Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

The teacher was competent enough to determine if something was in her classroom that didn't belong. She did the right thing bringing it to the principal's attention. The principal, recognizing that he didn't know what the purpose of the device was, but trusting that it wasn't about to blow up in his face because the teacher who was in the best position to judge the student's temperament didn't think it was a physical danger, contacted the school resource officers. He also did the right thing. The school resource officers, probably having very little knowledge of Ahmed personally (unlike the teacher) and probably having very little knowledge of the teacher (unlike the principal) viewed the intentions of the student with even greater skepticism and caution. Still, being trained, they may have realized that there was no explosive material, and so, aside from its potential as an electrical hazard when plugged into A/C power, it posed no physical threat. That was not the end of it though because they had a duty to determine whether the device was meant to cause alarm or if it was meant to be used for some other nefarious purpose. It was perfectly reasonable for them to interrogate Ahmed. At that point, we run out of information. We only really have a vague idea that Ahmed told them it was a clock and didn't think any other explanation was necessary, and the officers thought additional explanation was necessary. The official line is that Ahmed was passive-aggressive, although Ahmed's supporters have ridiculed such a notion, as if the idea of being passive-aggressive was alien to them or that it shouldn't matter that somebody being interrogated by the police was passive-aggressive. My take on it is that it's certainly possible to be passive-aggressive during questioning, and it's even possible for a 14 year old boy to be so. Furthermore, I think being passive-aggressive is likely to exacerbate suspicions rather than ameliorate them.


Was she competent to determine that it offered no threat?

If so, why escalate?

It sounds like you want her to be both competent enough to determine on her own that no threat existed, and not competent enough to be sure that no threat existed.

Bumping the whole mess up to a higher level was nothing but an abrogation of her own responsibility. If she was that unsure of her determination she had no right to continue to endanger her students. The only responsible thing to have done would have been to remove them from the possible threat until the higher authority she wanted to rely on gave her the all-clear.

She can't have the authority and not have it at the same time.

You're just dancing around that with weak obfuscation.
 
I've snipped large parts of the posts I'm quoting for easier reading and to shorten the response.

Well why would YOU say that when nothing in the situation indicates that is what happened. You saw the kid and he's a mannered, well spoken young man and doesn't act in any way that suggests he in a gang or has a gun.

Jumping the gun to bigotry is racist in and of itself. In my opinion.

Perhaps what I am seeing is easier for me to recognize because I have two Arab Muslim boys

One came out like his Dad, very dark skin and dark eyes and kinky hair

The other one came out like my side of the family (Picture the little girl in Poltergeist although his hair got darker as he got older)


I've watched over the years people making presumptions about them just based on what they LOOKED LIKE

You'll notice I didn't really take issue with it until people started mentioning his "dark skin" because I've seen racism myself with my own two kids.

I don't feel like derailing the thread with it, but to me the insistence that they targeted Ahmed because of what he LOOKED LIKE and insisting that they thought things about him because of what he LOOKED LIKE is just as racist to me.

Example People saying to me and my son "Oh wow were people mean to you after 911?" No why would they be? "Well because you look Arab and Muslim and your name is one of the terrorists names."

I'd get really pissed off because NO people don't treat him that way because he's a beautiful respectful young man and people think his name is cool you *********** *******.

I wasn't going to investigate this line of reasoning, but you've repeated it. The implication is that Ahmed isn't a beautiful and respectful young man, and that people are only or largely only racist against people who aren't 'beautiful, mannered, respectful, or well spoken'.

The second invocation of this line of reasoning is even more troubling, and perhaps I should have gone into the huge flaw in your reasoning I first quoted. Racism isn't rational. It doesn't follow at all that people wouldn't act racist towards 'beautiful, well spoken, mannered' people. We know there are people who are. That there isn't good reason to be racist is besides the point. They are concerned that they may have been treated badly based on the way they look because a non-trivial number of people do treat people badly based on the way they look.

Furthermore, your attitude towards a concerned question (which is how you yourself presented it) over something that is not only possible, but documented in other cases, is very troubling. I certainly hope you don't reply to them as bombastically as you have been conversing here.


And again, the actions of the police are very different than the actions of the school simply because the Teacher KNEW HIM and so did the principal. The cops may have made a judgment about him, but what indications do you have that ANYONE in the school targeted him for being a "Dark Skinned Muslim" ???

So I can see your argument about the police, (as I have said several times) but not about the teacher and the school.

Insisting that they targeted him for being a "Dark skinned Muslim" is racist. Insisting that the only reason they took him to the office was because of him being a "Dark Skinned Muslim" when that's not what happened is perpetuating racism.

The school brought in the police. To address something you've said in posts I don't believe I've quoted here, they followed policy.

Yes, following policy can indeed be an act motivated by bigotry. If there is discretion and they don't apply discretion because they are bigoted against Muslims (or Arabs, or Persians), then following the policy where they would have normally not is the result of bigotry.

This is closely paralleled by the examples of men and black people consistently receiving harsher sentences than women and white people. They are still inside sentencing guild-lines (following policy), but it's still evidence of bigotry.

I know it's a slight nuance that is difficult to see so I'll leave it at agreeing to disagree.


You could try seeing it this way.


Imagine we are having the conversation at a dinner table and my son is sitting there. You all keep saying "Well of course they targeted him for being a Dark SKinned Muslim" and my son is sitting there listening to this. What message are you sending to my son?

The message that you are sending to my son is that if someone has an issue with you it's always because of what you "look like" not about who you are as person.

When I see Ahmed I see a well spoken young man. He seems very polite and nice and he's cute too.

You see a label.

I doubt very much that his teachers just see the label. I bet they know him very well.


The cops may have been racist. But when you discuss a child by his "label" you identify to all children who look like that label that there is something inherently "wrong with them" according to society.

Consider again both my sons sitting at the table and the one who is "WHITE" is never told that there is something problematic about what he looks like. But the one who is DARK is told constantly that there's a problem.

Who is the racist here now?

An old picture of the boys. :)

[qimg]http://i717.photobucket.com/albums/ww178/ralboro/boys111_zpscie63j36.jpg[/qimg]

I'll be deleting the link later.




I'd rather not keep discussing your sons as examples. If you'd like a response, I've also put it in spoilers.

And if you kept insisting it couldn't be because of prejudice, then you are marginalizing something that will in all likelihood actually effect your sons at some point in their life. I'm a 'white' male, and racism has directly effected even me in my life. Do you not want them to be able to voice those concerns to you?


Here's another example.


I'm shopping with a friend of mind who is black and another "well meaning white chick" The black chick comes out of the store annoyed. "The stupid sales girl was up my ass the entire time I was in there!"

The "well meaning white chick" "Why did she think you were trying to shoplift? What a ***** "

Black chick "No she saw my expensive bag and thought she was going to get a big commission out of me, why would you think she thought I was shoplifting?"

The "well meaning white chick" "Well because you're black, and you know how "those people" think that you shoplift, she's probably a racist."


Um........no errrrr......who's the racist here?

You do realize that the 'white chick' could have been right and the 'black chick' wrong, don't you?

I agree, there are many times where people assume racist motives where none are needed, indicated, or are even very unlikely. That doesn't mean it's wrong to investigate, be concerned of, or acknowledge racism. It doesn't mean we dismiss it as an explanation.

(It's like it hasn't registered to so many that Texas isn't made up of tons of white people. A large Hispanic population lives in Texas. You don't even know the race of the teacher involved and you are just jumping the gun.)

How do you know the teacher isn't Arab or Persian, Black? Or Mexican?

You don't.

First and foremost, people who aren't white can be racist. It's one of the things I get most annoyed about in regards to my fellow liberals that they so often minimize and even justify the racism coming from non-white people. One of those times I've been directly effected by racism, even as a white guy, was when a girl who liked me couldn't date me, in part, because her family wouldn't approve of her dating a white man. That didn't stop us from having some fun, but I would have much preferred (this is an understatement) an actual romantic relationship.

Secondly, while any of those teachers might be Muslim, if any of them are Arab or Persian, it isn't by name or appearance.

Thirdly, working with a diverse group of people doesn't mean one doesn't have bigotry.

Maybe they're all married to people of middle-eastern decent. Maybe all the white ones hate the black ones. Maybe the dark skinned ones talk down to the light skinned ones. All of these speculations, including yours, are not known facts. They're speculation on details that might make bigotry more or less likely.


What does the MAYOR have to do with what the TEACHER and the PRINCIPAL and the school did?

The mayor is an example of people who fall for (or cynically use) anti-Muslim fears of a very foolish nature.
 
I've snipped large parts of the posts I'm quoting for easier reading and to shorten the response.





I wasn't going to investigate this line of reasoning, but you've repeated it. The implication is that Ahmed isn't a beautiful and respectful young man, and that people are only or largely only racist against people who aren't 'beautiful, mannered, respectful, or well spoken'.

The second invocation of this line of reasoning is even more troubling, and perhaps I should have gone into the huge flaw in your reasoning I first quoted. Racism isn't rational. It doesn't follow at all that people wouldn't act racist towards 'beautiful, well spoken, mannered' people. We know there are people who are. That there isn't good reason to be racist is besides the point. They are concerned that they may have been treated badly based on the way they look because a non-trivial number of people do treat people badly based on the way they look.

Furthermore, your attitude towards a concerned question (which is how you yourself presented it) over something that is not only possible, but documented in other cases, is very troubling. I certainly hope you don't reply to them as bombastically as you have been conversing here.




The school brought in the police. To address something you've said in posts I don't believe I've quoted here, they followed policy.

Yes, following policy can indeed be an act motivated by bigotry. If there is discretion and they don't apply discretion because they are bigoted against Muslims (or Arabs, or Persians), then following the policy where they would have normally not is the result of bigotry.

This is closely paralleled by the examples of men and black people consistently receiving harsher sentences than women and white people. They are still inside sentencing guild-lines (following policy), but it's still evidence of bigotry.



I'd rather not keep discussing your sons as examples. If you'd like a response, I've also put it in spoilers.

And if you kept insisting it couldn't be because of prejudice, then you are marginalizing something that will in all likelihood actually effect your sons at some point in their life. I'm a 'white' male, and racism has directly effected even me in my life. Do you not want them to be able to voice those concerns to you?




You do realize that the 'white chick' could have been right and the 'black chick' wrong, don't you?

I agree, there are many times where people assume racist motives where none are needed, indicated, or are even very unlikely. That doesn't mean it's wrong to investigate, be concerned of, or acknowledge racism. It doesn't mean we dismiss it as an explanation.



First and foremost, people who aren't white can be racist. It's one of the things I get most annoyed about in regards to my fellow liberals that they so often minimize and even justify the racism coming from non-white people. One of those times I've been directly effected by racism, even as a white guy, was when a girl who liked me couldn't date me, in part, because her family wouldn't approve of her dating a white man. That didn't stop us from having some fun, but I would have much preferred (this is an understatement) an actual romantic relationship.

Secondly, while any of those teachers might be Muslim, if any of them are Arab or Persian, it isn't by name or appearance.

Thirdly, working with a diverse group of people doesn't mean one doesn't have bigotry.

Maybe they're all married to people of middle-eastern decent. Maybe all the white ones hate the black ones. Maybe the dark skinned ones talk down to the light skinned ones. All of these speculations, including yours, are not known facts. They're speculation on details that might make bigotry more or less likely.




The mayor is an example of people who fall for (or cynically use) anti-Muslim fears of a very foolish nature.


Clearly you are a "racialist".

Or something.

By TT's standards that means you are unequivocally racist.

Welcome to the club. It's gonna get crowded, I think.
 
The fact that he has done things like a "mock trial" (whatever that is) against quram burning and ran for the elections in Sudan (where there are no elections, AFAIK) makes this business smell a bit fishy... He´s not just some random citizen who shies away from the spotlight.

Come now, you aren't even trying. Google found "sudan election" pretty easy.



So, in all seriousness, what's the point? Really. The kid made a clock. He told people it was a clock. He was arrested.



Somehow the fact that his father is......whatever........matters?

I don't get it.

ETA: In the 2015 elections, Ahmed's father got 42,399 votes, placing him in fourth place.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudanese_general_election,_2015
 
Last edited:
Bad example perhaps http://www.martyduren.com/2015/09/19/that-ahmeds-clock-vs-suitcase-bomb-meme-its-more-fake-news/

The picture I posted is not an actual bomb, but an elecronics case that the owned admits could look like a bomb in an airport baggage checkpoint... So it´s not that different after all

I had been about to post on it, and note that it doesn't look at all like a bomb. There are lots of things about it that make it not very bomb-like at all. It would never be mistaken at an airport for a bomb.* People who are trained in what bombs look like would not suspect it was one. People who are frightened by devices they don't understand might well be suspicious.

I used to travel through airports, including customs, with similar devices. They were always checked for explosives, just like my laptop computer was always checked for explosives, but the TSA agents, or their equivalents in Mexico, never seemed nervous about it, because it doesn't look at all like a bomb.

The Mexicans usually suspected me of smuggling in manufacturing equipment without paying the duty. On one occasion, they were right.

*Although I wouldn't leave it unattended in the restroom. But that goes for any suitcase.
 
Last edited:
Bad example perhaps http://www.martyduren.com/2015/09/19/that-ahmeds-clock-vs-suitcase-bomb-meme-its-more-fake-news/

The picture I posted is not an actual bomb, but an elecronics case that the owned admits could look like a bomb in an airport baggage checkpoint... So it´s not that different after all

That photo was discussed in a different thread: Debunking a meme: clock vs suitcase bomb.

While it is not a real bomb if you download the photo and look at the larger version it has simulated plastic explosive molded into the front edge of the case assembly. It appears it was a made by an ex-Army Honeywell security systems employee as a training device to show what a booby-trapped salesman's demo case could look like. There's more information in that other thread.
 
I've read through the mad crawl.

I want people to do this. When you go to your parent teacher conferences. Please give them CASH. Not coffee mugs and whimsical gifts that teachers have up the whazoo.

If NOTHING has come of this thread, it's this, this sad reality which I spoke about pages ago.

That a teacher's job is to facilitate LEARNING. They have spend HOURS prepping, probably money that you don't even know.

And here we are at the end of this entire discussion with people suggesting that the solution to the problem is to get teachers to be trained for "spotting fake bombs"

Because god forbid we restrict a child's right to bring a gizmo to school.

If that doesn't tell you EVERYTHING that is wrong with the educational system in the US

Translation: people and parents who have ZERO respect for the job they are actually there to do.

Then nothing does.

I sincerely mean this. I hope that of the people reading this thread, NOT the posters, but the readers.

This Christmas hand your teacher a $50 gift card.

Because THIS is the reality of the ******** they have to deal with every day.
 
My take on it is that it's certainly possible to be passive-aggressive during questioning,
yes

and it's even possible for a 14 year old boy to be so.
yes
Furthermore, I think being passive-aggressive is likely to exacerbate suspicions rather than ameliorate them.
yes

But when do we get to the "probable cause" part? Suspicion is not probable cause.
 
Here´s the thing about his father: http://www.nydailynews.com/news/nat...sted-clock-standout-citizen-article-1.2363466

The fact that he has done things like a "mock trial" (whatever that is) against quram burning and ran for the elections in Sudan (where there are no elections, AFAIK) makes this business smell a bit fishy... He´s not just some random citizen who shies away from the spotlight.

That certainly explains why the family would publicize this incident. However even if they set it up, it would have be an easy trap to avoid. Following from what quadraginta had said - if they evacuated the school and called the bomb squad, then at least their actions would have been internally consistent. It was the lack of this action, combined with the calling the police and the consequent arrest that highlights where the school and police went wrong.
 
Come now, you aren't even trying. Google found "sudan election" pretty easy.



So, in all seriousness, what's the point? Really. The kid made a clock. He told people it was a clock. He was arrested.



Somehow the fact that his father is......whatever........matters?

I don't get it.

ETA: In the 2015 elections, Ahmed's father got 42,399 votes, placing him in fourth place.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudanese_general_election,_2015

Yes, "elections" indeed....

On 20 April 2015; Norway, the United Kingdom and the United States issued a joint statement saying that the Sudanese Government failed "to create a free, fair, and conducive elections environment" and that the "outcome of these elections cannot be considered a credible expression of the will of the Sudanese people"
 
I had been about to post on it, and note that it doesn't look at all like a bomb. There are lots of things about it that make it not very bomb-like at all. It would never be mistaken at an airport for a bomb..

Then why does the original author of the photo say " I'm also happy I didn't bring the Honeywell demo kit with me it since it is full of electronics and switches and I'm sure it would have raised some questions."? Would TSA officials think it was a new type of drug? A stuffed crocodile?
 
That certainly explains why the family would publicize this incident. However even if they set it up, it would have be an easy trap to avoid. Following from what quadraginta had said - if they evacuated the school and called the bomb squad, then at least their actions would have been internally consistent. It was the lack of this action, combined with the calling the police and the consequent arrest that highlights where the school and police went wrong.

It is not claimed that he made an actual bomb threat, what they accused him of is that he made a "hoax bomb". According to some accounts he was "disruptive" and "uncooperative" and they told him to put away the clock but didn´t, so they called the cops. It´s like if you yell "fire!" without actually being a fire, they´ll call the cops on you, not the firemen.

There could still be some level of discrimination in how they handled it, but we don´t have enough details to decide. At this point it´s all speculation, on both sides.
 
Yes, "elections" indeed....

On 20 April 2015; Norway, the United Kingdom and the United States issued a joint statement saying that the Sudanese Government failed "to create a free, fair, and conducive elections environment" and that the "outcome of these elections cannot be considered a credible expression of the will of the Sudanese people"

What's your point? How does this relate to arresting a kid who rewired a clock?
 
Then why does the original author of the photo say " I'm also happy I didn't bring the Honeywell demo kit with me it since it is full of electronics and switches and I'm sure it would have raised some questions."? Would TSA officials think it was a new type of drug? A stuffed crocodile?

Well, I notice that the original author didn't actually take it with him, so perhaps he is unfamiliar with what TSA does.

TSA would have thought it was an industrial controller, because that's what it looks like.
 
It is not claimed that he made an actual bomb threat, what they accused him of is that he made a "hoax bomb". According to some accounts he was "disruptive" and "uncooperative" and they told him to put away the clock but didn´t, so they called the cops. It´s like if you yell "fire!" without actually being a fire, they´ll call the cops on you, not the firemen.

There could still be some level of discrimination in how they handled it, but we don´t have enough details to decide. At this point it´s all speculation, on both sides.

What if you yell, "Wake up!" That's kind of like what alarm clocks do.

The point that a lot of anti-Ahmed people are missing is that he took it to school, showed it to a teacher, and said, "This is a clock."

If you tell people that you have a clock, then you don't have a hoax bomb. To do anything else creates a situation where your perceptions define my crimes. You are saying that if you think something, but are wrong, the person do the thing you are mistaken about is responsible for what you think.

Now, he was "uncooperative". I'm sure he was. And? We are all familiar with the phrase "you have the right to remain silent", but a lot of people forget that those words actually have meaning. You really do have the right to remain silent. As with any of your other rights, you are not subject to arrest when you exercise that right. There has to be probable cause that a crime has been committed. Since he showed the clock to teachers and he said it was a clock, it obviously isn't a hoax bomb.

He was "disruptive". Actually, that word won't be found in any official communication relating to this incident, although it has turned up in a lot of post-hoc analysis. Regardless, it isn't a crime.
 
Last edited:
What's your point? How does this relate to arresting a kid who rewired a clock?


Here's what I want to know.

If merely suggesting that prejudice might have contributed to the atrocious treatment Ahmed received is racist (or "racialist" :rolleyes:), as we have been told, then what is claiming that the kid was motivated by the father's political and religious affiliations?

Seems like a double standard to me.
 
What is your response to the questions I asked you?

I specifically picked the SECOND definition (which was not something I came up with btw), because theprestige pointed out the distinction in what I was saying.

Frankly I do consider it racist and agree with YOUR choice, but it seemed not to match the definition theprestige was going for.


I consider someone who can't fathom "another possible reason than race" without any evidence to back it up, to be racist.

And when I say that I distinguish between the person being a member of the same race.

So for example if a black person feels they are always being targeted because they are black, I'm going to leave them to their experiences.

But if a white, asian, mexican, arab, etc can only see the "racial" element of a black person's experiences in life, in my mind it is because they are racist.


They may consider themselves a "good guy" but to me they are racist.


Here's another example in a different way.

Two of my friends are married lesbians. My program in grad school was a motley crew of Muslims, Jews, White Hipsters, Atheists, Spanish, Black and Gay folks. We'd have routine of meeting for dinner once a month. One night I invited this very "cool" "open minded" type woman from England. (Let's call her Edna)


All of us brought our spouses or significant others and as we sat at the table Edna kept constantly drawing the conversation back to the lesbian couple. She kept going on and on about how amazing she thought they were as a couple. And wow, tell me how you met, don't let anyone get you down, go you! "Don't hide your hand holding under the table, you're among friends"

No matter how many times we tried to pull the conversation back to a general topic she kept putting a "spotlight" on the lesbian couple.

To us they were our friends. Their relationship was "normal" to us because we'd known them for years. Edna seemed like a jackass to us. I had to finally take her outside for a smoke and tell her to STOP IT.

She kept saying that she felt the rest of the table was not addressing their relationship and it was wrong since we were all their with our spouses why shouldn't she feel as welcome with hers.

I was like DUDE SHE DOES. They feel NORMAL with us because they ARE NORMAL with us. You are the one who keeps pointing out how "different they are"

So that's what this reminds me of. Her actions were really no different than a born again Christian questioning them relentlessly about their relationship.

PS My friend thanked me later and both she and her wife thought Edna was an idiot. I wound up unfriending her.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom