Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I don't see how that is possible when you look at the actual photograph of Ahmed's clock. The bottom part of the case doesn't have a hole cut in it to reveal the clock at all??

http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/cpsprodpb/8123/production/_85595033_clock_irving_police_ap.jpg


Sorry but I think you are mistaken there.

The clock display you're looking at on top is the back of the clock. the hole is covered by the display. on the opposite side. The side with the lenticular image.
 
Last edited:
Um if you "click on the link" I provided it's the exact definition I posted here.

Are we back to reading comprehension issues again?


When you typed in "racialist" as a search term was that the first hit you got?

Mine was;

Racialism

Racialism is the belief that the human species is naturally divided into distinct biological categories called "races."

Note that I did not enter "racialism". Google decided that this was the most relevant result.

Was it the second result you got?

Mine was;

2. racial prejudice or discrimination. Both adjectives refer to theories or beliefs that hold race to be the determinant of human traits. The broader cross-reference at racialism to racism suggests that racialist is often used as a synonym for racist


Note the highlighted portions. None of that offers any suggestion that recognizing the existence of racism or ethnic prejudice or suspecting that such prejudices might be in play is itself intrinsically racist, which is the assertion you have been making.

Wanna go for three?

How far down and how much cherry picking did you need to engage in to find a variation which you could try and apply to your wacko claims?

Reading comprehension isn't a problem here.

Honesty seems to be, though.


(ETA: Your snide little LMGTFY link, unsurprisingly, offered the same results I had gotten and cited in my earlier post.

How come you overlooked all the other definitions? According to you you had to have seen them first.

Inquiring minds want to know why you cherrypicked.)
 
Last edited:
When you typed in "racialist" as a search term was that the first hit you got?

Mine was;

Racialism

Racialism is the belief that the human species is naturally divided into distinct biological categories called "races."

Note that I did not enter "racialism". Google decided that this was the most relevant result.

Was it the second result you got?

Mine was;

2. racial prejudice or discrimination. Both adjectives refer to theories or beliefs that hold race to be the determinant of human traits. The broader cross-reference at racialism to racism suggests that racialist is often used as a synonym for racist


Note the highlighted portions. None of that offers any suggestion that recognizing the existence of racism or ethnic prejudice or suspecting that such prejudices might be in play is itself intrinsically racist, which is the assertion you have been making.

Wanna go for three?

How far down and how much cherry picking did you need to engage in to find a variation which you could try and apply to your wacko claims?

Reading comprehension isn't a problem here.

Honesty seems to be, though.


Yes, but you don't need to go for an argument by dictionary to say that recognising racism isn't inherently racist.

Otherwise, by Truethat's logic, it would be racist to say that the Klan is racist, or that Apartheid was racist... or any openly racist body/person.

Which is ridiculous.
 
Dude again I'm showing people exactly :D


http://lmgtfy.com/?q=racialist


There's a large definition at top

Then a wiki page

Then the exact definition (first definition) that I picked. Everyone can read it. I think you may have twisted the tinfoil a little too tight this time.
 
Last edited:
The clock display you're looking at on top is the back of the clock. the hole is covered by the display. on the opposite side. The side with the lenticular image.

If you look carefully you can see the outline of the segments in the picture. They are partially obscured by the red plastic color filter left in place over the display.

So it is the front of the LED display not the back (there are no segment outlines visible on the back of a 7-seg display).
 
Yes, but you don't need to go for an argument by dictionary to say that recognising racism isn't inherently racist.

Otherwise, by Truethat's logic, it would be racist to say that the Klan is racist, or that Apartheid was racist... or any openly racist body/person.

Which is ridiculous.

Um, again.................WHAT ACTIONS did the teacher or the school do that you consider RACIST?

In case you haven't noticed, the KKK has a few (just a few) actions under their belt that could probably be considered racist.

:rolleyes:
 
The clock display you're looking at on top is the back of the clock. the hole is covered by the display. on the opposite side. The side with the lenticular image.

Oh I see the confusion and yes thanks for addressing it as well Paul Hutch. The clock panel is facing the INSIDE of the case, but I could see how you could get confused by that.

Thanks for clarifying. See if you can see what Paulhutch pointed out.
 
Last edited:
The picture I've seen of Ahmed's clock looks NOTHING like the picture of the IED. I would also add that the picture you posted appears to be after someone has partially disassembled the clock, hence the wires are showing and pieces are visible; I highly doubt Ahmed put it into the case like that.

I highly doubt that he didn't actually. On the original blog explaining that it was a Radio Shack clock, there is a blown up version of the picture, and it doesn't look like there are any extra screws or screwholes or mounting tabs of any kind. You can also see the twisted up piece of wire that he used to close the lock (which looks messy), as well as a packet of desiccant in the right hand corner. He admitted that he spent only 20 minutes building this thing. It was probably just as messy as the picture shows.

As to your point about a teacher being able to recognize a bomb; why not? Considering the number of bomb threats and hoax bombs found in schools these days by pranksters, it would make sense for educators to be trained on how to spot a real bomb versus a fake one. I'm not saying they need to be trained to disarm them, but it would sure cut down on the unnecessary calling of the bomb squads for things that turn out to be hoaxes. Educators should also be schooled on the fact that a movie bomb looks NOTHING like a real life bomb, so they don't make the mistake Abooga made up above.

I'm really surprised that a military analyst like yourself would make such statements. A bomb can look like anything the bombmaker wants it to. There's no reason that functional parts can't be made to look like almost anything else, and there's no reason that non-functional parts can't be added to disguise the functional parts and make it look like almost anything else. Trying to say what a bomb looks like is kind of like trying to say what a container looks like, or a bunch of electronics, or a thing. The important way to distinguish Ahmed's device from something non-threatening (where threatening includes not just a threat to safety but also a threat to school discipline) is to determine that it falls into one of the many common categories of devices that school officials expect to find in the possession of students. For example: cell phones, laptop computers, calculators, rulers, backpacks, books, clothes, necklaces, piercings, car keys, paper, writing utensils, pencil boxes, and school projects. If something doesn't fit easily into one of these kinds of categories (and my list was far from exhaustive), then suspicion is warranted. I doubt there are very many people, even an electronics wizard without proper diagnostic equipment, who could determine within a short period of time all of the things that the device couldn't do.
 
Actual bombs do not typically resemble those seen in the movies. A Google image search for "improvised explosive device" turns up mostly the following types of images:

<snip>

Point being, people who actually know what bombs look like in real life and not according to the movies would never mistake Ahmed's retooled clock for a bomb.


And more to the point, the kid's not-a-bomb-clock-in-a-pencil-box didn't even look like a bomb to the cops who dragged him off in handcuffs or the people who called them. If the reports coming from officialdom are to be believed nobody thought it was a bomb, so claiming it looked like one is specious at the very least.
 
If you look carefully you can see the outline of the segments in the picture. They are partially obscured by the red plastic color filter left in place over the display.

So it is the front of the LED display not the back (there are no segment outlines visible on the back of a 7-seg display).

You know what, you're correct. I was mistaken.
 
If you look carefully you can see the outline of the segments in the picture. They are partially obscured by the red plastic color filter left in place over the display.

So it is the front of the LED display not the back (there are no segment outlines visible on the back of a 7-seg display).

Right. If he had actually cut a rectangular hole in the top of a pencil box, then I would actually be mildly impressed. It's not an easy thing to do.
 
What??? What did I speculate about apart from "suspecting that the father may have pushed his son to bring the contraption to school to goad them to overreact" That Obama may be kicking himself for inviting Ahmed to the White House too quickly before knowing that it was all a stunt?

Here:

No, but if it was a publicity stunt annd Ahmed behaved provocatively in order to be detained, asked to put handcuffs on for the photo, lied about his motives etc. it wouldn´t be a case of islamophobia.
 
I'm really surprised that a military analyst like yourself would make such statements. A bomb can look like anything the bombmaker wants it to. There's no reason that functional parts can't be made to look like almost anything else, and there's no reason that non-functional parts can't be added to disguise the functional parts and make it look like almost anything else. Trying to say what a bomb looks like is kind of like trying to say what a container looks like, or a bunch of electronics, or a thing. The important way to distinguish Ahmed's device from something non-threatening (where threatening includes not just a threat to safety but also a threat to school discipline) is to determine that it falls into one of the many common categories of devices that school officials expect to find in the possession of students. For example: cell phones, laptop computers, calculators, rulers, backpacks, books, clothes, necklaces, piercings, car keys, paper, writing utensils, pencil boxes, and school projects. If something doesn't fit easily into one of these kinds of categories (and my list was far from exhaustive), then suspicion is warranted. I doubt there are very many people, even an electronics wizard without proper diagnostic equipment, who could determine within a short period of time all of the things that the device couldn't do.

Well by that logic, all the people we train to recognize bombs are just wasting their time then, aren't they? I'm sure the federal government will be so pleased to hear that all their EOD specialists are not able to recognize bombs when they see them and therefore they won't have to waste the money on training them to spot them.

Seriously? There are simple ways to spot whether something is a bomb. I am not an EOD specialist by a long chalk, but even I know it is difficult to disguise a bomb IN REAL LIFE as something completely innocuous. There's always something that gives it away; a stray wire, an anomalous light where there shouldn't be, bits of tape visible here and there, the scent of the explosive in some cases; trust me, there's always something. And at the level that most high school kids would be able to piece something together, it would be MUCH more obvious. Hence my thought that teachers should at least be given the ammunition to recognize whether something requires the intervention of the principal... or the police bomb squad. It's not rocket science. Jesus...
 
What pray tell is so difficult about "Don't bring things like this to school?" A

and B. It wouldn't matter if they had been trained. No matter what they wouldn't be able to risk it. They'd have to go to the principal.

So you are willing to risk the lives of school children on a "two to three day training" of teachers to recognize bombs?

I mean this is your solution? Not "don't bring things like this into schools' but "let's train the teacher to recognize bombs"

And HEY we won't pay them any more for it, we'll just add it to the pile of **** we already expect them to do.


There are seriously NO WORDS>:confused::boggled::eye-poppi


Going by what you seem to be saying here the teacher was seriously if not criminally delinquent for irresponsibly failing to evacuate her class room and raise an alarm for the entire school.

You can't have it both ways.

Either she wasn't qualified to assess the device and failed in her responsibilities, or she was and the whole incident was blown out of proportion by the school's reaction.

You choose.
 
One which she conveniently neglected to actually cite.

How is that relevant? We often ask posters to explain which definition of a word they are using. Now you're criticising her for not using all of them?

Once truethat specified the word and definition she wanted to use, it cleared up the issue. What's the problem?
 
Well by that logic, all the people we train to recognize bombs are just wasting their time then, aren't they? I'm sure the federal government will be so pleased to hear that all their EOD specialists are not able to recognize bombs when they see them and therefore they won't have to waste the money on training them to spot them.

Seriously? There are simple ways to spot whether something is a bomb. I am not an EOD specialist by a long chalk, but even I know it is difficult to disguise a bomb IN REAL LIFE as something completely innocuous. There's always something that gives it away; a stray wire, an anomalous light where there shouldn't be, bits of tape visible here and there, the scent of the explosive in some cases; trust me, there's always something. And at the level that most high school kids would be able to piece something together, it would be MUCH more obvious. Hence my thought that teachers should at least be given the ammunition to recognize whether something requires the intervention of the principal... or the police bomb squad. It's not rocket science. Jesus...

I suspect that bomb detection is all about detecting the explosives itself, which can be done through chemical means, scent, various kinds of spectroscopy, and even electrical properties, but perhaps not so easily without the proper equipment.

Of course it's reasonable to be worried about a device even if no explosives are present. First, an explosive material could be stored nearby in the expectation of adding it later. Second, and perhaps more importantly from the school's perspective, is that a device can be disruptive even if it isn't designed to blow up. It may be designed to make loud noises, or create smoke, or to disrupt other electronic signals in the classroom. Maybe even trip a fire alarm or a circuitbreaker. There's all kinds of mischief that a school has to be on its guard for.
 
Um if you "click on the link" I provided it's the exact definition I posted here.

Are we back to reading comprehension issues again?

My post

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10915580#post10915580

The link I provided

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/racialist

If you follow the LMGTFY link you will see it is the first dictionary definition under the wiki page.

Just google it, "racialist" and everyone can see.


Your "hmmm interesting" point seems to be that you think I found some obscure definition of it, when in fact I just posted the first one there. This leads me to believe that your "hmmmm interesting" point applies to YOUR citations which you apparently bent over backwards digging around to find a different definition.

Hypocrisy much?


I quoted the first definition which your LMGTFY link came up with. (Not surprisingly the exact same one I got when I googled the same term.) Which, interestingly enough, is from wikipedia, one of the references you chose to single out in your original post, and is a word for word quote of the very first sentence in their page on the subject.

Not sure how much "digging around" you think that entails.

Seems to me you can't even keep your own story straight.

Nice try though.

You're right. Anyone else can google "racialist" and see for themselves what comes up first.

I hope they do.
 
Wait, his sister was there? How did she get there if he wasn't allowed to call his parents? Hmmm. I am even more skeptical of Ahmed's story than I was before reading this.

When his parents came to pick him up, his sister was with them. The cuffs were still on. His father requested that they be left on so that the sister could take the picture.

My source for the above is Breitbart. Didn't save link. Take it for what it's worth.

Numerous source have given his sister as the source of the picture. Various sources have differed on exactly when the picture was taken, and how long the cuffs were on. Some have said that the cuffs had been taken off, and they actually put the cuffs on to stage the picture. If that were true, it would mean..................................nothing. It would mean that they accurately recreated a real event. Everyone agrees that the cops really did put the kid in cuffs to take him to the station.

As for your increasing suspicion.........suspicion of what?

As for probable cause, they knew that it was a clock. They knew he told everyone who asked that it was a clock. They knew that he had shown it to a teacher and said, "Look at my clock." (Not an exact quote.) So, how do we get from that point to probable cause of anything? Probable cause of trolling?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom