Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I think that a lot of people who were inclined to be sympathetic to Ahmed's situation became much less so when the $15 million lawsuit got filed. I know I did. Yes, the school overreacted, and surely an apology was due to Ahmed for the way he was treated. But it wasn't worth $15 million.
 
I think that a lot of people who were inclined to be sympathetic to Ahmed's situation became much less so when the $15 million lawsuit got filed. I know I did. Yes, the school overreacted, and surely an apology was due to Ahmed for the way he was treated. But it wasn't worth $15 million.

Q: what kind of lawyer takes a case like this?
A: the kind of lawyer who knows it isn't worth half a darn on its own merits a figures you might as well go big.
 
How does one tell the difference between it being a setup versus a "naive work by a naive and technically unsophisticated experimenter" whose father just happens to be an activist?

Trying to cash in for millions of dollars is a dead giveaway.
 
Except that we don't know that it actually is opportunism.

If they should win, then we will have to see what is done with the money before we can make any judgements about that.

Making such an assumption now is nothing more than character assassination.

Poison the well.

Odd, you don't mind jumping to conclusions about the motivations of the school and the police and assassinating their character.
 
That doesn't address a thing I said. That evidence is poor evidence that goes two ways. It's even more wrong to base arguments on a conclusion based on this very tenuous evidence.

You're being extra inconsistent by believing her when she says she was suspended, but not that she was innocent. Perhaps the documents would destroy her claim that she was suspended at all. Perhaps the documents would indicate they had nothing but someone's own claim. And besides that, there is very good reason to not want more information made public when biased ideologues have already shown they are more than eager to hate the family on anything at all.

Your speculation is not evidence. Your speculation is all you have as to why they won't let the records be released.

Until they are released all you have is speculation as to what really happened but I notice that doesn't stop you and others about being sure that the school and the police were prejudiced and racist.
 
Everyone in the case agrees on the following: 1)Ahmed did not claim that his "invention" was a bomb, but rather repeatedly claimed it was a clock.

2) He was questioned about a "hoax bomb" despite him clearly stating that the device was not a bomb.

3) Ahmed was questioned by police without his parents.

4) Ahmed was handcuffed in his school and taken away by said police.

The claim being made is that this is all somehow a "hoax". But, if we take every assertion made here as true - his father's an activist, his sister was suspended because some other student claimed she said she was going to blow up the school, she coached him on what to say to some interviewers, they're suing after the event - you still have nothing that leads to a "hoax".

A "hoax" that meets the agreed facts would be if the family were planning with the teacher, or the police who walked him out in handcuffs, and were going to divide the money up in the end.

No, they don't agree. How can you know all that when the records are sealed?

You got a rock in a hat?
 
that had nothing to do with my post or the part of the post i was replying to...

It was a commercially manufactured clock that he took apart and stuck in a briefcase shaped pencil case. It did not look like a clock at all....

It looked like a timer that might be found on a bomb.
 
This means, of course, that any item is prohibited if the principal later determines that a danger exists. Seems pretty broad to me, and to violate the usual concept that the rules and laws must be written to clarify what is allowed and what is not. It is a lot like writing a law, "All actions are considered a felony if the governor of the State later looks at it and decides it was bad." I am not comfortable with this idea even in a school and can result in a suspension, arrest, or worse. What if, looking at the ISIS photo, the principal decided that a can of soda and a tampon were "dangerous?" Would we feel comfortable if he suspended a student on that basis?

More so, the rule you state requires the principal to determine that the object is "dangerous" not suspicious. The clock was not in fact dangerous and no one at the school seemed to believe that it was. Sure, perhaps the principal was thinking that if, somehow, someone thought it was a bomb that fright might be itself dangerous. But if they had just confiscated the clock for the day then I don't see how it was dangerous in any way.

Exposed electrical terminals are dangerous.
 
It looked like a timer that might be found on a bomb.

Only in the eyes of Hollywood. I keep saying this and no one seems to pay attention; most improvised explosive devices these days rarely if ever use timers. More often than not they use pressure switches, or some type of wire connection that can be pulled from a distance. Or a simple deadman's switch for your typical suicide bomber, where all they have to do is press a button and BOOM. Timers on the other hand are not as reliable as these simpler methods and can fail in unexpected ways. I can understand the teachers not being aware of this fact, necessarily, but the police, assuming their training is at all competent, would be trained to recognize explosive devices.
 
Odd, you don't mind jumping to conclusions about the motivations of the school and the police and assassinating their character.


They interrogated him without any counsel or family present. They threw handcuffs on him and dragged him downtown.

All the while knowing that there was no bomb and he had not done anything to suggest it was a bomb, but quite to the contrary repeatedly stated that it was a clock.

There is no "jumping to conclusions" there. It is all part of the record.

They're assassinating their own character. That doesn't require any help from me.
 
I think that a lot of people who were inclined to be sympathetic to Ahmed's situation became much less so when the $15 million lawsuit got filed. I know I did. Yes, the school overreacted, and surely an apology was due to Ahmed for the way he was treated. But it wasn't worth $15 million.

This.


Balloon boy's dad is jealous.
 
Only in the eyes of Hollywood. I keep saying this and no one seems to pay attention; most improvised explosive devices these days rarely if ever use timers. More often than not they use pressure switches, or some type of wire connection that can be pulled from a distance. Or a simple deadman's switch for your typical suicide bomber, where all they have to do is press a button and BOOM. Timers on the other hand are not as reliable as these simpler methods and can fail in unexpected ways. I can understand the teachers not being aware of this fact, necessarily, but the police, assuming their training is at all competent, would be trained to recognize explosive devices.


The eyes of Hollywood seems to have been the goal, not appearing realistic, whatever that means.

And a little circuit board and wires would indeed be consistent with it.

It is a fair cop until sorted out.
 
Only in the eyes of Hollywood. I keep saying this and no one seems to pay attention; most improvised explosive devices these days rarely if ever use timers. More often than not they use pressure switches, or some type of wire connection that can be pulled from a distance. Or a simple deadman's switch for your typical suicide bomber, where all they have to do is press a button and BOOM. Timers on the other hand are not as reliable as these simpler methods and can fail in unexpected ways. I can understand the teachers not being aware of this fact, necessarily, but the police, assuming their training is at all competent, would be trained to recognize explosive devices.

I think you are rather missing the point that making a bomb hoax is in and of itself illegal?
 
I think you are rather missing the point that making a bomb hoax is in and of itself illegal?

Ahmed didn't make a "hoax bomb". As he said, repeatedly and without fail, he "made" a clock. A. Clock. Not a "hoax bomb", not a timer intended to look like a bomb in the eyes of Hollyweird, a CLOCK. Had he intended it to be a hoax bomb, he would have reacted much differently, but instead he proudly showed it off to one of his teachers, telling that teacher that it was a clock. The fact that making a hoax bomb is illegal is irrelevant to the facts of the case, which are that Ahmed "made" a CLOCK and was handcuffed and questioned for the audacity of doing so.
 
The eyes of Hollywood seems to have been the goal, not appearing realistic, whatever that means.

And a little circuit board and wires would indeed be consistent with it.

It is a fair cop until sorted out.

No, Ahmed stated REPEATEDLY that it was a CLOCK, not something intended to have the appearance of a timer for a bomb in the eyes of Hollyweird. He put together a CLOCK. Had he intended it to be a "hoax bomb" or something similar, he would have hidden it somewhere and probably anonymously called in a bomb threat or something; instead he proudly showed it off to his teacher and said it was a clock. That's all. And for this he was handcuffed and questioned about his device for hours, despite repeatedly stating that it was a clock and nothing more.
 
I think that a lot of people who were inclined to be sympathetic to Ahmed's situation became much less so when the $15 million lawsuit got filed. I know I did. Yes, the school overreacted, and surely an apology was due to Ahmed for the way he was treated. But it wasn't worth $15 million.


AKA 5% of the city of Irving's budget for a single year.

Not exactly a killing blow.
 
Ahmed didn't make a "hoax bomb". As he said, repeatedly and without fail, he "made" a clock. A. Clock. Not a "hoax bomb", not a timer intended to look like a bomb in the eyes of Hollyweird, a CLOCK. Had he intended it to be a hoax bomb, he would have reacted much differently, but instead he proudly showed it off to one of his teachers, telling that teacher that it was a clock. The fact that making a hoax bomb is illegal is irrelevant to the facts of the case, which are that Ahmed "made" a CLOCK and was handcuffed and questioned for the audacity of doing so.

He didn't "make" a clock. He disassembled a perfectly functioning clock and put the parts in a "mini-briefcase." He showed it to a teacher who told him not to show it to others. He disregarded that instruction, plugged the hot mess in another classroom where the original "clock's" still functioning alarm (despite Ahemed's best attempt to electrocute himself) went off.

He made a "disruption" out a real "clock."
 
He didn't "make" a clock. He disassembled a perfectly functioning clock and put the parts in a "mini-briefcase." He showed it to a teacher who told him not to show it to others. He disregarded that instruction, plugged the hot mess in another classroom where the original "clock's" still functioning alarm (despite Ahemed's best attempt to electrocute himself) went off.

He made a "disruption" out a real "clock."

But that isn't a "hoax bomb." It's still a clock. Are you arguing that he was arrested for plugging in a clock and having the alarm go off (without meaning to)?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom