Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Yep. We got it. 14 year old does juvenile project. Brings to school to show it to his teacher. Gets arrested for it. Thank God standards were slacker when I was that age.

Missing a few steps there, aren't you.

But add the "profit" that we can agree is what they are very interested in. For making a clock and a pencil case much less useful.
 
a sundial would have been way more useful than what the lil' inventor made.

Oh that completely justifies the police reaction then.


Missing a few steps there, aren't you.

But add the "profit" that we can agree is what they are very interested in. For making a clock and a pencil case much less useful.


No.
 
This is getting extremely tiresome. He's a fourteen your old boy. He doesn't necessarily have a mastery of the English language, so using the word "invention" out of place is no reason to continually slag him for not being an "inventor."

Were you the perfect little boy (girl?) when you were a teenager? Did you write sonnets at the level of Shakespeare and poetry at the level of Milton at fourteen? Did you get straight As in all your courses? Did you always obey every instruction given to you by an adult, both in the letter and in the spirit? If not, I say you're hardly in a position to criticise him at the level you are.

It appears at least his command of English is better than yours. Contrary to the lie you posted above, he did not destroy the clock. He took a functioning clock, put it into a different case, and ended up with a functioning clock.

He also got arrested for having it and questioned by the police, who after the fact came up with a BS charge of "possession of a hoax bomb" in a pathetic attempt to deflect attention away from their abysmal handling of it.

You seem awfully quick to assume the worst possible explanation of this event. A little more intelligent commentary and a lot less fact-devoid smear campaign would be appreciated.

You seem obsessed with me. Take a deep breath....

As for the lil inventor, the number of people who are making up excuses for Him is remarkable. Oh he does not speak English well. :rolleyes:

By the way, you seem unaware of the fact that the invention was dangerous and could have electrocuted anyone who reached in the case. The actual useful clock that we wrecked did not have that problem.

A little more research and less fact-devoid obsession about me would be appreciated.
 
Missing a few steps there, aren't you.

But add the "profit" that we can agree is what they are very interested in. For making a clock and a pencil case much less useful.


We can?

Nope. I don't think so. That looks like another one of those unfounded, baseless accusations ya'll are so fond of.

What we can agree on is that they are suing for a hefty chunk of change. A hefty chunk is what is required to make a lawsuit like this more than a minor irritant. And it should be.

What we don't know is what they plan to do with any award they might receive. They could be planning to use it to set up a foundation to combat mindless prejudice against Muslims.

They could be planning to set up a defense fund for teenagers abused by law enforcement.

They could be planning to offer cultural awareness classes for bigoted school staff and small puddle politicians.

How do you *know* what their plans are? Are you privy to special information?
 
He took an off-the shelf clock made by Radio Shack, removed the innards from the case, and placed those innards into a pencil case that happens to look like a suitcase. Certainly not an overly sophisticated project, but he managed to do it without disrupting the proper functioning of the clock.

I don't recall doing anything similar to that at 14, and I come from a family that's very handy with tools and building things. My father built the house that he still lives in, model steam engines, a camping trailer, a sailboat (that one from plans and a kit) and a trailer to haul it around in.

Thanks. I don't subscribe to the view that he deliberately provoked a police reaction, but I find some of the family's opportunism after the fact to be off-putting.
 
Thanks. I don't subscribe to the view that he deliberately provoked a police reaction, but I find some of the family's opportunism after the fact to be off-putting.


Except that we don't know that it actually is opportunism.

If they should win, then we will have to see what is done with the money before we can make any judgements about that.

Making such an assumption now is nothing more than character assassination.

Poison the well.
 
Maybe we are overreacting about the wildly overstated demand for damages from a school district and municipality!

They might do something useful with it. Maybe buy a couple slaves in Qatar?

The school would just waste it! Let's give it to Ahmed the builder and his pop!

:rolleyes:
 
Except that we don't know that it actually is opportunism.

If they should win, then we will have to see what is done with the money before we can make any judgements about that.

Making such an assumption now is nothing more than character assassination.

Poison the well.

Whatever they plan to do with it, $15 million is excessive.
 
Whatever they plan to do with it, $15 million is excessive.


Whatever has been asked for, it won't be germane to anything at all until money is actually awarded to them. If it is awarded.

Then we can talk about whether or not it is excessive.

The starting price is always higher than what the lawyers expect to get.

Also, the question needs to be asked, "How much will it take to get their attention?"

Looking at documents provided by the city of Irving, TX on their website it would appear that their annual budget is significantly in excess of $300,000,000.

$15 million would be less than 5% of one year's expenses.

That's enough to get their attention, maybe. (Although I expect there will be some shield provided by insurance.)

But it isn't enough for city council members to have to brown bag their lunches to make ends meet.

It has to at least prick their pocketbook a little bit to do any good at all.
 
Last edited:
Whatever has been asked for, it won't be germane to anything at all until money is actually awarded to them. If it is awarded.

Then we can talk about whether or not it is excessive.

The starting price is always higher than what the lawyers expect to get.

Also, the question needs to be asked, "How much will it take to get their attention?"

Looking at documents provided by the city of Irving, TX on their website it would appear that their annual budget is significantly in excess of $300,000,000.

$15 million would be less than 5% of one year's expenses.

That's enough to get their attention, maybe. (Although I expect there will be some shield provided by insurance.)

But it isn't enough for city council members to have to brown bag their lunches to make ends meet.

It has to at least prick their pocketbook a little bit to do any good.

Is the significant media coverage of the case not sufficient to get their attention? I have my doubts that such was the incentive behind the $15 million figure.
 
Is the significant media coverage of the case not sufficient to get their attention? I have my doubts that such was the incentive behind the $15 million figure.


Of course you do.

:rolleyes:

The media coverage isn't costing them anything. Why should they care about that?

They might even enjoy it.

When their mayor made the national news for her Islamophobic campaign against a Sharia Law 'threat' that didn't even exist the town was perfectly fine with the media attention. They approved of her publicity efforts.

They are winning the hearts and minds of right wing religious fundie bigots all across the country. A judgement against them would probably result in a Kickstarter campaign that might even net them a profit.
 
You seem obsessed with me. Take a deep breath....
What? I make one post calling you out on your attitude and I'm "obsessed"?

I'm not obsessed. But I am quite upset at a couple of posters who continually slander and attack the victim in this case, namely Ahmed, and ignore facts to support their own negative narrative.

As for the lil inventor, the number of people who are making up excuses for Him is remarkable. Oh he does not speak English well. :rolleyes:
I repeat: he's a fourteen your old boy. That is a fact, and fourteen year olds aren't known for perfect little people or having an excellent command of English. Is that "making up an excuse"?

I get the distinct impression you're judging him by the years of experience you've gained as an adult, completely ignoring the fact he has not had the benefit of those years. That and the fact you clearly don't like him or his family. Is it because they're Muslim? Or because they got fifteen minutes of fame after the school and the police monumentally mishandled this affair?

By the way, you seem unaware of the fact that the invention was dangerous and could have electrocuted anyone who reached in the case. The actual useful clock that we wrecked did not have that problem.
That's his inexperience showing. That problem can also be fixed.

Also, how do you know the original clock is "wrecked"? For all we know, he could have meticulously disassembled the original case so that the clock could be put back into it. Finally, with the unsafe electrical issue fixed, he has a perfectly workable clock. Certainly not "destroyed" or "wrecked."

A little more research and less fact-devoid obsession about me would be appreciated.
Your posts in this thread are all the research I need. You've done nothing but slag this kid, his motives, his family, and his ethnic background from the time you started posting in it. Like your first post:
16.5 said:
15 million bucks? Cripes, a guy could buy a whole raft of slave laborers immigrant workers in Qatar for that kind of dough.
Nice broad brush you got there.

Your second post:
16.5 said:
yeah, it was a hoax bomb, and they did a magnificent job of manipulating the press. I hope Qatar needs more scam artists because that is where they went. they have plenty of slaves, tho.
(Emphasis mine.) So now you know for certain it was a hoax bomb (hint: it was clock], they're manipulators and scam artists, they've already moved to Qatar, and the people of Qatar own slaves. (One can infer from that comment you're saying the family will own slaves once they get there.)

Your third post (in response to Sabrina asking for evidence that it was a hoax bomb):
16.5 said:
everything, of course, from his family manipulating him to the fact that the "invention" is basically taking a digital clock and putting it into a new case, to running off to Qatar as soon as the tyrants there showed them a little folding money. Good riddance
I'm not sure what you actually mean by the tyrants there [in Qatar] showing them a little folding money, but I read it that the leaders in Qatar were paying them to emigrate from the States. That may be true, or you may have just made that up out of whole cloth.

That's just your first three posts here. In them I see a hominem attacks, calling the leaders and citizens of Qatar--and by extension this family--tyrants and slave owners, calling the family manipulators and scam artists, calling the boy "lil inventor" to denigrate him, jumping to conclusions about the kid making a "hoax bomb," then later saying the boy destroyed a device when it's still working ... a real class act.

We've suffered from this kind of person running our country for the last nine years. I for one was so happy to be rid of him.

(BTW, as soon as I post this, I'll report it to a moderator asking if I'm attacking the argument or the person.)
 
Last edited:
What? I make one post calling you out on your attitude and I'm "obsessed"?

I'm not obsessed. But I am quite upset at a couple of posters who continually slander and attack the victim in this case, namely Ahmed, and ignore facts to support their own negative narrative.


I repeat: he's a fourteen your old boy. That is a fact, and fourteen year olds aren't known for perfect little people or having an excellent command of English. Is that "making up an excuse"?

I get the distinct impression you're judging him by the years of experience you've gained as an adult, completely ignoring the fact he has not had the benefit of those years. That and the fact you clearly don't like him or his family. Is it because they're Muslim? Or because they got fifteen minutes of fame after the school and the police monumentally mishandled this affair?

That's his inexperience showing. That problem can also be fixed.

Also, how do you know the original clock is "wrecked"? For all we know, he could have meticulously disassembled the original case so that the clock could be put back into it. Finally, with the unsafe electrical issue fixed, he has a perfectly workable clock. Certainly not "destroyed" or "wrecked."


Your posts in this thread are all the research I need. You've done nothing but slag this kid, his motives, his family, and his ethnic background from the time you started posting in it. Like your first post:

Nice broad brush you got there.

Your second post:
(Emphasis mine.) So now you know for certain it was a hoax bomb (hint: it was clock], they're manipulators and scam artists, they've already moved to Qatar, and the people of Qatar own slaves. (One can infer from that comment you're saying the family will own slaves once they get there.)

Your third post (in response to Sabrina asking for evidence that it was a hoax bomb):

I'm not sure what you actually mean by the tyrants there [in Qatar] showing them a little folding money, but I read it that the leaders in Qatar were paying them to emigrate from the States. That may be true, or you may have just made that up out of whole cloth.

That's just your first three posts here. In them I see a hominem attacks, calling the leaders and citizens of Qatar--and by extension this family--tyrants and slave owners, calling the family manipulators and scam artists, calling the boy "lil inventor" to denigrate him, jumping to conclusions about the kid making a "hoax bomb," then later saying the boy destroyed a device when it's still working ... a real class act.

We've suffered from this kind of person running our country for the last nine years. I for one was so happy to be rid of him.

(BTW, as soon as I post this, I'll report it to a moderator asking if I'm attacking the argument or the person.)

:rolleyes:
 
What? I make one post calling you out on your attitude and I'm "obsessed"?


Yeah. Interesting, isn't it. Leaves one to wonder what their post count suggests.

<snip>

Your posts in this thread are all the research I need. You've done nothing but slag this kid, his motives, his family, and his ethnic background from the time you started posting in it. Like your first post:

Nice broad brush you got there.

Your second post:
(Emphasis mine.) So now you know for certain it was a hoax bomb (hint: it was clock], they're manipulators and scam artists, they've already moved to Qatar, and the people of Qatar own slaves. (One can infer from that comment you're saying the family will own slaves once they get there.)

Your third post (in response to Sabrina asking for evidence that it was a hoax bomb):

I'm not sure what you actually mean by the tyrants there [in Qatar] showing them a little folding money, but I read it that the leaders in Qatar were paying them to emigrate from the States. That may be true, or you may have just made that up out of whole cloth.

That's just your first three posts here. In them I see a hominem attacks, calling the leaders and citizens of Qatar--and by extension this family--tyrants and slave owners, calling the family manipulators and scam artists, calling the boy "lil inventor" to denigrate him, jumping to conclusions about the kid making a "hoax bomb," then later saying the boy destroyed a device when it's still working ... a real class act.

<snip>

You need to be more understanding.

If they don't make **** up they have nothing.
 
shakes head sadly. I mean, it has been mentioned REPEATEDLY that his father is an activist.

"clock project." You mean making a useful clock significant less useful?

I forgot to mention: the civil rights marchers who tricked the cops into beating them were activists themselves. The kid's dad may have been an activist but I haven't seen any evidence the kid was. As I said, the kid was a rank amateur by comparison. He picked a CLOCK to bring to school, and no one at the school or the police even thought it was a bomb! The kid was an idiot! At least the civil rights marchers knew how to look black enough to convince the cops enough to beat them up. The kid was just lucky he got arrested anyway even though everyone could see through his clock scheme. I think he was helped by his dark completion, but I know that we are only dealing with documented facts here so I will not bring that up.

And I agree: being an "activist" means that you are asking for it. Anything the authorities do to you is fine!
 
Last edited:
Maybe I'm out of step with current culture but I don't value spending ten minutes watching an angry idiot yell opionions at his laptop. I made it all the way to 49 seconds of that one only by grinding my teeth.

Also, I disagree 100% with the conclusion. For many and various reasons I've voiced many times in this very thread. No presentation of uninformed opinions will change my analysis of Ahmed's project as a naive work by a naive and technically unsophisticated experimenter. What he created resembles a bench-rugged electronics experimenter kit far more than it does a "bomb" or "hoax bomb" in my view, based on being an experimenter myself.

How can you disagree with his conclusion if you haven´t watched the video? I agree the style is a bit ranty but he makes a pretty good summary of the case:

- Activist publicity seeking father
- Previous history of hoax bombing by Ahmed´s sister
- Ahmed knowing it looked suspicious
- Disruptive behaviour, repeatedly not hiding the clock when told
- School having "zero tolerance" policies so not actually overreacting, just doing what they were compelled to do.

I would add: Obama´s cold reception at the White House. He didn´t approach Ahmed, didn´t look for a photo with him, after the warm invitation a few weeks earlier. And he was the most mediatic of the visitors that day. He eventually had to walk from the back of the room to be able to get close to Obama and take a picture with him. I know you´ll dismiss this as not proof of anything, but I was waiting so see how it turned up, whether Obama would receive Ahmed with open arms or whether he had already realised he´d been conned and tried to downplay it. It looked like the second option.
 
Last edited:
How can you disagree with his conclusion if you haven´t watched the video? I agree the style is a bit ranty but he makes a pretty good summary of the case:

- Activist publicity seeking father
That part's accurate. But I've not seen anything to suggest the father got involved until after stuff hit the fan.

- Previous history of hoax bombing by Ahmed´s sister
Evidence?

- Ahmed knowing it looked suspicious
You'll need to back that up with a quote from Ahmed himself. The only references to "suspicious" are from people who support the narrative that Ahmed did this as a publicity stunt and not as a case mod.

- Disruptive behaviour, repeatedly not hiding the clock when told
Evidence for "repeatedly"?

- School having "zero tolerance" policies so not actually overreacting, just doing what they were compelled to do.
There's some merit to this statement, but many posters here (myself included) believe the school authorities severely over-reacted to a teenager with a case-modded clock that he insisted was a clock.

I would add: Obama´s cold reception at the White House. He didn´t approach Ahmed, didn´t look for a photo with him, after the warm invitation a few weeks earlier. And he was the most mediatic of the visitors that day. He eventually had to walk from the back of the room to be able to get close to Obama and take a picture with him. I know you´ll dismiss this as not proof of anything, but I was waiting so see how it turned up, whether Obama would receive Ahmed with open arms or whether he had already realised he´d been conned and tried to downplay it. It looked like the second option.
So now people are able to read the President's mind?
 
That part's accurate. But I've not seen anything to suggest the father got involved until after stuff hit the fan.


Evidence?


You'll need to back that up with a quote from Ahmed himself. The only references to "suspicious" are from people who support the narrative that Ahmed did this as a publicity stunt and not as a case mod.


Evidence for "repeatedly"?


There's some merit to this statement, but many posters here (myself included) believe the school authorities severely over-reacted to a teenager with a case-modded clock that he insisted was a clock.


So now people are able to read the President's mind?

1 Ahmed´s sister:
Fresh from Google:
http://www.breitbart.com/big-govern...spension-alleged-bomb-threat-3-years-earlier/
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articl...med-moahmed-the-most-famous-boy-on-earth.html

2 Evidence Ahmed admits it looked suspicious: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9UGLM31S6II around 1:30 mark

3 Repeteadly?
"Mohamed showed his clock to his engineering teacher, who warned him not to show it to anyone else. But when the clock began beeping during English class, Mohamed revealed it to his English teacher, who alerted the principal." from: http://bulletin.equinoxpub.com/2015...meds-clock-says-about-belief-and-moral-panic/

4. I don´t know anything about those "zelo tolerance" policies because luckily we don´t have those over here in Spain, but as you admit, they could be the cause for the "everreaction".

Another red light: "The school district, a number of times, has asked the family, to release the records, so that you can have the balanced story out there. The family is ignoring the request from the ISD.” From: http://pamelageller.com/2015/09/irving-mayor-ahmed-mohameds-family-blocking-release-of-records-obama-tweeted-support-even-before-clock-pic-released.html/#sthash.43nn1xjq.dpuf"

It only took me a few minutes of googling to find those links. I don´t know whether the websites are legit or not, some of them might be dodgy, feel free to point out which information is wrong. (pointing out that a website is "right wing" or whatever doesn´t count)

Regarding what I wrote about Obama, I thought it was quite clear. Are you being intentionally obtuse? What I meant is that since Obama twitted so early his support of Ahmed, and then all this information started to come out pointing to the possibility that is was all a big trolling from Ahmed and his family, (his sister has been reported to be directing much of what he says, I´ll find the evidence if you want, if your google skills are that bad), I wanted to see if in the visit to the WH Obama would make a big show of his support of him. But apparently Obama didn´t pay any special attention to him, and Ahmed had to push his way though the crowd in order to get his picture taken with the Persident. I took this as confirmation that Obama had probably by then realised of the (possibility of the) big con and didn´t want to be seen too friendly with Ahmed. Clear now?
 
Last edited:
These arguments would have a lot more weight if his project was (were? I'm having a grammar moment) in some way inconsistent with the way naive experimenters play with electronic objects. But the fact is, Ahmed's Clock is 100% consistent with how young people explore electronic objects.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom