here is the statute:
Sec. 46.08. HOAX BOMBS. (a) A person commits an offense if the person knowingly manufactures, sells, purchases, transports, or possesses a hoax bomb with intent to use the hoax bomb to:
(1) make another believe that the hoax bomb is an explosive or incendiary device; or
(2) cause alarm or reaction of any type by an official of a public safety agency or volunteer agency organized to deal with emergencies.
(b) An offense under this section is a Class A misdemeanor.
*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*
There are three key words/phrases in that statute.
(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails.
(2) With intent to use the hoax bomb: Ahmed didn't intend to use the hoax bomb. He intended to show his teacher something he made. Unless you want to argue that "showing it to his teacher" is the same as using it. However, the entire phrase is "use the hoax bomb," which indicates that the use for the item must be as a hoax bomb.
(3) Make another believe...: Ahmed never told anyone it was a hoax bomb. He told everyone it was a clock, including his teacher, the principal, and the police.
Seems like there was probable cause to inquire why Ahmad took a perfectly useful clock, made a hot mess of it, and brought it to school.
There may be probable cause to ask why Ahmed ruined a clock (and how much did he ruin it if the alarm still went off..?) But when it comes to probable cause for building a hoax bomb, not even close.
It is if you intend for people to think it is a hoax bomb.
Except Ahmed didn't. He told everyone it was a clock.
Ahmed's intent determines whether or not it was a hoax bomb.
His intent for making the clock and bringing it to school is not known, true. His intent with respect to "clock vs. hoax bomb" is very clear. He told everyone it was a clock, even when asked if it was a bomb. He could have said it's a bomb; he didn't. Through the whole situation, he kept repeating that it was a clock.
The police interrogated him specifically to find out why he brought the device to school, and they claimed that he was being passive-aggressive.
Why did they say that? Because he wouldn't admit it was a bomb (or hoax bomb)? Because he asked (as is his right) for his parents to be present? Because he's a 14-year old boy and had been asked the same question over and over?
I'm not saying any of those things are the reason. I don't know; nor do you. But being passive-aggressive isn't a crime, and isn't grounds for arrest.
If all he said was that the device was a clock and kept repeating that, then I can see why they would consider him to be hiding something.
Why is that grounds to believe he is "hiding something?"
I don't believe that it is obvious that the police should not have believed that Ahmed's intent was to perpetrate a hoax.
If Ahmed intended to perpetrate a hoax, he could have. All he had to do was leave the clock sitting somewhere unattended. Someone finds a ticking device, and instant bomb threat.