Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Honestly, Sabrina,

The one labeled IED looks pretty similar to how Ahmed's clock looks to me. Just put in a suitcase. Ahmed's wasn't polished at all.

There's no clock on it, truethat. Seriously, show me the clock on that one.

ETA: It's in a goddamn box of screws, for Pete's sake.
 
The clockface on his is secured across the front of the top of the suitcase. (I edited it to add it.) I'm not saying it looks exactly like it, but the body of the rest of it looks just like the IED one to me.????
 
Here's what looks similar to me

Metal chunk plate (check in both)

Wires (check in both)

Battery attachment (check in both)

a randomness of slapdashed together look.

Ahmed's is not neatly packed into the suitcase at all. It's thrown in there. It's a jumble of wires, electronics and metal plates and battery attachments etc.

The box of screws? What does that have to do with anything? I'm not understanding your point?
 
The picture I've seen of Ahmed's clock looks NOTHING like the picture of the IED. I would also add that the picture you posted appears to be after someone has partially disassembled the clock, hence the wires are showing and pieces are visible; I highly doubt Ahmed put it into the case like that.

As to your point about a teacher being able to recognize a bomb; why not? Considering the number of bomb threats and hoax bombs found in schools these days by pranksters, it would make sense for educators to be trained on how to spot a real bomb versus a fake one. I'm not saying they need to be trained to disarm them, but it would sure cut down on the unnecessary calling of the bomb squads for things that turn out to be hoaxes. Educators should also be schooled on the fact that a movie bomb looks NOTHING like a real life bomb, so they don't make the mistake Abooga made up above.
 
The picture I've seen of Ahmed's clock looks NOTHING like the picture of the IED. I would also add that the picture you posted appears to be after someone has partially disassembled the clock, hence the wires are showing and pieces are visible; I highly doubt Ahmed put it into the case like that.

As to your point about a teacher being able to recognize a bomb; why not? Considering the number of bomb threats and hoax bombs found in schools these days by pranksters, it would make sense for educators to be trained on how to spot a real bomb versus a fake one. I'm not saying they need to be trained to disarm them, but it would sure cut down on the unnecessary calling of the bomb squads for things that turn out to be hoaxes. Educators should also be schooled on the fact that a movie bomb looks NOTHING like a real life bomb, so they don't make the mistake Abooga made up above.


Ok I can READILY acknowledge that to your more experienced eye the two look nothing alike.

But to me they look pretty much the same just shaped differently. If you put both in front of me and asked me which one was real and which one was fake and that you'd detonate the one I chose in a basket of puppies, I honestly wouldn't know which one to choose.

I can't understand why you wouldn't understand that to someone who didn't know what it was why they might be nervous about it.

My reason for not thinking it was a bomb would have more to do with knowing the kid and listening to what he was saying.

But I'd also be confused as to why he brought it to school and rigged it up to go off in the middle of my classroom.


And NO I do not think that teachers should be "trained" to recognize real and fake bombs. Unless you plan to double their salaries. As a tax payer are you willing to do that?

So now teachers are expected to teach, spend hours preparing lesson plans, spend hours grading work, spend hours documenting their work, baby sit, counsel, open the world up to kids, guarantee the safety of students in the classroom, watch out for child abuse

annnnnnnd Be able to detect bombs.

This is ............really there are no words..........it's so absurdly typical of how people think of teachers that it's not funny.


Especially since the alternative solution "Don't bring things like this to school" seems to outrageously offend people to the bottom of their toes. LMFAO
 
Last edited:
_85595033_clock_irving_police_ap.jpg


ied-a.jpg


Just to put them side by side, so to speak. Note the lack of any kind of timer on the actual IED, unlike the picture of Ahmed's clock. Certainly wires are showing in both, but that is likely because someone partially disassembled Ahmed's clock before they took that picture; I highly doubt he put it in there so shoddily. It looks to me as though that metal plate that's hanging down was in place to hold most of the now exposed wires in place; if it were in place, there would be no wires visible in Ahmed's clock. There is no plug on the actual IED; there is one on Ahmed's device. There are no batteries on Ahmed's clock; there are batteries on the IED. There is no compartment to hold explosive material in Ahmed's clock; on the IED, the explosive material is likely in the screw box, which I might add you can find at any Home Depot or Lowes store, and the visible wires are to connect the detonator to the explosive material. There are so many differences between these two that it's not even funny; there is no comparison, except in the general shape of the two devices.
 
Ok I can READILY acknowledge that to your more experienced eye the two look nothing alike.

But to me they look pretty much the same just shaped differently. If you put both in front of me and asked me which one was real and which one was fake and that you'd detonate the one I chose in a basket of puppies, I honestly wouldn't know which one to choose.

I can't understand why you wouldn't understand that to someone who didn't know what it was why they might be nervous about it.

My reason for not thinking it was a bomb would have more to do with knowing the kid and listening to what he was saying.

But I'd also be confused as to why he brought it to school and rigged it up to go off in the middle of my classroom.


And NO I do not think that teachers should be "trained" to recognize real and fake bombs. Unless you plan to double their salaries. As a tax payer are you willing to do that?

So now teachers are expected to teach, baby sit, counsel, open the world up to kids, guarantee the safety of students in the classroom, watch out for child abuse

annnnnnnd Be able to detect bombs.

This is ............really there are no words..........it's so absurdly typical of how people think of teachers that it's not funny.


Especially since the alternative solution "Don't bring things like this to school" seems to outrageously offend people to the bottom of their toes. LMFAO

You'd hardly need to double salaries. It's a matter of a simple two or three day class; I've sat through several myself. At the very least, teachers need to know that something that looks like a bomb from a movie is very likely not a bomb. What, pray tell, is so difficult about that?
 
The part to the right of the box of screws looks exactly like the part underneath the clock face to me, with the exception of the missing batteries.
 
You'd hardly need to double salaries. It's a matter of a simple two or three day class; I've sat through several myself. At the very least, teachers need to know that something that looks like a bomb from a movie is very likely not a bomb. What, pray tell, is so difficult about that?

What pray tell is so difficult about "Don't bring things like this to school?" A

and B. It wouldn't matter if they had been trained. No matter what they wouldn't be able to risk it. They'd have to go to the principal.

So you are willing to risk the lives of school children on a "two to three day training" of teachers to recognize bombs?

I mean this is your solution? Not "don't bring things like this into schools' but "let's train the teacher to recognize bombs"

And HEY we won't pay them any more for it, we'll just add it to the pile of **** we already expect them to do.


There are seriously NO WORDS>:confused::boggled::eye-poppi
 
The part to the right of the box of screws looks exactly like the part underneath the clock face to me, with the exception of the missing batteries.

And again I will point out that the piece you are referring to, if it were in its proper place and held in place by the metal plate, would likely not be visible when the clock is fully assembled. Comparing the partially disassembled clock to a picture of an IED is rather disingenuous, don't you agree? Perhaps we should see if there is a photo of the clock when it is fully assembled and then compare the two.
 
And again I will point out that the piece you are referring to, if it were in its proper place and held in place by the metal plate, would likely not be visible when the clock is fully assembled. Comparing the partially disassembled clock to a picture of an IED is rather disingenuous, don't you agree? Perhaps we should see if there is a photo of the clock when it is fully assembled and then compare the two.

This is HOW he brought it to school? It's a disassembled clock. That's the whole point.

What part of this are you missing?

Ok time for a break. :blush:
 
What pray tell is so difficult about "Don't bring things like this to school?" A

and B. It wouldn't matter if they had been trained. No matter what they wouldn't be able to risk it. They'd have to go to the principal.

So you are willing to risk the lives of school children on a "two to three day training" of teachers to recognize bombs?

I mean this is your solution? Not "don't bring things like this into schools' but "let's train the teacher to recognize bombs"

And HEY we won't pay them any more for it, we'll just add it to the pile of **** we already expect them to do.


There are seriously NO WORDS>:confused::boggled::eye-poppi

Where exactly did I say that it's not a good policy to "don't bring things like this to school"? Please, quote where I said that. Got news for you; you CAN'T. I don't disagree with that policy; I do however disagree that it should be the only solution to the problem. Kids are going to bring stuff to school that they shouldn't no matter what the policy in place is.

Setting that aside, however, offering teachers a brief course in how to recognize possible bombs seems fully logical to me. Educators are responsible for the childrens safety while they are at school; you agree with me on that, I trust? Why then is it such a bad idea to ensure that they can recognize in a general way when something is truly dangerous and requires intervention from the police versus something that is deliberately crafted to be a hoax?
 
Last edited:
This is HOW he brought it to school? It's a disassembled clock. That's the whole point.

What part of this are you missing?

Ok time for a break. :blush:

I doubt that. The picture in question, if I'm not mistaken, was taken in the police station. The police would have had to disassemble the clock partially in order to justify their claim that they thought it was a bomb.
 
I doubt that. The picture in question, if I'm not mistaken, was taken in the police station. The police would have had to disassemble the clock partially in order to justify their claim that they thought it was a bomb.

That's a fair observation but no one in Ahmed's camp has come forward stating that they thought the picture in the media distorted how it looked when he brought it to school.

So I've assumed that's how it looked. However that might be more information as well.

(I will say that the video showing how they disassembled the other clock and simply placed it in the case looks remarkably similar to Ahmed's and it looks "affixed" that way. Example the clock face is held up, the bar across is attached, the metal plate in the back seems affixed. I could be wrong though.)
 
Last edited:
His sister.

Why did the police allow it? Because it isn't illegal to take pictures, and we all have cell phones with cameras in them.

Wait, his sister was there? How did she get there if he wasn't allowed to call his parents? Hmmm. I am even more skeptical of Ahmed's story than I was before reading this.
 
Sorry. I typed "racialist" into google and pasted the first definition. Didn't realize it would be that hard to find.


Obviously I didn't find it to be, since I offered several (cited) definitions without any difficulty.

Definitions which all curiously do not seem to jive with the single one you so conveniently chose to offer. Even the one from one of the sources you offered as additional support (without quoting, it should be noted.)

Isn't that odd?

:rolleyes:
 
Obviously I didn't find it to be, since I offered several (cited) definitions without any difficulty.

Definitions which all curiously do not seem to jive with the single one you so conveniently chose to offer. Even the one from one of the sources you offered as additional support (without quoting, it should be noted.)

Isn't that odd?

:rolleyes:

Um if you "click on the link" I provided it's the exact definition I posted here.

Are we back to reading comprehension issues again?

My post

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10915580#post10915580

The link I provided

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/racialist

If you follow the LMGTFY link you will see it is the first dictionary definition under the wiki page.

Just google it, "racialist" and everyone can see.


Your "hmmm interesting" point seems to be that you think I found some obscure definition of it, when in fact I just posted the first one there. This leads me to believe that your "hmmmm interesting" point applies to YOUR citations which you apparently bent over backwards digging around to find a different definition.

Hypocrisy much?
 
Last edited:
The point about "who cares?" and "why does it matter?" is that some people have accuse Ahmed of deliberately doing something to attract attention.

All right, that is a possibility. Maybe he was deliberately doing something with the purpose of showing that the police were idiotic islamophobes. He was trolling them. He made something that did not look like a bomb. However, he made something that looked like something that was supposed to make people think that he had made something that looked like a bomb. (Yes, that sentence actually parses correctly, and contains only the descriptions necessary to explain the behavior of which he is suspected.)

Well, if that was his intention:

1. It isn't illegal, so he shouldn't have been arrested and
2. It worked. The police looked like idiotic islamophobes.

1. He wasn't arrested for doing something illegal. He was arrested on suspicion of doing something illegal. There is a world of difference. Arrests happen if there is a probable cause that a suspect has committed a crime. In this particular case, the police released Ahmed almost immediately, and determined within two days (and possibly one) that they did not have enough evidence that he did something illegal to justify charging him. You can argue that they didn't have probable cause, although I think we would need access to the transcript of the interrogation to come to a definite conclusion, but you can't argue that it is wrong to arrest people just because they didn't do anything illegal. Many people are held without bail and go to full-blown trials even though they didn't do anything illegal. That is the way our justice system works. Perfectly legal arrests of wholly innocent people are made thousands of times every day. Hopefully, most of them are released without charge, and the remainder are eventually exonerated, but there is no "beyond reasonable doubt" standard for arresting somebody, or even a "preponderance of the evidence" standard actually.

2. His trolling may have been to get attention for himself, rather than exposing Islamophobia. That would seem to be an equally plausible but much less admirable goal. In any case, if he were actually trolling, I think it makes sense to assume that there were things he did to provoke the response he got beyond just bringing the device in and showing it off. After all, if his goal was to provoke a response, why wouldn't he do extra things to provoke a response? That would make the police reaction look more reasonable I think.
 
Last edited:
Here's something that's obvious to me, but I haven't seen anyone say it.

Apologies if I missed it.

The picture of Ahmed's clock doesn't show the way he was carrying it or the way he presented it. The clock, AFAIK was presented as a closed case with a window cut out for the display. I believe it has been stated that it was a Vaultz pencil case with a picture of a tiger on it. So the object he was carrying around would have looked something liker this.

picture.php


If I'm incorrect about the tiger, please imagine the surrounding area as black if you wish. But please do remember that the size of the case is a little smaller than a standard piece of paper folded over, not the size of a suitcase by any means.

Of course when you open it you see a jumble of wires. If you opened any clock you'd see wires.

I'd appreciate it, and find it more honest if those talking about the visual Ahmed presented and what reasonable assumptions about it are, would use my image or something similar, rather than the opened (and most likely, riffled by officers) box.

I
 
Last edited:
I don't see how that is possible when you look at the actual photograph of Ahmed's clock. The bottom part of the case doesn't have a hole cut in it to reveal the clock at all??

http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/cpsprodpb/8123/production/_85595033_clock_irving_police_ap.jpg


Sorry but I think you are mistaken there.



ETA Looking closely at the picture it does appear that the "blue matting" on the bottom "could be" an unfurled piece of cloth that perhaps he rolled up to reveal the cut out.

Do we have any real pictures of him holding the clock as you describe? Off to do some research.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom