Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Going by what you seem to be saying here the teacher was seriously if not criminally delinquent for irresponsibly failing to evacuate her class room and raise an alarm for the entire school.

You can't have it both ways.

Either she wasn't qualified to assess the device and failed in her responsibilities, or she was and the whole incident was blown out of proportion by the school's reaction.

You choose.

No, this is wrong, and I'll say this for the fourth time in this thread. There are intermediate scenarios where a suspicious device causes enough concern to warrant an investigation, but not enough concern to warrant a highly disruptive evacuation of the school. The teacher, maybe knowing that Ahmed was a very nice kid, probably discounted the probability that he was actually trying to kill anybody to near zero, but she still might have thought that he was up to some sort of mischief (and perhaps trying to make other kids believe he had a bomb was one of the possibilities in her mind).
 
When it comes to the English teacher, that device was a thing that made noise during her class.

I have no problem with the English teacher taking issue with it.


With all the publicity that this has gotten, I'm surprised we haven't seen any accounts from students who witnessed the scene in the English class, which was the only portion that occurred in full view of non-official witnesses, i.e. those who weren't constrained by policy issues. The incident with the engineering teacher may also have been witnessed, but I don't know. Everything else happened behind closed doors. However, for one reason or another, I haven't seen any student blogs or even any "My son told me that ...." sort of blogs from parents. Maybe people are getting the clue that sharing too much info isn't always a good thing.
 
Yes, but you don't need to go for an argument by dictionary to say that recognising racism isn't inherently racist.


No. I don't. Unless they choose to use the word in what is a patently distorted fashion. Their motives for doing so are unclear, but the maneuver itself is blatant.

Otherwise, by Truethat's logic, it would be racist to say that the Klan is racist, or that Apartheid was racist... or any openly racist body/person.

Which is ridiculous.
Agreed.

I find it strange to see the other people trying to defend that claim.

TT I can understand. She has demonstrated repeatedly that she will say anything at all that she thinks will bolster her position, no matter how blatantly false or undeniably stupid it is. The ones backing her play on this are usually better than that.
 
Last edited:
When his parents came to pick him up, his sister was with them. The cuffs were still on. His father requested that they be left on so that the sister could take the picture.

My source for the above is Breitbart. Didn't save link. Take it for what it's worth.

So...the source was Brietbart.
 
Dude again I'm showing people exactly :D


http://lmgtfy.com/?q=racialist


There's a large definition at top


Which is the one I quoted.

Then a wiki page


The source for the one I quoted.

Then the exact definition (first definition) that I picked. Everyone can read it. I think you may have twisted the tinfoil a little too tight this time.


Exactly. You waded through everything that wasn't helpful to your claim until you found something sufficiently vague to try and pretend it supported what you are claiming.

I'm glad that you have finally admitted it. Now we can move on.
 
Last edited:
How is that relevant? We often ask posters to explain which definition of a word they are using. Now you're criticising her for not using all of them?

Once truethat specified the word and definition she wanted to use, it cleared up the issue. What's the problem?


That it is not representative of the commonly accepted meaning of the word, and thus is being used only as misdirection?

That's the problem.

It is dishonest on the face of it.
 
No, this is wrong, and I'll say this for the fourth time in this thread. There are intermediate scenarios where a suspicious device causes enough concern to warrant an investigation, but not enough concern to warrant a highly disruptive evacuation of the school. The teacher, maybe knowing that Ahmed was a very nice kid, probably discounted the probability that he was actually trying to kill anybody to near zero, but she still might have thought that he was up to some sort of mischief (and perhaps trying to make other kids believe he had a bomb was one of the possibilities in her mind).


She is still assessing the bomb, which means she at least feels qualified to do so.

If she didn't then she should have evacuated.

There is no "intermediate" She had enough confidence in her assessment of the device to determine it wasn't a bomb.

End of story. Or at least that part.

We were discussing whether or not it was reasonable to expect the teacher to be qualified to recognize a bomb.

It is abundantly clear that she believed she was.

That's the only point which matters, not whether she should have been expected or trained to be.

If she did not have the authority to make that assessment then she potentially endangered the class, but that has nothing to with claims that she couldn't be expected to have such knowledge.

She believed she did, and acted accordingly. That's the starting point, not what her previous training might or should have been.
 
Originally Posted by Abooga View Post
What??? What did I speculate about apart from "suspecting that the father may have pushed his son to bring the contraption to school to goad them to overreact" That Obama may be kicking himself for inviting Ahmed to the White House too quickly before knowing that it was all a stunt?
Here:

Originally Posted by Abooga View Post
No, but if it was a publicity stunt annd Ahmed behaved provocatively in order to be detained, asked to put handcuffs on for the photo, lied about his motives etc. it wouldn´t be a case of islamophobia.:

I´ve read accounts of those things, altough I can´t find them now. They could all be fabications, but I´ve definitely read somewhere that his sister actually asked the policemen to cuff him again for the picture (it doesn´t sound very plausible now that I think of it), I´ve also read that he wasn´t previously known as a genius of electronics (this is believable, looking at the clock) and that he was disruptive in classes in some other occasions. Also that his sister was also involved in some bomb threat hoax or something, and that his dad has done several publicity seeking acts around the issue of islamophobia.

I´ll try to find sources but I had a couple of beers and my google-fu is failing.
 
She is still assessing the bomb, which means she at least feels qualified to do so.

If she didn't then she should have evacuated.

There is no "intermediate" She had enough confidence in her assessment of the device to determine it wasn't a bomb.

End of story. Or at least that part.

We were discussing whether or not it was reasonable to expect the teacher to be qualified to recognize a bomb.

It is abundantly clear that she believed she was.

That's the only point which matters, not whether she should have been expected or trained to be.

If she did not have the authority to make that assessment then she potentially endangered the class, but that has nothing to with claims that she couldn't be expected to have such knowledge.

She believed she did, and acted accordingly. That's the starting point, not what her previous training might or should have been.

She doesn't need expertise assessing bombs. Expertise assessing her students is sufficient. If she knew Ahmed and thought it was highly unlikely he was some sort of homicidal maniac, then her decision was reasonable. Even if the thing really looked like a bomb, her decision would have been reasonable. The chances that a perfectly nice kid would bring an actual bomb to school are at least a billion to one. Even if he brings in something that really looks like a bomb, the probability it is a bomb might be increased by only a factor of a 1,000 or 10,000. That still leaves the probability at sufficiently low levels to preclude taking drastic action.
 
That means every clock looks like a bomb.



...what does that have to do with bombs?

clock-hoax.jpeg
 
She doesn't need expertise assessing bombs. Expertise assessing her students is sufficient. If she knew Ahmed and thought it was highly unlikely he was some sort of homicidal maniac, then her decision was reasonable. Even if the thing really looked like a bomb, her decision would have been reasonable. The chances that a perfectly nice kid would bring an actual bomb to school are at least a billion to one. Even if he brings in something that really looks like a bomb, the probability it is a bomb might be increased by only a factor of a 1,000 or 10,000. That still leaves the probability at sufficiently low levels to preclude taking drastic action.


You're saying that what the not-a-bomb-clock-in-a-pencil-case actually looked like is irrelevant?

Okay ... :confused:. I can go with that.

Where does it lead us?
 
You're saying that what the not-a-bomb-clock-in-a-pencil-case actually looked like is irrelevant?

Okay ... :confused:. I can go with that.

Where does it lead us?

No, you missed my point, which is that the teacher is a complete know-nothing when it comes to improvised explosive devices, but an expert when it comes to distinguishing things that belong in school and things that don't. She is also an expert at understanding the personalities of her students and each one's propensity for either mischief or violence.

So although she had no expertise in determining whether something was a bomb, or even meant to look like a bomb, she probably had a good idea of what was out of the ordinary for the classroom. She also probably had a good idea as to what Ahmed was capable of - to wit, mischief, but not violence.
 
No, you missed my point, which is that the teacher is a complete know-nothing when it comes to improvised explosive devices, but an expert when it comes to distinguishing things that belong in school and things that don't. She is also an expert at understanding the personalities of her students and each one's propensity for either mischief or violence.

So although she had no expertise in determining whether something was a bomb, or even meant to look like a bomb, she probably had a good idea of what was out of the ordinary for the classroom. She also probably had a good idea as to what Ahmed was capable of - to wit, mischief, but not violence.


No. I didn't miss your point, but you sure are dancing around mine.

Either the teacher was competent to determine if a threat existed or she wasn't.

If she was, and determined that no threat existed then every subsequent action in this farce was an overreaction without any foundation.

If she wasn't, then she was seriously delinquent in her responsibilities to her students and clearly put them at risk.

There isn't much middle ground here, no matter how much apologists for the school system and the cops try to pretend there is.
 
That it is not representative of the commonly accepted meaning of the word, and thus is being used only as misdirection?

That's the problem.

It is dishonest on the face of it.

At this point, I'd rather just accept that this is the definition she's going with. We understand what she means by it, so we can move on. Right?
 
No. I didn't miss your point, but you sure are dancing around mine.

Either the teacher was competent to determine if a threat existed or she wasn't.

If she was, and determined that no threat existed then every subsequent action in this farce was an overreaction without any foundation.

If she wasn't, then she was seriously delinquent in her responsibilities to her students and clearly put them at risk.

There isn't much middle ground here, no matter how much apologists for the school system and the cops try to pretend there is.

The teacher was competent enough to determine if something was in her classroom that didn't belong. She did the right thing bringing it to the principal's attention. The principal, recognizing that he didn't know what the purpose of the device was, but trusting that it wasn't about to blow up in his face because the teacher who was in the best position to judge the student's temperament didn't think it was a physical danger, contacted the school resource officers. He also did the right thing. The school resource officers, probably having very little knowledge of Ahmed personally (unlike the teacher) and probably having very little knowledge of the teacher (unlike the principal) viewed the intentions of the student with even greater skepticism and caution. Still, being trained, they may have realized that there was no explosive material, and so, aside from its potential as an electrical hazard when plugged into A/C power, it posed no physical threat. That was not the end of it though because they had a duty to determine whether the device was meant to cause alarm or if it was meant to be used for some other nefarious purpose. It was perfectly reasonable for them to interrogate Ahmed. At that point, we run out of information. We only really have a vague idea that Ahmed told them it was a clock and didn't think any other explanation was necessary, and the officers thought additional explanation was necessary. The official line is that Ahmed was passive-aggressive, although Ahmed's supporters have ridiculed such a notion, as if the idea of being passive-aggressive was alien to them or that it shouldn't matter that somebody being interrogated by the police was passive-aggressive. My take on it is that it's certainly possible to be passive-aggressive during questioning, and it's even possible for a 14 year old boy to be so. Furthermore, I think being passive-aggressive is likely to exacerbate suspicions rather than ameliorate them.
 
At this point, I'd rather just accept that this is the definition she's going with. We understand what she means by it, so we can move on. Right?


Let's go at this from a different tack.

Using the interpretation of the word which TT is advocating, do you believe that the label of "racialist" is an appropriate one for people who suspect that someone's actions might be influenced by racism, bigotry or prejudice?

Do you think that such people are actually "racists", as TT is asserting?

Keeping in mind that in common usage "racist" and "racialist" are generally understood to be largely synonymous ...

Do you think that some third party at some later date, upon being told that 'so-and-so' was shown in another thread to be a "racialist"' (and nothing else), would take that statement within the context of TT's interpretation, or would they assume that the standard, common, generally accepted meaning was what should be applied?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom