Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"


Actual quote?

"The sister claimed after the arrest that she had been suspended from a school for several days. “I got suspended from school for three days from this stupid same district, from this girl saying I wanted to blow up the school, something I had nothing to do with,” she said, without providing evidence or proof."

I have no idea what a Breitbart is, but that is a really pointless paragraph.

Did his sister get suspended for:

a) A fellow student suggesting she wanted to blow up the school, for which she was suspended, without there being any evidence that is what she said.
b) A fellow student suggesting she wanted to blow up the school, for which she was suspended, but she didn't provide evidence that she was actually suspended.
c) She was suspended for something, but didn't offer proof of exactly what.

That reporter really must try harder.


“Man, I went viral.”

And in breaking news, a 14 year old in the middle of a viral ********* gets excited.

I started getting bored after that.
 
Actual quote?

"The sister claimed after the arrest that she had been suspended from a school for several days. “I got suspended from school for three days from this stupid same district, from this girl saying I wanted to blow up the school, something I had nothing to do with,” she said, without providing evidence or proof."

I have no idea what a Breitbart is, but that is a really pointless paragraph.

Did his sister get suspended for:

a) A fellow student suggesting she wanted to blow up the school, for which she was suspended, without there being any evidence that is what she said.
b) A fellow student suggesting she wanted to blow up the school, for which she was suspended, but she didn't provide evidence that she was actually suspended.
c) She was suspended for something, but didn't offer proof of exactly what.

That reporter really must try harder.



“Man, I went viral.”

And in breaking news, a 14 year old in the middle of a viral ********* gets excited.

I started getting bored after that.

After the MSNBC segment, Eyman and I sit down in the hallway where she says the same thing happened to her as Ahmed.

“I got suspended from school for three days from this stupid same district, from this girl saying I wanted to blow up the school, something I had nothing to do with.”


Lazyness does not count as refutation
 
You have repeated the same line - what does it actually mean?

They way I read it is she didn't say she would blow up the school, but that another girl said she did, was believed, hence a suspension.

Does that make it better? Worse? Or perhaps a pattern not of 'activism' by the family, but stupid reactions by the school?
 
You have repeated the same line - what does it actually mean?

They way I read it is she didn't say she would blow up the school, but that another girl said she did, was believed, hence a suspension.

Does that make it better? Worse? Or perhaps a pattern not of 'activism' by the family, but stupid reactions by the school?

I was asked to provide evidence that Ahmed´s sister had some history of threatening to bomb the school, whether true or false, we don´t know, the teachers don´t know, I guess only she knows. But the evidence is there. She got suspended for something related to a bomb hoax. (hopefully hoax..)
 
You have repeated the same line - what does it actually mean?

They way I read it is she didn't say she would blow up the school, but that another girl said she did, was believed, hence a suspension.

Does that make it better? Worse? Or perhaps a pattern not of 'activism' by the family, but stupid reactions by the school?

while the family has been running their mouth off about the previous suspension and this event, they have refused the school board's request that they sign a waiver to release documents showing the school board's side of the story.

Why do you think that is? Hmmmm?
 
By the way, you seem unaware of the fact that the invention was dangerous and could have electrocuted anyone who reached in the case. The actual useful clock that we wrecked did not have that problem.

It also might've had an above-zero practical use if his "case mod" had bothered to include the buttons for setting the time and alarm. Without such things the "clock" wasn't much of a clock, but rather mostly just a large blinking light. Of course the button PCB was included (because he never disconnected it when he pulled the components out of the original cover and set them in his pencil box), but without the buttons themselves it wasn't good for much.

It certainly adds some context to his first's teacher's noncommittal "that's nice" comment. It's the kind of thing you say to a kid when they come to you wanting praise for something they've done or made that's objectively terrible or ridiculous, but you don't want to hurt their feelings by being honest with them. It does add the possibility though that the reason the teacher told him to keep it in his backpack and not show it to anyone else, was not because he thought it might look suspicious, but because he didn't the boy to embarrass himself any further.
 
Last edited:
I was asked to provide evidence that Ahmed´s sister had some history of threatening to bomb the school, whether true or false, we don´t know, the teachers don´t know, I guess only she knows. But the evidence is there. She got suspended for something related to a bomb hoax. (hopefully hoax..)


That's not evidence enough to conclude she has a history of hoaxing bomb threats. That's only evidence that she's been accused of threatening to blow up the school.

You came to the conclusion that she was indeed a bomb hoaxer and used that conclusion as support for your further speculation. Your speculation isn't baseless; it's badly based. More than that, it is just as strong (if not stronger evidence) of community bias against the family.

In short, this doesn't actually support your argument over the one you're arguing against.
 
That's not evidence enough to conclude she has a history of hoaxing bomb threats. That's only evidence that she's been accused of threatening to blow up the school.

You came to the conclusion that she was indeed a bomb hoaxer and used that conclusion as support for your further speculation. Your speculation isn't baseless; it's badly based. More than that, it is just as strong (if not stronger evidence) of community bias against the family.

In short, this doesn't actually support your argument over the one you're arguing against.

:eye-poppi

The evidence is she got suspended for making a threat. Claiming that she did not do it is worthless. If she wants to show her innocence, she should consent to the release of the documents, but she won't.

Hmmm, wonder if that is because the documents would destroy her claims?
 
:eye-poppi

The evidence is she got suspended for making a threat. Claiming that she did not do it is worthless. If she wants to show her innocence, she should consent to the release of the documents, but she won't.

Hmmm, wonder if that is because the documents would destroy her claims?


That doesn't address a thing I said. That evidence is poor evidence that goes two ways. It's even more wrong to base arguments on a conclusion based on this very tenuous evidence.

You're being extra inconsistent by believing her when she says she was suspended, but not that she was innocent. Perhaps the documents would destroy her claim that she was suspended at all. Perhaps the documents would indicate they had nothing but someone's own claim. And besides that, there is very good reason to not want more information made public when biased ideologues have already shown they are more than eager to hate the family on anything at all.

Your speculation is not evidence. Your speculation is all you have as to why they won't let the records be released.
 
How can you disagree with his conclusion if you haven´t watched the video? I agree the style is a bit ranty but he makes a pretty good summary of the case:

- Activist publicity seeking father
- Previous history of hoax bombing by Ahmed´s sister
- Ahmed knowing it looked suspicious
- Disruptive behaviour, repeatedly not hiding the clock when told
- School having "zero tolerance" policies so not actually overreacting, just doing what they were compelled to do.

I would add: Obama´s cold reception at the White House. He didn´t approach Ahmed, didn´t look for a photo with him, after the warm invitation a few weeks earlier. And he was the most mediatic of the visitors that day. He eventually had to walk from the back of the room to be able to get close to Obama and take a picture with him. I know you´ll dismiss this as not proof of anything, but I was waiting so see how it turned up, whether Obama would receive Ahmed with open arms or whether he had already realised he´d been conned and tried to downplay it. It looked like the second option.

Can you tell where it was going from 49-secinds in?

Does it suddenly change its tone and become Pulitzer-prize material after that?


Why should anyone have to watch a video to see what someone's argument is? It's most impolite. You might as well say that I am not qualified to comment on Dan Brown's writing because I only once made the mistake of getting a by him out of the library.
 
You have repeated the same line - what does it actually mean?

They way I read it is she didn't say she would blow up the school, but that another girl said she did, was believed, hence a suspension.

Does that make it better? Worse? Or perhaps a pattern not of 'activism' by the family, but stupid reactions by the school?

while the family has been running their mouth off about the previous suspension and this event, they have refused the school board's request that they sign a waiver to release documents showing the school board's side of the story.

Why do you think that is? Hmmmm?

I have no idea. I could assume like you, but if I was to assume, I would assume on the advice of their lawyers.

If I was in a position to have a nice comfortable life due to the idiocy of others, I would handcuff my lawyer to me, and let him/her use me as a ventriloquist's dummy.
 
- School having "zero tolerance" policies so not actually overreacting, just doing what they were compelled to do.

This is the part of this thread that has always driven me a little bit batty.

Did they really have a zero tolerance policy?

No. They didn't. Really. They didn't. Can someone show me a policy that uses the phrase "zero tolerance" or any synonymous phrase? Don't bother trying. There isn't one.

But, even if it wasn't "zero tolerance", even if it was "not much tolerance", what part of the policy did Ahmed violate?

The closest thing that anyone could come up with was that the clock was a "look alike weapon". That's really stretching it. A lot. You would have to say that any object that a teacher didn't recognize, but which anyone associated with a weapon, was actually a look alike weapon.

If you want to say that there was a violation of policy, then cite the policy. In fact, the policy has been cited, and that clock wasn't a violation of the policy.

And finally, if this had remained a school matter, it wouldn't have been such a big issue. What made it a big issue was that it became a police matter, and police don't have "zero tolerance" policies, they have laws. It didn't violate any laws, which was why the prosecutors declined to file charges, and the case was closed. If someone really brought a hoax bomb to school, I would want them prosecuted, but it wasn't a hoax bomb, so I would want him released. In fact, it so obviously wasn't a hoax bomb that his arrest on that charge is worthy of ridicule.

Now we'll get to see if it's worthy of money.
 
That doesn't address a thing I said. That evidence is poor evidence that goes two ways. It's even more wrong to base arguments on a conclusion based on this very tenuous evidence.

You're being extra inconsistent by believing her when she says she was suspended, but not that she was innocent. Perhaps the documents would destroy her claim that she was suspended at all. Perhaps the documents would indicate they had nothing but someone's own claim. And besides that, there is very good reason to not want more information made public when biased ideologues have already shown they are more than eager to hate the family on anything at all.

Your speculation is not evidence. Your speculation is all you have as to why they won't let the records be released.

1. her statement is not all we have learned about it, the school board confirmed it and offered to make the documents available.

2. "extra inconsistent"? :rolleyes: It is called an admission against self interest. The courts that created that exception assumed it unlikely that a person would make a statement against his own interest untruthfully.


3. The irony of accusing ME of speculation when your post is nothing but speculation makes me giggle. "perhaps"?
 
That's not evidence enough to conclude she has a history of hoaxing bomb threats. That's only evidence that she's been accused of threatening to blow up the school.

You came to the conclusion that she was indeed a bomb hoaxer and used that conclusion as support for your further speculation. Your speculation isn't baseless; it's badly based. More than that, it is just as strong (if not stronger evidence) of community bias against the family.

In short, this doesn't actually support your argument over the one you're arguing against.

I guess I´ll have to repeat: I was asked to provide evidence about Ahmed´s sister´s record. She was suspended for in some incident revolving around an alleged bomb threat. I provided her own admission. I´m not claiming anything about her guilt, I don´t know and neither do you. But together with the rest of the information about Ahmeds family, the fact that she seems to have been telling Ahmed what to say to the press, his dad etc. makes one think that they are not as innocent and naive as they want us to believe. Ahmed admitted the clock looked suspicious, he knew of his sister´s issue, but kept putting the suspicious looking clock on everyone´s face? Don´t you think there is a possibility that they wanted to stir up a reaction on purpose and then play the victims? I admit I could be wrong, at the moment we only have partial information, but I don´t understand how some people can so closed-mindedly dismiss the possibility of the hoax out of hand. Like that ranting guy said in the youtube video, this position cames from a different type of prejudice, you are assuming that the techers, police etc. behaved badly because it happened in Texas. And Texasphobia is an acceptable kind of prejudice in some leftist environments, it seems.
 
Can you tell where it was going from 49-secinds in?

Does it suddenly change its tone and become Pulitzer-prize material after that?


Why should anyone have to watch a video to see what someone's argument is? It's most impolite. You might as well say that I am not qualified to comment on Dan Brown's writing because I only once made the mistake of getting a by him out of the library.

I didn´t actually post the link to that video, it was some other poster. What I pointed out was that one can´t pretend to refute an argument without actually listening to the video that contains it. That would be inpolite, in my opinion.

Saying that the video is hard to listen to because of the tone, that it´s too long etc. is perfectly valid, but dismissing the argument without even hearing it? come on..
 
I didn´t actually post the link to that video, it was some other poster. What I pointed out was that one can´t pretend to refute an argument without actually listening to the video that contains it. That would be inpolite, in my opinion.

Having watched it - it's not anything different than what's being argued here, which is just a very poor attempt at making a personal attack against the kid.
 
This is the part of this thread that has always driven me a little bit batty.

Did they really have a zero tolerance policy?

No. They didn't. Really. They didn't. Can someone show me a policy that uses the phrase "zero tolerance" or any synonymous phrase? Don't bother trying. There isn't one.

But, even if it wasn't "zero tolerance", even if it was "not much tolerance", what part of the policy did Ahmed violate?

The closest thing that anyone could come up with was that the clock was a "look alike weapon". That's really stretching it. A lot. You would have to say that any object that a teacher didn't recognize, but which anyone associated with a weapon, was actually a look alike weapon.

If you want to say that there was a violation of policy, then cite the policy. In fact, the policy has been cited, and that clock wasn't a violation of the policy.

And finally, if this had remained a school matter, it wouldn't have been such a big issue. What made it a big issue was that it became a police matter, and police don't have "zero tolerance" policies, they have laws. It didn't violate any laws, which was why the prosecutors declined to file charges, and the case was closed. If someone really brought a hoax bomb to school, I would want them prosecuted, but it wasn't a hoax bomb, so I would want him released. In fact, it so obviously wasn't a hoax bomb that his arrest on that charge is worthy of ridicule.

Now we'll get to see if it's worthy of money.

The Student Code of Conduct prohibits students from possessing, among other items, “any articles not generally considered to be weapons, including school supplies, when the principal or designee determines that a danger exists.”

And the principal did. And does, still, even after the *********:

In the letter to parents, MacArthur High School principal Dan Cummings appeared to defend the decision to take the student into custody. “We will always take necessary precautions to protect our students,” wrote Cummings.

The letter says police found responded to a “suspicious-looking item” on Monday, but police found that the item posed no threat. An investigation remained ongoing, according to Cummings’ letter.

The principal added that parents should use Mohamed’s arrest as a teachable moment. “I recommend using this opportunity to talk with your child about the Student Code of Conduct and specifically not bringing items to school that are prohibited,” Cummings says in the letter. “Also, this is a good time to remind your child how important it is to immediately report any suspicious items and/or suspicious behavior they observe to any school employee so we can address it right away.”


From http://time.com/4036240/ahmed-mohamed-bomb-clock-principal-letter/
 
Having watched it - it's not anything different than what's being argued here, which is just a very poor attempt at making a personal attack against the kid.

As I said, it´s just a summary of the case for thinking that Ahmed and his family could have staged the whole thing. Not a personal attack*, just an interpretation of the information that is available. And they are choosing not to publish more information, which makes them look worse.

But the Ahmed believers, those of you who don´t doubt his story (you call yourselves skeptics???) I could also say that you are doing a personal attack on the school officials, police etc. don´t you think? You´re just assuming that they have acted on prejudice...

*OK, perhaps the video verges on the personal attack, but I´m sure I haven´t said anything that could be taken as such.
 
Last edited:
As I said, it´s just a summary of the case for thinking that Ahmed and his family could have staged the whole thing. Not a personal attack*, just an interpretation of the information that is available. And they are choosing not to publish more information, which makes them look worse.

But the Ahmed believers, those of you who don´t doubt his story (you call yourselves skeptics???) I could also say that you are doing a personal attack on the school officials, police etc. don´t you think? You´re just assuming that they have acted on prejudice...

*OK, perhaps the video verges on the personal attack, but I´m sure I haven´t said anything that could be taken as such.

Everyone in the case agrees on the following:

1)Ahmed did not claim that his "invention" was a bomb, but rather repeatedly claimed it was a clock.

2) He was questioned about a "hoax bomb" despite him clearly stating that the device was not a bomb.

3) Ahmed was questioned by police without his parents.

4) Ahmed was handcuffed in his school and taken away by said police.

The claim being made is that this is all somehow a "hoax". But, if we take every assertion made here as true - his father's an activist, his sister was suspended because some other student claimed she said she was going to blow up the school, she coached him on what to say to some interviewers, they're suing after the event - you still have nothing that leads to a "hoax".

A "hoax" that meets the agreed facts would be if the family were planning with the teacher, or the police who walked him out in handcuffs, and were going to divide the money up in the end.
 
It's a shame they had to move to Qatar to escape the outrage. You don't often hear about refugees fleeing the US. (Snowden is the only other one that comes to mind.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom