Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

We're running in circles, now. It wasn't a hoax bomb.

It was thought it might be a hoax bomb, or something else nefarious. Hence, the device was investigated, and he was interrogated. After receiving answers that they thought less than forthcoming, the police decided that there was probable cause to arrest him for creating a hoax bomb. Maybe they did not have probable cause, but it is hard for us to say without having detailed knowledge of the interrogation, which we do not have. If it goes to court, a judge or jury will be able to decide if there was probable cause or not, and we may have more information at that time.
 
But that isn't a "hoax bomb." It's still a clock. Are you arguing that he was arrested for plugging in a clock and having the alarm go off (without meaning to)?

here is the statute:

Sec. 46.08. HOAX BOMBS. (a) A person commits an offense if the person knowingly manufactures, sells, purchases, transports, or possesses a hoax bomb with intent to use the hoax bomb to:

(1) make another believe that the hoax bomb is an explosive or incendiary device; or

(2) cause alarm or reaction of any type by an official of a public safety agency or volunteer agency organized to deal with emergencies.

(b) An offense under this section is a Class A misdemeanor.

Seems like there was probable cause to inquire why Ahmad took a perfectly useful clock, made a hot mess of it, and brought it to school.
 
But that isn't a "hoax bomb." It's still a clock. Are you arguing that he was arrested for plugging in a clock and having the alarm go off (without meaning to)?

Whether or not it was a hoax bomb isn't really the question. The question is whether there was probable cause to believe it was a hoax bomb.

As for the disruption to class, that certainly justified an investigation in the first place (there is no evidence that Ahmed set the alarm to go off accidentally, by the way - on the contrary, he admitted setting either the time or the alarm). One of the results of the investigation was a determination that the device was not a threat, but that perhaps it was meant to be perceived as one. It is probably unfair to judge the police without knowing the details of the interrogation.
 
But it WASN'T one. Making a clock that some people think is a hoax bomb is NOT illegal, which is the point I was making to 16.5

It is if you intend for people to think it is a hoax bomb.

Ahmed's intent determines whether or not it was a hoax bomb. Ahmed's intent was not known at the time of the interrogation. It may still not be known.
 
It was thought it might be a hoax bomb, or something else nefarious. Hence, the device was investigated, and he was interrogated. After receiving answers that they thought less than forthcoming, the police decided that there was probable cause to arrest him for creating a hoax bomb. Maybe they did not have probable cause, but it is hard for us to say without having detailed knowledge of the interrogation, which we do not have. If it goes to court, a judge or jury will be able to decide if there was probable cause or not, and we may have more information at that time.

I think the two of use are coming closer to a resolution of this question. In any case I am going to re-quit the thread because it has become extraordinarily repetitive. My position overlaps part of yours, although with a different point of view:

Some at the school thought Ahmed's clock look odd and became concerned. They asked Ahmed, who said it was a clock. Still unsatisfied, one or more teacher took it and him to the principal's office. At that point it became clear that it was a clock, just as Ahmed claimed, but the school authorities remained (for whatever reason) concerned that it might disrupt the atmosphere in the classrooms. At this point they should have confiscated it for the day, told Ahmed that it was disruptive to class, and that he could pick it up at the end of the day. If they were a good school, they even should have explained to Ahmed how, if he was interested, he could begin a more challenging project with a teacher that would teach him more skills and be done in a non-disruptive manner. In fact we never would have heard of this if that was their reaction. I would have no objection to this resolution. In fact, if Ahmed planned to create a political or financial issue this, the proper response, would have derailed it at the very start.

Instead the school decided to bring in the police and have Ahmed suspended and arrested. This was a hugh mistake whether Ahmed just intended to make a clock or intended to gain a political and financial benefit as some have proposed. It was not probable cause either way because it was a clock, and Ahmed said it was a clock even before he was asked, and even the school authorities and police agree that he said it was a clock and denied it was a bomb or hoax bomb when asked. You can't be considered to have made a hoax bomb threat if you never made a threat and you only had an innocent object, even if some people mistakingly think it might have been threatening. And you are not obligated to say anything more at a police interrogation in the USA, so being "uncooperative" (apparently by refusing to sign a confession to a hoax bomb) is not probable cause.

I fully agree: the evidence in the law suit will probably help resolve the details of the case and may even help reveal Ahmed's motivation. But until then, I find it amazing how much some are willing to project onto this poor kids and his family in the absence of the appropriate facts.

Having said that- bye for now.
 
Last edited:
It is if you intend for people to think it is a hoax bomb.

Ahmed's intent determines whether or not it was a hoax bomb. Ahmed's intent was not known at the time of the interrogation. It may still not be known.
WTF? Ahmed's intent has been known ever since this started--he made a case mod of a clock. Only those people who buy into the fantastical narrative that Ahmed and his family cooked this whole thing up to make fools of the school and the police, and then win big on a fifteen million dollar lawsuit, support any idea at all that this was a "bomb," hoax or otherwise.

To me, the progression of events is very straightforward:
  • Ahmed case-modded a clock and took it to school.
  • When the clock's alarm went off in class, the teacher sent Ahmed to the office (I don't know why that was, to be sure--I would think most teachers would simply say "Turn that thing off and pay attention to the class.")
  • At the office things spiralled out of control, ending with Ahmed being hauled off to the police station in handcuffs, where he was questioned without counsel or guardians present.
  • When stuff hit the fan, the police trotted out the "hoax bomb" charge as justification for taking Ahmed to the station in the first place. IMHO that was an after-the-fact CYA move.
  • A that point Ahmed's father, very much in character as an activist, launches a lawsuit over the whole affair. The price tag--$15 million--is very high and has lost the family some sympathy, but in the end they may collect nothing because first it has to get to trial, and second the judge/jury has to decide in their favour, and third the damages are then awarded.
 
Last edited:
Exposed electrical terminals are dangerous.

How do you know the line voltage contacts were exposed-I can't tell from the photo if they were insulated or not. Even if they were exposed, I don't think many 14 year olds are arrested for an electrical hazard. Was that the problem the school and police have put forward to explain their actions?

There are sockets all around with live conductors that will shock you if you put a key in them. Even putting a standard electrical plug in them typically (in the USA) creates exposed portions of the plug that become live before the plug is fully seated, Hell, we have homes in my city with tube and post wiring where the entire attic has long lengths of exposed live 110 V wire.

Even if the line voltage contacts on the transformer were exposed in Ahmed's project (and remember they were in a box and usually not plugged in) the proper response of the school would be to confiscate the clock and pair the student with a teacher who can explain how to do a better project.

Bye again. I may need some help to stay away= is their an Internet's Anonymous?
 
WTF? Ahmed's intent has been known ever since this started--he made a case mod of a clock.

No it hasn't. Certainly not since the actual event itself started, putting aside for now what was known after it went viral. The police interrogated him specifically to find out why he brought the device to school, and they claimed that he was being passive-aggressive. If all he said was that the device was a clock and kept repeating that, then I can see why they would consider him to be hiding something. For example, if Ahmed had an urgent need to know what time it was, a watch or a phone would have been more practical.

Only those people who buy into the fantastical narrative that Ahmed and his family cooked this whole thing up to make fools of the school and the police, and then win big on a fifteen million dollar lawsuit, support any idea at all that this was a "bomb," hoax or otherwise.

No, I don't buy into that fantastical narrative. I only think the school officials acted appropriately, and the police may or may not have. I don't believe that it is obvious that the police should not have believed that Ahmed's intent was to perpetrate a hoax.

To me, the progression of events is very straightforward:
  • Ahmed case-modded a clock and took it to school.
  • When the clock's alarm went off in class, the teacher sent Ahmed to the office (I don't know why that was, to be sure--I would think most teachers would simply say "Turn that thing off and pay attention to the class.")
  • At the office things spiralled out of control, ending with Ahmed being hauled off to the police station in handcuffs, where he was questioned without counsel or guardians present.
  • A that point Ahmed's father, very much in character as an activist, launches a lawsuit over the whole affair. The price tag--$15 million--is very high and has lost the family some sympathy, but in the end they may collect nothing because first it has to get to trial, and second the judge/jury has to decide in their favour, and third the damages are then awarded.

I'm sorry, but the "case mod" was idiotic. Ahmed is 14 years old, not 7. It is not unreasonable to suspect that he was up to something a little more sophisticated.
 
We don´t know the reason, we just know that she was suspended. But if the teachers knew about the incident it could explain why they thought Ahmed could be doing something similar.

It could go both ways, it could mean that the school tends to overreact towards muslims or it could show a pattern of behaviour from Ahmed´s family.

That was kind of one of my main points if you didn't notice. You can't use it as a support for speculation about a conspiracy to make the police look bad by the family.





It´s a way of speaking. He was told to put it away, instead of that, he plugged it and set the alarm off in class.


Which was stupid and probably deserved punishment. Not suspension and not being led away in handcuffs after being interrogated by police.



Why irrelevant?


I already said. Even if true, it's not a defense for what the police did.


All I´m saying is that we don´t know what happened, and that it is as wrong to assume closed mindedly that Ahmed was up to something dodgy as to assume closed mindedly that he was innocent and that it´s all the school´s fault.


This is a special kind of false dilemma fallacy called the Balance Fallacy. No, those things are not equally likely, and it isn't equally bad to dismiss one as the other. It's also a standard false dichotomy. I don't think anyone here is arguing it's all the school's fault.


And that this last position is probably held by those who have a prejudice against Texans, and is not a reasonable, skeptical position.


Maybe, but that's poisoning the well. It is just as easy to point out the vile racist morons who are defending the officials and condemning this family. The argument should stand on it's merits, and the past actions of the officials do count, whether or not they happen to be in Texas.


No. first, research what I quoted and second, rewrite what you are trying to say....


Having trouble with English again? Careful, you might misuse a word and people can dismiss you as you have people who don't know to use 'creation' instead of 'invention'. Careful with 'trademark' and 'copyright'.

You only give any weight to the 'admission against self interest' and cite court standards. They don't only give weight to those.



Until they are released all you have is speculation as to what really happened but I notice that doesn't stop you and others about being sure that the school and the police were prejudiced and racist.


Oh? Want to try again? You aren't speaking out against the speculation that this was orchestrated by the family. Odd that. Because that's what I was doing.
 
here is the statute:

Sec. 46.08. HOAX BOMBS. (a) A person commits an offense if the person knowingly manufactures, sells, purchases, transports, or possesses a hoax bomb with intent to use the hoax bomb to:

(1) make another believe that the hoax bomb is an explosive or incendiary device; or

(2) cause alarm or reaction of any type by an official of a public safety agency or volunteer agency organized to deal with emergencies.

(b) An offense under this section is a Class A misdemeanor.

*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*

There are three key words/phrases in that statute.

(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails.

(2) With intent to use the hoax bomb: Ahmed didn't intend to use the hoax bomb. He intended to show his teacher something he made. Unless you want to argue that "showing it to his teacher" is the same as using it. However, the entire phrase is "use the hoax bomb," which indicates that the use for the item must be as a hoax bomb.

(3) Make another believe...: Ahmed never told anyone it was a hoax bomb. He told everyone it was a clock, including his teacher, the principal, and the police.

Seems like there was probable cause to inquire why Ahmad took a perfectly useful clock, made a hot mess of it, and brought it to school.

There may be probable cause to ask why Ahmed ruined a clock (and how much did he ruin it if the alarm still went off..?) But when it comes to probable cause for building a hoax bomb, not even close.

It is if you intend for people to think it is a hoax bomb.

Except Ahmed didn't. He told everyone it was a clock.

Ahmed's intent determines whether or not it was a hoax bomb.

His intent for making the clock and bringing it to school is not known, true. His intent with respect to "clock vs. hoax bomb" is very clear. He told everyone it was a clock, even when asked if it was a bomb. He could have said it's a bomb; he didn't. Through the whole situation, he kept repeating that it was a clock.

The police interrogated him specifically to find out why he brought the device to school, and they claimed that he was being passive-aggressive.

Why did they say that? Because he wouldn't admit it was a bomb (or hoax bomb)? Because he asked (as is his right) for his parents to be present? Because he's a 14-year old boy and had been asked the same question over and over?

I'm not saying any of those things are the reason. I don't know; nor do you. But being passive-aggressive isn't a crime, and isn't grounds for arrest.

If all he said was that the device was a clock and kept repeating that, then I can see why they would consider him to be hiding something.

Why is that grounds to believe he is "hiding something?"

I don't believe that it is obvious that the police should not have believed that Ahmed's intent was to perpetrate a hoax.

If Ahmed intended to perpetrate a hoax, he could have. All he had to do was leave the clock sitting somewhere unattended. Someone finds a ticking device, and instant bomb threat.
 
But that isn't a "hoax bomb." It's still a clock. Are you arguing that he was arrested for plugging in a clock and having the alarm go off (without meaning to)?

How do you know what he intended? If he didn't want it to go off he wouldn't have plugged it in.
 
WTF? Ahmed's intent has been known ever since this started--he made a case mod of a clock. Only those people who buy into the fantastical narrative that Ahmed and his family cooked this whole thing up to make fools of the school and the police, and then win big on a fifteen million dollar lawsuit,
Ahmeds intent was not known when the police were brought. Something about his answers probably made the police not sure about his intent. His family has chosen not to allow other facts to released that could have shed light on this matter.
We still do not really know his intent unless we can read minds.

You do not have to buy into the "fantastical narrative" to believe it is possible it was his intent to cause a hoax.
 
Ahmeds intent was not known when the police were brought. Something about his answers probably made the police not sure about his intent. His family has chosen not to allow other facts to released that could have shed light on this matter.
We still do not really know his intent unless we can read minds.

You do not have to buy into the "fantastical narrative" to believe it is possible it was his intent to cause a hoax.

If that was his intent, he was really stupid about it. Want to cause a bomb scare? Which is more likely to do that?

(1) Take it to a teacher and tell the teacher it's a clock.
(2) Leave it somewhere unattended.
 
How do you know what he intended? If he didn't want it to go off he wouldn't have plugged it in.

And I'm sure all the kids that were currently dozing off were scared awake, despairing that it was time to get out of bed. What a monster.
 
If that was his intent, he was really stupid about it. Want to cause a bomb scare? Which is more likely to do that?

(1) Take it to a teacher and tell the teacher it's a clock.
(2) Leave it somewhere unattended.

I was a kid once and I did some stupid things. I am now supposedly an adult and still do things stupidly. The fact that he was stupid about it does not show his intent.
 
You only give any weight to the 'admission against self interest' and cite court standards. They don't only give weight to those.

There you go!

To further explain, out of court admissions against self interest are admissible, out of court claims that are in a party's self interest are not admissible to prove the fact asserted.

As such, not only are they given no weight, they are not admissible.

By the way, I already pointed out that a perp's claim of innocence is as common as it is worthless.

So endeth the lesson.
 
How do you know what he intended? If he didn't want it to go off he wouldn't have plugged it in.


We have two alarm clocks plugged in 27/7 in our bedroom. One for me, one for Mrs. qg.

On occasion (more than a few occasions :o) either one of these has been known to go off when it wasn't intended.

Sometimes it was because we forgot to turn the alarm all the way off and simply hit the "stop" button, leaving it to go off the next day. Unintended.

In the case of one of them, one of our cats has learned that if she stands her paws in enough spots it will turn on the radio and get us up to feed her. Sometimes while doing that she manages to engage the slider switch which turns on the alarm. And later it will go off. Unintended.

How do you know he did intend for it to go off? Is that the only possible reason he could have had for plugging it in?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom