Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I don't fully agree with your analysis, but I'll note two things. Technophobia is widespread, and technophobia is not Islamophobia.

I don't think I'm a technophobe, although I'd agree with your point that it's widespread.

It's curious to me though to see how some people are very confident in their ability to identify something.

I know that if I was in the same situation I would not be willing to trust my own judgment of "what it was" because I'm not secure in my understanding of technology.

It's impressive to me to see others with that confidence. I'd never feel confident enough not to get a second opinion.


:o
 
Huh? What does being a 9/11 truther have to do with Islam or Islamophobia?

Or clock making?


What it shows is that people are looking for some explanation other than, "I like to fiddle with electronic gizmos." and are dragging in family associations and unrelated events in order to explain why someone would ever create a contraption like that, because, you know, creating devices like that is weird and unusual and scary.
 
Or clock making?


What it shows is that people are looking for some explanation other than, "I like to fiddle with electronic gizmos." and are dragging in family associations and unrelated events in order to explain why someone would ever create a contraption like that, because, you know, creating devices like that is weird and unusual and scary.

While I do agree that the majority of people doing this are coming from that perspective, I also think that the sudden "turn" of a events and sort of backlash of suspicion has more to do with his dad being some kind of "publicity machine" rather than his beliefs.

I mean it's very likely that if Ahmed was Muslim and his sister was Muslim that his dad would be Muslim as well.


This kinda harkens back to the "School Bus Aide" who wound up getting a huge outpouring of support and money. Then people started doing things deliberately to "go viral" and "get attention" and we find later that the stories are made up or not how they presented it.


It's kind of a new level of suspicion in general IMO

Like the Lesbian waitress who lied about being discriminated against
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...claiming-couple-didnt-tip-shes-gay-fired.html

People started sending her money and it turned out to be a hoax.


Or the woman who said KFC discriminated against her disabled child

http://www.11alive.com/story/news/nation/2014/06/23/girl-tossed-from-kfc-hoax/11291535/


I think the backlash came in two waves

One suspicion that the whole thing was done deliberately

Two annoyance of all the accolades and gifts heaped on Ahmed when it turns out he just took a clock apart and threw it in a pencil box. That backlash seems to come from people in the engineering fields who are a tad jealous IMO.
 
Responding to WHAT? I've consistently asked you the same question nearly every single time for two days now.

You say it's LIKELY that they responded to him in a racist way


WHY IS IT LIKELY? Just answer that one little question? Do you have comments he made? Do you have a track record of the teacher or principal (you keep mentioning the mayor)

Do you have something his sister may have pointed out about being treated that way by the same people?

Do you have an investigative reporter coming out with "behind the scenes information?"


What makes it LIKELY to you other than the fact that he is MUSLIM?


(I'm not sure what question you've actually asked me here, but can we at least start with you just answering a SIMPLE question. I'm totally willing to change my stance on this with EVIDENCE.)


Still not responding, I see.

Good on you. That's the way to stick to your guns.
 
I'm annoyed by the pile of Microsoft plastic for another reason. The boxed clock is a bench rugged piece of research hardware. A simple multimeter and a notepad can teach many things with this. They gave him shiny plastic consumption appliances. What he needs is actually a box that looks a lot like his boxed clock but adds breadboard and an assortment of mounted components in an assortment of values.
 
Still not responding, I see.

Good on you. That's the way to stick to your guns.

I honestly don't know what question you think I haven't answered.


Please post it again and I will. Then if I do, please answer the question I have posted to you.

Thanks
 
I honestly don't know what question you think I haven't answered.


Please post it again and I will. Then if I do, please answer the question I have posted to you.

Thanks


There is no question.

You said you weren't going to respond anymore. More than once.

I've just been enjoying watching you not respond.

Keep up the good work. We're all rooting for you.
 
Seriously? This is intelligent discourse to you? Okie dokie then. Keep in mind that most of the time when I post on here, it's for the benefit of the readers. Not necessarily the people posting. LOL
 
What is your response to the questions I asked you?

Since I do not agree that the two words are equivalent in the context of truethat's use, your question is meaningless. You are asserting that by "racialist" she means "racist" by pretending that she's using a different definition than the one she provided. I don't. Ergo I cannot answer your question because I do not agree with its premise.

ETA: Although now she said it was racist as well. So no, I don't agree with her on that. There.
 
Last edited:
Addressing the fake bomb question in principal and not weighing in on whether that was the intention or not but just why it may have been thought to be one.

We are talking about a 14 year old here who one would hope would have even less idea of what a real bomb looks like than his teachers might, TV/Movie bombs are often in suitcases and often have big red LED timers the lack of authenticity may be down to lack of knowledge or ability rather than intent (it doesn't look muck like a clock either with the display inside the case).

Another thing that has been repeated several times is that recasing the clock was behaviour that should be encouraged, I don't completely agree with this. Yes, curiosity and experimentation should be encouraged, but playing with mains voltage electrical equipment and bypassing the most basic safety feature (the insulating case) without making any attempt to make it safe? The first teacher should have confiscated it and had a talk with him on the safety basis alone. The clock was a fire and electrical shock risk.
 
God I hate when men get PMS. LOL Quad, the day tsig or Belz are even remotely leaning in a defense of me is the day that you know you have gone to the dark side of the moon in your arguments. LOL






Since I do not agree that the two words are equivalent in the context of truethat's use, your question is meaningless. You are asserting that by "racialist" she means "racist" by pretending that she's using a different definition than the one she provided. I don't. Ergo I cannot answer your question because I do not agree with its premise.

ETA: Although now she said it was racist as well. So no, I don't agree with her on that. There.


Well based on theprestige's interpretation and distinction I can say I'm shifting in that direction. Perhaps "racist" is too blanket of a statement. It comes across as "patronizing racism" if that makes sense. But hitherto forward I guess I'll use "racialist" instead.
 
Last edited:
And this is probably a bad idea simply because it could be seen as a bribe. And that is a more reasonable suspicion than assuming that a bit of electronics is a bomb.

I wanted to address this earlier. I used to think the same thing. Until I started talking with teachers. Unless the school has a rule about it, they'd rather get CASH (meaning gift cards) than ornaments etc etc etc.

So I don't know THAT POLICY in schools. But I agree with you that it does seem like it could be a "bribe" but most teachers I've spoken to say as long as it is a donation to the classroom it's not an issue.

Consider how many of them dig into their personal pockets for holiday supplies.

:)
 
Another thing that has been repeated several times is that recasing the clock was behaviour that should be encouraged, I don't completely agree with this. Yes, curiosity and experimentation should be encouraged, but playing with mains voltage electrical equipment and bypassing the most basic safety feature (the insulating case) without making any attempt to make it safe? The first teacher should have confiscated it and had a talk with him on the safety basis alone. The clock was a fire and electrical shock risk.

As regards electrical safety, true. However, that's not really what is at issue here. Again, making unsafe electrical devices does not usually result in handcuffs.


I think a lot of what happened here is that there is a strong element of "He doesn't deserve all this praise......"

Despite the attention, and the monetary value in some cases, it isn't real praise in any real sense. It's sticking up for the little guy. The kid shouldn't have been arrested. When people saw that picture of him in handcuffs, some pretty prominent guys jumped in on his side. One of those in particular is the kind of person that, when he praises someone, others feel they have to attack whoever has been praised. It's important that if Obama says something is good, others have to say it's bad, or that Obama shouldn't be saying it, or that Obama has nothing to do with it. Suddenly, it's all about Obama.

Ahmed got really lucky on this one.

So yes, the next time someone walks in with that sort of device, I do want someone to inspect it for safety and say, "That's great, but......" But I won't condemn the little scoundrel for not complying with UL codes.


As to your point about fake bombs, I keep going back to the idea that he said it was a clock.

Aha, some have said. That doesn't mean anything....and they have explained why, and have given examples that don't fit.

There's no indication that anyone felt threatened. There's no indication that he tried to make anyone feel threatened. At most, he might have possibly been wanting to demonstrate that there was pervasive Islamophobia, and to do that he would craft a device that was obviously safe, and would tell everyone it was obviously safe, and watch them freak out anyway. At most, he was trolling. If that's what he was doing, it worked. Well played, son. Maybe you won't be an engineer someday. Have you considered being an investigative reporter?


ETA: And, I said "it worked" which would suggest that it proved Islamophobia. That isn't necessarily true. I am not 100% certain that Islamophobia was at work here. It fits the data, but it could be coincidence. Regardless of whether or not it is true, a lot of people think it's true. If he was trying to make points in the field of public opinion, he succeeded beyond his wildest dreams.
 
Last edited:
Addressing the fake bomb question in principal and not weighing in on whether that was the intention or not but just why it may have been thought to be one.

We are talking about a 14 year old here who one would hope would have even less idea of what a real bomb looks like than his teachers might, TV/Movie bombs are often in suitcases and often have big red LED timers the lack of authenticity may be down to lack of knowledge or ability rather than intent (it doesn't look muck like a clock either with the display inside the case).

Another thing that has been repeated several times is that recasing the clock was behaviour that should be encouraged, I don't completely agree with this. Yes, curiosity and experimentation should be encouraged, but playing with mains voltage electrical equipment and bypassing the most basic safety feature (the insulating case) without making any attempt to make it safe? The first teacher should have confiscated it and had a talk with him on the safety basis alone. The clock was a fire and electrical shock risk.
Getting popped with 110vac generally has high enough educational value to encourage safety improvements and usually won't kill you. Buy him a bag of pigtail ended fuse holders and a box of fuses. Three dollar safety solution.
 
As regards electrical safety, true. However, that's not really what is at issue here. Again, making unsafe electrical devices does not usually result in handcuffs.


I think a lot of what happened here is that there is a strong element of "He doesn't deserve all this praise......"

Despite the attention, and the monetary value in some cases, it isn't real praise in any real sense. It's sticking up for the little guy. The kid shouldn't have been arrested. When people saw that picture of him in handcuffs, some pretty prominent guys jumped in on his side. One of those in particular is the kind of person that, when he praises someone, others feel they have to attack whoever has been praised. It's important that if Obama says something is good, others have to say it's bad, or that Obama shouldn't be saying it, or that Obama has nothing to do with it. Suddenly, it's all about Obama.

Ahmed got really lucky on this one.

So yes, the next time someone walks in with that sort of device, I do want someone to inspect it for safety and say, "That's great, but......" But I won't condemn the little scoundrel for not complying with UL codes.


As to your point about fake bombs, I keep going back to the idea that he said it was a clock.

Aha, some have said. That doesn't mean anything....and they have explained why, and have given examples that don't fit.

There's no indication that anyone felt threatened. There's no indication that he tried to make anyone feel threatened. At most, he might have possibly been wanting to demonstrate that there was pervasive Islamophobia, and to do that he would craft a device that was obviously safe, and would tell everyone it was obviously safe, and watch them freak out anyway. At most, he was trolling. If that's what he was doing, it worked. Well played, son. Maybe you won't be an engineer someday. Have you considered being an investigative reporter?



This is what I mean about you just making crap up. How in the hell could you write that????? Have you READ anything about the topic.

This is a quote DIRECTLY FROM AHMED

“She thought it was a threat to her,” Ahmed told reporters Wednesday. “So it was really sad that she took a wrong impression of it.”

This is the exact same article I've posted to you over and over again. Did you even read it?

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/17/u...olice-investigation-for-building-a-clock.html

Notice it's NY Times and sides with Ahmed. Not some crazy nutter site.

What is the point of having a discussion when you haven't even bothered to read anything, especially something that has been provided to you at least THREE TIMES in a link.

Unbelievable.
 
Last edited:
They tried to say that it was a "Hoax bomb." By that logic, they could call anything they don't recognize a hoax bomb. There is no way out of that for the accused.

Exactly.

I learned in grade school that it wasn't safe for me as a smart kid and that the teachers are the worst of the bullies. They were the leadership of the bullying, by pointing out who it was OK to bully. State sanctioned bullying.

He wants to go to MIT. If he was in one of the top five Asian regions, the high score regions on international tests, he would be the stud horse on school campus. His invention would be in the news, not as a hoax bomb, but as something worthy of acclaim for a 14 year old. A middle school student.

We have pseudo-college programs that don't even rise to this level of competence in the USA. Associate degrees in electronics.

Just another reason to homeschool.
 
This is related to something I find amusing.

Anti-Ahmed forces insist that Islamophobia played no role in this incident. Then, in order to justify the police actions, the blogosphere, and in some cases this thread, is full of references to his father being a Sudanese activist or a 9/11 truther.

Do they not see that they are reinforcing the perception that maybe Islamophobia played a role after all?

I can only speak for myself, but I´m not insisting that there was no discrimination in the way Ahmed was treated. In fact, when I first read about it in the Guardian, I thought that was the case. But later on, after reading this: http://blogs.artvoice.com/techvoice...gineering-ahmed-mohameds-clock-and-ourselves/ I started to think there was more to this story.

I just thought the writer of that website had a point:

. During this video interview he again claims it was his “invention” and that he “made” the device [...]

If we accept the story about “inventing” an alarm clock is made up, as I think I’ve made a pretty good case for, it’s fair to wonder what other parts of the story might be made up, not reported factually by the media, or at least, exaggerated[...]

[in the YouTube video interview] He explains that he closed up the box with a piece of cord because he didn’t want it to look suspicious. I’m curious, why would “looking suspicious” have even crossed his mind before this whole event unfolded, if he was truly showing off a hobby project, something so innocuous as an alarm clock. Why did he choose a pencil box, one that looks like a miniature briefcase no less, as an enclosure for a clock? It’s awful hard to see the clock with the case closed.


Ok, I´ve read in this thread that the screen showed through the back of the case so he could be wrong here.

Because, is it possible, that maybe, just maybe, this was actually a hoax bomb? A silly prank that was taken the wrong way? That the media then ran with, and everyone else got carried away? Maybe there wasn’t even any racial or religious bias on the parts of the teachers and police.

I don’t know any of these things. But I’m intellectually mature enough to admit I don’t know, and to also be OK with that. I don’t feel a need to take the first exit to conclusionville. But I do like to find facts where I can, and prefer to let them lead me to conclusions, rather than a knee jerk judgement based on a headline or sound bite.


I think this is my position too. Perhaps Ahmed just took the clock to school for inocent reasons, but what if it was all a hoax?

And the part about his father´s past is just some circumstantial evidence that would add credibility to the publicity stunt / hoax theory. As Truethat has explained, there have been this type of cases in the past.

So let´s not jump to any conclusion or resort to namecalling too early. I´m not being racist, Islamophobe (although I do think quite badly of Islam, but that´s got nothing to do with this) or anything else. Just suspicious. Let´s just try to learn more about the case and see if we can arrive at a more informed conclusion. Calling people who are just suspicious of a hoax racists is quite offensive.
 
Last edited:
As regards electrical safety, true. However, that's not really what is at issue here. Again, making unsafe electrical devices does not usually result in handcuffs.


I think a lot of what happened here is that there is a strong element of "He doesn't deserve all this praise......"

Despite the attention, and the monetary value in some cases, it isn't real praise in any real sense. It's sticking up for the little guy. The kid shouldn't have been arrested. When people saw that picture of him in handcuffs, some pretty prominent guys jumped in on his side. One of those in particular is the kind of person that, when he praises someone, others feel they have to attack whoever has been praised. It's important that if Obama says something is good, others have to say it's bad, or that Obama shouldn't be saying it, or that Obama has nothing to do with it. Suddenly, it's all about Obama.

Such complete nonsense that is. It makes me suspect that you're only attacking the school and the police in order to defend Obama's decision to wade in. It would explain why you're sticking to your guns and studiously avoiding the most cogent rebuttals.

As for whether or not Ahmed got real praise, he is being treated as a celebrity all over the place. What exactly do you call real praise? There are millions of people who think he's hot stuff. Whether or not you think that's "real," he's getting tangible rewards, and not just in terms of swag. He's meeting important people and having fantastic experiences that almost nobody else his age, including the most accomplished kids in the country, are able to have.

He was invited to the Google Science Fair and treated as a VIP among the 20 finalists - kids, by the way, who actually did real science projects. He visited New York City and was feted by the Mayor and other local politicians. He went to Maker Faire in NYC and visited Google's NY offices. He visited the UN and rubbed elbows with foreign dignitaries. He is now on tour in Qatar and Saudi Arabia. Later, he will visit Facebook, MIT and the White House, and he has standing offers to attend a prestigious science camp and also to intern at Twitter.

This isn't compensation for being mistreated. If it were, it would be ridiculously excessive. No, this is a statement by people with a political message, a stupid one in my opinion.
 
Getting popped with 110vac generally has high enough educational value to encourage safety improvements and usually won't kill you. Buy him a bag of pigtail ended fuse holders and a box of fuses. Three dollar safety solution.

:eek: Yup, usually ..., especially if there is a defibrillator on site. The old school electricians check for hot wires by touching with the back of their hand. That way, when their muscles seize up, their hand pulls away from the wire rather than grasps it more tightly. Kids just don''t learn such cool things anymore.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom