitiated, from the inside it looked like a bomb and timer mechanism because who in their right mind would destroy a perfectly good clock to cram it into a case.

Thank god the Lil Inventor could not get his hands on fissionable material!
 
The Student Code of Conduct prohibits students from possessing, among other items, “any articles not generally considered to be weapons, including school supplies, when the principal or designee determines that a danger exists.”

And the principal did. And does, still, even after the *********:

In the letter to parents, MacArthur High School principal Dan Cummings appeared to defend the decision to take the student into custody. “We will always take necessary precautions to protect our students,” wrote Cummings.

The letter says police found responded to a “suspicious-looking item” on Monday, but police found that the item posed no threat. An investigation remained ongoing, according to Cummings’ letter.

The principal added that parents should use Mohamed’s arrest as a teachable moment. “I recommend using this opportunity to talk with your child about the Student Code of Conduct and specifically not bringing items to school that are prohibited,” Cummings says in the letter. “Also, this is a good time to remind your child how important it is to immediately report any suspicious items and/or suspicious behavior they observe to any school employee so we can address it right away.”


From http://time.com/4036240/ahmed-mohamed-bomb-clock-principal-letter/

Therefore, anything, literally anything, may violate school policy. Anything at all.

And that makes perfect sense, unless it is applied retroactively to something that is not specified in the policy, saying that they have a zero tolerance policy and have no choice to act because of that policy.

I'm looking around the room I am in. I see a ceramic mug. Is that a violation of school policy? It isn't listed, but it could be dangerous. Would it be the case that the principal can declare it a banned item? Yes, he most certainly could. Would he be required to do so by policy? No, he certainly would not.

He exercised his discretion. He had the right to do so. We have the right to point and laugh about the way he did it.

And the courts have the right to decide if the way he did it violated Ahmed's rights.

By the way, your post also contradicts itself. You say that the policy applies to the clock because the principle "did, and still does" determine that a danger exists, but the police "found that the item presented no threat." Unless you are suggesting that the principal disagrees with the police. The only way to remove a contradiction would be to assume that the principal still believes the item is a danger, but informed parents that the police determined it was not a danger.
 
to the uninitiated, from the inside it looked like a bomb and timer mechanism because who in their right mind would destroy a perfectly good clock to cram it into a case.

Thank god the Lil Inventor could not get his hands on fissionable material!

But I thought that you couldn't see it was a clock from the outside? And that from the inside even a photo revealed to many posters that it was the guts of a Radio Shack clock with nothing that looked like a classical bomb or explosives. Probably because it was a clock. Maybe not a very good clock, but you should have seen my own projects at 14.

But as I said already, I don't want to argue about how stupid one has to be to think this was a bomb (especially since no one did, based on their statements and actions that day). Back to the core of my prior post: it is not a hoax if no one claims it to be what it is not. Ahmed always denied it was a bomb whenever asked, and volunteered that it was a clock to his engineering teacher at the beginning of the day. He never left it anywhere suspicious nor ever claimed it was a bomb. So it was not a hoax. Unless, as stated, a school official, knowing it wasn't a bomb, claimed that it was a bomb to get Ahmed arrested and then secretly share in any settlement money.
 
Last edited:
:eye-poppi

The evidence is she got suspended for making a threat. Claiming that she did not do it is worthless. If she wants to show her innocence, she should consent to the release of the documents, but she won't.

Hmmm, wonder if that is because the documents would destroy her claims?


The evidence seems to be that she was accused of making a threat.

Do you have more evidence than that.
 
But I thought that you couldn't see it was a clock from the outside? And that from the inside even a photo revealed to many posters that it was the guts of a Radio Shack clock with nothing that looked like a classical bomb or explosives.
You are wrong. Side-by-side comparison shows that it shared all the characteristics of a bomb, with plenty of room inside to hide a block of C4. Just to remind you here is the picture again. The top device is an actual suitcase bomb. The bottom one - which clearly is the same size - is Ahmed's 'clock'.

Ahmed always denied it was a bomb whenever asked, and volunteered that it was a clock to his engineering teacher at the beginning of the day.
Of course he told them it was a clock. If he told them it was a bomb then he wouldn't have been able to smuggle it into class, plug it in and set the detonation time without anybody trying to stop him!

how stupid one has to be to think this was a bomb
Not stupid, it's just that most people's idea of what a bomb looks like comes from Hollywood movies. Luckily for the school at least one person did recognize it for what it was, and was able to foil his plan.

The teachers, principal, and police all saw the inside as well as the outside of the box, right? And from the inside it looked like what it was- a clock, right? Which it was. And from the outside it looked like a pencil box with a wire tie, right?
You don't understand. It was definitely a suitcase bomb. However, just before the police arrived Ahmed switched it for a pencil case.

Here's how we know it was a bomb:-

1. 20,000 internet posters can't be wrong.

2. The color (brown) and the name (Ahmed Mohamed).

3. All muslims are terrorists.

4. His sister was suspended for trying to blow up the school with an identical device.

5. Liberals say it wasn't a bomb. Liberals always lie, so obviously it was a bomb.
 

Attachments

  • Clock Bomb.jpg
    Clock Bomb.jpg
    77.5 KB · Views: 7
Last edited:
The evidence seems to be that she was accused of making a threat.

Do you have more evidence than that.

hey, when she gets back from the family's all expense paid trip to Qatar she can consent to release the documents.

Until then, you can put me solidly in the skeptic pile.

:thumbsup:
 
You are wrong. Side-by-side comparison shows that it shared all the characteristics of a bomb, with plenty of room inside to hide a block of C4. Just to remind you here is the picture again. The top device is an actual suitcase bomb. The bottom one - which clearly is the same size - is Ahmed's 'clock'.

Of course he told them it was a clock. If he told them it was a bomb then he wouldn't have been able to smuggle it into class, plug it in and set the detonation time without anybody trying to stop him!

Not stupid, it's just that most people's idea of what a bomb looks like comes from Hollywood movies. Luckily for the school at least one person did recognize it for what it was, and was able to foil his plan.

You don't understand. It was definitely a suitcase bomb. However, just before the police arrived Ahmed switched it for a pencil case.

Here's how we know it was a bomb:-

1. 20,000 internet posters can't be wrong.

2. The color (brown) and the name (Ahmed Mohamed).

3. All muslims are terrorists.

4. His sister was suspended for trying to blow up the school with an identical device.

5. Liberals say it wasn't a bomb. Liberals always lie, so obviously it was a bomb.

you make a good case, although if you want anyone to take you seriously, you will want to drop the INCREDIBLY patronizing and therefore racist reference to a "brown" person
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom