Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Here's what I want to know.

If merely suggesting that prejudice might have contributed to the atrocious treatment Ahmed received is racist (or "racialist" :rolleyes:), as we have been told, then what is claiming that the kid was motivated by the father's political and religious affiliations?

Seems like a double standard to me.

You do realize that we all have different opinions right? Why are you lumping in someone else's opinion with mine.

And claiming that he kid was motivated by the fathers political and religious affiliations, without any evidence to back it up, is also racist to me.:thumbsup:

You're both doing the same thing just at different ends of the spectrum in my opinion.
 
I've read through the mad crawl.

I want people to do this. When you go to your parent teacher conferences. Please give them CASH. Not coffee mugs and whimsical gifts that teachers have up the whazoo.

If NOTHING has come of this thread, it's this, this sad reality which I spoke about pages ago.

That a teacher's job is to facilitate LEARNING. They have spend HOURS prepping, probably money that you don't even know.

And here we are at the end of this entire discussion with people suggesting that the solution to the problem is to get teachers to be trained for "spotting fake bombs"

Because god forbid we restrict a child's right to bring a gizmo to school.

If that doesn't tell you EVERYTHING that is wrong with the educational system in the US

Translation: people and parents who have ZERO respect for the job they are actually there to do.

Then nothing does.

I sincerely mean this. I hope that of the people reading this thread, NOT the posters, but the readers.

This Christmas hand your teacher a $50 gift card.

Because THIS is the reality of the ******** they have to deal with every day.

And this is probably a bad idea simply because it could be seen as a bribe. And that is a more reasonable suspicion than assuming that a bit of electronics is a bomb.
 
I had been about to post on it, and note that it doesn't look at all like a bomb. There are lots of things about it that make it not very bomb-like at all. It would never be mistaken at an airport for a bomb.* People who are trained in what bombs look like would not suspect it was one. People who are frightened by devices they don't understand might well be suspicious.

I don't really understand your logic here. Even people trained in what bombs look like (whatever that means) would not know what the hell that thing was. If it looked like a laptop computer, they would think it was a laptop computer. If it looked like a satellite phone, they would think it was a satellite phone. They might be suspicious that it was a bomb disguised as a laptop computer or a satellite phone, but if they had no reason to think an attack was imminent, and laptop computers or satellite phones were completely ordinary in the particular environment in which they were found, then experts and laymen alike would believe that they were looking at something harmless. The problem is that a completely different looking contraption, whose function is not obvious and whose presence in the particular environment is unusual, is going to merit suspicion. No expert is going to be able to tell that something is not a bomb just by looking at a picture of it or giving it a brief look. If a bomb can be made to look harmless (as many real bombs are made to look), then they can also be made to look like a weird piece of electronics that hides the functional parts of the bomb (e.g. timer, detonator, and explosives). I am convinced that anybody who claims that some wacky mess of wires and circuit boards stuffed in a box does not look like a bomb is suffering from hindsight bias. A bomb doesn't look like anything in particular, so if you can't say that a wacky mess of wires and circuit boards looks like something whose function we understand (e.g. computer, phone, router, video game console, coffee maker, or toaster), then it is impossible to say that it doesn't look like a bomb.
 
Going by what you seem to be saying here the teacher was seriously if not criminally delinquent for irresponsibly failing to evacuate her class room and raise an alarm for the entire school.

You can't have it both ways.

Either she wasn't qualified to assess the device and failed in her responsibilities, or she was and the whole incident was blown out of proportion by the school's reaction.

You choose.


Yes I can have it both ways because two different people were involved in the school and then two different agencies were involved in the situation.

What's up with the inability to make distinctions between different people's actions lately?

Breakdown below

A. The teacher didn't know what it was and took it to the office.
(That's one completely unique incident) She, as you pointed out, very likely didn't think it was a "bomb" because I doubt very much she would have handled it at all if she thought that.

We're all in agreement that she didn't think it was a bomb. She didn't know WHAT it was and she took it to the office.

B. The principal questions Ahmed and by his own admission and the statements from the school (which have not been disputed by Ahmed) he shut down and was not forthcoming with information. Except to say "It's not a bomb, it's a clock!!!"


Perhaps the principal thought it was part of a larger prank with more people involved. The principal ALSO has a track record of being quick to call police on students and running the school like a "Military State" as documented in the parent review from MAY 2015 on greatschools.

Still nothing to do with him being Muslim.


C. The cops are called and they, knowing nothing of the student, overreacted, slapped the kid in handcuffs and very likely responded out of a racist attitude towards Muslims. (We know this is likely because he was arrested (not prosecuted) for bringing in a Hoax bomb.)

Therefore my assessment of the situation is that the teacher followed protocol, the principal followed protocol (even in his tyrannical manner) and neither of these two did anything that seems to have been racist.

The cops are a different matter altogether.

You see, not only can we have it TWO WAYS we can have it THREE WAYS. Interesting how involving different people can make that happen.
 
Last edited:
What is your response to the questions I asked you?

I specifically picked the SECOND definition (which was not something I came up with btw), because theprestige pointed out the distinction in what I was saying.


Is Belz on board with you acting as his proxy?

I was asking him a specific question relating to his comments. I already know where you are coming from.

Frankly I do consider it racist and agree with YOUR choice, but it seemed not to match the definition theprestige was going for.


Well ... I thought I did, but after your vigorous defense of the definition you (cherry) picked out I would have thought you'd stick with it. Apparently constancy isn't one of those virtues you cherish.

I consider someone who can't fathom "another possible reason than race" without any evidence to back it up to be racist.


And who would that be?

You appear to be claiming this was my position, since you are apparently attributing the above quote to me.

Can you point out where I said that?

Can you point out where I said something approximating that?

I don't think so. If you can't then ... once again ... you are just making crap up.

Not a good practice if you want your claims to be convincing.

And when I say that I distinguish between the person being a member of the same race.

So for example if a black person feels they are always being targeted because they are black, I'm going to leave them to their experiences.

But if a white, asian, mexican, arab, etc can only see the "racial" element of a black person's experiences in life, in my mind it is because they are racist.


Where does the "only" come from. Are you trying to attribute this position to someone involved in this thread?

Are you just making more crap up?



They may consider themselves a "good guy" but to me they are racist.

<snip. remainder of irrelevant bull hockey>


No one has a right to recognize prejudice except for the targets of that prejudice?

Anyone who does is racist?

And I note that you don't even hold to that tenuous exception when it isn't convenient.

Only to be expected.
 
<snip>

But when do we get to the "probable cause" part? Suspicion is not probable cause.

Reasonable suspicion that the suspect has committed a crime is, by definition, probable cause:

In Brinegar v. United States, the U.S. Supreme Court defines probable cause as “where the facts and circumstances within the officers' knowledge, and of which they have reasonably trustworthy information, are sufficient in themselves to warrant a belief by a man of reasonable caution that a crime is being committed.”[3]

Whether or not the police's suspicion was reasonable is for a judge and jury to decide. Ahmed's family appears to be lawyering up to sue, so I guess we'll eventually know (unless the lawsuit is settled confidentially).
 
What if you yell, "Wake up!" That's kind of like what alarm clocks do.

The point that a lot of anti-Ahmed people are missing is that he took it to school, showed it to a teacher, and said, "This is a clock."

If you tell people that you have a clock, then you don't have a hoax bomb.

I have called "false" on this before, and I will do it again. If you walk into class with a bunch of fake sticks of dynamite strapped to your chest along with a digital clock, and you proclaim "this is not a suicide bomb vest; it's just a wearable clock" you won't get a free pass with respect to the hoax bomb laws. After all, somebody could walk in with a real bomb, and say "this is just a clock" too. Perhaps that will be part of their strategy to place the real bomb in a place that causes maximum damage. It is not just what you say; it is the impression you intend to leave, and what you bring in and show off speaks for itself and leaves its own impression to a large degree.
 
I've snipped large parts of the posts I'm quoting for easier reading and to shorten the response.





I wasn't going to investigate this line of reasoning, but you've repeated it. The implication is that Ahmed isn't a beautiful and respectful young man, and that people are only or largely only racist against people who aren't 'beautiful, mannered, respectful, or well spoken'.

The second invocation of this line of reasoning is even more troubling, and perhaps I should have gone into the huge flaw in your reasoning I first quoted. Racism isn't rational. It doesn't follow at all that people wouldn't act racist towards 'beautiful, well spoken, mannered' people. We know there are people who are. That there isn't good reason to be racist is besides the point. They are concerned that they may have been treated badly based on the way they look because a non-trivial number of people do treat people badly based on the way they look.

Furthermore, your attitude towards a concerned question (which is how you yourself presented it) over something that is not only possible, but documented in other cases, is very troubling. I certainly hope you don't reply to them as bombastically as you have been conversing here.

I snipped a lot of this out and popped yours in spoilers just to keep the thread from becoming huge in my replies.


I can see your point about saying the "beautiful" people thing but I think you are generalizing my use of it. I'm pointing out that if THEY THEMSELVES thought they were being treated with racism, I can trust their judgment even if I don't agree with it.

If Ahmed is saying his teacher was Racist, then I have to take him at his word and how he felt in the matter.

The same way if my black friend didn't feel like she was being profiled as a shoplifter I have to take her at her word.

From what I have read about this story it seems the impetus for outrage was that Ahmed was placed in handcuffs. He said that the teacher was intimidated by the device, not that she turned on him with racism.

sunmaster's angle of being intimidated by creative engineering efforts is more on point for what I've seen Ahmed talking about with his teacher.


That's why I keep asking for evidence.
 
Is Belz on board with you acting as his proxy?


Only to be expected.

Snipped

Just to keep it short.

A. Um I doubt Belz would consider me his "anything" since we pretty much can't stand each other on here. LOL

B. I was OBVIOUSLY joking when I said the "cherry picking comment" since your post was the very first one up there. :rolleyes::rolleyes:


C. I keep asking you "What ACTIONS did the Teacher and the School do that back up your claim of doing this to Ahmed as a "dark skinned Muslim"

You haven't given any. You keep lumping what the POLICE did in with what the school did. But you haven't shown any EVIDENCE that points to the teacher or the principal as being racist.

That is what I have continually addressed. You clearly have a blind spot in what you are saying and I think I've pointed out so specifically that at this point I really am fatigued at repeating myself. (I'm sure others are sick of reading the same thing over and over and over again as well)

So again, I won't be responding to direct questions to me from you on this topic because I feel I've answered it to completion. If you don't understand what I'm saying I pretty much give up. I don't know how else to explain it to you.

Mea culpa
 
I have called "false" on this before, and I will do it again. If you walk into class with a bunch of fake sticks of dynamite strapped to your chest along with a digital clock, and you proclaim "this is not a suicide bomb vest; it's just a wearable clock" you won't get a free pass with respect to the hoax bomb laws. After all, somebody could walk in with a real bomb, and say "this is just a clock" too. Perhaps that will be part of their strategy to place the real bomb in a place that causes maximum damage. It is not just what you say; it is the impression you intend to leave, and what you bring in and show off speaks for itself and leaves its own impression to a large degree.


I honestly don't understand what is so hard for people to understand about this. Good post, although it does veer a little to close to it being "bomby" thinking.

Ahmed walked up to his FIRST TEACHER and said "This is a clock" That teacher said "hey cool, looks kind of suspicious though, I'd not show it to the other teachers."

That teacher didn't react and panic because Ahmed walked up to him and said "This is a clock."

He didn't do that with the English teacher. He timed it to go off in the classroom and the teacher didn't know what it was and probably took him to the office for "timing it to go off in the classroom" and not knowing why he would do that or what it was.

Two totally different situations.
 
Here's what I want to know.

If merely suggesting that prejudice might have contributed to the atrocious treatment Ahmed received is racist (or "racialist" :rolleyes:), as we have been told, then what is claiming that the kid was motivated by the father's political and religious affiliations?

Seems like a double standard to me.

This is related to something I find amusing.

Anti-Ahmed forces insist that Islamophobia played no role in this incident. Then, in order to justify the police actions, the blogosphere, and in some cases this thread, is full of references to his father being a Sudanese activist or a 9/11 truther.

Do they not see that they are reinforcing the perception that maybe Islamophobia played a role after all?
 
This is related to something I find amusing.

Anti-Ahmed forces insist that Islamophobia played no role in this incident. Then, in order to justify the police actions, the blogosphere, and in some cases this thread, is full of references to his father being a Sudanese activist or a 9/11 truther.

Do they not see that they are reinforcing the perception that maybe Islamophobia played a role after all?

Yep, those comments are really racist in my opinion as well. But it's not an "either or" situation.
 
This is related to something I find amusing.

Anti-Ahmed forces insist that Islamophobia played no role in this incident. Then, in order to justify the police actions, the blogosphere, and in some cases this thread, is full of references to his father being a Sudanese activist or a 9/11 truther.

Do they not see that they are reinforcing the perception that maybe Islamophobia played a role after all?

Huh? What does being a 9/11 truther have to do with Islam or Islamophobia? It just shows that he's wacky, and that perhaps his version of events (which he can impress upon his son) is to be treated with more skepticism than usual. Remember, we have really only heard one side of the story so far. Also, his history of activism shows that maybe he is eager to attract publicity, so it would also warrant a little skepticism about the father's version of events since it is more likely to be exaggerated.
 
<snip>

C. I keep asking you "What ACTIONS did the Teacher and the School do that back up your claim of doing this to Ahmed as a "dark skinned Muslim"

You haven't given any.<snip>


Probably because I never made that claim. This makes it impossible for me to back it up.

You keep saying I did, but you haven't yet managed to point out where.

I did say that I thought it likely that the unusual, abusive treatment he received could have been influenced by his ethnicity.

Are you trying to assert that these two things are the same?

They aren't.
 
If you thought it "likely" what reasons make it "likely" to you?

Because the only reason you seem to have given so far is that he was Muslim.

How is that ANY different than saying that it was "likely" that he brought it in as a hoax bomb and the only reason given so far is that he was "Muslim"

LAST TRY HERE SERIOUSLY if this doesn't help you GET IT, I give up.
 
Keep not responding. It is fun to watch.

You're not very good at it, though.

Responding to WHAT? I've consistently asked you the same question nearly every single time for two days now.

You say it's LIKELY that they responded to him in a racist way


WHY IS IT LIKELY? Just answer that one little question? Do you have comments he made? Do you have a track record of the teacher or principal (you keep mentioning the mayor)

Do you have something his sister may have pointed out about being treated that way by the same people?

Do you have an investigative reporter coming out with "behind the scenes information?"


What makes it LIKELY to you other than the fact that he is MUSLIM?


(I'm not sure what question you've actually asked me here, but can we at least start with you just answering a SIMPLE question. I'm totally willing to change my stance on this with EVIDENCE.)
 
I don't really understand your logic here. Even people trained in what bombs look like (whatever that means) would not know what the hell that thing was. If it looked like a laptop computer, they would think it was a laptop computer. If it looked like a satellite phone, they would think it was a satellite phone. They might be suspicious that it was a bomb disguised as a laptop computer or a satellite phone, but if they had no reason to think an attack was imminent, and laptop computers or satellite phones were completely ordinary in the particular environment in which they were found, then experts and laymen alike would believe that they were looking at something harmless. The problem is that a completely different looking contraption, whose function is not obvious and whose presence in the particular environment is unusual, is going to merit suspicion. No expert is going to be able to tell that something is not a bomb just by looking at a picture of it or giving it a brief look. If a bomb can be made to look harmless (as many real bombs are made to look), then they can also be made to look like a weird piece of electronics that hides the functional parts of the bomb (e.g. timer, detonator, and explosives). I am convinced that anybody who claims that some wacky mess of wires and circuit boards stuffed in a box does not look like a bomb is suffering from hindsight bias. A bomb doesn't look like anything in particular, so if you can't say that a wacky mess of wires and circuit boards looks like something whose function we understand (e.g. computer, phone, router, video game console, coffee maker, or toaster), then it is impossible to say that it doesn't look like a bomb.


With respect to the "suitcase bomb" example, the thing that makes me say it is not very bomb-like is that it has a large number of screw terminals on one of the circuit boards. Bombs don't need connectivity to multiple devices. Things with lots of screw terminals have to send signals to multiple things. Bombs have to send maybe an output to the detonator, and maybe get an input from a timer or remote control.

However, that's some rather specialized knowledge I've got there. An ordinary citizen wouldn't do that, so what should an ordinary citizen do when encountering something like this?

Let's go through this slowly.

First, bombs are frequently disguised as something else, so literally anything looks like a bomb. A shoe can look like a bomb, right? That's why TSA officials inspect everything, because bombs can be hidden anywhere. The question is whether a particular device looks somehow more "bomb-like" than some other device.

In particular, does a "wacky mess of wires and circuit boards" look more bomb-like than, say, a shoe?

This is where the technophobia comes in. I don't know what it is. It's a wacky mess of wires. It's something I don't understand. It's scary. It could be anything! Bombs have wires and timers! Maybe it's a bomb!

What your are saying is that anything could be a bomb, and it is especially likely to be a bomb if I don't know what it is, and even more likely to be a bomb if I don't know what it is and it has wires.

That's not incredibly, awfully, ridiculous. However, what it does do is set up a situation where the geeky intellectual, who creates things that others do not understand, is automatically viewed with suspicion. What is really important in cases like that is to calm your own suspicion by finding things out. Fortunately, in this case, it was easy. Ahmed told everyone what it was. It was a clock. Examining it, we can see that there is nothing in it that is explosive. There are circuit boards. It tells time. It has an alarm. It's a clock.

And yet, this obviously clock-like device was viewed with suspicion, because no one involved could imagine why anyone would do that.


It just reeks of technophobia.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom